Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you thought a GP had missed your cancer would you do anything about it?

80 replies

namechange0998776554799000 · 23/06/2023 15:14

I've just been diagnosed with cancer and apparently have a 7cm tumour in my chest. My main symptom is chest pain, which I went to the GP about in 2016. She did a blood test, which found I was anaemic, and an ECG which wasn't normal but which she said was probably because my large chest was making it difficult for the sensors to get a reading. At the appointment to discuss the results, I distinctly remember her saying 'I don't know what's causing your chest pain'. I chalked it up to being fat/unhealthy/a stressed out mum and have lived with the pain ever since. It's got steadily worse to the point I couldn't stand it any more and went back to the GP a couple of weeks ago. He ordered blood tests, X-ray, then CT scan and overall it looks like I now have pretty advanced cancer. I honestly don't know if it's realistic that I've been living with this for 7 years but I understand that lymphoma can be very slow growing for a long time and then suddenly ramp up. It's a question I'll ask the consultant when I get an appointment (I'm only at early diagnostic stage so far).
I don't have access to my medical records from 2016 and need to figure out to get them, because I'd like to know if the blood tests at the time should have indicated anything more serious or if the GP should have followed up any further. But maybe I just need to let it go? What would you do? The GP in question has since retired and this is not necessarily about making a complaint - definitely not about compensation - more just about me wanting to know.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LadyWithLapdog · 21/09/2023 23:35

Thank you for updating and good luck with your treatment. It’s reassuring to know it wasn’t missed, so you can concentrate on recovery rather than anger. Best wishes.

lljkk · 21/09/2023 21:53

OP reckons she did NOT have a diagnosis missed. She did have lots of investigations when she sought help. OP was Listened to.

Escapingtherealityoflife · 21/09/2023 20:08

Thank you for updating OP.
It’s interesting about talking about multiple symptoms - some of the GPs at our practice only allow you to talk about one symptom/problem per appointment which is really poor I think.

SnobblyBobbly · 14/07/2023 17:54

bluedomino · 23/06/2023 15:42

All these media campaigns tell you to see your GP if you feel unwell or have symptoms. Yet when you go, as a woman you are routinely ignored and made to feel like a malingerer. You are made to feel mad when you keep telling them something feels wrong or they tell you not to Google.

I'm sure I read that almost all women with pernicious anaemia are given various types of antidepressants before they eventually get a diagnosis.

I've just came out of hospital after being repeatedly ignored by GPs for years. My hospital ward was full of women with advanced cancer through being ignored by their GPs. Many of them very angry after going to GP with bloating, weight loss and period symptoms, ignored and now on their final few months of life. It was tragic.

Perhaps if more people did sue or pursue an answer as to why they were not sent for diagnostic tests earlier, then it may make the GPs take women a little more seriously.

Absolutely. Look for changes, early detection saves lives but then you're made to feel as though you're just a worrier.

It's not the public who need convincing to take action, but the medical staff who seem to think they know more about your bits & pieces than you do.

SnobblyBobbly · 14/07/2023 17:51

My breast cancer was also missed, or rather they failed to refer me despite my concerns and family history.

The nurse who examined me told me to stop worrying, she had vast experience with BC, just because my sister had had it at a young age didn't mean I would get it and to stop checking myself because I was probably making it worse...

When I got a terminal secondary diagnosis a few months later after accepting her professional assurances I just didn't have the energy to fight.

I wrote an initial complaint to the surgery and they called me to ask what had I been doing in the two month's in between....umm not worrying and not checking it anymore as advised. I realised then it would just be my word against hers and her notes would say whatever she wanted them to say.

However all is not lost. I plan to haunt her big time Grin

lljkk · 14/07/2023 17:39

Thanks for update. :)

namechange0998776554799000 · 14/07/2023 17:38

Mrspoopoohead · 14/07/2023 15:47

Good luck with your treatment it is intense but the good news is lymphoma can be cured and I speak from experience! X

Great to hear, thank you!

