Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not negotiate a higher salary because I'm worried I'll look greedy

91 replies

Spearshake · 24/06/2023 10:17

I have been offered a promotion to a managerial position, managing a team of 6 people. I was initially happy with the salary they had offered me (£46K), but my partner thinks I should ask for more, because who knows when the next pay rise will come, he says. My manager explained how they arrived at the figure, saying that the salary is in line with what the other managers are getting, but she did (twice) mention the difference in my experience and theirs, ie that they have only been with the company for a year and I have been here for 15 years. I am nervous to ask for more, because I'm worried what impression it will give them. My partner says it's business and they expect it. Is £46K a reasonable salary for this kind of role, given my experience, etc? For information, it's a US company and my managers are American. That's for cultural reference. If I do ask for more, how do I go about it?

OP posts:
Yoyooo · 24/06/2023 13:48

Would recieving more salary affect any child benefit?

G5000 · 24/06/2023 13:42

Oh and 10% increase when you go from individual contributor to manager of 6 is also too low.

Spearshake · 24/06/2023 13:40

TiaraBoo · 24/06/2023 12:08

How much was your increase and what was that as a percentage?
I don’t think saying I was expecting at least 50k is unreasonable. Go for it!

The are offering me a 10% increase from my current salary.

OP posts:
G5000 · 24/06/2023 13:40

My manager explained how they arrived at the figure, saying that the salary is in line with what the other managers are getting, but she did (twice) mention the difference in my experience and theirs, ie that they have only been with the company for a year and I have been here for 15 years.

Your manager is almost literally TELLING you to ask for more and their offer is too low.

Spearshake · 24/06/2023 13:35

PucketyPuckPuck · 24/06/2023 11:20

The time to negotiate a new salary is at point of offer, definitely NOT x months down the line. Lots of salaries are initially negotiable at management level but when a new salary is accepted, confirmed, input then you're very often at the mercy of set annual pay review periods from then onwards. A couple of leaner years for the company and organisation pay/recruitment wide freezes and you're stuffed and stuck where you are.

ALWAYS ask for more on a negotiable salary. And always give them a range, never one figure. And always face to face/by zoom initially.

On a £46k offer I'd approach it (face to face) as
'Hi x! Thank you for the job offer, I' d love to work with (insert something about job/team/area), I really feel like I could make a difference due to (very brief reminder of your skills or additional experience). I must be honest, the salary didn't quite meet my expectation... due to my additional experience in this area I was thinking that between £50 and £55k would be more fitting. I'm hoping there's some room for further review on this? '

Then followed up with an email. Again including a brief reminder of what you have to bring that differs from the existing team.

I'd be hoping they'd come back at £51, lower end of my suggestion but never rock bottom.

I've had two face-to-face discussions with my manager already, and was planning to put my counter-offer in an email, so as to give her time to reflect on it, etc. Do you think better to set up a third meeting with her to discuss the counter-offer, rather than in an email?

OP posts:
Newname47 · 24/06/2023 13:32

How long have the others doing the job been there? If they just joined the salary is comparable and the difference would be experience but if they've been there a few years then I'd add inflation to their starting salary and assume you'd start on slightly more than them now as the big pay rises are generally when you move rather than year on year. I'm always disappointed when a woman doesn't negotiate as a man nearly always does.

Spearshake · 24/06/2023 13:32

ThomasHardyPerennial · 24/06/2023 11:49

Don't understand why people are saying this is the only time to get a pay rise. Depends on the company, doesn't it? You can always ask at your next review.

We had pay freezes in the company all through covid and not as many pay increases before that, so my original salary was pretty static for ages. Plus, they stopped doing annual reviews, meaning no pay increases.

OP posts:
Spearshake · 24/06/2023 13:26

Getoutofherenow · 24/06/2023 10:44

As employers we have done our research we know industry rates and we set our pay rates with a great deal of thought and analysis, so if you do ask for more make sure you know what you are talking about and have a good reason with some data to back it up.
A couple of people in our team have tried to negotiate using inaccurate information - which we easily proved to be completely wrong. One mentioned skills - which we expected as an absolute minimum to have for the role not something that deserved extra reward - tbh their negotiation tactics made them look bad not because it was greedy but because they had not done proper research and chosen the wrong thing to highlight - they looked ill-prepared and naive - which was worse than greedy as it made me question recruiting them. Our rates of pay are set to be generous, so trying to negotiate upwards when it's already 60% increase on their previous salary did look...greedy.

I'm sure most /some employers do their research, but I'm not sure it's the case with mine. For one thing, it's not the HR department that are involved with it, but apparently the CEO and CFO. Plus, each of the managers (my counterparts) are in different locations (one in the US, one in China), with varying degrees of experience, so it will be tough for them to create a benchmark, I imagine. The raise is 10% from my past salary, but a completely different role.

