Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There are two sexes…

635 replies

ItJustFellOutLikeWordVomit · 23/06/2023 13:34

Well just that really….I have gay, straight, bi sexual and transsexual friends and absolutely have no problem with that, very much a do what makes you happy person.

Butttt….AIBU to think the world is going a bit mad with all the non-female, cis female and whatever other labels are floating about. I’m a woman and that’s that, you are either biologically a male or biologically a female and I don’t mean that in an insensitive way dress how you like and date who you like but surely we can’t just be inventing different/new sexes and telling straight women they are no longer a woman they are now XYZ?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
nothingcomestonothing · 26/06/2023 17:00

StormShadow · 26/06/2023 16:17

Even then, it's abundantly obvious if you read the publicly available and easy to find judgement. But the press so seldom mention it. I suspect some of the people who think Caster is just a female with an unusually high level of testosterone might think differently if they knew about the Y chromosome.

The press quite deliberately obfuscate it, because they don't want to tell the truth. If everyone clearly understood that CS is male and has all the advantages conferred by male puberty, that would open up a seam of conversation about how that's unfair.and shouldn't be allowed. Which might then also be applied to males with special identities. And we can't have that because most marginalised and vulnerable ™.

It was this issue which really brought home to me that main stream media will blatantly lie and throw women under the bus in service of the queer agenda. To describe CS (or the other athletes with DSDs competing in women's sports) as a woman with a high natural testosterone is a bare faced lie which MSM have made again and again. They know, everyone involved knows, that CS is male. They've just decided it's best we not say so. Best for who? Not women, but who gives a shit about them?

Tippingadvice · 26/06/2023 16:54

@nothingcomestonothing I was 100% sure if it had been confirmed. That’s why I used allegedly. Thanks for the confirmation.

Helleofabore · 26/06/2023 16:51

If anyone is interested in the background of why the IOC dropped sex testing, you might want to read this.

Again, note the usage of the word 'female' to describe male DSD conditions. No female is insensitive to testosterone. That would only ever be a male person, I believe.

But it is this language that misinforms. And that is fine people haven't the interest or time to check. But .... if you have not taken the time to research further, please stop posting it with such certainty and moral superiority.

https://www.nature.com/articles/gim2000258.pdf?origin=ppub&utm_medium=affiliate&utm_source=commission_junction&utm_campaign=CONR_PF018_ECOM_GL_PHSS_ALWYS_DEEPLINK&utm_content=textlink&utm_term=PID100045542&CJEVENT=0a3f7d38143811ee80fd01310a18b8fb

https://www.nature.com/articles/gim2000258.pdf?origin=ppub&utm_medium=affiliate&utm_source=commission_junction&utm_campaign=CONR_PF018_ECOM_GL_PHSS_ALWYS_DEEPLINK&utm_content=textlink&utm_term=PID100045542&CJEVENT=0a3f7d38143811ee80fd01310a18b8fb

NalafromtheLionKing · 26/06/2023 16:23

GeriatricMumma · 23/06/2023 13:46

Sonographer at my scan: "would you like to know the sex of your baby"

Me: "yes please"

Pretty sure there are only two options 🙄

Sonographer: “You are having a beautiful baby trans, the baby is a cis boy and does have a penis but we will arrange for an emergency operation to remove it immediately upon birth”.

StormShadow · 26/06/2023 16:17

nothingcomestonothing · 26/06/2023 15:18

There's no 'allegedly' about it, the court for sport arbitration (might not be called that exactly) judgement is upthread. Caster Semenya has 5ARD, which is a DSD which only affects males. He is male, all involved in the sport know this, only the public are deliberately kept uninformed about it.

Even then, it's abundantly obvious if you read the publicly available and easy to find judgement. But the press so seldom mention it. I suspect some of the people who think Caster is just a female with an unusually high level of testosterone might think differently if they knew about the Y chromosome.

BCCoach · 26/06/2023 16:12

CampervanKween · 26/06/2023 15:05

I believe he has also fathered several children with his wife, although the details of all that are kept quiet for some reason 🤔

It's really not a secret at all, there have been plenty of magazine articles about their family in ZA and they have the girls on their instagram: https://zalebs.com/relationships/caster-semenya/meet-caster-semenyas-wife-and-beautiful-children

Meet Caster Semenya's Wife And Beautiful Children

Here is everything you need to know about Caster Semenya’s wife who is one of her biggest supporters, their love story, and their beautiful children.

https://zalebs.com/relationships/caster-semenya/meet-caster-semenyas-wife-and-beautiful-children

borntobequiet · 26/06/2023 15:32

While sport is being mentioned, can I recommend Sharron Davies’ book (with Craig Lord, a swimmer and sports journalist) Unfair Play. It’s a very good read, well-written and well evidenced, and even though I knew quite a lot already I was shocked at some of the instances of men self-identifying in to women’s sport, the way sporting bodies (including the IOC) enabled and continue to enable this, the way women’s concerns were dismissed and the shocking abuse those who speak out are forced to endure.
It also details the historical biases against women in sport and the difficulties and deliberate humiliations they had to endure in order to compete. An eye-opener.

nothingcomestonothing · 26/06/2023 15:18

Tippingadvice · 26/06/2023 15:04

The easiest way to tell if Caster is male or female is a blood test. Secondary sex characteristics (genitals) no longer need to be examined.

Apparently Princess Anne is the only female Olympic competitor to not have undergone the compulsory sex test to ensure athletes competing in the female category. I believe the tests have evolved from the 1940s onwards and now are hormone based.

The hormone tests allegedly showed Caster has a DSD only men can have.

There's no 'allegedly' about it, the court for sport arbitration (might not be called that exactly) judgement is upthread. Caster Semenya has 5ARD, which is a DSD which only affects males. He is male, all involved in the sport know this, only the public are deliberately kept uninformed about it.

