Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask why this isn't being addressed as a huge sexist issue that frankly shits on women completely?!

240 replies

howaboutl · 23/06/2023 15:21

I know some men are in this position but let’s be honest, it’s mostly women. Why isn’t there outrage about this? If there is how do I join and help make change?

My ex partner walked out on me and dd when she was 1. He doesn’t see her, his choice entirely. He has no other children and doesn’t live with any other children. I am left to pay a childcare bill of 1,300 alone, while he contributes 500 quid when he is working. He works on temporary contracts so now and then I receive nothing despite him having in excess of 100k savings.

How is this accepted that I pay our child’s childcare bill alone? Is it just that there aren’t actually that many women (or men to lesser extent) in this situation so nothing is down about it because in the grand scheme of things we are a minority?

I cannot understand why I am expected to pay for OUR child’s nursery bill so we can both work? Why am I footing the bill for this and he is not?

OP posts:
Nepmarthiturn · 25/06/2023 11:50

@ThursdayFreedom see my posts below. If CMS rates are set at an appropriate level and non-payment is criminalised and pursued with the same vigour as tax evasion - with similar criminal penalties including imprisonment - then the desire to attempt this would reduce significantly (currently people know they can do so with minimal, if any consequence).

We have people imprisoned for non-payment of Council tax even. It is a choice for society to accept non-payment of your share of your child's costs as a less serious offence. Even the US enforces child maintenance payments far, far more robustly, and at much more significant percentages of earnings.

If taxes can be applied and pursued and under-declarations of income investigated and punished and absconders pursued abroad, there is no reason the same can't be done for child maintenance.

ThursdayFreedom · 25/06/2023 11:40

howaboutl · 23/06/2023 16:00

@Makemyday99 I think there is an easy way to calculate it. Get the average cost of nursery on the days the resident parent is working, then divide by two and make payment direct to the nursery. Men need to start being forced to behave decently.

How exactly??

it's all very well saying that & writing to your MO, but HOW do YOU think people can be forced to step up?

Nepmarthiturn · 25/06/2023 11:32

And then make a huge amount of media noise about them doing so, if they continue to vote through a Government budget bill again which doesn't change these tax rules, after this being a breach of the Equality Act has been pointed out to them.

Mumsnet and some of the women and children's charities should have lawyers who'd be able to get onto such a campaign? You'd hope! I can't think of many more worthy causes that affect women's lives to such a hugr extent and would have such an enormous impact just from making these very simple changes to tax law.

Nepmarthiturn · 25/06/2023 11:27

Yes someone like Marcus Rashford could give this a lot of publicity. Having been raised by a single mother he might be interested in it. It might also help to shame female MPs into action that they have ignored the issue and a young man is able to grasp a feminist issue and the deliberate penalisation of women when they have not...

One other thing that baffles me is that I thought that when a bill goes through Parliament there was a required to analyse whether it complies with the Equality Act 2010 or whether it discriminates against anybody with a protected characteristic. It is quite clear that the tax rules we have constitute indirect discrimination against women for the reasons I've stated (nearly 90% of resident single parents being women). So therefore when the budget is passed each year and these discriminatory rules are tacitly reconfirmed as Parliament passes that budget bill without making any changes to them, where is that Equality Act analysis of compliance? This us one way that a campaign could pressure for change: to point out to the MPs that they cannot vote in favour of any Government budget bill without breaching the Equality Act.

BelieveThemtheFirstTime · 25/06/2023 11:21

*although I think

BelieveThemtheFirstTime · 25/06/2023 11:21

Nepmarthiturn · 25/06/2023 11:00

It will take some campaigning to change it. I don't think a petition will do much: even if it gets enough signatures to be discussed in Parliament, no change would come from that discussion. What is needed is a concerted campaign from women's charities, children's charities and Mumsnet to hammer this home to politicians in every interview of meeting they have with them and press for a commitment to get this into next year's election manifestos: a commitment to immediately make these changes to the tax system and to criminalise non-payment of CMS, while increasing the rate of CMS substantially to somewhere more than a pittance.

I agree that a petition won’t change much, allow I think it should still be created.

As you said it would require women’s and children’s charities, Mumsnet, etc to pick it up and run with it.
Imagine a big celebrity/personality getting involved, such as Marcus Rashford MBE who shamed the Goverment by taking action, and which resulted in school children continuing to receive free meals during the school holidays.

@Mumsnet ?

Nepmarthiturn · 25/06/2023 11:15

And in terms of avoiding CMS through self-employment, a robust regime could address this as it does with tax: if HMRC deem someone's lifestyle not supportable from the income they have declared, and investigation ensues and criminal charges will be brought.

