Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be annoyed with people who can't afford to look after their pets

155 replies

Allelbowsandtoes · 23/06/2023 18:23

Just saw a post on Facebook, someone trying to fundraise for surgery for her 7 month old puppy that has hip dysplasia. Lots of people were commenting about how vets charge way too much and it's all a "money making racket". I pointed out that veterinary surgeons are highly skilled and train for years, and we only think its expensive because we have the NHS and mostly don't pay our own healthcare costs.

Maybe I ABU because its a shame if people can't afford pets, because they bring joy to our lives.

OP posts:
whiteroseredrose · 24/06/2023 09:09

I believe it's the pet insurance industry that has caused the massive rise in costs, (same as the US healthcare system where on an itemised bill a cotton ball was something ridiculous like $2 when you can buy a pack of 50 retail for that price).

We didn't insure DDog when we got him 15 years ago as the vet said that he heard a heart murmur that was never heard again. So we put £5k into an account.

He had a lump a few years later which the vet was pretty sure was a cyst. She asked if we had insurance because she would have sent him for a scan.

She gave me a couple of numbers to call from the waiting room to get a price - which she thought would be about £1500 but were £3-5k or £4-7k for one scan! Even the vet was shocked. I'd paid under £200 for a similar private scan myself a few weeks prior.

Insurance has made the whole thing bonkers IMO.

Maverickess · 24/06/2023 08:43

meganorks · 24/06/2023 00:08

Both can be true. Yes people should have insurance to cover illness and injury of their pets. But also, the costs are inflated because of the insurance based system. My brother's dog was ill while he was in Europe and he was shocked at how cheap an overnight stay was compared to how much it would be in the UK.
And I often see threads where people recommend just putting the money you would spend on insurance in a savings account for your pet which is very much reliant on the idea you dog will never need any treatment till it is old. Also, doesn't really make sense, as if you genuinely put that money aside, you won't have it either way, so you could have paid insurance

The thing is the money itself will be sat there to spend with no restrictions, where someone else, namely the insurance company, gets to decide if the vet will get paid by them. It's always a risk though if you've not had enough time to save a decent amount, but then if you have to find the cash to pay the vet anyway because the insurance company dick around so much then it's pretty much the same situation. There are still limitations on if it will be, or the amount to be paid when insured, and not always set by the owner by the policy they choose.

As I said in a pp, one of my dogs legs is completely exempt because about 5 years ago she ripped a dew claw, it didn't need stitches or surgery, and as the cost was only a few quid above the excess anyway, I didn't claim. I had to declare it though because it's in the terms of the policy. Vet has obviously come across this before because they put in their 'report' that there was a) no further need for treatment and b) it was a minor injury that would cause no further problems.
The insurance still exempt that leg, in an otherwise fit and healthy dog, for any reason, no other insurer will cover that leg because of the exemption from this insurer, and in fact no other insurer will cover her at all because she's now too old. It was a good, lifetime comprehensive policy that wasn't cheap when I took it out and they've gradually added more and more clauses and exemptions as she gets older, while the premium increases.
Some of the exemptions and conditions are fair enough, especially as an animal gets older, but after my own experiences and that of people I know, many times it's just an excuse to not pay out or to reduce cover while charging the same or more.

You end up paying a fortune and you're covered in actuality for very little when it comes down to it, even though you've initially taken out the right cover and you don't have a choice because they refuse the cover. Ultimately now, if my dog injured her right foreleg, no cover at all, injure one of the other 3 and she's covered. Despite the vet and the past 5 years showing that the injury caused no further problems at all.

Personally in a dog the age she is now, any serious injury to any leg and I would PTS because quality of life through recovery would likely be very poor anyway and would probably be in her best welfare interests.

