Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mum keeps asking for money

116 replies

tiredmumma8696 · 23/06/2023 20:45

I thought I would come to Mumsnet to understand if it's me being unreasonable for thinking this way.

My mum lives in a large house, she's early 60s; no mortgage. Still working but on a low ish salary and lives alone. The house is 5 bedrooms and is worth around £650-700k. Mum is struggling to maintain the house due to the investment needed (it's a Victorian house). She's lived their 30 years and done very little to it.

She is struggling for money on monthly basis and is asking for help. My siblings and I have broached the subject about selling the house but she refuses saying it will be too stressful.

I feel resentful handing over money when she is sat in a huge house by herself. Our mortgage is about to go up by £1000 per month (we were on a low fixed rate and now remortgaging). We also have two children in nursery which is expensive.

To give some more background we are not particularly close. My oldest is over 3 and a half and never been offered so much as an hours babysitting or anything like that.

I feel like there is a lot of guilt tripping on her part and I just offer some money to help but starting to feel resentful given she is sat on several hundred thousand if she sold.

AIBU?

OP posts:
tiredmumma8696 · 23/06/2023 21:35

@UpaladderwatchingTV
Thank you for your message. Hope all goes well with the move and you settle into your new home ❤️

OP posts:
gamerchick · 23/06/2023 21:35

Gymmum82 · 23/06/2023 21:31

‘Actually mum I was going to ask if you could give me some money since we’re struggling to pay our mortgage and fees our kids’

This. Always ask for money when you have a pest like that.

Hugasauras · 23/06/2023 21:33

She needs to downsize and do it now while she's able. Once she gets older, she will end up trapped in a house that is too big, falling into disrepair and where she might eventually be unable to access most of the rooms due to stairs. Tough love perhaps!

WhatADrabCarpet · 23/06/2023 21:33

She needs to cut her cloth accordingly.

She needs to downsize and live within her means.

UpaladderwatchingTV · 23/06/2023 21:33

OP, I am around the same age as your mother, and disabled. Since moving to our current home a few years back, my DH has gone from being a healthy man, to suffering from just about every ailment you could think of. Life has changed dramatically for us, and while, like your mother, we could bury our heads in the sand, and let all the hard work and love that we've put into making this house and garden into our dream home, go to wrack and ruin, we know that that would be an awful waste when someone younger, and perhaps with a family could enjoy it as it is, and then continue with the work that we've done, as the need arises. We have therefore decided to sell up and move, hard as it will be both physically and mentally, to somewhere smaller and more manageable for us, because this is the 'sensible' thing to do.

If we didn't do this, we would then become a burden on our family, much as your mother is doing to you, and we have much more self respect than to do that. It's time to tell your mother that she's a grown woman, there's nothing wrong with her, so far as you have told us, and that she is being utterly selfish, expecting her own children to bail her out, when she's perfectly capable of moving to somewhere smaller, more affordable, and probably far more pleasant to live in, than a big old house, that is gradually going to fall apart around her, and is probably a nightmare to keep warm in the winter. You really don't owe her anything OP, and if she can't see that for herself, then she needs to be told. Good luck!

Gymmum82 · 23/06/2023 21:31

‘Actually mum I was going to ask if you could give me some money since we’re struggling to pay our mortgage and fees our kids’

Summerishereagain · 23/06/2023 21:31

Every time you give money to your Mum you are taking money away from your children to give it to a woman who has a huge amount in equity.

Tell her now with the CoL you can’t give her anymore money. If you are willing to you could offer her help with moving.

stargirl1701 · 23/06/2023 21:30

Tell her you're selling yours and moving in to hers as you need to combine households in order to afford giving her money. That may concentrate her thoughts!

Doggymummar · 23/06/2023 21:30

She could release some equity if she doesn't want to sell.

mayorofcasterbridge · 23/06/2023 21:28

tiredmumma8696 · 23/06/2023 21:06

Thank you everyone for your responses. I thought maybe I was being selfish but it's sounding like lots of you agree with me.
Any spare money we have should go on my children and be put away for their future. I think I need to have this conversation with her and if it causes a row so be it

No, your mother is the selfish one! Your little ones will become even more expensive when they start school, and start things like swimming lessons etc.

For context mum died in her early 60s. We had three young children in childcare and mum was the one helping us out financially!

Mossstitch · 23/06/2023 21:27

Holly60 · 23/06/2023 20:57

OP I'm a mum to adult children and I would NEVER ask them for money. I chose to bring them into this world not the other way around. They owe me nothing.

Plenty of money goes the other way 😂 but again their existence was my choice not the other way around.

Please stop giving your mother money. You don't actually owe her anything at all. When we choose to have children we have a responsibility towards them. That is what being a parent is. That doesn't then give us the right to demand financial support from them.

☝I'm mid 60s, still work in NHS so not rich but I would never ask my kids for money! They didn't ask to be born, I had them for purely selfish reasons and it is my responsibility to look after them no matter how old they are not the other way around! I frequently give them money, they don't need it but it gives me pleasure to pay for things for them. Your mother is an adult and should be sorting her own finances. Tell her that it's no longer possible due to the interest rates and leave her to sort her own finances out😏

BMW6 · 23/06/2023 21:24

No. Her parents were / are well off. They bought her first property for her many years ago. She has never had to support them

Well it sounds like your Mum has been rather spoilt and is selfish as a result.

