Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There are two sexes…

635 replies

ItJustFellOutLikeWordVomit · 23/06/2023 13:34

Well just that really….I have gay, straight, bi sexual and transsexual friends and absolutely have no problem with that, very much a do what makes you happy person.

Butttt….AIBU to think the world is going a bit mad with all the non-female, cis female and whatever other labels are floating about. I’m a woman and that’s that, you are either biologically a male or biologically a female and I don’t mean that in an insensitive way dress how you like and date who you like but surely we can’t just be inventing different/new sexes and telling straight women they are no longer a woman they are now XYZ?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
loislovesstewie · 23/06/2023 19:20

I wish I hadn't Googled that!

literallyarabbit · 23/06/2023 19:17

nothingcomestonothing · 23/06/2023 18:45

And the example given re Lady Colin Campbell is interesting because according to her, there was no confusion over whether she was male or female, either to her parents or doctors. They knew she was a female with a DSD, but thought in the case of babies with ambiguous genitals that as they'd been given a raw deal in life they should get given a break by being recorded and treated as male, the superior sex. So even though she was raised as male, the adults knew she was female with a DSD. There was no confusion or mistake, but a deliberate choice to say.she was male. Because male is better.

Yes.

It's actually really sad that due to being born with a fused labia and clitoris, her true sex was ignored, and Lady Colin Campbell was raised as a boy called George. What's worse, is that during puberty, as she developed breasts and her hip widened, her father forced testosterone injections on her. Her father's attitude, not to mention his behaviour is appalling.

BMW6 · 23/06/2023 19:13

*Hotsummerlatenightstrolls · Today 15:00

She was assigned as a female from birth and has lived as a woman. She is not really male or female she is intersex and was raised from birth as a woman. You deciding she will be he and she was born with a medical condition doesn't sit well and is offensive.*

CS has FATHERED a child. With HIS wife.

He is a man with DSD. Always was a man. He has a Y chromosome.

HermioneWeasley · 23/06/2023 19:10

At any given time there are around 600 men on the planet that have 2 penises. Nobody suggests that makes a case for the number of penises a man has being on a spectrum - is is accepted as an incredibly rare medical condition or mutation from which absolutely nothing can be extrapolated.

CampervanKween · 23/06/2023 19:10

There are only two sexes. Intersex is not a third sex. It's a disorder but still either of the male or female sex.

Helleofabore · 23/06/2023 19:06

DogandMog · 23/06/2023 19:01

It's not the chromosomes per se which determine sex... it is the genes within those chromosomes which do. Hence it is possible (but extremely rare) for a woman to have XY chromosomes, and for a man to have XX chromosomes. The conditions are Swyer syndrome and De La Chapelle syndrome.

The deciding gene is SRY... if it is activated, then a male reproductive physiology develops, and if it is silent then a female reproductive system develops. A male reproductive developmental pathway is called a Wolffian system, and a female pathway is called a Müllerian system.

But... just as clown fish biology only pertains to... clown fish, the medical biology of DSDs only pertains to people diagnosed with DSDs. No political or sociological claims can be extrapolated out of such conditions into the general population to attempt to assert notions about the mutability of sex. In gonochoric species (all mammals, all birds & 98% of fish) sex is as binary as it gets.

Yes. Chromosomes make up one part of determining sex.

That is why the definition that I have seen about 'body formation' covers those very rare cases of the DSDs as you mention.

It is generally reliable that chromosomes will accurately categorise sex, but not always.

DogandMog · 23/06/2023 19:01

It's not the chromosomes per se which determine sex... it is the genes within those chromosomes which do. Hence it is possible (but extremely rare) for a woman to have XY chromosomes, and for a man to have XX chromosomes. The conditions are Swyer syndrome and De La Chapelle syndrome.

The deciding gene is SRY... if it is activated, then a male reproductive physiology develops, and if it is silent then a female reproductive system develops. A male reproductive developmental pathway is called a Wolffian system, and a female pathway is called a Müllerian system.

But... just as clown fish biology only pertains to... clown fish, the medical biology of DSDs only pertains to people diagnosed with DSDs. No political or sociological claims can be extrapolated out of such conditions into the general population to attempt to assert notions about the mutability of sex. In gonochoric species (all mammals, all birds & 98% of fish) sex is as binary as it gets.

WickedSerious · 23/06/2023 18:58

Hotsummerlatenightstrolls · 23/06/2023 15:00

She was assigned as a female from birth and has lived as a woman. She is not really male or female she is intersex and was raised from birth as a woman. You deciding she will be he and she was born with a medical condition doesn't sit well and is offensive.

