Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

There are two sexes…

635 replies

ItJustFellOutLikeWordVomit · 23/06/2023 13:34

Well just that really….I have gay, straight, bi sexual and transsexual friends and absolutely have no problem with that, very much a do what makes you happy person.

Butttt….AIBU to think the world is going a bit mad with all the non-female, cis female and whatever other labels are floating about. I’m a woman and that’s that, you are either biologically a male or biologically a female and I don’t mean that in an insensitive way dress how you like and date who you like but surely we can’t just be inventing different/new sexes and telling straight women they are no longer a woman they are now XYZ?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
22
Spambod · 23/06/2023 17:14

Sistanotcista · 23/06/2023 13:50

Exactly this. Look up Caster Semenya for a real life example.

No, people with intersex conditions, of which there are about 16, are either male or female with an intersex condition. They are not a different separate sex. Caster semenya is a man who lives as a man and who has undescended testicles and a propensity for cheating.

nothingcomestonothing · 23/06/2023 17:13

NeedToChangeName · 23/06/2023 17:08

@Mamabear04 intersex isn't an option on birth certificates

I think that when a baby is born without clear genitals, the healthcare professionals and parents decide whether male or female is the closest fit and that sex is recirded

Seriously MN, we need a RTFT emoji.

Panama2 · 23/06/2023 17:13

I just goggled so it must be correct that it is estimated 1.7% of the population have intersex trait and approx 0.5% have clinically identifiable sexual or reproductive organs

NeedToChangeName · 23/06/2023 17:13

MoirasSaggyBundles · 23/06/2023 14:41

Everyone is male or female. Some people have additional X or Y chromosomes that result in DSDs - differences in sexual development. This does not make them a different sex or a third sex. It means they are a male or a female with a genetic condition. "Intersex" is an antiquated and offensive term, that bodies representing people with DSDs have asked no to be used.

@MoirasSaggyBundles I haven't heard of DSD as a term. Thanks for explaining that

luffkinks · 23/06/2023 17:13

@ASGIRC

"A trans person is discrimitated against.

Here in this very thread you see that.

The biggest thing being toilet use (I dont want to get into it, Im just citing it as an example).

Women want trans women to not use their toilets, because they think its a man.
However, it isnt as simple as having the trans woman using the mans toilets, because, by identifying as female, she will be at risk in those toilets.

So no, there isnt protection.

Discrimination is real (in many forms, not just against trans people!) and it is disengenuous to pretend otherwise."

-------------

I didn't say trans people don't face discrimination.
I didn't say Gay people don't face discrimination
I didn't say women don't face discrimination

I DID say that they are all protected in law.

You said that the trans community are facing the same problems are Gay people 30 years ago. I said they weren't because trans have legal protection and can legally marry unlike the Gay community 30 years ago.

I also said, very importantly, that the GAY community never demanded anything that affected other protected groups rights.

I don't want to get into the toilet argument because it's not a good one and to my memory trans women have always used women's toilets. The toilet issue is the fact women's toilets are becoming a thing of the past with introduction of gender neutral toilets where dignity and privacy is being eroded.
Are you aware around 21% of school's do not have single sex toilets and girls are, (amongst other things) pleading for the privacy and dignity of changing sanitary wear away from boys?

It's the fight for trans women self ID ing into women's prisons.

It's the right for children at school to be able to play sport and change in sex separated changing rooms and not be forced to undress in front of males.

This is NOT about trans women using women's loos!

nothingcomestonothing · 23/06/2023 17:12

neveradullmoment99 · 23/06/2023 17:05

That person has both sexes and they can choose. which sex they feel is right - male or female.

FFS sex is not a feeling. Everyone who has ever existed on this planet is either male or female, including those with DSDs.

GoldfincTart · 23/06/2023 17:11

But what about societies where there's is a recognised third or more gender? For example in South Asia, or in Native American cultures? It's not binary everywhere and never has been.

Hejira? Fa'aafafine? That's those traditional society's solutions to homosexuality, in particular the solution for swishy camp men who can't do full-on masculinity. They can't be allowed to be men, so their societies created new categories. The men are still XY and male, the women are still XX and female. It's binary. It always has been. Why are you so invested in denying science?

Other cultures have other solutions. In Iran being lesbian or gay is tolerated as long as one of the same-sex couple has surgery/ hormones to create a superficial approximation of being a straight couple.

People have already tried to pull DSDs into the argument. Please don't start trying to claim homosexuality as some kind of 'gotcha'.

shatteredmum1 · 23/06/2023 17:11

TastesLikeStrawberriesOnASummerEvening · 23/06/2023 13:51

Do you mean the male Caster Semenya, the one who is a sports cheat?

Caster Semenya has a vagina. She was brought up as female. She is actually a very rare example of a person born intersex.
Her treatment by various sporting authorities and judgement from the ignorant public has been truly shocking.

porridgecake · 23/06/2023 17:10

neveradullmoment99 · 23/06/2023 17:05

That person has both sexes and they can choose. which sex they feel is right - male or female.

Seriously? Where are you getting this stuff?

ASGIRC · 23/06/2023 17:09

nothingcomestonothing · 23/06/2023 16:42

Being a man or woman is a biological reality, fixed and constant throughout history. Social constructs of masculinity and femininity change according to place and time. Being a woman is fixed, what we consider appropriate for women is not.