CampervanKween · 26/06/2023 15:05

I believe he has also fathered several children with his wife, although the details of all that are kept quiet for some reason 🤔

Tippingadvice · 26/06/2023 15:04

The easiest way to tell if Caster is male or female is a blood test. Secondary sex characteristics (genitals) no longer need to be examined.

Apparently Princess Anne is the only female Olympic competitor to not have undergone the compulsory sex test to ensure athletes competing in the female category. I believe the tests have evolved from the 1940s onwards and now are hormone based.

The hormone tests allegedly showed Caster has a DSD only men can have.

Florissante · 26/06/2023 15:02

hollyblueivy · 26/06/2023 14:22

Does Caster have a penis or vagina?

Caster has a micro-penis.

LoopyLoo1991 · 26/06/2023 14:31

SummerLovingg · 23/06/2023 13:42

Some people are born neither male or female.

Or have an immunity to male or female sex hormone.
So XY but present as completely female. Only extensive medical scans or chromosomal analysis will show they are actually biologically male.

And vice versa with XX individuals presenting as males.
And that's not even getting into XXY XXXY XXXXY and so on.

ditalini · 26/06/2023 14:26

Caster's genitals are Caster's own business, but other people with this condition find that their male external genitalia is virilised at puberty (BBC news story about a village in the Dominican Republic where a higher than average number of boys are born with 5-ARD: The extraordinary case of the Guevedoces - BBC News)

Catherine and his cousin Carla, Guevedoces in the Dominican Republic

The extraordinary case of the Guevedoces

Children in a remote village in the Dominican Republic have an extremely unusual condition.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-34290981

hollyblueivy · 26/06/2023 14:22

Does Caster have a penis or vagina?

loislovesstewie · 26/06/2023 13:39

hollyblueivy · 26/06/2023 12:43

Is Caster a man though?

Yes Caster is a man. We are however obliged under the 'be kind' mantra to say 'she'. because upsetting Caster by being biologically correct isn't acceptable.

ArabeIIaScott · 26/06/2023 12:45

Yes, a man with a DSD or an intersex condition.

hollyblueivy · 26/06/2023 12:43

Is Caster a man though?

Sistanotcista · 26/06/2023 12:38

FatNoMoreSue · 26/06/2023 08:39

Caster Semenya is a man. He had a DSD that only occurs in men.

I never stated s/he was either a man or a woman. I merely quoted from Wikipedia which stated that s/he was a woman. I also stated early on in the thread that I was happy to be educated, and have taken on board the comments people have made about using "intersex" and also enjoyed reading the links @LimitIsUp , @BMW6 and @FOJN provided.

ArabeIIaScott · 26/06/2023 09:31

Kucinghitam · 25/06/2023 17:14

It's the confidence of being buoyed along upon a fluffy cloud of one's own Righteousness, secure in the knowledge that of course this is Correct and above all Being Kind, and that in the unlikely event that it isn't, one is still Righteous because any pious fraud can be justified in service of the Right Side of History.

To be fair to those who have adopted these very skewed views, the NHS, the government, the media and the legal system have been complicit in promulgating them.

The BBC showed teachers telling children there were '100 genders'.
The NHS ask men if they may be pregnant.
The Scottish government claim a rapist can have a female penis.
The GRA suggests it's possible to change sex.
The international sporting community has colluded in the idea that Caster Semenya is female for years.

It's fairly understandable that many people have accepted the lies, given the authority of those pushing them!

FatNoMoreSue · 26/06/2023 08:39

Sistanotcista · 23/06/2023 13:50

Exactly this. Look up Caster Semenya for a real life example.

Caster Semenya is a man. He had a DSD that only occurs in men.

SmartHome · 26/06/2023 08:17

It's lack of education too. In this country you are only forced to do science up to 16 and only at a rudimentary level if you do double award GCSE. Someone that bunked off and scraped through/failed really has very, very little understanding of human biology (or statistics) and hence you get people believing all kinds of rubbish. It's a problem in this country imo, we are falling behind a lot of other countries where young adults are now better educated.

Emotionalsupportviper · 26/06/2023 08:15

porridgecake · 25/06/2023 16:01

Did anyone see that episode of Question Time when Lord Winston put his head in his hands when that silly person in the audience told him science had moved on?
She was arguing with him so disrespectfully. Robert Winston. Astonishing. This thread reminds me of that.

Yes - but be fair.

She was a drama student . . . 😄

(Apologies to all drama students who DON'T think they know more about genetics, and the causes of infertility than Lord Winston. A man who is also an award-winning theatre director, as it happens.)

TastesLikeStrawberriesOnASummerEvening · 25/06/2023 21:00

Kucinghitam · 25/06/2023 17:14

It's the confidence of being buoyed along upon a fluffy cloud of one's own Righteousness, secure in the knowledge that of course this is Correct and above all Being Kind, and that in the unlikely event that it isn't, one is still Righteous because any pious fraud can be justified in service of the Right Side of History.

Absolutely this.
I also think they just aren't very bright.

Kucinghitam · 25/06/2023 17:14

ArabeIIaScott · 25/06/2023 16:13

What surprises me is the confidence. Anyone can get confused or have a poor understanding of the issues, that's understandable, but to come out with 'facts' like this with such assertiveness is really quite problematic.

It's the confidence of being buoyed along upon a fluffy cloud of one's own Righteousness, secure in the knowledge that of course this is Correct and above all Being Kind, and that in the unlikely event that it isn't, one is still Righteous because any pious fraud can be justified in service of the Right Side of History.

Kilopascal · 25/06/2023 16:55

Is it a confusion between 0.1 (10%) and 0.1%, I wonder?