Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask why this isn't being addressed as a huge sexist issue that frankly shits on women completely?!

240 replies

howaboutl · 23/06/2023 15:21

I know some men are in this position but let’s be honest, it’s mostly women. Why isn’t there outrage about this? If there is how do I join and help make change?

My ex partner walked out on me and dd when she was 1. He doesn’t see her, his choice entirely. He has no other children and doesn’t live with any other children. I am left to pay a childcare bill of 1,300 alone, while he contributes 500 quid when he is working. He works on temporary contracts so now and then I receive nothing despite him having in excess of 100k savings.

How is this accepted that I pay our child’s childcare bill alone? Is it just that there aren’t actually that many women (or men to lesser extent) in this situation so nothing is down about it because in the grand scheme of things we are a minority?

I cannot understand why I am expected to pay for OUR child’s nursery bill so we can both work? Why am I footing the bill for this and he is not?

OP posts:
MarmaladeAndToast · 24/06/2023 04:39

Twocrabs20 · 23/06/2023 17:29

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz

“He works on temporary contracts so now and then I receive nothing despite him having in excess of 100k savings

Obviously too late now, but this is why these boards are full of women saying "marry before kids". Half of his assets minimum would have been available as part of a divorce settlement.“

…But again, this is just another example of the way in which UK legislation hasn’t caught up to protect women.

In countries like Australia, Australian law generally treats unmarried spouses in a de facto relationship in the same way that it treats married spouses. So after 6 months - 2 years of residing together, a non-married partner can make a claim on the shared assets, especially with regard to looking after children.

UK law is a disgrace with regards to protecting single mothers. The child maintenance scheme is an absolute disgrace also; too many mothers get nothing and are left to carry the financial and practical burden of raising children which is enormous.

Your anger is rightly placed. The pendulum has swung to far with regard to Parliamentary laws protecting men’s interests. There needs to be a massive revolution with regards to changes to laws for how children are financially supported.

Yes it’s a joke. My ex, despite picking up a new job six months ago, had not contributed. The CMS told me that their policy was to write off anything owed for more than three months..

meanwhile as single mother, I have to pay all debts and bills..

Can you imagine me asking my credit card company to write off any debts older than three months? They would laugh in my face.

MarmaladeAndToast · 24/06/2023 04:34

Blackbyrd · 23/06/2023 15:57

Can I just add that when an absent parent is on benefits, their child maintenance is an insulting £6 odd a week. Yet this deduction from benefits is deemed the very lowest priority and very often isn't taken if other deductions are due ie utility debts, court fees etc. So men quite often deliberately rack up debts by not paying their share of council tax, rent etc to avoid paying even that paltry child maintenance amount. It should be a priority debt and always deducted

I’ve got £7.50 from my ex for two kids. :-D

pinkginfizz9 · 24/06/2023 04:23

Don't you get to claim all the tax credits for childcare without your dad contributions to the household pot even being taken into account?

Makemyday99 · 24/06/2023 02:35

RosaGallica · 24/06/2023 02:04

I can answer the question in your op very easily and simply. Because we live in a sexist country. Women have always been screwed by the males we give life to. We take huge risks for them in birth and then they grow up to arrogantly presume that we will always and should always do so, supported by other males who collectively force their will with muscle power. We need to fight back or let this most disgusting of species die out.

Very well put but as mothers of sons generally do you think that we perpetuate that otherwise how does it exist?

RosaGallica · 24/06/2023 02:04

I can answer the question in your op very easily and simply. Because we live in a sexist country. Women have always been screwed by the males we give life to. We take huge risks for them in birth and then they grow up to arrogantly presume that we will always and should always do so, supported by other males who collectively force their will with muscle power. We need to fight back or let this most disgusting of species die out.