OP posts:
Mrspoopoohead · 14/07/2023 15:47

Good luck with your treatment it is intense but the good news is lymphoma can be cured and I speak from experience! X

namechange0998776554799000 · 14/07/2023 15:33

In case anyone comes back to this, I did get my full medical records and it's very unlikely I had the cancer back in 2016. I've probably had to for about 18 months based on my symptoms, and honestly I don't think any doctor along the way has done anything wrong. I think the biggest mistake I made was being influenced about all the hype about perimenopause. I'm 43 and had never thought about it until a couple of years ago, but I had many minor symptoms that I assumed were peri because I was hearing so might about it in the press/on Mumsnet/from friends - things like night sweats, heart palpitations, aches & pains etc. I think in my case they were probably all due to the lymphoma. Either way, I should have gone to the GP with a full list of all the little niggles in one appointment and maybe they'd have put two and two together. As it is, my cancers now quite advanced but I think that is common with lymphoma. I'm facing 6 months of quite intense chemo but the good news is that the chance of complete cure is 90%. I'm feeling quite at peace and positive about things, and glad I saw my medical records so I could put my curiosity to the side.

OP posts:
user1471453601 · 23/06/2023 22:55

For anyone who is scared shitless by the posts about cancer being missed, which it clearly has been in the cases outlined above, I'd like to share my (well, one of) my cancer story.

I woke one morning with a slight ache in my shoulder blade and a tingling I my little finger. Thought I'd just slept "funny" but for reasons unconnected, I decided to see GP. surgery

After exam, she sent me for an xray. A week later, got a call from the surgery that "something" had shown up in my lung, probably scarring from chest infections.

But, because I'd previously had cancer, they thought it better that I go for a ct scan.

I had lung cancer. No cough, no blood, just a tingling sensation.

because they caught it early (and because of the type of lung cancer it was) I had an operation, and no further intervention was needed.

So, GPs do sometimes get it right, though my sympathy is with those of you who were not quite so lucky.

Mrspoopoohead · 23/06/2023 22:37

I had lymphoma it was slow growing so I could have had it some time and it then transformed into high grade. If it is lymphoma it isn’t easy to diagnose and all my bloods were fine. I was diagnosed following a ct scan and biopsy. The treatments are very good so please try not to worry x

eewno · 23/06/2023 22:33

I'm so sorry you're going through this op.

It should be really easy to get your medical records. I requested mine from the GP and they had them all printed out ready for me to collect within a week. It'll show you everything.

I understand your desire to find out answers - I went through it for issues I had. It's really easy for people to say they'd leave it and focus on the future when they've not experienced medical negligence.

Oblomov23 · 23/06/2023 22:25

Ask for a copy of your notes.
Ask for a meeting with the Practice Manager of your GP surgery.

SkaterBrained · 23/06/2023 22:08

None of these things are mutually exclusive, unfortunately. It's unlikely they'd have said low blood pressure, unless you had low blood pressure. Were you the age people experience peri menopause, when that explained a lot of your symptoms?

Unfortunately a lot of these are very general symptoms, most of which would not be explained by cancer in very early stages. It's a lot more likely you had both low blood pressure and a tiny cancer cell starting to divide, which didn't cause problems yet.

People with complex health needs are also a higher risk of cancer, it is more likely you had risk factors for both other issues and cancer than cancer causing the other issues 7y ago.

I'd focus on the future for now, purely for your sake. It doesn't sound like a symptom was overlooked, rather that your body had a lot to cope with that was hard to pull apart into separate causes.

Good luck.

C152 · 23/06/2023 21:31

I'm sorry to hear about your diagnosis, OP; and I hope you get whatever treatment you need now.

I can understand wanting to know how long you've been ill. I think it's natural. I want to know the same thing about my child's illness, but no one can say when his tumour started growing.

As to whether I would do anything if a GP missed a cancer diagnosis, I personally wouldn't have the energy to do anything. (Particularly as I don't believe anything will change.) At most I may write a single complaint to the relevant body, but it's really hard dealing with the NHS for serious illnesses requiring long, intensive treatment like cancer. I found it rapidly saps all your energy and strength, which you will need to be on top of the Drs responsible for your treatment moving forward.

However, if you have the energy and it will give you some kind of comfort, then do raise the issue.

https://www.which.co.uk/consumer-rights/advice/how-to-complain-if-you-re-unhappy-with-your-gp-or-doctor-s-surgery-a2fyc8v0Q7Nj

How to complain if you're unhappy with your GP or doctor's surgery - Which?

