Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There are two sexes…

635 replies

ItJustFellOutLikeWordVomit · 23/06/2023 13:34

Well just that really….I have gay, straight, bi sexual and transsexual friends and absolutely have no problem with that, very much a do what makes you happy person.

Butttt….AIBU to think the world is going a bit mad with all the non-female, cis female and whatever other labels are floating about. I’m a woman and that’s that, you are either biologically a male or biologically a female and I don’t mean that in an insensitive way dress how you like and date who you like but surely we can’t just be inventing different/new sexes and telling straight women they are no longer a woman they are now XYZ?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
LaPerduta · 23/06/2023 23:08

neveradullmoment99 · 23/06/2023 17:19

I always thought it was decided later on though. Ive no idea. No need to be so aggressive.

If you've no idea then STFU!

LaPerduta · 23/06/2023 23:06

neveradullmoment99 · 23/06/2023 17:19

Dont be so literal. Honestly. Im not intersex so I don't know how they decide. I guess they have to choose one or the other. I know it is a medical condition. If that isn't based on how they feel about what sex they are ive no idea. Maybe the parents decide.

Please just stop now.

LaPerduta · 23/06/2023 22:56

neveradullmoment99 · 23/06/2023 17:05

That person has both sexes and they can choose. which sex they feel is right - male or female.

Why make a statement like this which is totally inaccurate? You clearly don't know what you're talking about.

thebloodycatwontstopmeowing · 23/06/2023 22:55

What about identifying as a cat? 🐱

LaPerduta · 23/06/2023 22:48

DogandMog · 23/06/2023 19:01

It's not the chromosomes per se which determine sex... it is the genes within those chromosomes which do. Hence it is possible (but extremely rare) for a woman to have XY chromosomes, and for a man to have XX chromosomes. The conditions are Swyer syndrome and De La Chapelle syndrome.

The deciding gene is SRY... if it is activated, then a male reproductive physiology develops, and if it is silent then a female reproductive system develops. A male reproductive developmental pathway is called a Wolffian system, and a female pathway is called a Müllerian system.

But... just as clown fish biology only pertains to... clown fish, the medical biology of DSDs only pertains to people diagnosed with DSDs. No political or sociological claims can be extrapolated out of such conditions into the general population to attempt to assert notions about the mutability of sex. In gonochoric species (all mammals, all birds & 98% of fish) sex is as binary as it gets.

Hurrah. Accurate and clear. Agree 100%. Thank you. (I have Swyer's Syndrome.)

FurryPelmet · 23/06/2023 22:45

SummerLovingg · 23/06/2023 13:42

Some people are born neither male or female.

No, they absolutely are not. If you mean people with DSDs (who used to be labelled ‘intersex’ but thankfully this has changed because it’s dated) they are still biologically either male or female, and not something in between the sexes or a third sex.

Not one single human on this planet is anything other than a male or a female.

The gender activists are doing their best to try to get the world to think that the educated people are the ones who understand new developments and sophisticated nuances in science that place sex on a binary scale. The ones who actually understand the science are supposedly just not up to date with the changing world of biology. Interestingly, none are prepared to sit on a panel with biological scientists and have each and every one of their claims addressed.

The proper scientists would have a field day. It’s like trying to convince flat earthers that they are talking absolute crap when millions of other flat earthers are sharing memes and pseudo science and nodding encouragingly and blocking anyone who wishes to challenge them with some facts.

It’s also why this poll is currently at 93%.

LaPerduta · 23/06/2023 22:43

I am intersex. There is an awful lot of misinformation/misapprehension on this thread.

I don't mind the term intersex, but I absolutely do not accept DSDs being used as "proof" of sex being generally non-binary, or as justification for trans ideology.

It is difficult enough to be an intersex woman without trans women using us as proof that you can be a woman with XY chromosomes. Not unless you have a very specific congenital condition you can't.

No trans woman has a womb, fallopian tubes and a vagina, and a complete absence of male characteristics.

nothingcomestonothing · 23/06/2023 22:29

Dovetail40 · 23/06/2023 22:23

Dangerous how society has ran with this and so many in IRL are terrified about offending anyone.

Needed to have been stopped in its tracks a long time ago.

It wasn't an accident. This ideology has deliberately and quietly infiltrated government, the civil service, the law, the NHS and many other institutions, without most people noticing or understanding the implications.

Dovetail40 · 23/06/2023 22:23

Dangerous how society has ran with this and so many in IRL are terrified about offending anyone.

Needed to have been stopped in its tracks a long time ago.

Stillcountingbeans · 23/06/2023 22:21

ditalini · 23/06/2023 22:07

Not a doctor, I should imagine if the phenotype is typically male then they will be raised male, possibly not even diagnosed but almost certainly infertile.

If phenotypically female then the same - also possibly not diagnosed until puberty, almost always infertile.

I don't know what the investigation and decision making process will be for vey ambiguous genitalia and possibly streak gonads. Still not a third sex, probably no gametes.

This is where it gets interesting...
As a philosophical exercise, how is the sex of such a person determined? Are they sexless? Both sexes?
Agree there is no such thing as a 'third sex'

And for the sake of clarity to any other readers who may still be here, no-one can 'change sex', and sex is most definitely not a 'spectrum' despite the existence of vanishingly rare chimera cases.

Off to bed now, as getting up very early tomorrow.

ditalini · 23/06/2023 22:07

Stillcountingbeans · 23/06/2023 21:52

So how does one determine the sex of such a person? Is it just by phenotyping?
What gametes do they produce (if any)?

Not a doctor, I should imagine if the phenotype is typically male then they will be raised male, possibly not even diagnosed but almost certainly infertile.

If phenotypically female then the same - also possibly not diagnosed until puberty, almost always infertile.