Makemyday99 · 24/06/2023 01:42

I’m absolutely shocked by how many women have been ‘shafted’ by the men they had kids with. My kids Dad was very fair with maintenance so I didn’t have to do it via cms, he is self employed so we came to an agreement because he wanted to ensure kids were cared for properly financially not by a computer calculation. We agreed 50/50 residency (we live close by) as it was in their best interests & it worked for years until they were adults. I’m really sorry for mums that go through BS financially & struggled to get a decent amount to raise their children..eye opener for sure

DifficultBloodyWoman · 24/06/2023 00:21

SueVineer · 23/06/2023 22:15

Marriage should be irrelevant when it comes to financial responsibility for your kids.

Agreed.

I truly believe that deadbeat parents (yes, it’s almost always the dads) should be jailed for not contributing towards their children’s upbringing. And I think the CSA/CMS or whatever initials are currently being used should be taken over by HMRC.

BelieveThemtheFirstTime · 24/06/2023 00:02

BibbleandSqwauk · 23/06/2023 22:32

@BelieveThemtheFirstTime oh I agree, they'd do it if they absolutely had to, but in the meantime how many balls get dropped and experiences, costumes, trips, correct equipment etc missed, and that's just the trivial stuff. My ex isn't at all involved in that aspect, though he was when we were together..to go back to the "you should have picked better" theme...he genuinely was great, until he wasn't.
To the pp who said working out agreed costs is too difficult, well that's just a weak position that basically says its easier to let women be continually screwed over then actually put in the legwork to figure it out. If there has to be unfairness, I'd rather rather it was skewed in favour of the RP who is actually providing all the meaningful parenting, than a Disney eow dad. At least then the child gets decently provided for.

Sometimes you have to let the balls drop. The kids will be fine. Maybe these fathers
need to see the disappointment in their children’s faces for them in order for them to shape up.

For the record, I would never say “You should have chosen better” to anyone. That’s red pill/misogyny speak!
I’ve been there and luckily got out. I speak from experience and would never allow myself to go back there. Unfortunately, I learnt the hard way. Fortunately, I learnt early enough.

PurpleBugz · 23/06/2023 23:01

I know this thread is on cost of childcare but I think literal childcare should be tackled too.

My ex does pay the minimum maintenance he has to. But won't take time off work to look after our disabled child. I've had to quit work to care for him. My whole future earning gone, no pension etc etc etc. maintenance only lasts while this kid is a child I'm not sure my care responsibilities end there. I'm poor for life whe I wasn't just as well as ex pre kids. my ex moves on with life and because he has his challenging kiddo every other week is lauded a saint for doing so much.

Ex can refuse to care for his kid but when I go to social services say I need help I can't do this please take him so I can have a break and be able to cope they come at me from child protection point of view. They don't have any concerns about the father who refuses to step up. Didn't even talk to him it's just expected this child is mum's problem

It's wrong. Children are our blessing but they should not be the end to our independence. Men need to be answerable

PurpleBugz · 23/06/2023 22:52

NettleTea · 23/06/2023 17:28

see Id also like to see the father's company split the cost of maternity leave too - he cant actually CARRY the baby, and yes I know there now is an arrangement to split leave (although in early days its still likely to be the mother) but I think it would be interesting to see if the promotions and opportunities that seem to start slowing down women's career progressions when she is of an age where she MIGHT be considering children would be less impacted if the maternity costs were balanced between both parents.

because we know that they are not allowed to ASK if you are planning a family, but it doesnt stop them considering it, and Im pretty sure that Ive heard that its regarded as detrimental to women, yet a bonus for men, to have children.

That maternity burden could also include some pension contribution too. Balance the gap up, and take it at souce so that women are not penalised for carrying a child created by both sexes

This is an absolutely brilliant idea

Twocrabs20 · 23/06/2023 22:46

@SueVineer

I agree it’s not about marriage. It’s about every aspect of our social / cultural / familial / working environments which mean women are left with lesser resources but having to do so much heavy lifting, especially with the care of children.

