Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mum keeps asking for money

116 replies

tiredmumma8696 · 23/06/2023 20:45

I thought I would come to Mumsnet to understand if it's me being unreasonable for thinking this way.

My mum lives in a large house, she's early 60s; no mortgage. Still working but on a low ish salary and lives alone. The house is 5 bedrooms and is worth around £650-700k. Mum is struggling to maintain the house due to the investment needed (it's a Victorian house). She's lived their 30 years and done very little to it.

She is struggling for money on monthly basis and is asking for help. My siblings and I have broached the subject about selling the house but she refuses saying it will be too stressful.

I feel resentful handing over money when she is sat in a huge house by herself. Our mortgage is about to go up by £1000 per month (we were on a low fixed rate and now remortgaging). We also have two children in nursery which is expensive.

To give some more background we are not particularly close. My oldest is over 3 and a half and never been offered so much as an hours babysitting or anything like that.

I feel like there is a lot of guilt tripping on her part and I just offer some money to help but starting to feel resentful given she is sat on several hundred thousand if she sold.

AIBU?

OP posts:
CaveMum · 24/06/2023 10:46

Another one against equity release here! MIL did equity release of £25k from her home as she wanted to buy a new car, get a new boiler and go on some nice holidays. She didn’t chat with DH or BIL about it and when they found out after the fact they both said they would have lent her the money to do those things if she really needed it.

Fast forward about 8 years and MIL was too unwell to stay in the house and needed to move to a flat quickly. We didn’t have the time to sell the house (she was literally about to be discharged from hospital after a 6 week stay due to a fall), so the plan was to rent out her house to fund the rental of a flat and give her a small income on top of her pension. We were covering the cost of the flat rental while tenants were found for her house (thankfully in a very desirable university city so we had tenants sorted within 6 weeks). On checking the terms of the equity release we found small print that said the property could not be rented out in any way and that we either had to sell the house or buy out the equity release. That £25k released had turned into a bill of £60k and between us and BIL we had to scrape together the money from our own savings to pay it off. Thankfully we were able to raise it, and had our money ringfenced within the value of the property so that we could get it back in the future when the house was eventually sold.

Long story short, avoid equity release if at all possible!

Sugarfree23 · 24/06/2023 10:15

jackstini · 24/06/2023 09:45

Well she has 2 options:

1 - sell it and downsize
2 - stay in it and do an equity release for enough money to do the repairs and maintenance (which actually would help with the inheritance tax issue too!)

You ask her which one she wants to do
On repeat
Until she gets it

Equity release is a massive scam. Be very careful before you recommend it to anyone.

People seem to end up with a release of say £50k against a £250k house so should have equity of £200k left.

But they 'pay' crazy interest rates against the £50k coming out of the £200k, so really every year the equity in the house drops, few years and the £200k is eroded.

Hence you read threads with people with parents who are stuck, the house needs repairs the parents can't pay it and the have lost so much equity that they can't afford to downsize either.

wwyd2021medicine · 24/06/2023 09:55

Im a little younger but literally counting down the months to when I can sell my house and move to somewhere smaller. Im fed up of house and garden maintenance.
Sorry not helpful

4Kilos2go · 24/06/2023 09:54

I would 'train' her to stop asking through a mixture of these suggestions. Asking her for money. Responding to every request for money with a suggestion that she take in a lodger. Let her figure out that ASKING FOR MONEY ALWAYS LEADS TO THE DISCUSSION SHE REFUSES TO HAVE.

@tiredmumma8696 you could suggest swapping houses!? If she won't sell.

jackstini · 24/06/2023 09:45

Well she has 2 options:

1 - sell it and downsize
2 - stay in it and do an equity release for enough money to do the repairs and maintenance (which actually would help with the inheritance tax issue too!)

You ask her which one she wants to do
On repeat
Until she gets it

tiredmumma8696 · 24/06/2023 07:19

@nowahousewife
Well done for standing firm and asking for a charge on the property.
I think it will definitely impact our relationship. She doesn't like being told no or not getting her own way. I've been avoiding saying something as we have a big family wedding in 3 weeks time but after starting this thread and hearing all the comments I feel I have the confidence to speak up next time

OP posts:
nowahousewife · 24/06/2023 07:14

Hi OP, have just skimmed the thread so sorry if I’ve missed anything but I am in exactly the same situation. DM aged 83 now started asking for money about 5 years ago. At the time I suggested she downsize, of course she was not having it. Her comment was “your father and I worked hard to have something to leave you children” to which I responded I do not need it and I’d rather you were living well. Over the last 5 years we have given her £25000 in 3 chunks, my DB who can also afford it has given her nothing but does help her in practical ways.

Fast forward to this year and she’s asked me to give her money for a new bathroom. I’ve told her I’m happy to but it will give given as a charge against her house and this needs to be drawn up by her solicitor. Likewise any future help I give her will be a charge against her house. She went very silent and has not broached the subject again and my brother is not happy about my choice.

What I did will shut down the conversation but I would say it has impacted my relationship with her. But I think once money is involved relationships do become effected.

euff · 24/06/2023 06:53

My friends parents moved just before 60 from a similar house to a 2 bed ground floor flat and love it. They freed up money to enjoy themselves, help their children and had less home to maintain and clean.