Boulshired · 24/06/2023 08:30

Having insurance and knowing it’s worth the paper it’s written on is two different things, you only find out when the bill comes in. Over the years speaking to so many dog owners whilst walking the dog there are so many stories of vet bills not covered by insurance. My dog who we’ve had for 11 years was days away from being PTS in the kennels that I now volunteer in and yes some owners may not be able to pay for comprehensive insurance and there is a risk but many of these same people provide love and time. Many of the dogs saved, as there are limited spaces are undesirable breeds or unknown breeds are more often than not are saved by the elderly and the less well off, whilst those with the money spending thousands to encourage more breeding. At the kennel we of course would prefer insurance but the reality these dogs have been saved once

LaylaLjungberg · 24/06/2023 08:30

I think vets have become a racket. Since insurance came to be a must the prices have skyrocketed because they can charge insurance companies anything. I do agree that situations change and you’ll see the I bet you think people who can’t afford children shouldn’t have them get trotted out. But if I’m honest I do think people should think ahead a bit more and stop being victims of their own doing all the bloody time.

Pythacalling702 · 24/06/2023 08:02

Florenz · 24/06/2023 00:01

I have nothing against dogs but they are animals. I do have something against the way people fetishize pets nowadays. I don't know if that is the right word but I can't think of a better one.

I remember watching "All Creatures Great and Small" when I was a kid and there was an elderly woman who was always taking her dog to the vets, spoiling it with treats and talking to it like it was a child. She was a ridiculous comedy character in the show and people laughed at her and treated her as a figure of fun. But there are a lot of people like her nowadays, and they expect people to take them seriously.

I get what you are saying. I am a massive animal lover - very much interested in the physical and emotional well-being of my pets - but some people over-feed, under-exercise, over-indulge and dress up their pets in the name of “kindness” when it’s no such thing.

I can’t stand this form of anthropomorphism as it’s all about the owner and not the animal itself. One of my adopted dogs arrived with a bandana and a cute “hair cut” but it’s previous owners had basically fed him crap all of his life and neglected to walk him, socialise him, or get him the basic injections he should have had as a puppy.

A dog which “earns” its grub, is not allowed to rule the household, and lives with kind but reasonably firm boundaries to my mind anyway, is happy. And it’s appearance is not more important than it’s access to muddy trails, puddles, thick undergrowth in which to sniff out things of interest.

Also,I get that animals are life enhancing and can be comforting in the “here and now” but some people use animals to avoid life and avoid interacting with other humans, which I don’t think generally speaking is balanced or healthy, and sorry, but having lived abroad for a while, I do think there’s something wrong in our society in uk where people are prepared to pay thousands of pounds to have their dog operated on, and yet they are not prepared to pay even five quid towards the cost of a gp appointment or an ER visit, or on looking after their own health.

And yes, sorry, I would say that a pet is a blessing not a “right” and if you can’t afford to feed it reasonably well and you can’t afford to be at home to look after it or have it taken out for walks in your absence, and can’t afford basic vet care and insurance then no, you shouldn’t be taking on the care of an animal because it’s ALL about their welfare not yours.

If you intentionally give up driving a car or going on holiday in order to be able to
afford a dog or cat, then that’s fair enough, but if you can’t afford electricity or to feed and clothe your children, then no, sorry, I don’t think a pet should be a first priority.

And in the situation the op is referring to, maybe not, but I hazard a guess that the 7 month old puppy with hip dysplasia came from a puppy farm and not a reputable breeder.

Wildandwonderful · 24/06/2023 07:39

Not had time to RTFT but we need to ban backstreet breeding. Hip dysplasia is largely avoidable with testing and good breeding.

Missingmyusername · 24/06/2023 05:55

And another thing the vet doesn’t set the prices- the practice does (unless the vet owns the practice outright- unlikely). My vet is disgusted by its own surgery’s prices for god sake!

Explain that.

tabulahrasa · 24/06/2023 05:47

Redebs · 23/06/2023 20:59

You can't get pet insurance if you can't prove how old they are.

Yes you can... you just tell them it’s a rescue and give the estimated age.

I did it a few weeks ago for our newest one.

Missingmyusername · 24/06/2023 05:44

Oh and always get a prescription, your vet probably won’t bother informing you that it’s cheaper to get repeat drugs online.

Though my vet now charges £50 for a prescription. Two years ago it was £18. It’s a piece of paper …. My dog is on meds for life, but I had to fight like hell to get a prescription longer than 3 months. Not in it for the money mind 🤣🤣🤣if you say so op.