And I think we need to target all aspects of our social / cultural / familial / working environments to create change for better support, entitlements and protections for women.

For eg, Women in defacto relationships (including those who have children) do not have legal and/or financial protections for their often non-financial contribution. As compared to if they were married. This issue disproportionately impacts women to men. This is unacceptable.

Culturally, that men in defacto or married relationships more often than not have weaponised incompetence and don’t do their fair share of domestic and caring work - again, unacceptable.

And it makes me despair. There needs to be a reckoning and honest conversations about how to make changes in all these environments to improve the lived experiences of women, and for all.

As a society we have stalled in making progress in chipping away at the structures that keep women disadvantaged.

BibbleandSqwauk · 23/06/2023 22:32

@BelieveThemtheFirstTime oh I agree, they'd do it if they absolutely had to, but in the meantime how many balls get dropped and experiences, costumes, trips, correct equipment etc missed, and that's just the trivial stuff. My ex isn't at all involved in that aspect, though he was when we were together..to go back to the "you should have picked better" theme...he genuinely was great, until he wasn't.
To the pp who said working out agreed costs is too difficult, well that's just a weak position that basically says its easier to let women be continually screwed over then actually put in the legwork to figure it out. If there has to be unfairness, I'd rather rather it was skewed in favour of the RP who is actually providing all the meaningful parenting, than a Disney eow dad. At least then the child gets decently provided for.

SueVineer · 23/06/2023 22:18

Twocrabs20 · 23/06/2023 21:50

@IceCreamQueen86

But then defacto couples can get protections from arranging a binding financial arrangement before they move in or before the 6 months period is reached.

A Binding Financial Agreement takes into account what each person brings into the relationship, their contributions during the relationship and other conditions that would come into effect, for example, such as the birth of any children.

And if either partner wants one, it forces a conversation about your respective contributions and what is ‘fair’ going forward.

I think the current status quo of non-married women so often carrying the domestic load, caring load and left with nothing in unmarried relationships can’t continue; and is immoral and too often leaves women in perilous circumstances.

It’s not about marriage. I was the higher earner and was better off not married. It’s not about women needing men to support them - it’s about men not carrying their share of the responsibility for their own children. And not being forced to do so by the state or society.

SueVineer · 23/06/2023 22:15

Northernparent68 · 23/06/2023 18:20

In “countries like Australia, Australian law generally treats unmarried spouses in a de facto relationship in the same way that it treats married spouses. So after 6 months - 2 years of residing together, a non-married partner can make a claim on the shared assets, especially with regard to looking after children. “

the problem with the above is it forces the consequences of marriage on people who’ve chosen not to get married.

Marriage should be irrelevant when it comes to financial responsibility for your kids.

Twocrabs20 · 23/06/2023 21:50

@IceCreamQueen86

But then defacto couples can get protections from arranging a binding financial arrangement before they move in or before the 6 months period is reached.

A Binding Financial Agreement takes into account what each person brings into the relationship, their contributions during the relationship and other conditions that would come into effect, for example, such as the birth of any children.

And if either partner wants one, it forces a conversation about your respective contributions and what is ‘fair’ going forward.

I think the current status quo of non-married women so often carrying the domestic load, caring load and left with nothing in unmarried relationships can’t continue; and is immoral and too often leaves women in perilous circumstances.

BibMeUp · 23/06/2023 21:28

Mumuser124 · 23/06/2023 19:26

@BibMeUp

The reality is, that money is his partners and has nothing really to do with you. If she wants to use her money to treat her partner to a holiday then she should be able to. It doesn’t matter that you don’t get to go on a holiday because she’s not your partner. It’s just the brutal reality of spliting when you have kids unfortunately.

I know this is the rule, but it’s complete bullshit and needs to change. I just don’t agree with it.

If the ex’s new woman has any kids of her own living with them, those kids get taken into account on the calculation. But when calculating what your ex owes to you, all of a sudden they are not a financial unit?

