Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not negotiate a higher salary because I'm worried I'll look greedy

91 replies

Spearshake · 24/06/2023 10:17

I have been offered a promotion to a managerial position, managing a team of 6 people. I was initially happy with the salary they had offered me (£46K), but my partner thinks I should ask for more, because who knows when the next pay rise will come, he says. My manager explained how they arrived at the figure, saying that the salary is in line with what the other managers are getting, but she did (twice) mention the difference in my experience and theirs, ie that they have only been with the company for a year and I have been here for 15 years. I am nervous to ask for more, because I'm worried what impression it will give them. My partner says it's business and they expect it. Is £46K a reasonable salary for this kind of role, given my experience, etc? For information, it's a US company and my managers are American. That's for cultural reference. If I do ask for more, how do I go about it?

OP posts:
TiaraBoo · 24/06/2023 12:08

How much was your increase and what was that as a percentage?
I don’t think saying I was expecting at least 50k is unreasonable. Go for it!

LosingMyPancakes · 24/06/2023 12:05

Please ignore all the shit advice of 'prove yourself first'. This is the kind of nonsense that holds women back in the workplace!

I've worked in recruitment for years and believe me your best chance to get a salary jump is in between jobs. It's very naive to think pay reviews will result in anything other than the minimum, they'll throw policy at you and no matter how well you've performed there will be a cap.

Olderandolder · 24/06/2023 12:02

PucketyPuckPuck · 24/06/2023 11:20

The time to negotiate a new salary is at point of offer, definitely NOT x months down the line. Lots of salaries are initially negotiable at management level but when a new salary is accepted, confirmed, input then you're very often at the mercy of set annual pay review periods from then onwards. A couple of leaner years for the company and organisation pay/recruitment wide freezes and you're stuffed and stuck where you are.

ALWAYS ask for more on a negotiable salary. And always give them a range, never one figure. And always face to face/by zoom initially.

On a £46k offer I'd approach it (face to face) as
'Hi x! Thank you for the job offer, I' d love to work with (insert something about job/team/area), I really feel like I could make a difference due to (very brief reminder of your skills or additional experience). I must be honest, the salary didn't quite meet my expectation... due to my additional experience in this area I was thinking that between £50 and £55k would be more fitting. I'm hoping there's some room for further review on this? '

Then followed up with an email. Again including a brief reminder of what you have to bring that differs from the existing team.

I'd be hoping they'd come back at £51, lower end of my suggestion but never rock bottom.

Great suggestion and nice wording!

Olderandolder · 24/06/2023 12:00

“Greedy” is a nonsensical thought.

But you do need to think about why you are worth it.

Do your years of experience make you a better manager, working more quickly, inspiring the team, requiring less senior management time, increasing output?

Or did it take you fifteen years and others only one because they are better?

If the business hits hard times and needs to cut staff, will your higher salary mean you are more likely to go?

Asking for more is generally a good thing, to show you value yourself. But you need an understanding of why you are valuable TO THEIR BUSINESS otherwise it can look silly. You don’t want to show you don’t understand the financial drivers of the business.

rookiemere · 24/06/2023 11:56

ThomasHardyPerennial · 24/06/2023 11:49

Don't understand why people are saying this is the only time to get a pay rise. Depends on the company, doesn't it? You can always ask at your next review.

Pay reviews are normally percentage based and hard to go outside policy. That's why it's even more important to start on the maximum possible.

LillyCandC · 24/06/2023 11:54

Yeah, it’s hard for women. If you don’t ask - you’re a not ambitious enough and you don’t know how to sell yourself. If you ask - you’re greedy.

in the end of the day, any business is just that. Business. It’s not personal. You definitely need to ask for more otherwise you will sell yourself short. 15 years in the same company! Talk about loyal! It does make a huge difference that they are American. They will expect you to negotiate.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 24/06/2023 11:52

Go for it. Men have far fewer qualms about asking. I work in the City and I have always pushed back on the first salary offer (in a constructive way).

Don’t talk down any of your comparators but do be very unBritish and talk yourself up. Push your experience, highlight any key achievements, explain what you are bringing to the role and the positive contribution you can make. Don’t make threats that you will leave etc unless you are actually prepared to do it.

IncomingTraffic · 24/06/2023 11:51

Always negotiate like a man. As women we too often end up underpaid because we are afraid of looking greedy or chancing our arm.

Look at comparable jobs and negotiate on the basis that it’s the market rate. Ask for more than you think you’d should get!

ThomasHardyPerennial · 24/06/2023 11:49

Don't understand why people are saying this is the only time to get a pay rise. Depends on the company, doesn't it? You can always ask at your next review.

Dirtyslippers · 24/06/2023 11:49

Don’t forget that it might affect your child benefit if you get it. You don’t want to cancel any increase by losing it.

billy1966 · 24/06/2023 11:46

Do your research.

If the market shows a higher salary, go for it.

It's not being greedy.

It's not being a mug.

Know your value and worth, it is always respected.

Judgyjudgy · 24/06/2023 11:41

Be greedy. This is probably your own opportunity (starting a new role), once you've got it, it's hard to get big payrises in the future

notavillager · 24/06/2023 11:35

Yabu. Always be expensive.