He is a man though.

theDudesmummy · 23/06/2023 18:54

On my previous point about being OK with someone with Y chromosome in my loos, as long as they are not a threat, of course it happens all the time and we are fine with it. Little boys. They don't have to be redefined as female to come in. We just recognise that they are not a threat and act accordingly.

theDudesmummy · 23/06/2023 18:50

Yes that is an interesting paper

Helleofabore · 23/06/2023 18:48

Helleofabore · 23/06/2023 18:43

Apologies if I am repeating posts. This thread is moving fast and I have read much of it. But it seems to need repeating if it has been posted.

A female human, is a human with the body formed around the production of large gametes, or ova. This categorisation works reliably regardless of whether that production has ever happen, will ever happen or is currently happening. This requires the body formation around ovaries.

There may have been a handful of human beings with chimerism where they ended up with both. But that is because their body has developed with a part of another human's cells inside their body where those cells are not supposed to be. I think there is one recorded case of this where if I remember there was an internal teste (that I don't believe worked) and an ovary.

No human with a difference of development has both working testes and working ova production capability. With modern medical testing all human beings are reliably able to be categorised as male or female. Even mature human beings.

Using any human with a DSD condition as some kind of gotcha to destabilise the absolute reliability of 'there are only two sexes' is offensive and othering.

And there are not 1.7% of the world's population with a DSD. That number is false. It is around 0.18%. Because the higher number includes female people and male people with issues from birth that are not actually a DSD where their sex needs to be tested because of ambiguous genitalia. For instance the male people in that wider number simply have the opening of their urethra displaced on their penis. That is all. That is not ambiguous genitalia.

There is no 'third' sex. There is no third gamete. There is no third sex for any reproduction purposes.

Even one of the often misquoted authors of a paper that people cite as evidence, Claire Ainsworth clarified, there are two sexes. There is plenty of body variation within each sex. But only two sexes.

For anyone wanting an explanation of the 1.7% figure:

https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/intersex-is-not-as-common-as-red

Intersex Is Not as Common as Red Hair

The claim that intersex people comprise 1.7% of the population is wildly inaccurate.

https://www.realityslaststand.com/p/intersex-is-not-as-common-as-red

theDudesmummy · 23/06/2023 18:47

On the (vanishingly rare) issue of Swyer syndrome (or other DSDs which mean that a person with a Y chromosome does not have male testosterone levels OR male sexual characteristics) I actually would be fine with them being in my loos or my prison tbh. They are genetically men but do not pose the threat to me that other men do. So OK, if you are one of those people, I will be prepared to make an exception for you. It doesn't mean I have to change the definition of woman though, or say that there is a third sex. It just means that sometimes you have to make exceptions in very rare circumstances.

nothingcomestonothing · 23/06/2023 18:45

PaintbrushSoap · 23/06/2023 18:36

Karyotyping was invented in 1955!

And the example given re Lady Colin Campbell is interesting because according to her, there was no confusion over whether she was male or female, either to her parents or doctors. They knew she was a female with a DSD, but thought in the case of babies with ambiguous genitals that as they'd been given a raw deal in life they should get given a break by being recorded and treated as male, the superior sex. So even though she was raised as male, the adults knew she was female with a DSD. There was no confusion or mistake, but a deliberate choice to say.she was male. Because male is better.

Helleofabore · 23/06/2023 18:44

shatteredmum1 · 23/06/2023 18:30

Some people are born intersex. This is extremely rare and not through choice.

What proof do you have that Semenya has a vagina?

Helleofabore · 23/06/2023 18:43

Apologies if I am repeating posts. This thread is moving fast and I have read much of it. But it seems to need repeating if it has been posted.

A female human, is a human with the body formed around the production of large gametes, or ova. This categorisation works reliably regardless of whether that production has ever happen, will ever happen or is currently happening. This requires the body formation around ovaries.

There may have been a handful of human beings with chimerism where they ended up with both. But that is because their body has developed with a part of another human's cells inside their body where those cells are not supposed to be. I think there is one recorded case of this where if I remember there was an internal teste (that I don't believe worked) and an ovary.

No human with a difference of development has both working testes and working ova production capability. With modern medical testing all human beings are reliably able to be categorised as male or female. Even mature human beings.

Using any human with a DSD condition as some kind of gotcha to destabilise the absolute reliability of 'there are only two sexes' is offensive and othering.

And there are not 1.7% of the world's population with a DSD. That number is false. It is around 0.18%. Because the higher number includes female people and male people with issues from birth that are not actually a DSD where their sex needs to be tested because of ambiguous genitalia. For instance the male people in that wider number simply have the opening of their urethra displaced on their penis. That is all. That is not ambiguous genitalia.

There is no 'third' sex. There is no third gamete. There is no third sex for any reproduction purposes.

Even one of the often misquoted authors of a paper that people cite as evidence, Claire Ainsworth clarified, there are two sexes. There is plenty of body variation within each sex. But only two sexes.

BaronessEllarawrosaurus · 23/06/2023 18:39

theDudesmummy · 23/06/2023 18:37

I just give up on trying to explain about the use of the term intersex...