It is the brutal reality of marrying a divorced man, I think. He has commitments and those commitments become your problem too.

My ex has shacked up with someone that is monied and now his household income is over £100,000. It’s an absolute disgrace that he doesn’t owe on this total, when he is enjoying all the benefits of it.

BelieveThemtheFirstTime · 23/06/2023 21:19

BibbleandSqwauk · 23/06/2023 20:18

You cannot "legally impose" actual day to day parenting on someone who doesn't want it. Can you imagine the kind of childhood that would create? I don't disagree it could be imposed if one parent was trying to block it for no good reason, but not forced on an unwilling participant...eg a man with the "big job" who has been used to swanning in and out for the fun bits and doesn't know a school comms app from his arsehole.

I agree. I wouldn’t force my DC to spend time with anyone who doesn’t want them, including their Father. Not the case here as our DC are very close to their Father.

But, the problem is the fact that these men have been allowed to get away with not being involved in the day-to-day running of their children’s lives, downloading school apps, etc.
We both work. I work PT in a pressured role. DP is the higher earner and owns multiple businesses. I make sure DP receives all the school communication I receive, has the school apps, I send him calendar invites re. all child related, health appointments, activities, school events/dates, the school runs he’s agreed to do for our youngest DC, etc. School admin from two schools is a lot to keep up with, so it’s only fair that DP is bombarded with it all too! Hopefully, between the two of us we won’t miss anything important.

Don’t be under any illusion that if these seemingly incompetent and clueless men had to work out recognise a school app from their arseholes for their employers, they’d work it out super fast! It’s called weaponised incompetence. Start dropping phrases such as these into conversations with your children’s Fathers whenever they claim to not have a clue, they’ve forgotten and/or say you’re better at the task at hand.

E.g., When DP phones or messages me whilst I’m working to query our DC’s term dates for what seems like the hundredth time, I simply tell him I’m busy and remind him that the dates are already in his Calendar. Just throw it back.

Another example from this week - DP rang me to tell me he was running late to collect DC from school and was seeking clarity on what the school procedure would be. I told him to call the school. I was not WFH on that day, and was at my office 60 mins away.

Makemyday99 · 23/06/2023 21:10

BibbleandSqwauk · 23/06/2023 20:18

You cannot "legally impose" actual day to day parenting on someone who doesn't want it. Can you imagine the kind of childhood that would create? I don't disagree it could be imposed if one parent was trying to block it for no good reason, but not forced on an unwilling participant...eg a man with the "big job" who has been used to swanning in and out for the fun bits and doesn't know a school comms app from his arsehole.

I understand that but I also don’t think you can impose nursery fees that are unilaterally decided by one parent, in an ideal world parenting should be discussed & shared, sadly it’s not so who knows the answer..certainly not me

BibbleandSqwauk · 23/06/2023 20:18

You cannot "legally impose" actual day to day parenting on someone who doesn't want it. Can you imagine the kind of childhood that would create? I don't disagree it could be imposed if one parent was trying to block it for no good reason, but not forced on an unwilling participant...eg a man with the "big job" who has been used to swanning in and out for the fun bits and doesn't know a school comms app from his arsehole.

Makemyday99 · 23/06/2023 20:12

BibbleandSqwauk · 23/06/2023 20:05

@Makemyday99 but so many fathers who leave do not want 50/50 and it doesn't suit all children either. If an NRP only sees their child eow which is do often the case they should be able to do a damn sight better than minimum wage. The RPs earning potential is frequently severely impaired by not being able to long hours, overnight trips, late meetings etc but an NRP has no such constraints.

Of course I get that, I’m not trying to diminish the responsibility of the nrp (lets face it mostly fathers) I’m purely trying to give example of how imposing shared childcare fees wouldn’t necessarily work. Fwiw my ex had our kids 50/50 for the entirety of their childhood & spent a hell of a lot more money on his time than I was able to so not all men are crap although I understand that it’s unique. I think 50/50 residency should be legally imposed rather than constant fighting over money which majority of mothers end up at the brunt end.

