Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There are two sexes…

635 replies

ItJustFellOutLikeWordVomit · 23/06/2023 13:34

Well just that really….I have gay, straight, bi sexual and transsexual friends and absolutely have no problem with that, very much a do what makes you happy person.

Butttt….AIBU to think the world is going a bit mad with all the non-female, cis female and whatever other labels are floating about. I’m a woman and that’s that, you are either biologically a male or biologically a female and I don’t mean that in an insensitive way dress how you like and date who you like but surely we can’t just be inventing different/new sexes and telling straight women they are no longer a woman they are now XYZ?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
suggestionsplease1 · 23/06/2023 15:48

nothingcomestonothing · 23/06/2023 15:42

I really recommend this site for info on the perspective of people with DSD, and the co-option of DSDs by those pushing TQ+ ideology

https://differently-normal.com/author/clarecais/

And you could maybe look up all the intersex organisations whose members are quite happily using that term with respect to DSDs.

SmartHome · 23/06/2023 15:47

Sceptic1234 · 23/06/2023 15:42

As a scientist this is the bit I can't understand. Caster is almost (but not quite) totally insensive to testosterone .... so why is the circulating level of testosterone so important??

This is wrong. Caster Semenya has 5α-Reductase 2 deficiency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/5%CE%B1-Reductase_2_deficiency not Complete or Partial Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome.

In the case of 5ARD that CS has, they actually experience an approaching normal male puberty at puberty when the testes take over production of testosterone.

Even PAIS patients can have near normal circulating testosterone. Probably not enough to beat eleite female athletes though. That's why immoral scouts were previoulsy looking for 5ARD cases in African and India and why all the podium places in the 2008 Olympics 800m female finals were taken by genetic males.

5α-Reductase 2 deficiency - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/5%CE%B1-Reductase_2_deficiency

HereForTheFreeLunch · 23/06/2023 15:47

Begsthequestion · 23/06/2023 15:34

What would you (and others on this thread) say to an adult person (30+) who was born with a female-sexed body (XX) but who never felt like they were a woman, or ever understood from personal experience what "being a woman" meant?

Genuine question.

Being a girl and a woman where I come from used to mean doing the cooking and cleaning, equivalent of being a domestic slave, having no control over your own life. And for many it meant NOT going to school, college.

I soooo didn't feel like a girl. In fact half my class in a girls school didn't feel like a girl.

I am just me, doing me. You do you. No need to do to anything you don't want to do.

For a 30+ woman in modern day UK, I really don't know what it means to identify (or not) as a woman. You are free to not wear makeup, not simper, not wear dresses, wear trousers, do any job you like and can get, kiss another woman, have sex with a woman (if that's what floats your boat), go anywhere , long hair, short hair, drink, smoke, swear, fart.... heck even mansplain and manspread if you like.

Doesn't change the fact that you ARE a woman.

MartyMcFlysPurpleUnderwear · 23/06/2023 15:47

suggestionsplease1 · 23/06/2023 15:45

Ok, so say someone has been brought up as female, has anatomy that is suggestive of female, is happy identifying as female as that is all they have ever known, but a test reveals that person has male chromosomes...would you compel that person to use male toilets from that point onwards?

I am not entirely sure what point you’re trying to make here or why you’re bringing toilets into this when I never mentioned them.

Biologically speaking that person would be male.

ItJustFellOutLikeWordVomit · 23/06/2023 15:46

Begsthequestion · 23/06/2023 15:34

What would you (and others on this thread) say to an adult person (30+) who was born with a female-sexed body (XX) but who never felt like they were a woman, or ever understood from personal experience what "being a woman" meant?

Genuine question.

I would say if you would feel more comfortable to dress as a male try that and if makes you happy dress as a man full time speak to a GP about what hormones without rushing into anything and after speaking to professionals take it as far as makes you happy but this doesn’t change your sex your organs are still your organs and there are only 2 sets available you are born with one of the two and that can’t be changed

OP posts:
nothingcomestonothing · 23/06/2023 15:45

Sceptic1234 · 23/06/2023 15:42

As a scientist this is the bit I can't understand. Caster is almost (but not quite) totally insensive to testosterone .... so why is the circulating level of testosterone so important??

As I understand it, in 5ARD the testosterone is unable to be used in utero, but when puberty occurs the male development kicks in. So taller stronger faster etc

suggestionsplease1 · 23/06/2023 15:45

MartyMcFlysPurpleUnderwear · 23/06/2023 15:38

That still doesn’t make them a third sex or change the fact they will still be either male or female.

Ok, so say someone has been brought up as female, has anatomy that is suggestive of female, is happy identifying as female as that is all they have ever known, but a test reveals that person has male chromosomes...would you compel that person to use male toilets from that point onwards?

Naunet · 23/06/2023 15:44

Begsthequestion · 23/06/2023 15:41

What makes you sure you are a woman, is it anything other than the fact you know you're not a man?

Biology I imagine. What’s confusing you?

TastesLikeStrawberriesOnASummerEvening · 23/06/2023 15:44

Clementineorsatsuma · 23/06/2023 15:19

@TastesLikeStrawberriesOnASummerEvening

People who are intersex may have a mix of chromosomes, such as XXY. Or they may have some cells that are XY and some cells that are XX. Or they may have just one X chromosome (XO).

Stop using intersex.

