Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be annoyed with people who can't afford to look after their pets

155 replies

Allelbowsandtoes · 23/06/2023 18:23

Just saw a post on Facebook, someone trying to fundraise for surgery for her 7 month old puppy that has hip dysplasia. Lots of people were commenting about how vets charge way too much and it's all a "money making racket". I pointed out that veterinary surgeons are highly skilled and train for years, and we only think its expensive because we have the NHS and mostly don't pay our own healthcare costs.

Maybe I ABU because its a shame if people can't afford pets, because they bring joy to our lives.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MavisMcMinty · 25/06/2023 17:29

I’m very late to this thread and haven’t read a single post apart from the thread header…

…but just wanted to say when I was working I kept horses, dogs and cats and never worried for a minute that I couldn’t afford to keep them in food and vet bills. Since retiring I have at times had to ignore their sudden limps and other injuries in the hope they’d get better on their own - they always have, so far.

Only ever had one horse insured, and that was to cover a friend who competed on her. Never made a claim in 20 years and at at its peak it cost me £60 a month, so I’ve never bothered again, it’s no bargain unless you have a chronically sick animal, and nobody buys those intentionally. Also animal insurers (and maybe people health insurers too?) will “write off” any treated/claimed for illness or injury, so recurrent e.g. tendon problems may not be claimed for.

Circumstances change, pets were never considered a “luxury” (by me anyway), and I’m actually looking forward to being pet-free in about 10 years time.

Libraryloiterer · 25/06/2023 17:16

Gymmum82 · 24/06/2023 13:54

@Libraryloiterer i said ONE of the highest. And just myself personally I know 7 people who have committed suicide. Not all men. But all of them Veterinary professionals.

That's tragic, I'm sorry

Judydoes2 · 25/06/2023 14:12

YANBU. I don't think enough people talk about how expensive it is owning a pet, and people get them without thinking about just how expensive it can get, especially when things go wrong. At the very least, if you don't have access to relatively large amounts of money, the pet should be insured. I hope the woman you mentioned finds a way of treating her puppy though :(

I have a mutt, so that in itself means she's unlikely to develop any pre-existing conditions in any one breed. I didn't insure her for this reason as well as being skeptical about pet insurance. I reconsidered this one-my parent's house is on a hill and backs onto another house, over a small fence but via a huge drop. One day I was playing ball with her in the garden and it went into the neighbour's garden and my heart stopped. Luckily she didn't jump over the fence but she could have done, perhaps really hurting herself-and I rang around insurance companies to make enquiries. None of them would insure for accidents. Their attitude was that if an accident like that happens and she needed treatment, It's my fault so they wouldn't pay out. Fair enough you may think, but accidents happen to the best of us.

So my dog still isn't insured, unlikely to need treatment for illness and insurers won't pay out for accidents HOWEVER I have savings and credit cards with huge limits -if something did go wrong I could afford it to sort it and I would. I've thought it through, many don't.

My skepticism about insurance is borne from other people's experiences, I know a fair few people whose pets have needed treatment and insurers have 'smallprint' which means they've refused to pay out. My friend fought tooth and nail about hip dysplasia when it happened to her dog, insurers stating they'd not pay at first (I can't remember the ins and outs of why). A family member's dog developed a gum condition and the insurance didn't cover it.

Some people seem to factor in costs of food and upkeep and care but not think about illness and accidents. Vets deserve to be paid fairly. I hear of too many stories like this when people just don't have the money and haven't considered that they might need plans for circumstantial change when it comes to pets.

Ilovetea42 · 25/06/2023 13:42

Nicecow · 24/06/2023 01:08

Guess it depends on how bug yiur yard it, I think it's cruel especially for a large dog. I love dogs but have never had one for that reason.

It depends on how much time you're prepared to spend exercising your pet. We have a high energy breed and a small garden. We use a daycare a few times a week to let him socialise and run off steam, then the other days we take him out for a few hours to local forest trails/ parks/ hiking etc and do lots of scent work and let him run provided it's safe to do so. He only uses our garden for his toilet because he wants to be with us inside. If you're relying on your garden for stimulation and space to play then yes you'd need a big one but few homes have that now especially around city areas.

redboxer321 · 25/06/2023 12:44

Rainrainstayawaytilseptember · 23/06/2023 18:42

Years ago our dpuppy had HD. Despite surgery she had a miserable life. My dm taught me it is never OK to allow a dpet to suffer because you are too selfish to pts...

This. I think something has got to be done about people who refuse to see that their pet is suffering or can't face up to what they need to do.
It's one of the hardest decisions many of us have to make but make it we must.

Nicecow · 25/06/2023 12:36

WowIlikereallyhateyou · 24/06/2023 13:58

DONT GET A PET IF YOU HAVE NO MONEY FOR A RAINY DAY OR A FINANCIAL BACK UP THEN.