BibbleandSqwauk · 23/06/2023 20:05

@Makemyday99 but so many fathers who leave do not want 50/50 and it doesn't suit all children either. If an NRP only sees their child eow which is do often the case they should be able to do a damn sight better than minimum wage. The RPs earning potential is frequently severely impaired by not being able to long hours, overnight trips, late meetings etc but an NRP has no such constraints.

Makemyday99 · 23/06/2023 19:55

howaboutl · 23/06/2023 16:10

@Makemyday99 do you mean off set it as in the child Maintenance happened to cover half the nursery fees with some left over? My point there would be that the child is a joint expense and it isn’t the resident parent’s role to financially support their ex partner, so they must find the funds just as the mother has to (or father, I know it’s not always the mother).

As for whether the mother was wealthier I guess my sentiment still stands that it isn’t her problem to support her ex partner financially but if he actually couldn’t afford to live then I suppose there would be a cut off. I think we can all agree that earnings over 25k can include nursery fees, for example.

For me it is the fact that it is just totally abandoned as an issue. Not even a standard contribution amount is set as a bare minimum. The issue is simply ignored.

Yes that’s what I meant. I definitely think that both parents should be jointly responsible for any childcare to facilitate both of them working but I also think there should be a cut off..if a parent only earns min wage full time then take home after tax would be around £1650 so if child maintenance is approx £250 a month for 1 child & then child is in nursery FT that could then be approx £700 a month on top so non resident parent would have to pay £950 a month which leaves them £700 a month..nobody can survive on that single or not so it has to be reasonable & not imposed as 50% of fees as thats absurd. I think 50/50 residency is the realistic answer

BelieveThemtheFirstTime · 23/06/2023 19:53

Marriage is a financial contract, where men seem to get most out of it financially, due to the sacrifices and unpaid labour that women overwhelmingly contribute to marriages.

The big white Disney dress Wedding Day is an expensive and commercial ploy to draw unsuspecting women in. Then in most cases, we’re well and truly fucked. Women should never give up their financial independence. Always have options. Money gives you options and autonomy over your own life, especially when things got tits up.

IceCreamQueen86 · 23/06/2023 19:32

Twocrabs20 · 23/06/2023 17:29

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz

“He works on temporary contracts so now and then I receive nothing despite him having in excess of 100k savings

Obviously too late now, but this is why these boards are full of women saying "marry before kids". Half of his assets minimum would have been available as part of a divorce settlement.“

…But again, this is just another example of the way in which UK legislation hasn’t caught up to protect women.

In countries like Australia, Australian law generally treats unmarried spouses in a de facto relationship in the same way that it treats married spouses. So after 6 months - 2 years of residing together, a non-married partner can make a claim on the shared assets, especially with regard to looking after children.

UK law is a disgrace with regards to protecting single mothers. The child maintenance scheme is an absolute disgrace also; too many mothers get nothing and are left to carry the financial and practical burden of raising children which is enormous.

Your anger is rightly placed. The pendulum has swung to far with regard to Parliamentary laws protecting men’s interests. There needs to be a massive revolution with regards to changes to laws for how children are financially supported.

NO NO NO!

If a person wants the protection of marriage then they should bloody well get married - they have that choice!

Why the hell should those us who are deliberately NOT getting* *married in order to protect ourselves financially be drawn into a de facto marriage & put ourselves at financial risk? Why should our choice be taken away because others make poor decisions?

Mumuser124 · 23/06/2023 19:26

@BibMeUp

The reality is, that money is his partners and has nothing really to do with you. If she wants to use her money to treat her partner to a holiday then she should be able to. It doesn’t matter that you don’t get to go on a holiday because she’s not your partner. It’s just the brutal reality of spliting when you have kids unfortunately.