It’s all storytelling. You’re not a charity. State your value. “Based on [some comparable metric] I am worth £xxxxxx.” Not “could you give me”, but “this is my what I cost”. That way you are not being greedy, and instead they have justify paying you less than you’re worth. And they are being stingy if they refuse.

Gorringe · 24/06/2023 11:29

Pkhsvd · 24/06/2023 10:25

Men never seem worried about looking greedy and always ask for more which is probably why a lot are paid more

Exactly this

latetothefisting · 24/06/2023 11:22

Timeforabiscuit · 24/06/2023 10:27

They should be paying you for the job you are doing. I.e. the exact same job those others being paid more are!

others aren't being paid more though?
the amount op has been offered is in line with what the other managers are already getting paid, not less.
Although I agree with the pp who said that by mentioning your longer time with the company your manager was basically hinting you could ask for more than them - although tbf the argument could work the other way - you have more experience with the company but they have at least a year's more managerial experience than you.
I would ask now, and then if they refuse ask if there's a possibility of a reconsideration after a year, once you've gained experience in the role. If not, as others said, usually you get a far bigger payrise through external job change rather than internally, and management experience is invaluable, so after a year or so you could definitely look elsewhere if you needed/wanted another payrise - it's an employees market atm.
Congratulations btw!!

PucketyPuckPuck · 24/06/2023 11:20

The time to negotiate a new salary is at point of offer, definitely NOT x months down the line. Lots of salaries are initially negotiable at management level but when a new salary is accepted, confirmed, input then you're very often at the mercy of set annual pay review periods from then onwards. A couple of leaner years for the company and organisation pay/recruitment wide freezes and you're stuffed and stuck where you are.

ALWAYS ask for more on a negotiable salary. And always give them a range, never one figure. And always face to face/by zoom initially.

On a £46k offer I'd approach it (face to face) as
'Hi x! Thank you for the job offer, I' d love to work with (insert something about job/team/area), I really feel like I could make a difference due to (very brief reminder of your skills or additional experience). I must be honest, the salary didn't quite meet my expectation... due to my additional experience in this area I was thinking that between £50 and £55k would be more fitting. I'm hoping there's some room for further review on this? '

Then followed up with an email. Again including a brief reminder of what you have to bring that differs from the existing team.

I'd be hoping they'd come back at £51, lower end of my suggestion but never rock bottom.

JellyfishandShells · 24/06/2023 11:19

Labraradabrador · 24/06/2023 10:35

If you boss is American they will probably be more open to a frank discussion about salary, though it might be completely outside their control. There are ways to have a salary conversation without being directly confrontational: ‘I have done a bit of research (glassdoor, salary reports, etc.) and this salary seems low relative to responsibilities.’ Remind them of your broader experience, and data points on performance. If the won’t budge initially, ask about when the next salary review is and what metrics they will be looking at.

100% this - I worked in a similar corporate situation and learnt to be more proactive about describing and valuing my achievements. Felt counter to my cultural upbringing at the time: British, where understatement and nuance has coded meanings and female: taught overt asking is forward , impolite and somehow unfeminine. It’s not greedy - it’s business.

SlightlygrumpyBettyswaitress · 24/06/2023 11:19

Ask.

Summerhillsquare · 24/06/2023 11:14

Isthisexpected · 24/06/2023 10:26

There is research that men very rarely think like this and that's a big part of the gender (sex) pay gap. It is literally don't ask don't get!

Mmm there is, there's also research to show that when women do the same thing it can backfire, alas. We lie in a sexist world. I would look to ask after a year in post, if you're confident you can perform well, or even over perform - after all, women are generally also more efficinet than men!

MRex · 24/06/2023 11:12

Salary really depends on your industry and location, "manager" is too generic a term to be useful for salaries. Look up salaries somewhere like glassdoor.co.uk and use that to negotiate. There is no harm in saying you believe your 15 years at the company and equivalent salary comparisons suggests £52k would be a fairer rate, so you'd like to discuss the salary and benefits package further. Mention benefits as that leaves it open to agreeing a higher pension rather than salary if that's their preference.

Labraradabrador · 24/06/2023 11:10

i would also add that in my experience (my own, dh and colleagues), you get a bigger jump when you move companies than through internal salary review. I would personally expect 25-30% uplift at a minimum to move companies, and have seen people get 50% more. Internal promotion is more like 25% max, and more like 10-15%.

ThreeFeetTall · 24/06/2023 11:07

The manager is basically telling you to ask for more!

ThirtyThrillionThreeTrees · 24/06/2023 11:05

Most peopen don't accept the first offer.

Look up salary reports for your sector and job title to see what the industry expectations is. Check Glassdoor also.

Just ask, what is the worst that can happen?
I ask every single time, most times I've got movement or when I haven't I've got a derailed explanation as to why not.

Sportyleopard · 24/06/2023 11:04

"As employers we have done our research we know industry rates and we set our pay rates with a great deal of thought and analysis"

My arse!

Kitcaterpillar · 24/06/2023 11:01

As employers we have done our research

Bold of you to speak for employers as a whole 🤨