There are also “not for profit practices”. Can be hard to find and have long waiting lists. Can’t imagine why. I think pet ownership has become a luxury. Practices will close down as people will stop having pets. No wonder rescues are full. Shame.

Missingmyusername · 24/06/2023 05:37

“I pointed out that veterinary surgeons are highly skilled and train for years, and we only think it’s expensive because we have the NHS”.

This is bollocks. Vets haven’t always charged inflated prices. They simply haven’t.
Stop comparing the vets to the NHS- ridiculous, trolled out several times on mn.

Veterinary practices- the ones run by “partners/ hedge fund managers etc” who realised they can buy practices and charge what they want absolutely DO profit from overcharging. I know a vet who had her own practice, successful. Sold it but stayed employed and has walked away after seeing the utter greed, incompetence and not putting the animal first- her words. She said her late husband would be heartbroken by what had taken place.

There’s a reason they’ll ask if you have insurance, it’s often so they can max out! My dog had a £300 blood test- vet “oh I repeated it twice as your insured so that’s £600”. FFS!

YABU and very uneducated.

There are good practices and good vets. There are also shitty practices and vets. Same with every profession. We have a local vet, he owns the practice, he’s not in it for the money, doesn’t rip people off. You can’t get in to that practice for love nor money.

Anyone on benefit, you may get free/subsidised treatment via the PDSA.

Theoldgreygoose · 24/06/2023 05:24

Flamingporkpie · 23/06/2023 20:02

Completely agree with you regarding not having pets unless you can afford to look after them and that includes having to pay any potential vet bills even if they are extortionate. You either have to have the money or have insurance.

The only thing I will say is I do think vet practices charge ridiculous amounts for domestic pets just because they can. I have some livestock and they are purely pets. One of them had to have an emergency c section recently which involved a scan, x ray, complicated operation and medication. Total cost was £180!! Now just imagine if that was a cat or a dog…

I agree with you about the ridiculous amounts being charged for domestic pets just because they can. I paid $700 last year to take my cat to a vet out of hours. He had a few blood tests and was prescribed antibiotics and painkillers for an infection. Compare that to what you paid for your animal to have much more work done!

Theoldgreygoose · 24/06/2023 04:58

YANBU, but having said that vet costs have gone up a huge amount over the years (well, they have here anyway), and also animals are treated for things they wouldn't have been years ago. I don't have pet insurance, as aside from one cat who cost me a fortune the costs of insuring my cats (four at one time!) would have been far more than what I have spent on them, and it would have been the same for my dogs - and I've had a dog with epilepsy, a cat with diabetes and a dog with arthritis.

QueenBitch666 · 24/06/2023 03:44

I'd bet my butt that it's a 'pedigree' with common breeding conditions 🙄
Shame on anyone that buys from a greeder 😡

MissingMoominMamma · 24/06/2023 03:43

Took my dog to the vet in France last year. Loads cheaper than our vet here, yet the same qualifications…. 🤔

Phoebo · 24/06/2023 03:36

Like many things, it's a pity that it's not more heavily regulated. If you knew that you should have x time to spend with your pet, that they should have enough room to run around, that you need to walk them at least x times, that they will cost x a year etc. I'm not sure many people would take on the responsibility. Like most things we do to them for selfish reasons rather than altruistic ones. Particularly with dogs, it saddens me that so many people buy certain breeds knowing they have ailments or will have problems later due to their breeding.

gillefc82 · 24/06/2023 02:45

I’ve owned 3 dogs in my lifetime, one of which sadly died last March. All have been fully insured for at least £8-15k lifetime cover limits from the day they came home.

My eldest dog, Fiona has had two procedures in the six years since we rescued her - removal of a cancerous lump on her back and a laparoscopic spay with hernia repair whilst she was under anaesthesia. In total, I paid probably around £1500 across those two surgeries and treatments and was able to reclaim around £800 (relating to the lump removal).

With my dog Logan who died, his treatment, tests and stay in animal hospital, plus cost for a home visit to PTS, came to £1420. I got back £820 (lots of deductions due to individual cremation, home visit etc), plus £360 reimbursement payment due to him dying.