Same with moving abroad: systems exist to chase someone absconding abroad to avoid a tax liability, or indeed even student loan repayments.

It's harder but by no means impossible to implement systems to address this and make it clear that it is socially and legally unacceptable and will be pursued and punished. What is needed for that are new laws criminalising it and a CMS with far more resources and teeth, linked up to other agencies like HMRC to share information etc. That would also discourage such behaviour as absent parents would know non- or under-payment of CMS might lead to an HMRC investigation into their undeclared taxable income as well!!

So the excuses abound, but are nonsense. It's simply a matter of a lack of political will to address is hence my belief that the only way to change it would be some organisations with clout and access to politicians and the media making a lot of noise about it and a sustained campaign to publicise the issues until there is a commitment to change it all.

The tax system changes I proposed - a simple doubling of the allowances and thresholds for single adult households - is SO easy to implement, a very simple change to tax law. And there really is no justification for NOT doing it given the data over many years from other countries showing this works, and actually pays for itself in the long-term because you have better child outcomes (so less state reliance, better health and more productivity from them as adults) and it also means it is easier for single parents to work, again productivity increase plus less reliance from those parents on the state both now and later in life (to top up lost pension incomes, etc).

It's a no brainer really from a moral and financial point of view so really the ONLY reason it's not being done is misogyny, plus the fact that single parents - the ones who are responsible and stick around and do the work of two adults - are demonised rather than applauded and nobody wants to be seen to be "helping" us. By simply not taxing us more on the same household earnings! It's not like we're asking for the moon on a stick. 🙄

Nepmarthiturn · 25/06/2023 11:00

It will take some campaigning to change it. I don't think a petition will do much: even if it gets enough signatures to be discussed in Parliament, no change would come from that discussion. What is needed is a concerted campaign from women's charities, children's charities and Mumsnet to hammer this home to politicians in every interview of meeting they have with them and press for a commitment to get this into next year's election manifestos: a commitment to immediately make these changes to the tax system and to criminalise non-payment of CMS, while increasing the rate of CMS substantially to somewhere more than a pittance.

BelieveThemtheFirstTime · 25/06/2023 10:52

@Nepmarthiturn
My post above was in response to you.

BelieveThemtheFirstTime · 25/06/2023 10:51

Excellent post. You summed it all up nicely. We have a shit and misogynist system/Government, which none of the main political parties want to change.

Nepmarthiturn · 25/06/2023 10:22

It is a disgrace. Around 90% of resident single parents are women, and it is very deliberate that the entire system is set up to disadvantage them.

Child maintenance set at 15% income? What resident parent has 85% of their income left to spend as they choose having covered the costs of housing, feeding and clothing their child, let alone anything beyond the essentials?

CMS should be set at a level that covers 50% of the costs of raising a child, including childcare. And it needs to be enforced in a similar way to non-payment of tax: a criminal offence, automatic deduction from salaries, and severe penalties for non-payment. Confiscation of passports/ driving licences would be a good initial step, until all outstanding amounts are cleared and prison sentences in the event of prolonged non-payment. Deduction should also be prioritised - like taxes - above any other debts the person owes or other expenses they may have.

And then we have the tax system which enormously penalises single parents. A two parent household gets twice the tax free allowance, can still receive child benefit at twice the income, earn twice as much before higher rate tax is applied, and can earn twice as much before losing their personal allowance, tax free childcare and funded nursery hours.

The effect of that is that the single parent is taxed far, far more than a two parent household with the same household income, despite the fact that they are already trying to do everything (provide and care) in only 24 hours per day not 48, and are also therefore likely to have much higher childcare costs on average, so the tax system deliberately compounds this disadvantage.

If you run the calculations on the effect on net income after tax/ benefits and childcare, a single parent with two children in childcare has to earn £140k to have the same net income as a couple both earning average salaries of £30k. That is just astonishingly unfair, by any objective standard.

Of course it will always more expensive to cover housing etc on your own but then to be taxed more on the same income on top of that, making it even harder or almost impossible to earn enough to reach the average standard of living for a two parent family no matter what you do, there is something very seriously wrong with the system itself. In most countries the tax system gives higher allowances to single parents to level the playing field with two parent households, rather than deliberately compounding the disadvantage those families have already by virtue of one parent trying to fulfil two roles at once.

And yet, when these issues have been raised with both the Conservatives and with Labour, neither care or have any intention of removing these deliberate disadvantages and penalisations of single parents. The tax part is very easy to fix, any chancellor could do it. You simple double all thresholds and allowances for single adult households.

