Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There are two sexes…

635 replies

ItJustFellOutLikeWordVomit · 23/06/2023 13:34

Well just that really….I have gay, straight, bi sexual and transsexual friends and absolutely have no problem with that, very much a do what makes you happy person.

Butttt….AIBU to think the world is going a bit mad with all the non-female, cis female and whatever other labels are floating about. I’m a woman and that’s that, you are either biologically a male or biologically a female and I don’t mean that in an insensitive way dress how you like and date who you like but surely we can’t just be inventing different/new sexes and telling straight women they are no longer a woman they are now XYZ?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
theDudesmummy · 23/06/2023 17:03

Of FFS @neveradullmoment99 please do read the thread...

borntobequiet · 23/06/2023 17:03

But what about societies where there's is a recognised third or more gender? For example in South Asia, or in Native American cultures? It's not binary everywhere and never has been.

You are conflating/confusing sex and gender. Those “otherwise gendered”people will, as individuals, be either male or female, men or women.

QueenVerilas · 23/06/2023 17:03

Mamabear04 · 23/06/2023 13:47

Some people are intersex so there are three sexes, female, male and intersex. Gender is a whole other story.

Intersex is not a sex.

if you believe it is, what do the resulting humans look like from a coupling of a female and intersex person. Or a male and intersex person?
what is the evolved reproductive purpose and benefit of this third sex?

You can’t answer those questions as there is no third sex. What there are, are DSDs for male people, and DSDs for female people. There are a tiny number of people with DSDs who are genuinely of indeterminate sex, but they are not a third sex as their DSD does not give them a distinctive new role in human reproduction.

theDudesmummy · 23/06/2023 17:03

and @EctopicSpleen I did not use the term "real woman". I would not use such a term (except to distinguish from a fictional woman I suppose). There are no "real" or nonreal women. There are women. And then there are men.

neveradullmoment99 · 23/06/2023 17:01

Rainbowshit · 23/06/2023 13:44

Bullshit. Every single human in the planet is either male or female.

Agree unless they have the rare condition where they are born intersex.

nothingcomestonothing · 23/06/2023 17:01

ASGIRC · 23/06/2023 16:57

A trans person is discrimitated against.

Here in this very thread you see that.

The biggest thing being toilet use (I dont want to get into it, Im just citing it as an example).

Women want trans women to not use their toilets, because they think its a man.
However, it isnt as simple as having the trans woman using the mans toilets, because, by identifying as female, she will be at risk in those toilets.

So no, there isnt protection.

Discrimination is real (in many forms, not just against trans people!) and it is disengenuous to pretend otherwise.

Honestly, piss off with this. Not being able to have what you want is NOT the same as discrimination.

And re toilets, there is no evidence of transwomen being at risk in men's toilets. None. None at all. But there is evidence of risk to women, of males of any identity in women's toilets. Including the 10 year old girls sexually assualted in the women's toilets by transwoman 'Katie' Dolatowki.

Once again, not having everything you want is not discrimination.

ilovesooty · 23/06/2023 16:59

MillicentTrilbyHiggins · 23/06/2023 16:35

Men's shirts, short skirts?
Colour my hair, do what I dare?

Beat me to it 🤣

theDudesmummy · 23/06/2023 16:59

I think that Swyer and de la Chapelle do present some challenges to the definitions, yes, but they are of course very very rare, and in dealing with them in society, ethical and moral considerations come very much into play as much as what the actual biological reality is. The decisions to be made in such cases are in my opinion, very different from trans issues.

We do define the sexes by the chromosomes. In my opinion that is what we must continue to do. A Y chromosome makes you a biological male, whatever else is going on. A lack of a Y chromosome makes you a biological female. It does not mean we cannot have sympathy and empathy for people for whom the very definition causes problems.

TheShellBeach · 23/06/2023 16:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Begsthequestion · 23/06/2023 16:58

GoldfincTart · 23/06/2023 16:55

This suggests being a "woman" is a social construct. It's not fixed and depends on how different societies define it, historically and globally.

No, being male or female has been absolutely consistent for thousands of years because it's biology and biology hasn't changed. XX body = female/ woman. XY body = male/ man. Sex is consistent and real.

What changes are social norms and expectations expected of women and men. Gender roles, sex stereotyping — call it whatever you want, that's the social construct. Not biology.

This is true for some parts of the world during some of human history, but not everywhere all the time.

ASGIRC · 23/06/2023 16:57

luffkinks · 23/06/2023 14:58

@ASGIRC

It is absolutely not akin to being Gay 30 years ago.

Gay rights were asking for the law to include protections not to discriminate.

Trans already have protection in law specifically for trans people.

Gay rights were asking for marriage to be legal

Trans people can legally marry whom ever they want.

What rights do trans people not have?

Being Gay is a reality, a man who is attracted to a man. It is reality, it doesn't affect anyone else's rights.

A trans person is discrimitated against.

Here in this very thread you see that.

The biggest thing being toilet use (I dont want to get into it, Im just citing it as an example).

Women want trans women to not use their toilets, because they think its a man.
However, it isnt as simple as having the trans woman using the mans toilets, because, by identifying as female, she will be at risk in those toilets.

So no, there isnt protection.