For me, insurance isn’t an optional expense - I consider it a mandatory part and cost of owning a dog and if I have to cut back spending elsewhere to keep affording to pay monthly premiums, then so be it.

Of course, it would be much nicer if vets and insurance companies could figure out a way to be more effective in working together to assess and approve claims so that the default is direct claim and settlement, instead of pet owners having to find the money up front and then claim back. Particularly in circumstances involving the death of a beloved pet, it’s an additional stress that isn’t needed.

Sarahtm35 · 24/06/2023 02:39

Yes I agree to a point although I think peoples circumstances can change dramatically and they can go from £150k salary to homeless overnight with the right misfortune. However it’s the idiots with the big high maintenance dogs, and the dogs with known health conditions Who are already on a low income. I also get annoyed when I see people with completely unsuitable breeds for their situation or big high energy dogs dragging their owners across fields on a lead..let your bloody dogs off they NEED to run!!. The other thing that annoys me is perfectly preened dogs on leads who aren’t allowed to get muddy or play because their owners care more about what they look like then their mental health.

MidnightMeltdown · 24/06/2023 01:52

YANBU it annoys me too.

However, I do think that some people are simply unaware of how expensive vet bills can be. We had cats when I was growing up and never had insurance for them - nobody did in those days.

When I got a kitten a couple of years ago, the vet gave me a lecture about getting insurance when I took him in for his first vaccinations, and warned me about how high vet bills can be.

I took her advice and got insurance, and I will keep it as long as he is in his prime, but I'm not sure that I would insure an older cat. Once they are past a certain age, I think it's better to PTS if they have something seriously wrong, rather than try to treat them. They aren't able to tell us when they are suffering.

Judgyjudgy · 24/06/2023 01:17

BodegaSushi · 24/06/2023 01:14

Why the fuck are children always compared to dogs?

Probably because people treat them like children 🤣

BodegaSushi · 24/06/2023 01:14

Whadda · 23/06/2023 18:24

I assume you’re equally annoyed with people who can’t afford the children they have?

Why the fuck are children always compared to dogs?

Nicecow · 24/06/2023 01:08

Ponoka7 · 24/06/2023 00:53

You don't need a garden at all. I had a GS and just a yard. He was walked, taken to large parks for off lead exercise and came camping with us.

Guess it depends on how bug yiur yard it, I think it's cruel especially for a large dog. I love dogs but have never had one for that reason.

Mademetoxic · 24/06/2023 01:06

Florenz · 23/06/2023 23:16

People have gone crazy about pets. They're animals, not people. When they get sick they need putting down, not spending thousands to prolong their lives for the benefit of the owner, not the animal. Spending £8000 a year on insurance for a pet is utter insanity.

They feel love, pain, every sentiment that we as humans do.

Are you that dense to realise this?

Emptycrackedcup · 24/06/2023 01:03

XenoBitch · 24/06/2023 00:59

Why is it wrong?
People who don't work are allowed to have pets. They don't cost you anything.
If there is something like the PDSA who can help them take part in the joy that is pet ownership, then why not?

I don't work (unable to), and I have a dog. Is that a bad thing?

Yes that's true and I can see that would be a good thing. I was talking about the many people near me who don't feed their kids, but then have huge dogs (and probably don't feed them or look after them properly either). But yes, agree that not all situations are the same.

XenoBitch · 24/06/2023 00:59

Emptycrackedcup · 24/06/2023 00:56

Of course, and I understand that. There's plenty of people where I live with multiple dogs who have never had a job which imo is wrong.

Why is it wrong?
People who don't work are allowed to have pets. They don't cost you anything.
If there is something like the PDSA who can help them take part in the joy that is pet ownership, then why not?

I don't work (unable to), and I have a dog. Is that a bad thing?

Emptycrackedcup · 24/06/2023 00:56

XenoBitch · 24/06/2023 00:55

Circumstances change.
You could go from a high earner to someone relying on PDSA in a heart beat.

Of course, and I understand that. There's plenty of people where I live with multiple dogs who have never had a job which imo is wrong.