Rachel Reeves was in fact asked about this in her interview with Mumsnet not long ago but was not interested, when she could do this on her first day in office is she becomes Chancellor. 😡 Mumsnet themselves should be working on exactly this type of campaign and stated previously they'd research it further but have never said anything further about it that I have seen. And while it's been raised on many threads here before, there always seems to be a cohort of women who pipe up saying it would be "unfair" to tax single parents the same as a couple with the same income. 😒 Like they can't stand the thought of a single parent having an "advantage" (not being taxed more than them while continuing to do everything on their own, an advantage?! Basic fairness, more like).

These things really do need to change and anybody who cares about women and children would be behind such a campaign. I hope you manage to make some headway with it OP. Maybe it is worth yet again trying to ask Mumsnet to get behind such a campaign, I don't know. Sadly most single parents are probably too exhausted to do much about it and those in power do not seem to care about it at all. We have no voice in parliament, even from the female MPs.

heartofglass23 · 25/06/2023 08:42

I agree with PP- criminalise non payment as child neglect.

Changechangechanging · 24/06/2023 13:07

pinkginfizz9 · 24/06/2023 04:23

Don't you get to claim all the tax credits for childcare without your dad contributions to the household pot even being taken into account?

How much to you suppose 'all the tax credits' actually is? and what do you think happens to those women who claim 'all the tax credits' when their children reach 18 and leave home?

Do you consider it reasonable that in a single parent household where the parent earns £60k they are exempt from claiming child benefit but that in a house hold where 2 parents each earn £45k (so a total household income of £90k), child benefit can be claimed on top? Do you consider it reasonable that a single parent income household earning £60k has one tax free earning limit but a household earning two lots of £30k has 2 tax free earning limits?

It is great that there is support through tax credits and universal credit for childcare and to top up genuinely low wages. But there are many, many hard working single parents who don't benefit from this whilst also not receiving child maintenance from either a non-working or tax dodging, self employed or agency worker ex.

cleanbreak2022 · 24/06/2023 12:28

@howaboutl you are definitely not alone. You are part of an army. I was with my ex 15yrs!

A quote I read on here would have saved me so much anguish

'When someone shows you who they are look'

I wish I had looked, but we are where we are, it's what we choose to do next that counts.

Nothing stays the same Daffodil

howaboutl · 24/06/2023 12:21

cleanbreak2022 · 24/06/2023 11:13

@howaboutl I'm happy to help. I became a single parent 18mos ago to a then 15mos old and 7yr old. This has become the most single eye opening experience of my life.

Our children need a voice, and the absent parents need to be held accountable. Not heralded as victims. The warriors are the parents that stay behind and the trophies (for want of a better word) are the children that will become our future. Our future health service, our future educators and our future government.

We need to stop blaming single parents and we need to change our tolerance of absent and bare minimum parenting. That's who should be held accountable. Not the warriors that have the grit for the fight and be assured, single parenting is a fight on every level.

@cleanbreak2022 thanks for sharing. I’ve felt so alone since my ex did this. He was a decent partner before our dc arrived, despite him saying he desperately wanted to be a dad. He’s a lowlife and I had absolutely no idea.

OP posts:
cleanbreak2022 · 24/06/2023 11:13

@howaboutl I'm happy to help. I became a single parent 18mos ago to a then 15mos old and 7yr old. This has become the most single eye opening experience of my life.

Our children need a voice, and the absent parents need to be held accountable. Not heralded as victims. The warriors are the parents that stay behind and the trophies (for want of a better word) are the children that will become our future. Our future health service, our future educators and our future government.

We need to stop blaming single parents and we need to change our tolerance of absent and bare minimum parenting. That's who should be held accountable. Not the warriors that have the grit for the fight and be assured, single parenting is a fight on every level.

howaboutl · 24/06/2023 11:00

cleanbreak2022 · 24/06/2023 09:35

@pinkginfizz9 would you elaborate on your comment?

Is it widely assumed that single mothers claim 'all the tax credits'? I can assure you, I don't claim a penny from the state. Not even child benefit. My ex on the other hand is entitled to more state assistance than me.

I am sick to death of that narrative. That I must be rolling in it because as a single mother I have bundles of state assistance and if I can't meet the cost, the government will.

That is simply not true. I work damn hard to provide for my children and I do a good job of it. I know plenty of other women in my situation also. Most of the single mothers I know, did not choose this situation. They found themselves here. For one reason or another, their partners decided family life/responsibility was not for them. They upped and left. Every one of the men I know who left, ended back at their mothers house. That says a lot.