Discrimination is real (in many forms, not just against trans people!) and it is disengenuous to pretend otherwise.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 23/06/2023 16:56

Quite @luffkinks it’s so bloody insulting!!

Begsthequestion · 23/06/2023 16:56

nothingcomestonothing · 23/06/2023 16:42

Being a man or woman is a biological reality, fixed and constant throughout history. Social constructs of masculinity and femininity change according to place and time. Being a woman is fixed, what we consider appropriate for women is not.

Thanks for your reply.

I think that could apply to the many societies and cultures which only recognise the existence of man/male sex and woman/female sex.

But what about societies where there's is a recognised third or more gender? For example in South Asia, or in Native American cultures? It's not binary everywhere and never has been.

luffkinks · 23/06/2023 16:55

@EctopicSpleen

What on Earth do you mean? Infertile women still have female chromosomes.
Honestly where did you get that idea?

GoldfincTart · 23/06/2023 16:55

This suggests being a "woman" is a social construct. It's not fixed and depends on how different societies define it, historically and globally.

No, being male or female has been absolutely consistent for thousands of years because it's biology and biology hasn't changed. XX body = female/ woman. XY body = male/ man. Sex is consistent and real.

What changes are social norms and expectations expected of women and men. Gender roles, sex stereotyping — call it whatever you want, that's the social construct. Not biology.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 23/06/2023 16:55

As an infertile women it pisses me the fuck off to be used as some kind of gotcha in this bullshit

im infertile because my female biology doesn’t work properly, it doesn’t make me not a woman

TheShellBeach · 23/06/2023 16:55

EctopicSpleen · 23/06/2023 16:13

Never heard of Klinefelter's syndrome then? Look it up.

I don't need to look it up but it isn't a third sex, as you seem to imagine.

Klinefelter syndrome (sometimes called Klinefelter's, KS or XXY) is where boys and men are born with an extra X chromosome.

Chromosomes are packages of genes found in every cell in the body. There are 2 types of chromosome, called the sex chromosomes, that determine the genetic sex of a baby. These are named either X or Y.

Usually, a female baby has 2 X chromosomes (XX) and a male has 1 X and 1 Y (XY). But in Klinefelter syndrome, a boy is born with an extra copy of the X chromosome (XXY).

The X chromosome is not a "female" chromosome and is present in everyone. The presence of a Y chromosome denotes male sex.

Boys and men with Klinefelter syndrome are still genetically male, and often will not realise they have this extra chromosome.

ContinuousProcrastination · 23/06/2023 16:54

SummerLovingg · Today 13:42
Some people are born neither male or female

This isn't really true, some people are born intersex /DSD but there's usually specificity whereby these individuals are from a scientific perspective aligned with one sex or the other.

ArabeIIaScott · 23/06/2023 16:54

There are only two sexes.

It is not possible to change sex.

BreatheAndFocus · 23/06/2023 16:53

Begsthequestion · 23/06/2023 16:39

I get what you're saying. Female sexed bodies are female.

However, the idea of what a woman is, how she acts, what she is expected to do and not do, know, work as, live as, even how young she can be, etc. has changed dramatically over the centuries.

This suggests being a "woman" is a social construct. It's not fixed and depends on how different societies define it, historically and globally.

It absolutely doesn’t suggest being a women is a social construct. Female people are girls and women whatever culture they grow up in. The fact the gender expectations might differ, and have changed through history and through time, is irrelevant.

10 year old boys used to be sent up chimneys to sweep them in the 19th century. The fact we don’t do that any more doesn’t mean the words “10 year old boy” have a different meaning now.

nothingcomestonothing · 23/06/2023 16:53

SinnerBoy · 23/06/2023 16:43

nothingcomestonothing

I really recommend this site for info on the perspective of people with DSD, and the co-option of DSDs by those pushing TQ+ ideology.

You're almost certainly flogging a dead horse with suggestions as they always ignore any evidence and just carry on punting the same old false schtick.

They and some other posters have ignored any articles, blogs and interviews on the subject and merely keep banging on that people with DSDs are happy to be referred to in derogatory terms.

Hopefully, some readers who don't have a rigid agenda in the subject will be able to gain some knowledge from reading your linked blog!

I know - posting for the benefit of lurkers really. I think that blog is great, so informative.

luffkinks · 23/06/2023 16:52

I'm so confused.
38 voters said you were being unreasonable 😂😂😂

Emotionalsupportviper · 23/06/2023 16:51

Mamabear04 · 23/06/2023 13:47

Some people are intersex so there are three sexes, female, male and intersex. Gender is a whole other story.

No such thing as intersex.

Gender is a fallacy.

EctopicSpleen · 23/06/2023 16:49

theDudesmummy · 23/06/2023 16:37

Swyer individuals look like girls externally and will be raised as such because the syndrome may often not even be detected until puberty. But they will not develop into women or even people who look like woman without treatment, as they have no gonads. In these (incredibly rare) cases, it is obviously kindest and best to treat them at puberty and let them present as and think of themselves as women. They are not really though. They are not some form of third sex either.

Seriously? They are born with female genitalia, have lived their whole lives with female genitalia, been dressed and treated their whole lives as female, and your response is "not a real woman".
What about women who are infertile for other reasons and need medical help to conceive? Are they "not real women" either?

Emotionalsupportviper · 23/06/2023 16:49

Cross post @Arabella.