Fair point

Maverickess · 24/06/2023 15:33

summerpug · 24/06/2023 14:21

But …that’s great in theory ,but in practice,the vets refused to put my dog down
he had Alabama rot and cushings …because of the cushings the vets couldn’t treat the Alabama rot as he needed steroids ..
I had a long meeting with the vets saying he needed to be put down ..they refused and wanted to send him to a specialist vet half way across the country,on his own …at this point they had him in the vets in a tiny cage trying different things ,they had had him in over a week already ..
they wouldn’t give him back for me to take to another vets nor would they put him down .
by the time they finally agreed to PTS ,he was half dead anyway
the cost was close to £6,000 just after 2 weeks of vet intervention
thank god I had Tesco insurance who paid out without a quibble .
so ….thinking your going to have your animal PTS when u decide,…if u get a vets practice like we did ,it may not happen..had I of not had pet insurance,I’d still be paying that bill of now

That's appalling and to be honest I'd have seriously considered reporting that to the RCVS.

With the older dog no longer with me I mentioned upthread, I felt I was talked into the surgery she had, because I did consider PTS, tried antibiotics and pain relief and cleaning but it didn't work and then the options were surgery or PTS.
The dog was 16, had CCD (dementia) and was starting to fail and I regret the surgery because she just never recovered, was PTS a month later and suffered for that month. My instinct was to PTS, but the vet was very positive about the surgery and recovery, I'm careful to say I wasn't pushed and the decision was mine, and while they didn't refuse to PTS, they were reluctant without trying surgery.

I didn't get the impression though that it was to make money, more that they truly believed they could save the dog and fix the problem - but failed to consider that maybe that wasn't in the dogs best interests as recovery was the issue due to her decline anyway, age and the CCD.

I'm really sorry that happened to you and your dog, I'd have been beside myself.

I've recently faced a very similar situation with a different animal and I chose to PTS before it got to the point where quality of life was severely compromised, it was heartbreaking but the right decision because it was only going one way. I could have been thinking I'd 'saved' him, I'd given him 6 more months, or another summer but ultimately what for? For him to decline further, suffer more and the end result to be the same anyway, and possibly in traumatic circumstances in an absolute emergency.

I'm sorry for your loss 💐

summerpug · 24/06/2023 14:21

willstarttomorrow · 23/06/2023 20:30

Having a pet is expensive and as a kitten/cat foster person I do get very annoyed. I also have been a front line child child protection worker for nearly 2 decades and I have seen far too many dogs kept in kitchens/cats that have not been neutered having endless kittens/lone rabbits kept in tiny hutches etc.

However, I have grown up with animals and all were taken to the vets when needed, no insurance. We had rescue moggies, paired guinea pigs and my mum seemed to rescue every rabbit needing rehoming within a 20 mile radius who then hopped around the house or had the run of half the garden which was bunny proofed. The reason it was affordable is that they were treated if it was something simple or if not PTS.

I have an old girl tabby who turned up in our garden without a chip. She is not insured because at the time she turned up I could not afford to insure her. She has been here 8 years and has a pampered and happy life. When her time comes, she will be PTS. We adore her but spending several 1000s on an animal in pain, particularly when the treatment itself can be horrific, is more about the owner needs than that of the pet.

But …that’s great in theory ,but in practice,the vets refused to put my dog down
he had Alabama rot and cushings …because of the cushings the vets couldn’t treat the Alabama rot as he needed steroids ..
I had a long meeting with the vets saying he needed to be put down ..they refused and wanted to send him to a specialist vet half way across the country,on his own …at this point they had him in the vets in a tiny cage trying different things ,they had had him in over a week already ..
they wouldn’t give him back for me to take to another vets nor would they put him down .
by the time they finally agreed to PTS ,he was half dead anyway
the cost was close to £6,000 just after 2 weeks of vet intervention
thank god I had Tesco insurance who paid out without a quibble .
so ….thinking your going to have your animal PTS when u decide,…if u get a vets practice like we did ,it may not happen..had I of not had pet insurance,I’d still be paying that bill of now

Allelbowsandtoes · 24/06/2023 14:15

Also I've learned a lot through this about how crap the pet insurance industry can be....which is shit! I'd always had them pay out without any issue which maybe skewed my view of things

OP posts:
Allelbowsandtoes · 24/06/2023 14:14

Fallenangelofthenorth · 24/06/2023 13:52

You don't know the dog isn't insured though. Could be underinsured. Either way I'm sure she regrets it now, and isn't it better to show compassion rather than hatred?

Of course you're right, although I'm not sure I've been hateful- just annoyed.
I've read through a lot of these comments and I hadn't realised that some veterinary practices charge so outrageously or suggest things that aren't needed, I've always found vets to be helpful and trying to keep costs down where they can - probably naive of me to think that this is always the case.
I also agree with whichever PP it was who said that pets shouldn't be a luxury, only affordable for the middle and upper classes.
From reading everyone's replies and thinking on it more I guess what annoys me most is when people buy these poor overbred animals which go on to develop health issues which a normal mongrel dog wouldn't, and then cant afford the treatment.

OP posts:
WowIlikereallyhateyou · 24/06/2023 13:58

Starhead69 · 23/06/2023 18:48

FINANCIAL SITUATIONS CHANGE

DONT GET A PET IF YOU HAVE NO MONEY FOR A RAINY DAY OR A FINANCIAL BACK UP THEN.

