Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think no teacher is affirming animal/moon/object genders

263 replies

Greenpotatosoup · 23/06/2023 13:13

Surely no teacher in the UK would or could affirm a child who claimed to be a cat or a moon or any other sort of animal or object - eg letting them wear non-uniform, eat from bowl, disrupt learning with neo-pronoun requests. Just nonsense. This must be kids taking the piss and feeding bullshit to gullible journos.

I’ve also seen posters on here claiming their kid/cousin’s kid/neighbour’s goat breeder’s Auntie Sue’s best friend has first hand knowledge of this, and again I call bullshit. Bullshit. Any posters who say it’s not bullshit, get off here and write to Gillian Keegan, who explicitly requested examples of batshittery in schools at a recent select committee hearing, and name the school, and write to your local MP and ofsted too. But I think it’s just bullshit and teacher bashing.

YABU: I believe teachers ARE affirming cat/moon/anything genders

YANBU: I don’t believe any teacher would affirm an animal or object gender.

I understand there are strong views on here about transgender issues. My AIBU is not intended to be about that.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
Moopsi · 23/06/2023 20:41

*denying

Begsthequestion · 23/06/2023 20:41

Clymene · 23/06/2023 20:41

But it's true @Begsthequestion

Humans can't change sex. This isn't controversial or revolutionary. It's basic science

Who said it wasn't?

Gender is a different matter however.

Moopsi · 23/06/2023 20:41

Isn't it ironic that the people claiming that the existence of transpeople is being denied are the very people denting the existence of transcats...

Clymene · 23/06/2023 20:41

But it's true @Begsthequestion

Humans can't change sex. This isn't controversial or revolutionary. It's basic science

Begsthequestion · 23/06/2023 20:40

ExtraOnions · 23/06/2023 20:39

…but that recording is nonsense, and has been seized by the right-wing media as part of the “culture war”. At no point does the teacher refer to anyone referring to themselves as a cat , there is no evidence that anyone in that school refers to themselves as a cat, the only people who mention cats are eye girls that made the recording - which is a small excerpt from a longer conversation, that we were not party to .. the sole purpose of which seemed to be to get “likes” on Tik-Tok

https://bylinetimes.com/2023/06/22/dead-cats-and-transphobic-lies/

Glad someone has actually bothered to take in what was said.

Begsthequestion · 23/06/2023 20:39

DdraigGoch · 23/06/2023 20:36

Have you got a recording where they said that? Or can you even infer it from what the teacher said?

No, they didn't say anything of the sort.

The student argued that gender is determined by biological sex - “if you have a vagina you’re a girl and if you have penis you’re a boy. That’s it”.

So according to that student, there is no such thing as a trans person.

Perhaps you should listen to it yourself, so you know what you're arguing about.

ExtraOnions · 23/06/2023 20:39

…but that recording is nonsense, and has been seized by the right-wing media as part of the “culture war”. At no point does the teacher refer to anyone referring to themselves as a cat , there is no evidence that anyone in that school refers to themselves as a cat, the only people who mention cats are eye girls that made the recording - which is a small excerpt from a longer conversation, that we were not party to .. the sole purpose of which seemed to be to get “likes” on Tik-Tok

https://bylinetimes.com/2023/06/22/dead-cats-and-transphobic-lies/

Dead Cats and Transphobic Lies – Byline Times

The political and media firestorm over a school girl claiming to identify as a cat, turns out to be a story 'too good to check'. Byline Times has spoken to a witness

https://bylinetimes.com/2023/06/22/dead-cats-and-transphobic-lies/

strawberry2017 · 23/06/2023 20:38

School near me has 3 that identify as dogs and bark in class.
Utterly ridiculous

PrincessHoneysuckle · 23/06/2023 20:37

Is this a secondary thing? No cats as of yet at the primary inwork at and I wouldn't recognise a dc as a cat if they "presented" as one.Ridiculous.

DdraigGoch · 23/06/2023 20:36

Begsthequestion · 23/06/2023 20:22

Their belief is that trans people don't exist.

Have you got a recording where they said that? Or can you even infer it from what the teacher said?

No, they didn't say anything of the sort.

StephanieSuperpowers · 23/06/2023 20:35

Begsthequestion · 23/06/2023 20:29

Sex and gender are two different things. No one is saying you can change your chromosomes.

But you can totally grow a cervix, so why not?

And if teachers are all over the fact that you can't change sex, why are so many toilets and sports unisex?

Begsthequestion · 23/06/2023 20:35

AlexandriasWindmill · 23/06/2023 20:32

I did listen to it. I heard them asserting their right to their own beliefs about sex and gender. A belief that Forstater proved was worthy of respect in society. The teacher tried to browbeat them into retracting their beliefs as though they were despicable. They are not. They are protected beliefs and they are shared by the majority.

So you heard that the teacher was addressing their views on gender - not about cats.

PrincessHoneysuckle · 23/06/2023 20:35

@BellaTheDarkOverlord Grin

DdraigGoch · 23/06/2023 20:34

Ywudu · 23/06/2023 20:17

2 cat children in our secondary.
What would you like teachers to do? Go along with it which is seen as accepting children can be cats or tell them they are a child and get fired. I feel sorry for the teachers.