Verv · 23/06/2023 15:43

AngelinaFibres · 23/06/2023 14:01

My son works with a woman who identifies as a bat. She's also non binary. Who knew bats could be non binary....and work in finance

I think bat-woman could probably do with a dose of Francis Aaron

Francis Aaron – Boys Will Be Girls

A rap song about transgenderism. The point: people are free to live their lives however they so desire, but biology cannot be overthrown.If you think BAT LIV...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pQrYQAYmaOk

SmartHome · 23/06/2023 15:43

Begsthequestion · 23/06/2023 15:41

What makes you sure you are a woman, is it anything other than the fact you know you're not a man?

Being an adult human female

Sceptic1234 · 23/06/2023 15:42

FOJN · 23/06/2023 15:40

Oh for goodness sake.

Casters case has nothing to do with lack of empathy and everything to do with respect for scientific fact and fairness in sport.

How would you propose excluding Caster from female competition without acknowledging facts? Caster is male and produced testosterone at a level which gave them an unfair advantage and would have a woman banned from competition for suspected doping.

Woman is a material reality not an identity.

Caster is free to describe themself however they like but they are male.

As a scientist this is the bit I can't understand. Caster is almost (but not quite) totally insensive to testosterone .... so why is the circulating level of testosterone so important??

luffkinks · 23/06/2023 15:42

FOJN

This

Woman is a material reality not an identity.

nothingcomestonothing · 23/06/2023 15:42

suggestionsplease1 · 23/06/2023 15:37

Many people with DSDs are quite happy with the term intersex, actually.

But that doesn't fit in with the political motivations and machinations of others, hence why you see this line parroted here frequently.

I really recommend this site for info on the perspective of people with DSD, and the co-option of DSDs by those pushing TQ+ ideology

https://differently-normal.com/author/clarecais/

CAISFiles

CAISFiles

Read all of the posts by CAISFiles on Differently Normal

https://differently-normal.com/author/clarecais

SmartHome · 23/06/2023 15:42

suggestionsplease1 · 23/06/2023 15:37

Many people with DSDs are quite happy with the term intersex, actually.

But that doesn't fit in with the political motivations and machinations of others, hence why you see this line parroted here frequently.

Really? Can you link to one? Somoeone with a DSD that does not identify as trans that is happy to be called intersex. I have only ever seen trans-identifying people claim to be intersex.

There are many posters on twitter who have DSDs (and represent DSD organisations/charities) and specifically and vocally and frequently object to trans people claiming intersex as a trans identitiy or third sex.

Wassa123 · 23/06/2023 15:42

Theeyeballsinthesky · 23/06/2023 15:39

How does one “feel like a woman”? 🤔

Maybe they feel like they have periods? Or feel like they've given birth?

That would be a good test wouldn't it. Get them to go through child birth!

loislovesstewie · 23/06/2023 15:41

I feel sympathy for lots of people but that should not get in the way of facts. Making a mistake in observation at birth, doesn't make a male into a female.

Begsthequestion · 23/06/2023 15:41

SmartHome · 23/06/2023 15:39

I'd say crack on. I don't really have a gender identity either. I am not particulary feminine, am gender non-conforming and don't dress in stereotypically female clothing.

I know I'm female and a woman though and then no male can ever be.

What makes you sure you are a woman, is it anything other than the fact you know you're not a man?

Theeyeballsinthesky · 23/06/2023 15:41

They already do @Wassa123 lots of studies say things like “women including trans women & non binary” ie women including men

and yes exactly! How can we have any accurate data about women when men are included?

FOJN · 23/06/2023 15:40

CoalCraft · 23/06/2023 15:30

Horrible la k of empathy for people with DSD on this thread. So someone was born with apparently female genitalia and was raised as a girl, always believed themselves to be female and built being female into their identity, but then turns out to have XY chromosomes, should immediately abandon their previous lifestyle and adopt, essentially, a new persona, because, suddenly, they're a man?

Do I think such a person should be allowed to compete in the female category I'm sports? No, but I don't think their identity as a woman should be denied either.

Oh for goodness sake.

Casters case has nothing to do with lack of empathy and everything to do with respect for scientific fact and fairness in sport.

How would you propose excluding Caster from female competition without acknowledging facts? Caster is male and produced testosterone at a level which gave them an unfair advantage and would have a woman banned from competition for suspected doping.

Woman is a material reality not an identity.

Caster is free to describe themself however they like but they are male.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 23/06/2023 15:39

How does one “feel like a woman”? 🤔

Wassa123 · 23/06/2023 15:39

It is so very concerning that it's actually scary. Are they just going to include biological men in studies about women now? How can we recognise what women's issues are if we are allowing anyone to identify as one. We need to stick together ladies!

literallyarabbit · 23/06/2023 15:39

Florissante · 23/06/2023 15:36

Wait. What. Pantomime horses aren't real horses? Next you're going to tell me that near and far are two different things.

The horse comment made me think of this

There are two sexes…
SmartHome · 23/06/2023 15:39

Begsthequestion · 23/06/2023 15:34

What would you (and others on this thread) say to an adult person (30+) who was born with a female-sexed body (XX) but who never felt like they were a woman, or ever understood from personal experience what "being a woman" meant?

Genuine question.

I'd say crack on. I don't really have a gender identity either. I am not particulary feminine, am gender non-conforming and don't dress in stereotypically female clothing.

I know I'm female and a woman though and then no male can ever be.

RufustheSpecuIatingreindeer · 23/06/2023 15:38

phatt · 23/06/2023 15:33

Most original discussion I’ve ever seen. Enthralling.

Then why keep reading?

is it purely to moan?