Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Child's school asking for biometric data

144 replies

DyslexiaNightmare · 23/06/2023 21:05

Fingerprint data and facial recognition. Is this widespread? How is it even allowed? Children can't consent to giving biometric data. It's not for me to give away. Even if it is to a school.

How difficult will it make things due to the fact that I'm not consenting to this?

OP posts:
SinnerBoy · 25/06/2023 03:02

I haven't heard of this, all I know is that I put money on Parent Pay. I'll ask my daughter, she's in Year 5 at middle school. At first school, the dinner nannies knew them all and marked them down.

LaJolieMuse · 24/06/2023 22:09

I've never heard of this... Didn't know it was a thing. I'm in my 30s with DC at school although they are still at the free school lunch age.

I don't like the idea of it to be honest. Also unsure how well it would work, certainly I have major issues with fingerprint scanners. When I go to America I have to get ink fingerprints taken. I can't use it on my phone. Also don't use facial recognition.

cakeorwine · 24/06/2023 22:05

You can't reverse engineer fingerprints?
Can you?

So if someone had a bit of fingerprint data, they couldn't use that data to gain access elsewhere...

I don't think - maybe someone else knows better?

Snowtrails · 24/06/2023 22:01

Amazing people are so anxious about this but put real faces on social media
Not necessarily the same people though.....

GeraltsBathtub · 24/06/2023 20:30

Surely this is nothing new? When I was at school in the early 2000s we used fingerprints in the primary school library.

EvelynBeatrice · 24/06/2023 19:51

I refused consent and the school implemented a workaround. The reason my daughter gave was that it would be an impediment if she ever wished to embark upon a career as a spy or master criminal.

Dacadactyl · 24/06/2023 19:45

I didn't like it either OP. This has been in place since my DD started high school.

Because i didnt like the fingerprint idea, DD16 always had a card provided by the school (that we credited with money) to buy her dinners. She would just swipe it at the till.

She was the only one in her whole year who wasn't using a fingerprint.

cunningartificer · 24/06/2023 19:40

Amazing people are so anxious about this but put real faces on social media. As others have said no way to go back to the original print- and if anyone wants my child's fingerprint that's not hard to find... be more careful about meaningful data and less anxious about this

TeenDivided · 24/06/2023 13:08

hoophoophooray · 24/06/2023 09:25

We have both. They don't store the fingerprint so it can't be stolen as data, an algorithm is used to generate a code from it that is linked to the child's lunch money account. Even if the codes are stolen, there is no way to generate a fingerprint from it, as it only reads 6 or 8 points. Same with facial recognition, it's used to generate a code, the code is stored, but no way to back calculate the face.

Schools have photos on SIMS usually to verify that students are who they say they are, but it's just a straight photo file.

This.
They aren't storing the actual fingerprint or face.
they generate a code from it.
Nothing to worry about in my opinion.

Elphame · 24/06/2023 13:04

NeverDropYourMooncup · 24/06/2023 12:51

They'd have a job as I've just cleared it off the server to make way for the next cohort.

Just deleting doesn't mean that data cannot be recovered.

Did you also delete all the back ups and made sure that backed up data isn't copied elsewhere as well (which is should be if the back ups are worth anything).

How securely are they kept? And for how long and who else has access to them? I've restored computer files from back ups many times and I'm no expert. I do know enough though to know that a digital record can be very persistent and it is naive to assume otherwise.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 24/06/2023 12:51

Elphame · 24/06/2023 12:49

Until they are hacked or the Govt requests the data for its own purposes.

If you really believe that the data is secure then good for you.

They'd have a job as I've just cleared it off the server to make way for the next cohort.

Elphame · 24/06/2023 12:49

NeverDropYourMooncup · 24/06/2023 12:11

There's set timeframes for the storage of data - and frankly, with the cost of servers or cloud storage, there are far more important things to be taking up space than the biometric codes for people who are now in their thirties.

Until they are hacked or the Govt requests the data for its own purposes.

If you really believe that the data is secure then good for you.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 24/06/2023 12:11

Elphame · 24/06/2023 11:46

Thank goodness my children were adult before the current craziness that seems to be the modern education system.

I would also say no purely because of the data security issues. I wouldn't trust them to be able to keep the data safe and to wipe it when the children leave. Data gathering is too addictive for some.

There's set timeframes for the storage of data - and frankly, with the cost of servers or cloud storage, there are far more important things to be taking up space than the biometric codes for people who are now in their thirties.