Gymmum82 · 24/06/2023 13:54

@Libraryloiterer i said ONE of the highest. And just myself personally I know 7 people who have committed suicide. Not all men. But all of them Veterinary professionals.

Fallenangelofthenorth · 24/06/2023 13:52

You don't know the dog isn't insured though. Could be underinsured. Either way I'm sure she regrets it now, and isn't it better to show compassion rather than hatred?

Artoodeetoo · 24/06/2023 13:40

Libraryloiterer · 24/06/2023 13:33

They have elevated rates of suicide but not the highest, or not in the UK at least. That would be people (usually men) in low skilled labouring and construction roles.

PP said ONE of the highest, which is true according to ONS.

Libraryloiterer · 24/06/2023 13:33

Gymmum82 · 23/06/2023 18:39

Yanbu. Obviously there are exceptions but someone who has spend £3k or more on a puppy relatively recently and then can’t afford to treat said puppy absolutely boils my piss.

And of course it’s always the money grabbing vets fault 🙄 no wonder they have one of the highest suicide rates of any profession.
I utterly despise people sometimes

They have elevated rates of suicide but not the highest, or not in the UK at least. That would be people (usually men) in low skilled labouring and construction roles.

thetemptationofchocolate · 24/06/2023 13:23

I have a pet here who is uninsurable. He's had so much wrong with him that no insurer in their right mind would take him on. I've had lots of pets like that, and for those I do have savings to cover vet bills. None of them have gone without for lack of funds.

It's when our pets get older that insurance becomes difficult. They obviously get more things going wrong, so the cost of the policy goes up, and the cover decreases.

Artoodeetoo · 24/06/2023 12:58

Lots of people are ignorant to the potential cost of animals before they get them, especially cats etc which you can often get for free. It's different if your financial situation drastically changes through no fault of your own, but people who knowingly do so are selfish.

User087 · 24/06/2023 12:42

Mademetoxic · 24/06/2023 01:06

They feel love, pain, every sentiment that we as humans do.

Are you that dense to realise this?

So do pigs, sheep and cows. I assume you're a vegetarian?

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 24/06/2023 09:40

I see both sides of this argument.

Pets aren't a right or a necessity and nobody should knowingly take on an animal when they can't afford it.

But insurance doesn't cover everything - dental is often something people get caught out with as many policies don't cover basic dental care or removal.

And it's not always as straightforward as saying "don't have a pet you can't afford" - circumstances change and prices rise.

Ginmonkeyagain · 24/06/2023 09:39

I grew up on a farm and we always had dogs and cats. The dogs were working dogs mainly.

I don't remember a lot of vet visits but farmers are very adept at treating minor injuries and will have stocks of things like pencillin at home.

Also farmers tend to be practical and older sick animals would be humanely put to sleep. We had a much loved older dog who developed back problems and double incontinence, my parents lost no time in putting him to sleep.

SilverTotoro · 24/06/2023 09:31

While I absolutely agree people should work out costs and of course take out insurance, I do think the OP hasn’t quite experienced how difficult insurance can be for pre existing conditions and those instances that exceed insurance premiums.

It cost us 3000 this year for one of our rescues because the insurer found a loophole in their preconditions. Luckily we could afford this but I can quite see how given rising costs lots of people might struggle.

Similarly if the lady crowd funding took a rehomed dog straight to the vets (which is a sensible thing to do) then any insurance she had put in place would likely not have kicked in as it’s common not to be able to claim in the first two weeks - it would then likely be listed as a pre-existing condition and be excluded.

whiteroseredrose · 24/06/2023 09:20

Florenz · 24/06/2023 09:17

If being a vet is so lucrative, I would think a lot more people would be looking to train to be vets. Maybe some of the people would would have been doctors will switch to veterinarian because of the big money to be made in that sector.

I don't think that it's the vets making the money. Our vet costs were always reasonable. It was cost of services that are not in-house, like the scan I mentioned, that are exorbitant.

Florenz · 24/06/2023 09:17

If being a vet is so lucrative, I would think a lot more people would be looking to train to be vets. Maybe some of the people would would have been doctors will switch to veterinarian because of the big money to be made in that sector.

Barleysugar86 · 24/06/2023 09:12

Rainrainstayawaytilseptember · 23/06/2023 18:42

Years ago our dpuppy had HD. Despite surgery she had a miserable life. My dm taught me it is never OK to allow a dpet to suffer because you are too selfish to pts...

As an adult human with Hip Dysplasia/ surgery treated I can't imagine this is true. it's affected my life sure but it's still been a happy one even with ongoing twinges and tweaks. Dogs are so resilient I imagine they'd cope better than humans do anyway 😂

C1N1C · 24/06/2023 09:11

I actually have a very black and white view on this. You should not take on a life without an untouchable fund in the bank to support it. The cost of a cat over a lifetime is around £10k. Why should a life suffer because of your mistakes?

Mortgages and things are different. Virtually everyone has to go into debt to pay for a house... but for pets (etc), you shouldn't be having one unless you can guarantee their wellbeing.

Unpopular opinion :)