The issue is not single mothers, the issue is it is socially acceptable for men to make a decision to opt out. To simply wipe their hands of their obligations. It is the single mothers who stand, who remain, who do the grudge work, the hard never ending shifts. They don't get to check out and rest and recharge. They go and go and go. Single mothers/fathers should be championed for what they do, supported and as a society we should admire them. We don't, we look down on them, because something should be wrong with them for the man to leave. Their children must be feckless and ill behaved because their isn't a father figure on the scene.

Men, and women for that matter, should be seen as pond life for not having active, physical, emotional and financial roles in their joint children's lives.

So no, the answer to your question is we don't all, get 'all the tax credits' many of us get no state assistance whatsoever, because we work our backsides off.

@cleanbreak2022 wow, this totally. I’m going to be dedicating a lot of time to promoting change. Single motherhood really does expose the sexism in this country, doesn’t it.

OP posts:
BibbleandSqwauk · 24/06/2023 09:45

@cleanbreak2022 wish there was a "love" button on here for posts - exactly what you said.

cleanbreak2022 · 24/06/2023 09:35

@pinkginfizz9 would you elaborate on your comment?

Is it widely assumed that single mothers claim 'all the tax credits'? I can assure you, I don't claim a penny from the state. Not even child benefit. My ex on the other hand is entitled to more state assistance than me.

I am sick to death of that narrative. That I must be rolling in it because as a single mother I have bundles of state assistance and if I can't meet the cost, the government will.

That is simply not true. I work damn hard to provide for my children and I do a good job of it. I know plenty of other women in my situation also. Most of the single mothers I know, did not choose this situation. They found themselves here. For one reason or another, their partners decided family life/responsibility was not for them. They upped and left. Every one of the men I know who left, ended back at their mothers house. That says a lot.

The issue is not single mothers, the issue is it is socially acceptable for men to make a decision to opt out. To simply wipe their hands of their obligations. It is the single mothers who stand, who remain, who do the grudge work, the hard never ending shifts. They don't get to check out and rest and recharge. They go and go and go. Single mothers/fathers should be championed for what they do, supported and as a society we should admire them. We don't, we look down on them, because something should be wrong with them for the man to leave. Their children must be feckless and ill behaved because their isn't a father figure on the scene.

Men, and women for that matter, should be seen as pond life for not having active, physical, emotional and financial roles in their joint children's lives.

So no, the answer to your question is we don't all, get 'all the tax credits' many of us get no state assistance whatsoever, because we work our backsides off.

SoWhatEh · 24/06/2023 09:17

I agree. I think men get away with behaving like wild animals these days - plant their seed then saunter off to plant it elsewhere. It repulses me. Men who walk out on young families are the lowest form of pondlife and I think society should put pressure on them and mock them as spineless and pathetic. Just as it is now seen as pathetic to drink and drive, it should be seen as weak to walk out. We need a social shift. Why do people judge single mothers? What about the feckless fathers?

anniegun · 24/06/2023 09:13

A government that made Boris Johnson their leader is never going to make feckless men pay for their children

BibbleandSqwauk · 24/06/2023 08:11

@pinkginfizz9 seriously?

  1. Maintenance payments are / were so poorly kept that the state itself recognised it was unfair to link them to receipt of benefits
  2. Many single mothers do actually earn decent money so don't get much if any tax credit or UC. But they cant earn enough due to childcare responsibilities for this not to matter.
  3. Even if most of the bill IS covered by UC, the other parent still ought to be responsible for half of the remainder. The childcare is allowing them to work also.
Orangetang · 24/06/2023 05:37

There seem to be an awful lot of shitty dads on benefits. Are they really all unfit for work?

It doesn’t surprise me so many dads don’t pay but I am shocked at the amount of 20-40 year olds claiming benefits and not working as an excuse not to pay.

MarmaladeAndToast · 24/06/2023 05:06

Good points that this is neglect and financial abuse.

MarmaladeAndToast · 24/06/2023 04:43

Tlolljs · 23/06/2023 17:02

I think I quite clearly wrote that op’s ex is a shitbag.
But what if he doesn’t have the money. Not op but any one else?

My ex has now made a point of not having any money. The CMS said they doesn’t even earn £7 a week. He told me he isn’t looking for a job or claiming benefits because claiming benefits when you are not looking for a job would be immoral.

so I’m battering myself into the ground trying to balance a full time job and child with complex needs.

I feel there should be compulsory voluntary work for the state for someone in his position.

Swipe left for the next trending thread