We all have the right to good health care. If you’re unhappy with your GP or doctor's surgery, you can complain directly or to the NHS in your region. 

https://www.which.co.uk/consumer-rights/advice/how-to-complain-if-you-re-unhappy-with-your-gp-or-doctor-s-surgery-a2fyc8v0Q7Nj

UpaladderwatchingTV · 23/06/2023 20:52

I just want to wish you well with any treatment they are able to offer you OP. What an awful shock this must be for you. Sending you a hopefully comforting cyber hug.

Greengagesnfennel · 23/06/2023 20:30

I'm so sorry you are going through this op. It must be messing with your head. Cancer is full of what-ifs. I hope you have still caught it in time. It is great that you posted to warn others. GPs can make mistakes so can we as patients. I had a similar experience in that i went in and was told no it's ok and 2 years later went back and immediately got surgery in 2w. Cancer is not called the silent killer for nothing. It's a sneaky hider. Don't despair yet, some are very slow growing and you may yet be ok. Focus on what your dr days not us muppets online. Hugs xxx

ffsgiveitarest · 23/06/2023 18:13

After going to the GP for postpartum bleeding for months after having my daughter, I was told it was normal. I then went on to start coughing up blood, to be told it’s probably a burst blood vessel and I was too young for it to be something sinister. (I was late 30’s)

It turned out to be cancer, although rare. Yes I did complain, mainly to raise awareness and to properly check symptoms.

Binningtonianrose · 23/06/2023 18:09

All your stories are why I joined Benenden healthcare for 11 quid a month.

They immediately allot you 1500 to spend on scans/investigations or suspicious symptoms, instead of the ENDLESS fobbing off of GPs.
When my dear friend and dear dad died of late diagnoses to cancer it seems worth it.
Had an emergency hysterectomy on it five years ago, after NHS wouldn't give me a gynae appt for over a year. Had an op two weeks after being scanned..

I'm sorry for all of your great losses. Some really sad stories here.

Livelovebehappy · 23/06/2023 18:03

Hbh17 · 23/06/2023 15:27

No, what would be the point? People are human, mistakes can be made and your energy would be better focused on the present rather than the past.

Seriously? Small mistakes can be overlooked, but this is kind of a pretty big one if it’s found that the prognosis is poor, and proven that there was medical negligence. OP, ask to see your records, mention it to your consultant, and you will be able to tell by his response/reaction whether there has been some sort of negligence here. Just get all the information you can, which will help you get an idea of whether they have a case to answer. It’s not, like you say, about compensation, but if mistakes were made people need to learn from them, and be accountable.

Gracewithoutend · 23/06/2023 17:59

The first thing I was asked when I went for an uLyra sound on a breast lump was ‘can you show me where you think this lump is’. How they were looking in the wrong area is very odd.

I remember going for a D&C and there had been so many stories at the time of errors, I went under the anaesthetic shouting, don't chop anything off. Can't be too careful.

namechange0998776554799000 · 23/06/2023 17:55

Also, I'm sorry for all of those who have been through such awful experiences themselves or seen it happen to loved ones. Flowers to all

OP posts:
namechange0998776554799000 · 23/06/2023 17:53

Oh and the GP I saw in 2016 was a lovely female doctor who I'd been seeing for many years and who retired shortly afterwards. I've seen many different GPs since (large practice) and most of them have been reasonably sympathetic, attentive and professional. As much as I'm worried things might have been missed, this isn't a criticism of GPs in general or of one specific arrogant male doctor as many seem to have assumed/experienced!

OP posts:
SayHi · 23/06/2023 17:44

and I can't help but wonder if I should just drop it and focus on whatever treatment/recovery is to come.

I personally would focus on getting better and then deal with it.

We only have so much energy and so many battles we can fight.

Your health is more important than passing blame.
If once you’re better you think mistakes have been made then you’ll be in a much better head space to deal with it.

HappiDaze · 23/06/2023 17:44

My advice is if you're unsure with any results get a private check up / diagnosis etc and then you can use those results if positive for cancer etc to then get the correct treatment via the NHS