Elphame · 24/06/2023 11:46

Thank goodness my children were adult before the current craziness that seems to be the modern education system.

I would also say no purely because of the data security issues. I wouldn't trust them to be able to keep the data safe and to wipe it when the children leave. Data gathering is too addictive for some.

LlynTegid · 24/06/2023 10:31

I would not agree to this because I am not 100% confident about the security of any school's IT system. Which is no slight on the school or any of the staff who work there.

Countdown2023 · 24/06/2023 09:46

We have finger biometrics. It used for lunches and by the LRC for book loans

hoophoophooray · 24/06/2023 09:25

We have both. They don't store the fingerprint so it can't be stolen as data, an algorithm is used to generate a code from it that is linked to the child's lunch money account. Even if the codes are stolen, there is no way to generate a fingerprint from it, as it only reads 6 or 8 points. Same with facial recognition, it's used to generate a code, the code is stored, but no way to back calculate the face.

Schools have photos on SIMS usually to verify that students are who they say they are, but it's just a straight photo file.

Betterlatethanontime · 24/06/2023 09:22

Can you just say no?

Fandabedodgy · 24/06/2023 09:19

It's not reached any schools where I live but I wouldn't be bothered about it.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 24/06/2023 09:13

EnthENd · 23/06/2023 21:51

Am I showing my age and luddite-ness by thinking this is weird and wondering what it will do to the next generation to grow up thinking being fingerprinted and scanned everywhere is normal?

In my day, I can't remember at primary but at secondary we just paid cash or handed over an FSM coupon.

Also, if the reader's anything like my iPhone touch ID ... that doesn't work more often than it works for me.

So some kids would lose/have stolen/not be given cash for food and have to go hungry, some would spend it in the shop round the corner on chocolate and crisps at 8am and others would just have the ritual humiliation of everybody knowing they were poor?

This is not hyperbole, by the way - I remember both being told in front of everybody that 'your Mummy will have to get a job and pay for your food from now on' when the FSM entitlement hadn't come through on time and then the AAAHHHHHH! YOU'RE POOR! YOU'RE THE POOR KIDS! when queueing in the corridor for 30 minutes to get a manky plastic token to hand over at the till, meaning that if you got there at midday on the dot, you got to the counter at 10 to 1 after then having to queue for the canteen as well.

The fingerprint thing stops other kids spotting their code or stealing their card and using it, the FSM entitlement is invisible and if parenting/financial issues mean they aren't getting any credits on their account, it's easy to see on the software, so neglectful parents can't claim 'I gave her £30 last Monday, it's not my fault if she's spent it on Haribo and Costa on the way in, she's lying about going hungry'.

Dressydress · 24/06/2023 08:50

I'm 31 and we had the fingerprint scans on the second half of secondary school when it was introduced. I proffered it to cash as friends used to ask me for things and I was a kid who couldn't say no.

Also, it worked just fine. Was quicker than cash. Kids didn't lose it. And I haven't grown up thinking a fingerprint scanner world is normal so don't worry.

Marteenie · 24/06/2023 08:49

I remember a poor soul in my year would always have his money for lunch and later on his card stolen, teachers never did anything about it at least he'd be able to have something for lunch this way!

Just ask for the alternative if you don't want to consent on their behalf.

cadetmumstress · 24/06/2023 08:48

Our school used fingerprints but switched to facial recognition during the pandemic to avoid the need to wipe the fingerprint scanner between students. They kept the fingerprint scanners to use if the facial recognition cameras are playing up.
The data is used just for paying for dinners. I read the terms and conditions and was happy to consent. The 'third party' mentioned is just the company that maintains the equipment and databases / software for the system. They don't keep full data and adhere to GDPR (obviously). Not 100% safe because nothing ever is but carefully regulated and used by most schools now.

princesssugarless · 24/06/2023 08:45

We have facial recognition for the canteen. Saved germy children touching the same scanner

Circethemagician · 24/06/2023 08:37

Are you sure it’s ‘facial recognition’ and not just taking a photo of them for the school system?

My kids schools have fingerprint scanners for school meals, saves all the problems of lunch money being stolen, also it’s better for kids on free school meals as there is no obvious difference so they don’t have to take up a coupon to the till which might be embarrassing.

However there is an option of a lunch card too (which you have to leave a deposit for in case it gets lost).

Swipe left for the next trending thread