If she goes off on one stand your ground. You have your children to look after.

tiredmumma8696 · 23/06/2023 21:06

Thank you everyone for your responses. I thought maybe I was being selfish but it's sounding like lots of you agree with me.
Any spare money we have should go on my children and be put away for their future. I think I need to have this conversation with her and if it causes a row so be it

OP posts:
mayorofcasterbridge · 23/06/2023 21:04

Tell her you can't afford it - your children are your priority - and she has the option to sell the house she can't afford.

Oldnproud · 23/06/2023 21:01

You say your mum is in her early sixties. It sounds like the right time for her to sell up and downsize, while she still has her health. It isn't just about freeing up capital, although that is clearly a major reason if she keeps asking for money, but she also needs to think about what sort of property will best meet her needs for the next twenty or thirty years. Yes, selling up now might be stressful, but things will only get harder, so the sooner she addresses this the better for both her and you and your siblings.

tiredmumma8696 · 23/06/2023 21:01

@Holly60 thank you. This is how I feel. Although my kids are small, I would never want them to feel they owe me anything.

OP posts:
CurlyhairedAssassin · 23/06/2023 21:01

tiredmumma8696 · 23/06/2023 20:45

I thought I would come to Mumsnet to understand if it's me being unreasonable for thinking this way.

My mum lives in a large house, she's early 60s; no mortgage. Still working but on a low ish salary and lives alone. The house is 5 bedrooms and is worth around £650-700k. Mum is struggling to maintain the house due to the investment needed (it's a Victorian house). She's lived their 30 years and done very little to it.

She is struggling for money on monthly basis and is asking for help. My siblings and I have broached the subject about selling the house but she refuses saying it will be too stressful.

I feel resentful handing over money when she is sat in a huge house by herself. Our mortgage is about to go up by £1000 per month (we were on a low fixed rate and now remortgaging). We also have two children in nursery which is expensive.

To give some more background we are not particularly close. My oldest is over 3 and a half and never been offered so much as an hours babysitting or anything like that.

I feel like there is a lot of guilt tripping on her part and I just offer some money to help but starting to feel resentful given she is sat on several hundred thousand if she sold.

AIBU?

Why on earth would you hand her money if you're in a worse financial position than her? Absolutely baffling that you felt you should do this in the first place. Just stop, that's ridiculous. Your children will suffer.

woodhill · 23/06/2023 20:59

Totally agree Holly

She needs to downsize

tiredmumma8696 · 23/06/2023 20:59

Turnthelightoff · 23/06/2023 20:55

Did she support her parents when you were young? I’m guessing not, might be time to point that out?

No. Her parents were / are well off. They bought her first property for her many years ago. She has never had to support them

OP posts:
WeAreTheHeroes · 23/06/2023 20:59

tiredmumma8696 · 23/06/2023 20:50

@lightlypoached thank you replying. She makes me feel like I owe her for bringing us up etc.
if she was living in a sensible sized property and struggling to eat then of course I would help but this seems silly. I think I will have to say no but I worry about a huge family row but feel I'm being taken for a ride

Jeez no - you bring up children to be independent of you and certainly not to support you. Either she downsizes or gets lodgers.

Holly60 · 23/06/2023 20:57

OP I'm a mum to adult children and I would NEVER ask them for money. I chose to bring them into this world not the other way around. They owe me nothing.

Plenty of money goes the other way 😂 but again their existence was my choice not the other way around.

Please stop giving your mother money. You don't actually owe her anything at all. When we choose to have children we have a responsibility towards them. That is what being a parent is. That doesn't then give us the right to demand financial support from them.

BMW6 · 23/06/2023 20:57

There's been a saying quoted on here recently

"Don't set yourself on fire to keep someone else warm"

Of course you should not give money when she is sitting on huge equity in a property she cannot afford to maintain! Madness!

She can sell, gat a much smaller well maintained place and have a nice safety net of capital in the bank.

You didn't ask to be born. You owe nothing.

Bluebells1970 · 23/06/2023 20:57

Don't enable her delusion of being able to manage there. Every time she asks, you say "Mum, I have my own family and own expenses and am struggling each month as it is. You can't afford to live in that house, and I am not going to continue to pretend that you can".

lightlypoached · 23/06/2023 20:56

@tiredmumma8696 you are most welcome.

Since I posted lots of people have come on to say the same thing. She sounds emotionally manipulative and this is a power play.

Ignore. Or just say no that doesn't work for me mum. I have priorities now which include my children, who I always put first.

EvilElsa · 23/06/2023 20:56

"I don't have any to give you mum" on repeat. Say you'd be happy to help her look at options for downsizing or taking in a lodger etc. If you are not even close don't waste your time feeling guilty over her own life choices. Absolutely nothing to do with you. To be honest if she texts the requests I wouldn't even bother responding. If she calls and nags, cut her off and say you don't have any and to stop asking as the situation won't be changing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread