Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask why this isn't being addressed as a huge sexist issue that frankly shits on women completely?!

240 replies

howaboutl · 23/06/2023 15:21

I know some men are in this position but let’s be honest, it’s mostly women. Why isn’t there outrage about this? If there is how do I join and help make change?

My ex partner walked out on me and dd when she was 1. He doesn’t see her, his choice entirely. He has no other children and doesn’t live with any other children. I am left to pay a childcare bill of 1,300 alone, while he contributes 500 quid when he is working. He works on temporary contracts so now and then I receive nothing despite him having in excess of 100k savings.

How is this accepted that I pay our child’s childcare bill alone? Is it just that there aren’t actually that many women (or men to lesser extent) in this situation so nothing is down about it because in the grand scheme of things we are a minority?

I cannot understand why I am expected to pay for OUR child’s nursery bill so we can both work? Why am I footing the bill for this and he is not?

OP posts:
BibbleandSqwauk · 25/06/2023 18:53

@Kpo58 you may well be right, I'm not an economist, but I think the whole subject of childcare is another can of worms,; what we pay providers, the fact that it's paid out of net income etc.

Tryingtogetonwithit · 25/06/2023 18:53

Court awarded access to fit around HIS work schedule and he pick and choose out of those days to fit around his social life all child care was my responsibility, massive twat that he was. Absolutely minimum CM paid but got like I was living the high life. All grown now but it was so hard and heartbreaking that the same shit is still going on 🤬

Kpo58 · 25/06/2023 18:39

BibbleandSqwauk · 25/06/2023 18:08

@Orchidgal but it's not free is it? You mean funded childcare.. can't see that going down well in a society where people of tax paying age are increasingly choosing not to have children. Most people who have both pay their cleaners more p/ h than their childminders. I don't have the answers but asking the general public to fully fund childcare because feckless irresponsible dads can't apparently be made to meet their responsibilities isn't it.

There is also the possibility that it will increase childbirth rates as many people aren't having them currently because of the childcare costs.

It could also bring in more tax and lower other benefits that are paid as the 2nd parent could then afford to work/work full time and there would be more people recruited to give childcare, so that's potentially 2 extra people to tax and pay less benefits to. It might even help increase the UK's productivity rates.

JMSA · 25/06/2023 18:09

It's a fucking SCANDAL, OP. YANBU.
Flowers

BibbleandSqwauk · 25/06/2023 18:08

@Orchidgal but it's not free is it? You mean funded childcare.. can't see that going down well in a society where people of tax paying age are increasingly choosing not to have children. Most people who have both pay their cleaners more p/ h than their childminders. I don't have the answers but asking the general public to fully fund childcare because feckless irresponsible dads can't apparently be made to meet their responsibilities isn't it.

Orchidgal · 25/06/2023 17:23

Free childcare would make this problem go away.

Kpo58 · 25/06/2023 17:22

I think that there are 2 separate problems that need solving.

1/ Making sure that the non resident parent pays a fair proportion of maintenance and actually pays it

2/ Childcare costs needs to be subsided properly for all children from the age of 6 months.

With number 2, if a family with 2 working or 1 working/1 stay at home parent is only just managing to stay financially afloat with 1 household to pay, there is no possible way that if they were to separate that they could afford between them to run 2 households, pay the correct amount of maintenance AND pay for childcare on top of all this. We have to be realistic on this.

cleanbreak2022 · 25/06/2023 17:16

@Nepmarthiturn I think that's a great idea. I have to motivation and determination but you are a lot more articulate than me.

Nepmarthiturn · 25/06/2023 15:24

cleanbreak2022 · 25/06/2023 13:43

@Nepmarthiturn single mums are the masters of a multi task, I'd gladly throw my hat in the ring to form a consortium

Maybe we should establish a separate group from here by PM for anybody who wants to join and see what we can do between us. I have the motivation, but am so unwell and struggling just to keep our heads above water without my health collapsing that I'm not sure how useful I would be. 😔

SoccerStars · 25/06/2023 13:46

For those blaming women for making poor choices it doesn’t always work like that - my aunt was married with 3 kids. Her husband
( who she met at her church) abandoned her and the kids when they were all under 5 once he finished retraining for his science degree. He went onto earn big bucks for a pharmaceutical company and managed to not pay a penny except a handful of cheques for £1000 each over the year. No cards, no presents etc. he came from a stable and close family and was very well educated and seemingly family orientated with good morals. It wasn’t obvious he was a poor choice.

cleanbreak2022 · 25/06/2023 13:43

@Nepmarthiturn single mums are the masters of a multi task, I'd gladly throw my hat in the ring to form a consortium

Nepmarthiturn · 25/06/2023 13:22

But why the so-called charities and organisations meant to represent women and children haven't taken this up on their behalf is another matter. People who have media contacts and political access and a platform. I'd love to hear their excuses.

Maybe @mumsnet will answer why they still haven't launched a campaign to get these tax changes enacted and enforce proper rates of CMS robustly?

Nepmarthiturn · 25/06/2023 13:20

@BelieveThemtheFirstTime yes, but the things generally looked at in terms of diversity are wrong. Just the easily visible: race, sex. Where are the disabled people represented, where are the lone parents? That kind of diversity would have much more impact but because of the way society compounds the inbuilt disadvantages of those people they are even less able to take on being a representative in order to change things. It is catch 22. Too ill or too overworked and exhausted to even consider it.

Also in many cases - because of the demonsation and vilification and not wanting to have their lives publicly pulled apart with exactly the type of appalling comments received on this thread already, in many cases wouldn't even do it even if practically and physically it was possible. So continue to be marginalised and ignored. Some democracy. Like I said, the mark of one is that those who are in easier situations stand up for those who are not.

That said, while personally I'd never be prepared to do anything involving being a public figure or press intrusion, if they want to appoint me head of the CMS with a commitment to put in place the regulatory powers I'd need and resources to fix it - I could sort it out within two years so that it fulfils its purpose. I mean, what its purpose is meant to be, not the lip-service pretence it is at the moment.

Or appoint me to advise Jeremy Hunt or Rachel Reeves on the required tax policies to not only fix these issues but also address the UK productivity issues. It's really not that hard. They just don't want to do it.

BelieveThemtheFirstTime · 25/06/2023 13:03

Nepmarthiturn · 25/06/2023 12:53

Oh. That might explain their very poor response to when the issue has been raised previously, on multiple threads I have seen. 😔 If you can't even rely on "Mumsnet" to champion simple tax and regulatory changes that discriminate against women and children, then what on Earth would make a change? Everything is stacked against it, set up to prevent any change. How many MPs are single parents? Compared to what percentage of the adult population? That would be an interesting comparison. I suspect the answer is that Parliament is not remotely representative so, as a PP said, no surprise that our children have no voice in the political decisions made.

I suspect the answer is that Parliament is not remotely representative so, as a PP said, no surprise that our children have no voice in the political decisions made.

Most of the MP’s (and their partners) all went to the same few schools, so no it’s not remotely representative of the UK population.

Things are changing, albeit too slowly. We also need to inspire our children to get in there and make those changes.

Nepmarthiturn · 25/06/2023 12:55

cleanbreak2022 · 25/06/2023 12:50

@Nepmarthiturn if I could high five you and scream it from the roof tops I would!

We really need to stand together as a force to get these changes enacted. But that is SO hard for single parents to do given everyone is so exhausted and overworked already, trying to do the work of two adults. It is a great shame that women not in this situation - even those who claim to be feminists - do not take up the cause on our behalf.

Nepmarthiturn · 25/06/2023 12:53

BelieveThemtheFirstTime · 25/06/2023 12:29

I’ve just remembered that Ian Katz, formerly the deputy editor of the Guardian, then the editor of BBC’s Newsnight, now head of programming for Channel 4 was until quite recently married to Justine Roberts, the founder of Mumsnet, for twenty-five years. Therefore, sadly Mumsnet is unlikely to champion this.

Oh. That might explain their very poor response to when the issue has been raised previously, on multiple threads I have seen. 😔 If you can't even rely on "Mumsnet" to champion simple tax and regulatory changes that discriminate against women and children, then what on Earth would make a change? Everything is stacked against it, set up to prevent any change. How many MPs are single parents? Compared to what percentage of the adult population? That would be an interesting comparison. I suspect the answer is that Parliament is not remotely representative so, as a PP said, no surprise that our children have no voice in the political decisions made.

cleanbreak2022 · 25/06/2023 12:50

@Nepmarthiturn if I could high five you and scream it from the roof tops I would!

lousyatchoosingnames · 25/06/2023 12:50

I had this issue, my ex paid £120 per month and I was left to pay £780 per month nursery bills plus all other bills relating to DD. Then when DD was 13, and needed no childcare, he managed to persuade her to stay at his more so he could claim from me, it would have been £700 per month as I earn more nowadays. But he was self employed and fiddled for years to keep his payments minimum. It's infuriating!!!!

Nepmarthiturn · 25/06/2023 12:40

So depressing that there's always at least one economically illiterate idiot who comes out of the woodwork supporting misogyny and discrimination and victim-blaming. Living in cloud cuckoo land under the impression that this could never happen to them and so prepared to throw other women and their children under the bus.

BelieveThemtheFirstTime · 25/06/2023 12:29

I’ve just remembered that Ian Katz, formerly the deputy editor of the Guardian, then the editor of BBC’s Newsnight, now head of programming for Channel 4 was until quite recently married to Justine Roberts, the founder of Mumsnet, for twenty-five years. Therefore, sadly Mumsnet is unlikely to champion this.

Nepmarthiturn · 25/06/2023 12:27

Mumuser124 · 25/06/2023 12:02

You can’t force somebody to be decent.

and you cannot seriously expect such sanctions from the government? The government already puts a safety net in for low income families. Maintenance is not taken into consideration when they calculate how much financial assistance somebody needs. Therefore maintenance becomes a ‘bonus’ so to speak.

honestly, what you are asking for is for the state to be responsible for your picking to have a baby with an idiot, it’s not the governments business, they already offer housing, childcare and benefits to you, why would they then waste even more money on chasing, prosecuting and impronsoning your waste of space ex? What would the government get out of doing such a thing?

Oh here we go again.

It must be your fault, women are responsible for men's behaviour. 🙄🙄🙄🙄

No. We are not.

And no, many single parents do not receive any state support whatsoever. Nor are we asking for it. No, I do not receive "housing or benefits" and it is demonstrative of your prejudices against single parents that you presume so.

We are stating that both of a child's parents should be forced - if necessary - to pay 50% of the cost of raising them. And yes, I do "seriously" expect that this should be enforced in the same way with similar penalities as for non-payment of taxes. Why would it not? Tax is paid for the benefit of wider society. Refusing to pay for YOUR OWN CHILD's needs is far more morally reprehensible and the law should reflect that. As it does in many, many other countries.

The Government exists to serve its citizens. Deliberately disadvantaging women and children does not do so. The mark of a decent society is how it treats its most vulnerable members.

And no, I should not be paying more tax than a couple with the same household earnings. That is an absurd situation and like I said, one that long-term data from abroad proves to be a false economy as a policy and cost the state MORE in the long-term as well as harming children's life outcomes. As well as those of the women you want to demonise.

BelieveThemtheFirstTime · 25/06/2023 12:24

Maintenance is not taken into consideration when they calculate how much financial assistance somebody needs. Therefore maintenance becomes a ‘bonus’ so to speak.

Maintenance should most definitely be taken into consideration, and this is what needs to change. Maintenance to feed, clothe and raise a child up to 18 years of age should not be considered a ‘bonus’!

I dodged creating and raising my DC with an idiot, but I still want the system to change for others, including my children and society as a whole.

Nepmarthiturn · 25/06/2023 12:20

cleanbreak2022 · 24/06/2023 09:35

@pinkginfizz9 would you elaborate on your comment?

Is it widely assumed that single mothers claim 'all the tax credits'? I can assure you, I don't claim a penny from the state. Not even child benefit. My ex on the other hand is entitled to more state assistance than me.

I am sick to death of that narrative. That I must be rolling in it because as a single mother I have bundles of state assistance and if I can't meet the cost, the government will.

That is simply not true. I work damn hard to provide for my children and I do a good job of it. I know plenty of other women in my situation also. Most of the single mothers I know, did not choose this situation. They found themselves here. For one reason or another, their partners decided family life/responsibility was not for them. They upped and left. Every one of the men I know who left, ended back at their mothers house. That says a lot.

The issue is not single mothers, the issue is it is socially acceptable for men to make a decision to opt out. To simply wipe their hands of their obligations. It is the single mothers who stand, who remain, who do the grudge work, the hard never ending shifts. They don't get to check out and rest and recharge. They go and go and go. Single mothers/fathers should be championed for what they do, supported and as a society we should admire them. We don't, we look down on them, because something should be wrong with them for the man to leave. Their children must be feckless and ill behaved because their isn't a father figure on the scene.

Men, and women for that matter, should be seen as pond life for not having active, physical, emotional and financial roles in their joint children's lives.

So no, the answer to your question is we don't all, get 'all the tax credits' many of us get no state assistance whatsoever, because we work our backsides off.

Yes: all of this.

I am a lone parent. I've been doing that since my children were 4 months old and 1 year old.

No, I don't get UC or tax credits or child benefit. 🙄 Yes, I have a full time job.

I also have a chronic health condition myself. And zero family support.

And like you I am sick to the back teeth of the comments about how we must be getting lots of state help. I've never seen it?! Only the enormous tax bill, paying far more than a couple with the same household income, while trying to do everything myself.

I'm sick of these misogynistic assumptions. We must all have just slept with random men or "tricked them into having children" (like you can force a man to have unprotected sex)? Nope, my children's father was my ex-husband and they were very much planned. In fact he pushed for it. Recklessly married someone we barely knew? Nope, we'd been married for years before kids and lived together for many years before marriage. We must just be stupid and ignored "red flags" and if we'd been as wise as others and married someone else it would have been fiiiine? Which ignores all of the research which shows that many men become abusive or leave only AFTER children are born.

Constantly trying to find some way to blame the women for men's behaviour, the women who are doing EVERYTHING, who are the heroes and the responsible ones sticking around and caring for and providing for their children, rather than the feckless men who run off and do and pay nothing.

It needs calling out every single time. And frankly even if a woman did make some unwise choices, she and her children do not deserve to be penalised, denied the state enforcing that the father pays 50% of the cost of raising THEIR child, or to be taxed more than a couple on the SAME household income, deliberately making her and her children poorer on top of the disadvantages of having to provide for children and raise them alone with only 24 hours per day to do all of this.

Anybody who comes out with this nonsense needs to take a long, hard look at their moral compass and stand up against this deliberate discrimination against women and children, and the narrative that it must all be the women's fault. 😒😡

BibbleandSqwauk · 25/06/2023 12:11

@Mumuser124 maintenance is not a "bonus". Single parents on low incomes due to childcaring and using state help are barely scraping by. Why the bloody hell should the men, regardless of how early or late they abandoned their responsibilities not be pursued by the same agencies that pursue tax avoiders?

Mumuser124 · 25/06/2023 12:02

You can’t force somebody to be decent.

and you cannot seriously expect such sanctions from the government? The government already puts a safety net in for low income families. Maintenance is not taken into consideration when they calculate how much financial assistance somebody needs. Therefore maintenance becomes a ‘bonus’ so to speak.

honestly, what you are asking for is for the state to be responsible for your picking to have a baby with an idiot, it’s not the governments business, they already offer housing, childcare and benefits to you, why would they then waste even more money on chasing, prosecuting and impronsoning your waste of space ex? What would the government get out of doing such a thing?

Swipe left for the next trending thread