OP posts:
OnlyFannys · 24/06/2023 13:25

As employers we have done our research we know industry rates and we set our pay rates with a great deal of thought and analysis
Some.companies might do this but others will absolutely pay the minimum they can get away with. I have been looking for a new role recently and my current position the salary ranges anywhere from 40k to 120k (job descriptions pretty much the same and all local)

Spearshake · 24/06/2023 13:22

mintbiscuit · 24/06/2023 10:34

Have you managed a team before? Whilst exp within your company is valuable and has a price, so does a proven track record of leadership. My team managers are on different salaries depending on experience of both.

I have managed a team before, within this company, so I have that experience. I will add that point when I make my counter-offer.

OP posts:
Spearshake · 24/06/2023 13:17

The salary that they are proposing is a 10% increase to my current one, but I am not sure how relevant that is, given it's a completely different job role, right?

OP posts:
Getoutofherenow · 24/06/2023 12:56

Kitcaterpillar · 24/06/2023 11:01

As employers we have done our research

Bold of you to speak for employers as a whole 🤨

I didn't - do you always like to argue over nothing or is it just a social media thing?

KaleFairy · 24/06/2023 12:51

I would negotiate with an American company. Can you look the title up on glassdoor and see the range? You should also be able to see other salaries for the company on glassdoor. "I'm excited about the offer and working on xyz! Can I ask if there's any flexibility in the salary? For this role, given the scope and responsibilities and with my x years of experience in x, it would make sense for my compensation to be in a higher range of 54k-58k."

I always negotiate and I've always gotten a higher than initial offer. Only once did someone hold it against me, but they still gave me the money and I was still promoted within two years. I know you're not necessarily interviewing with multiple people, but my mentor once told me that if the company is one that would be offended by a woman asking for a higher salary then it's not a great place to work anyway. I think I read that only 10% of women negotiate and that we leave thousands in lifetime earnings on the table. Get your bags girl.

I hope you'll update us if you counter. Good luck!

sazzy5 · 24/06/2023 12:44

Ask. Annoyingly if you switched companies you would get more money. Your company would pay an external person more money and probably a recruitment company. Don’t be afraid to ask, in my company anyone who gets a promotion doesn’t get a pay rise the next time. So check that out as well.

Trying2understand · 24/06/2023 12:27

Also a point about child benefit - please remember if you getting several thousand more than 50k, that is likely worth far more than child benefit.

Trying2understand · 24/06/2023 12:25

I would ask them for 50k and specifically speak to your commitment to the company! I would also look at your annual leave and see if you are happy with that. I had a promotion this year and was able to negotiate terms that make the job and new role much more palatable for having a more senior role and family.

Your worries are well documented for women, I felt the same. But this is also a really important part of lessening the gap that has and continues to harm women.

IncomingTraffic · 24/06/2023 12:23

She HAS proved herself. This is a promotion to a more senior role.

Obviously she should negotiate!

Peppapigboresme · 24/06/2023 12:23

This reply has been withdrawn

The OP has privacy concerns about this thread, so we've agreed to take it down.

MrsMillhouse · 24/06/2023 12:20

Ask for more. I’d ask for £60k. You probably won’t get £60k but it sets a higher benchmark. Future salary rises are often a % of existing salary, so set the standard high

Unknownunknowns · 24/06/2023 12:19

How much of an increase is it? If you're going from 42k to 46k to take on extra responsibility and people management that's not great. If you're moving from 30k to 46k that's a lot better (obviously!)
But I agree with PPs, don't ask don't get! Just say based on the role and responsibilities, and your experience and skillset, you feel 50k is more appropriate. They can only say No, but if they say Yes that's great - more money for you!
BTW, I'm all talk and would be sick at the thought of it! I really wish I had the balls to do this given half the chance, so I understand your reticence.

readbooksdrinktea · 24/06/2023 12:17

YABU. Negotiate.

No man would ever think he was too greedy. Don't sabotage your own success. If they say no, you tried. If they say yes, you have more money.

Grumpigal · 24/06/2023 12:16

“ hey boss, I am so excited about the role change and really looking forward to getting stuck in. I’d like to have a quick chat about salary, I’ll be honest I did expect it to be more in the 50k range due to my experience and skill set. Is there possibility for negotiation here?”

if there’s not, then get boss to agree when the salary will be reviewed

don’t ask - don’t get. It’s business not personal, it’s not greedy to negotiate a salary, it’s what you should be doing - unless the employer distinctly says no movement on salary during the interview process.

theyve offered - you can counter offer

Appleandoranges · 24/06/2023 12:15

Also remember your next salary is often based on what you had before

Appleandoranges · 24/06/2023 12:13

Definitely negotiate. And who cares if you look greedy! Successful people are greedy for success and money. They might actually think less of yoy if you don’t negotiate. Say you have more years experience. That’s why you are asking for more ! It also shows you have negotiation skills which may be important for your job.

yipeeyiyay · 24/06/2023 12:12

Timeforabiscuit · 24/06/2023 10:27

They should be paying you for the job you are doing. I.e. the exact same job those others being paid more are!

The others are getting paid the same