It's such a shame that people choose to stay and struggle. I wish my parents had downsized when it would have been easier. My dad started talking about moving then mum got diagnosed with dementia at 61 so they stayed as it would be familiar for longer. I understand that decision as I moved and every time I brought her to my house it was new to her. Their house wasn't a big one but it's still not great for ageing or mobility issues. Mums gone now but dads had so many issues himself that it's just too much for him to think of.

Pythacalling702 · 24/06/2023 06:27

Could you swap houses op?

The other thing that occurred to me is: does she have very low self esteem? Is all of her “standing” in the world (from her pov) tied up in her house?

She really needs to sell up and move now (or take on a lodger who is also handy with diy) because if she is in good health she could live another 30 years by which time the house could have deteriorated very badly.

AmIbeingTreasonable · 24/06/2023 06:05

Ask her for all the money back that you've previously given her, say you need it as mortgage has risen.

ColdHandsHotHead · 24/06/2023 04:55

You have to say no. You can’t subsidise her for the rest of her life.

JoniBlue · 24/06/2023 04:48

I would tell her you are tightening your belts and want her to know that you won't be able to help her ou, but before she asks, to save awkwardness if she asks and you need to say no. You've helped a lot, but she has solutions, just hasn't tried. She may even quite like the company too, if the right person moved in.

Sugarfree23 · 24/06/2023 00:44

Just say No (where's Zammo)

Seriously, If I was your partner I'd seriously resent you giving family money away.
Anything you give is taking away from your savings or treats for your family.

The more you give into your mother the more she will ask for.

HideousKinky · 24/06/2023 00:36

She needs to downsize. This is the financial reality of her situation.

If you start giving her money this will simply delay the inevitable and leave you struggling yourself

CalmAndCosy · 24/06/2023 00:21

I recently lent my parent (also in 60s) money to help with house costs. HOWEVER this is whilst they are preparing the property for sale as they want to downsize ASAP, for the same sort of reasons that it sounds like your mum should do so too. Of course the process is stressful and takes an emotional toll, but until she commits to selling and downsizing to a financially feasible property, this house will continue to be a drain on your mum's finances (and on the finances of anyone who lends her money to stay in it indefinitely). Sorry OP, there are probably some difficult conversations to be had and I feel for you.

uncomfortablydumb53 · 24/06/2023 00:02

Just say No
Do not feel guilty, you must prioritise your own family and you don't have to justify your decision
She needs to sell up and downsize
As a parent of adult DC, I can't even imagine asking

CharChar91 · 24/06/2023 00:02

I would say to her 'Mum, our mortgage is about to go up £1000 soon, is there any way you can help us out please?'
She'll obvs say no any hopefully understand that you won't be in a position to help her.

RosesAndHellebores · 23/06/2023 23:38

@tiredmumma8696 I'm 63 and still working. DH and I live in a huge house Blush. Hell.would freeze over before we asked dd to chip in.

Hell would freeze over if dd were struggling, and we let her continue. If we didn't have the money to help but were remaining in a huge house we didn't need, hell would freeze over thrice.

Your mother is being unreasonable. Say no. Please. I would sell up in a heartbeat, and move somewhere smaller if it meant my dc and prospective gc could have a happy, secure and good life. Who wouldn't.

echt · 23/06/2023 23:27

SoWhatEh · 23/06/2023 23:23

Say no. The cost of living is rising and you can't afford to keep subbing her when there are two obvious solutions to her money problems: sell up and buy somewhere smaller, or rent out rooms to lodgers. She's a grown up and she's still young enough to be working!

The mum is working.

SoWhatEh · 23/06/2023 23:23

Say no. The cost of living is rising and you can't afford to keep subbing her when there are two obvious solutions to her money problems: sell up and buy somewhere smaller, or rent out rooms to lodgers. She's a grown up and she's still young enough to be working!

DreamTheMoors · 23/06/2023 23:22

“We simply don’t have the money, mum. If you need money, you’re going to have to suck it up like thousands upon thousands of others in your situation and sell your house and downsize. That’s the only avenue you have. We can’t afford to pay our own bills and subsidise you.”

Don’t say you’re sorry, just repeat over and over that she needs to sell if she needs money.

Maybe she won’t sell, but it might put her off of constantly badgering you.
Repeat repeat repeat.

JoniBlue · 23/06/2023 23:12

Maybe she could share the house with somebody, a senior woman on her own perhaps?

UpaladderwatchingTV · 23/06/2023 23:05

tiredmumma8696 · 23/06/2023 21:35

@UpaladderwatchingTV
Thank you for your message. Hope all goes well with the move and you settle into your new home ❤️

That's really kind of you OP. I really hope your Mum sees the light. With any luck she might have another 20 years or more, tell her to get out there, and live them, instead of relying on you to bail her out of a mess that's of her own making. Parents are the ones who are supposed to help their kids out if they can, not the other way around.

2birthdayday · 23/06/2023 22:43

Your DM can rent out a room or rooms

Viviennethebeautiful · 23/06/2023 22:41

Jeepers. I am your mums age and my dad is mid 90s. I moved to a more manageable home when I was 55. V decent, nice location but not what I had when I had two children at home (and all their friends).

dad is still in his five bed. He wants to die there. It isn’t ideal but he funds all his own bills. Who am I to say otherwise? I do have POA.

you mum is being enabled by your behaviour. You need to say no to financial bailouts She needs to play a part in her own future.

I do despair. At her age I am travelling the world, my house is in excellent order and whatever my children earn I will help them financially. Emotional help is one thing, financial help from children is a no no in this situation