I agree.
And that might be one of the reasons young people think they are trans. They dont conform with whatever it is they think should be the norm for their sex, and, as such, believe they must be the opposite sex.

Which is why I also think that any gender affirming care must come with a heavy dose of psychological help, before any medical treatment starts (particularly in a young age!)

However, I do know fully grown adults who do believe they are in the wrong body. I dont necessarily understand how that happens, but it does, and those people deserve to be treated with respect and to not leave in fear.

Grimbelina · 23/06/2023 17:09

A Y chromosome makes you a biological male, whatever else is going on. A lack of a Y chromosome makes you a biological female.

This. Intersex people will have with some X and Y - therefore male - or a number of X chromosomes - therefore female.

NeedToChangeName · 23/06/2023 17:08

Mamabear04 · 23/06/2023 13:47

Some people are intersex so there are three sexes, female, male and intersex. Gender is a whole other story.

@Mamabear04 intersex isn't an option on birth certificates

I think that when a baby is born without clear genitals, the healthcare professionals and parents decide whether male or female is the closest fit and that sex is recirded

Barbie222 · 23/06/2023 17:08

Mamabear04 · 23/06/2023 13:47

Some people are intersex so there are three sexes, female, male and intersex. Gender is a whole other story.

That's incredibly offensive - you need to educate yourself. People with a DSD aren't a 'third sex'.

nothingcomestonothing · 23/06/2023 17:07

Begsthequestion · 23/06/2023 16:56

Thanks for your reply.

I think that could apply to the many societies and cultures which only recognise the existence of man/male sex and woman/female sex.

But what about societies where there's is a recognised third or more gender? For example in South Asia, or in Native American cultures? It's not binary everywhere and never has been.

Biology,male and female bodies, is binary in every culture throughout time throughout the world.

Some cultures have included extra social categories, usually as a way of categorising feminine or gay men, but it's important to note that in none of these did people move from the male to female category or vice versa . So they might recognise more than 2 'genders', social categories, but there have never been more than 2 sexes anywhere.

ArabeIIaScott · 23/06/2023 17:06

neveradullmoment99 · 23/06/2023 17:05

That person has both sexes and they can choose. which sex they feel is right - male or female.

What person? 'Intersex' covers a range of different conditions. Which one are you referring to?

speakout · 23/06/2023 17:06

nothingcomestonothing · 23/06/2023 17:01

Honestly, piss off with this. Not being able to have what you want is NOT the same as discrimination.

And re toilets, there is no evidence of transwomen being at risk in men's toilets. None. None at all. But there is evidence of risk to women, of males of any identity in women's toilets. Including the 10 year old girls sexually assualted in the women's toilets by transwoman 'Katie' Dolatowki.

Once again, not having everything you want is not discrimination.

Pisses me off too.

So some men who think they are women and like to wear dresses need to use women's spaces to keep them safe.

So some men want to use women to protect them from other men.

How is that fair?

theDudesmummy · 23/06/2023 17:06

This is getting tedious. No-one has "both sexes". You either have a Y chromosome or you do not. Finis.

borntobequiet · 23/06/2023 17:06

What do you think gender means?

Whatever it is, it’s not biological sex.

Helleofabore · 23/06/2023 17:06

nothingcomestonothing · 23/06/2023 16:42

Being a man or woman is a biological reality, fixed and constant throughout history. Social constructs of masculinity and femininity change according to place and time. Being a woman is fixed, what we consider appropriate for women is not.

It is quite remarkable to see people reject being a 'woman' because a group in society has convinced people the word relates to all the tropish stereotypes and stereotyped roles that most women actually don't fit into and don't wish to.

The word woman means 'adult human female', that is all it is. The only thing in common we have is our bodies. Even the way we respond to our bodies will be unique although there may be some commonalities.

theDudesmummy · 23/06/2023 17:05

And (saying it AGAIN for those at the back), intersex is an outdated term, which WAS indeed an accepted medical term in its day (cf cretin, idiot, Mongol) but IT IS NOT ANY MORE.

neveradullmoment99 · 23/06/2023 17:05

That person has both sexes and they can choose. which sex they feel is right - male or female.

loislovesstewie · 23/06/2023 17:05

And I will repeat, the number of people born with both male and female sex organs is in the low hundreds throughout the world.

neveradullmoment99 · 23/06/2023 17:04

ArabeIIaScott · 23/06/2023 17:04

I'll just keep posting this, then.

'Intersex' is a term that covers various 'disorders/differences of sexual development'.

It's not a third sex.

https://dsdfamilies.org/

I never said it was a third sex.

ArabeIIaScott · 23/06/2023 17:04

neveradullmoment99 · 23/06/2023 17:01

Agree unless they have the rare condition where they are born intersex.

I'll just keep posting this, then.

'Intersex' is a term that covers various 'disorders/differences of sexual development'.

It's not a third sex.

https://dsdfamilies.org/

Home :: DSD Families

https://dsdfamilies.org

Begsthequestion · 23/06/2023 17:03

borntobequiet · 23/06/2023 17:03

But what about societies where there's is a recognised third or more gender? For example in South Asia, or in Native American cultures? It's not binary everywhere and never has been.

You are conflating/confusing sex and gender. Those “otherwise gendered”people will, as individuals, be either male or female, men or women.

What do you think gender means?