It's very deliberate and not worth the effort of correcting

Confusedmumannoyedson · 23/06/2023 18:38

To most people there are males and females and an extremely rare condition where both body parts although smaller or underdeveloped but the XX XY XXY etc denote male by having a Y in the chromosomes and without Y is female.

However, the TRA will tell you that there are lots of different alphabet soup people and sex is like a rainbow or spectrum and confusing lots of kids and a few handmaidens as well. Gender is a social construct and whilst you might be more or less masculine or feminine (going on stereotypical ideas) or non binary or fe fi fo fum or one of the hundred or so other variants that apparently children or adults with a mental health issue can pick from nowadays.

Be who you want to be but keep the men out of the women's sports/prisons/safe spaces/rape centres etc etc and keep the status of biological sex according to XX XY and life would rock along much easier. The push into women's spaces by men is the problem and men would have women move over for them rather than use men's spaces or create a third space.... therein lies the problem.

theDudesmummy · 23/06/2023 18:37

I just give up on trying to explain about the use of the term intersex...

PaintbrushSoap · 23/06/2023 18:36

jonahjones · 23/06/2023 14:13

yes true the DNA sequencing is done now to determine sex. unfortunately in previous generations this wasn't the case and the poor babies were just raised in the sex that they thought their genitals most closely resembled. as was the case with lady Colin Campbell being raised as male.

Karyotyping was invented in 1955!

theDudesmummy · 23/06/2023 18:35

@EctopicSpleen that has, as far as I am aware, only ever happened once? And this was a surrogate situation of course, as the person did not have gonads or gametes. They were not, biologically, a mother.

I still contend that we should not be calling an XY chromosome individual a woman, as the biological definition of a woman is an adult human without a Y chromosome. (Obviouly other definitions have existed in the past as we did not always know about the chromosomes, but I would contend that this person would not fall within those definitions either eg human with large immobile gametes, of which this person had none).

This unbelievably rare case does not in my opinion lead to the concusion that we should change our definition of what sex is.

shatteredmum1 · 23/06/2023 18:30

Some people are born intersex. This is extremely rare and not through choice.

Helleofabore · 23/06/2023 18:30

shatteredmum1 · 23/06/2023 17:11

Caster Semenya has a vagina. She was brought up as female. She is actually a very rare example of a person born intersex.
Her treatment by various sporting authorities and judgement from the ignorant public has been truly shocking.

shatteredmum1

How do you know that Semenya has a vagina?

Caster Semenya has 5ARD, it is recorded as evidence for their court case to be allowed to compete over the past few years. 5ARD is only a male condition. It is not a female condition.

Please though, link up the evidence that Semenya has a vagina? I believe though that Semenya had undescended testes. It is irrelevant whether Semenya had any sort of vaginal opening. That 'vagina' never was part of a female reproductive system.

"Her treatment by various sporting authorities and judgement from the ignorant public has been truly shocking.Her treatment by various sporting authorities and judgement from the ignorant public has been truly shocking."

Sadly, it seems that you are the ignorant person here. And it is truly shocking that you would support a person who has been proven to have experienced male puberty, due to those testes that they have, to take the records, acclaim and financial benefit that should have always gone to an outstanding female athlete.

Aplantismanycolours · 23/06/2023 18:28

SmartHome · 23/06/2023 14:52

Caster Semenya is a male with a DSD. There is no such thing as intersex and the term is no longer mediclaly used.

Caster Semenya is about as far from possible as being a woman - as you can clearly see in the video linked in the many threads about him - I cba to go and find it again right now. Look at the last CS threadon here a couple of weeks ago.

For anyone interested, I think this is one of the examples SmartHome is referring to.

Caster: "I grew up with boys, everything was all about boys. Girls were a little bit boring to me because they're too soft."
Female presenter: "So you think I'm soft?"
Caster: "I think you're soft, of course."

Caster Semenya on THE LINK - EP42 Season 3

South African Olympian Caster Semenya joins Lerato Kganyago in studio to chat about her childhood and how she got into running as well as upping her game on ...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hvg50P4FwTk&t=1s

ItJustFellOutLikeWordVomit · 23/06/2023 18:27

So for the 52 people who are saying that people born with DSD are a third sex? (I’m not saying I believe that) or do any of you think it’s a possibility to change your sex (your actual sex not your appearance/life style)? If all agreeable that the latter can’t happen then surely no need to be calling anyone a cis woman because they are a woman not a man and it’s as simple as that? Again not saying you can’t be a trans man or woman you do you but you can’t change your actual sex if I/you like it or not, there are no variations on actual sex.

OP posts:
Cailin66 · 23/06/2023 18:24

Sistanotcista · 23/06/2023 13:50

Exactly this. Look up Caster Semenya for a real life example.

Caster is male, because he’s also has an intersex condition they thought he was female at birth. The clue that he is male can be deduced by his XY chromosomes. It’s also the reason he’s banned from certain women’s races.