I'd sooner risk disciplinary over this, than capitulate and pretend that Jane really is a cat.

Merrilydancing · 23/06/2023 20:33

Bloody hell, we’d have had a field day with this when we were teenagers and i went to a nice school.

Can you imagine, today Tom identifies as a cat, Jerry as a mouse and Pluto as a dog and then we could have an almighty fight! Or blame Pluto for eating our homework.

Complete madness not to think that teenagers are doing this to take the piss.

DdraigGoch · 23/06/2023 20:33

ilovesooty · 23/06/2023 20:15

I could. I didn't want to.

I suspect this thread will be an excuse to rehash all the stuff from the last one, and I would like this stuff to stay in Sex and Gender discussion quite frankly.

And yet here you are, bumping it and making sure that it appears in "threads I'm on". Probably in active too. Whereas if you'd just hidden or ignored the thread (or even reported it if you thought that MNHQ should consider moving it) you wouldn't keep seeing it pop up.

Leastsaidsoonestscrewed · 23/06/2023 20:32

Greenpotatosoup · 23/06/2023 13:13

Surely no teacher in the UK would or could affirm a child who claimed to be a cat or a moon or any other sort of animal or object - eg letting them wear non-uniform, eat from bowl, disrupt learning with neo-pronoun requests. Just nonsense. This must be kids taking the piss and feeding bullshit to gullible journos.

I’ve also seen posters on here claiming their kid/cousin’s kid/neighbour’s goat breeder’s Auntie Sue’s best friend has first hand knowledge of this, and again I call bullshit. Bullshit. Any posters who say it’s not bullshit, get off here and write to Gillian Keegan, who explicitly requested examples of batshittery in schools at a recent select committee hearing, and name the school, and write to your local MP and ofsted too. But I think it’s just bullshit and teacher bashing.

YABU: I believe teachers ARE affirming cat/moon/anything genders

YANBU: I don’t believe any teacher would affirm an animal or object gender.

I understand there are strong views on here about transgender issues. My AIBU is not intended to be about that.

Of course they aren't but you'll get lots of people here earnestly telling you it's a slippery slope, etc etc.
And they act completely shocked if you point out this is the exact same gameplay the homophobes use: " if we allow same sex marriage people will end up marrying animals".

Moopsi · 23/06/2023 20:32

They did not say "trans people don't exist". They said that girls have vaginas and boys have penises. That's it.

AlexandriasWindmill · 23/06/2023 20:32

I did listen to it. I heard them asserting their right to their own beliefs about sex and gender. A belief that Forstater proved was worthy of respect in society. The teacher tried to browbeat them into retracting their beliefs as though they were despicable. They are not. They are protected beliefs and they are shared by the majority.

Moopsi · 23/06/2023 20:31

There are two sexes and genitalia determines sex in 99.9% of cases.

Begsthequestion · 23/06/2023 20:30

AlexandriasWindmill · 23/06/2023 20:27

That's a misrepresentation.
If you take an atheist to a communion service, do they deny the existence of the bread? No. They can see the bread exists but they don't believe in transubstantiation - they don't believe the bread is the body and blood of Christ.
No-one is denying transpeople exist. It's just that the majority don't share transpeople's beliefs about gender.

If you listen to the conversation, the students did indeed say that trans people don't exist, and that your genitalia determines your gender, of which they said there are two.

Begsthequestion · 23/06/2023 20:29

StephanieSuperpowers · 23/06/2023 20:27

It is indeed difficult to imagine that there ux sn adult anywhere agreeing with teens if they claim to be cats.

A few years ago, it would have been just as difficult to imagine teachers falling over themselves to say that people can definitely change sex.

Must say, I would like to understand how the second improbable scenario is fine but the first utterly outrageous?

Sex and gender are two different things. No one is saying you can change your chromosomes.

StephanieSuperpowers · 23/06/2023 20:27

It is indeed difficult to imagine that there ux sn adult anywhere agreeing with teens if they claim to be cats.

A few years ago, it would have been just as difficult to imagine teachers falling over themselves to say that people can definitely change sex.

Must say, I would like to understand how the second improbable scenario is fine but the first utterly outrageous?

Lindy2 · 23/06/2023 20:27

Some teachers were practically falling over themselves to affirm my ASD daughter as a boy. This was despite us specifically and clearly explaining why she wasn't ready to make a decision like that and not giving permission. They did it anyway.

I guess I should be grateful DD is still human.

The Government information on this has taken too long. As soon as we have an opportunity to join a group legal action against what has been allowed to happen in schools, we will.

AlexandriasWindmill · 23/06/2023 20:27

Begsthequestion · 23/06/2023 20:22

Their belief is that trans people don't exist.

That's a misrepresentation.
If you take an atheist to a communion service, do they deny the existence of the bread? No. They can see the bread exists but they don't believe in transubstantiation - they don't believe the bread is the body and blood of Christ.
No-one is denying transpeople exist. It's just that the majority don't share transpeople's beliefs about gender.