I don't know what the investigation and decision making process will be for vey ambiguous genitalia and possibly streak gonads. Still not a third sex, probably no gametes.

Stillcountingbeans · 23/06/2023 21:52

ditalini · 23/06/2023 21:49

Yes. 45X/46XY does have a spectrum of phenotypical presentation from normal male through ambiguous to normal female.

So how does one determine the sex of such a person? Is it just by phenotyping?
What gametes do they produce (if any)?

ditalini · 23/06/2023 21:52

And I say "normal", obviously it's normal for the person whose body it is - there's a wide range of normal for human bodies. Typical would be a better word.

ditalini · 23/06/2023 21:49

Stillcountingbeans · 23/06/2023 21:41

Are there any cases of human chimeras who present as male? Or are these people always female (on the pathway to produce large gametes, to use Kathleen Stock's very helpful definition).

Yes. 45X/46XY does have a spectrum of phenotypical presentation from normal male through ambiguous to normal female.

Stillcountingbeans · 23/06/2023 21:41

Are there any cases of human chimeras who present as male? Or are these people always female (on the pathway to produce large gametes, to use Kathleen Stock's very helpful definition).

Helleofabore · 23/06/2023 20:31

ItJustFellOutLikeWordVomit · 23/06/2023 20:17

Well the people who have decided my post is in the wrong place, I don’t think it is because I’m asking if my opinion reasonable or not hence the AIBU poll.

Same goes for the “ooh how original”/“not this again”

You are clearly annoyed at the thread for whatever reason…the title doesn’t mislead if you don’t like the title of a thread don’t click it? 😑

I think it’s an important subject that needs to be recognised and addressed, if you don’t then don’t involve yourself.

Yes OP. There is a group of posters who have little impulse control or who expect MN to curate a board just for them. It is always the same posters.

If you thread is moved, do ask for it to be moved back. But that will remove the poll. Still, it has been an important thread with lots to learn. So thank you.

Rainbowshit · 23/06/2023 20:26

LimitIsUp · 23/06/2023 13:54

@Rainbowshit - don't embarrass yourself love. Look up intersex

🤭 🤭

Love, you're the one that has embarrassed yourself here. Could not be cringing more for you.

Intersex is a misleading, outdated and offensive term as many many others on this thread have said. Hope you have realised what an arse you have made of yourself

Every single human even those with a with a difference of sexual development is either male or female.

ItJustFellOutLikeWordVomit · 23/06/2023 20:17

Well the people who have decided my post is in the wrong place, I don’t think it is because I’m asking if my opinion reasonable or not hence the AIBU poll.

Same goes for the “ooh how original”/“not this again”

You are clearly annoyed at the thread for whatever reason…the title doesn’t mislead if you don’t like the title of a thread don’t click it? 😑

I think it’s an important subject that needs to be recognised and addressed, if you don’t then don’t involve yourself.

OP posts:
Bookist · 23/06/2023 19:41

There are only two sexes.

As for what gender people choose to identify is there's male/female and Other. And I'm too old, tired and menopausal to give the slightest shit about anything happening with the Others.

Newrumpus · 23/06/2023 19:40

CatchYouOnTheFlippetyFlop · 23/06/2023 13:41

It actually isn't. It's super regressive, stereotypical bullshit.

Yes. Woke nonsense

GailBlancheViola · 23/06/2023 19:39

Women want trans women to not use their toilets, because they think its a man.

Not think, know.

However, it isnt as simple as having the trans woman using the mans toilets, because, by identifying as female, she will be at risk in those toilets.

You can't identify as female, female is a biological reality. TW, who are male, using the female toilets puts women at risk and also results in some women having to self exclude from their own toilet space. That's discrimination.

There is ZERO evidence that TW are at any risk using the male toilet facilities yet there is evidence of risk and harm to women with TW using the female facilities.

loislovesstewie · 23/06/2023 19:33

Not being scientific I don't think it's difficult. Caster is male, the fact that at some point he 'claimed' to be female isn't enough to 'be' female.

viques · 23/06/2023 19:29

viques · 23/06/2023 19:27

But Caster presents as a man , so although they have continued , despite verified medical evidence, to claim to be a woman ( no doubt because they want to keep up the pretence of being an international female cheat athlete) they clearly live their life as a man. Which is what he is.

And yes, DSD is a rare condition, which is why it is a statistical puzzle about why it appears so often within the already niche population of middle distance female runners.

viques · 23/06/2023 19:27

Sceptic1234 · 23/06/2023 14:58

I'm afraid I think it is wrong to refer to Caster as "him" despite my scientific understanding (I have been involved in research into steroid hormone action....now retired).

DSD cases are very rare and very, very difficult to live with and I think it is important to respect the perspective of an individual who finds themselves in that situation. Carter's situation is very difficult and very complex

But Caster presents as a man , so although they have continued , despite verified medical evidence, to claim to be a woman ( no doubt because they want to keep up the pretence of being an international female cheat athlete) they clearly live their life as a man. Which is what he is.

Helleofabore · 23/06/2023 19:20

ilovesooty · 23/06/2023 14:28

The Sex and Gender discussion board

I think you have tried this one enough times to realise it has become increasingly rare for MN to move a thread to the Feminist chat board if there is a poll and the OP does not wish the thread to move.

I know that you and others find these threads as irresistible as can be that you simply cannot scroll past and ignore them. And you feel compelled to attempt to either shame OPs for starting them or get them moved.

This is a discussion that I believe stemmed from current news items about a teacher who declared that there were three sexes. It is relevant as this is a concept that is being taught in our schools.

I think the poll results are rather conclusive that this is an important discussion and that the majority of posters are here for it. And we are all learning along the way.

By all means, scroll on past it or hide it.