Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think no teacher is affirming animal/moon/object genders

263 replies

Greenpotatosoup · 23/06/2023 13:13

Surely no teacher in the UK would or could affirm a child who claimed to be a cat or a moon or any other sort of animal or object - eg letting them wear non-uniform, eat from bowl, disrupt learning with neo-pronoun requests. Just nonsense. This must be kids taking the piss and feeding bullshit to gullible journos.

I’ve also seen posters on here claiming their kid/cousin’s kid/neighbour’s goat breeder’s Auntie Sue’s best friend has first hand knowledge of this, and again I call bullshit. Bullshit. Any posters who say it’s not bullshit, get off here and write to Gillian Keegan, who explicitly requested examples of batshittery in schools at a recent select committee hearing, and name the school, and write to your local MP and ofsted too. But I think it’s just bullshit and teacher bashing.

YABU: I believe teachers ARE affirming cat/moon/anything genders

YANBU: I don’t believe any teacher would affirm an animal or object gender.

I understand there are strong views on here about transgender issues. My AIBU is not intended to be about that.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
JazbayGrapes · 24/06/2023 00:04

I would have been that kid.

TastesLikeStrawberriesOnASummerEvening · 24/06/2023 00:04

Setyoufree · 23/06/2023 23:44

Isn't the key bit less about the cat thing, and more about the fact that the girls were told their view that there are only two sexes was unacceptable?

I see the cat thing as an extension to all the other gender stuff really - when you have to affirm everything without question, why not cat?

Exactly, and the teacher called them homophobic for not believing in gender which makes no sense.

Moonandstarzz · 23/06/2023 23:51

I think the two girls were absolutely correct in what they have done. If this ideology is being taught in schools it needs to be called out & exposed. I think many other kids will follow suit & hopefully expose anymore bullshit thats being peddled to kids.
Kids have the absolute right to question, debate & absolutely not believe what is being forced down their throats. Good on those girls. Teachers will need to think twice.
Fact over fiction. Always.

Setyoufree · 23/06/2023 23:44

Isn't the key bit less about the cat thing, and more about the fact that the girls were told their view that there are only two sexes was unacceptable?

I see the cat thing as an extension to all the other gender stuff really - when you have to affirm everything without question, why not cat?

TastesLikeStrawberriesOnASummerEvening · 23/06/2023 23:42

ginghamstarfish · 23/06/2023 23:26

I find it hard to believe any of this is real ... the person 'identifying' as a cat - well if they shit in a box, eat mice and lick their own arse then I might believe, but I'm sure they don't.

Transwomen don't have vaginas, periods or the ability to carry a baby, yet we are expected to go along with their delusions.
What makes pretending to be a cat any different?

Moonandstarzz · 23/06/2023 23:38

It's inevitable it was going to happen.. If people decide they can identify as the opposite sex why not identify as a cat, unicorn, the moon, dinosaur or horse?

redfacebigdisgrace · 23/06/2023 23:35

Teacher here. No way would I affirm an animal identity. It’s verging on abusive to the specific pupil and to the other pupils. This is a hill I will die on.

As an aside, I have a non binary pupil and just avoid using pronouns.

PearlClutch · 23/06/2023 23:32

ilovesooty · 23/06/2023 20:15

I could. I didn't want to.

I suspect this thread will be an excuse to rehash all the stuff from the last one, and I would like this stuff to stay in Sex and Gender discussion quite frankly.

So you think these are actually genders, then?

PickAChew · 23/06/2023 23:28

I epd hope YANBU but something suggests that there's always one.

ginghamstarfish · 23/06/2023 23:26

I find it hard to believe any of this is real ... the person 'identifying' as a cat - well if they shit in a box, eat mice and lick their own arse then I might believe, but I'm sure they don't.

PearlClutch · 23/06/2023 23:25

SeaSaltAir · 23/06/2023 19:03

They’re not. But there’s no hysterical pearl clutching in the truth.

I'm not even a little bit 'hysterical', I promise.

Moonandstarzz · 23/06/2023 23:22

There was a woman who had lots of surgery to make herself more feline looking.. This was years ago.. Not sure if she actually identified as a cat though.. Away to Google..
It will become dangerous if these kids start getting surgery to look like their animal of choice like the trans kids are getting surgery to change gender...

Fairislefandango · 23/06/2023 23:20

Their belief is that trans people don't exist.

No it isn't. Nobody believes trans people don't exist. A trans person is a person who wants to be, or thinks they are, the opposite sex from the one they actually are. Of course those people exist
It's very tedious and disingenuous when supporters of gender ideology pretend that knowing that people can't change sex is the same as saying trans people don't exist. "You're debating/denying our existence!" Umm... no we're not. You're right there, we can definitely see you. You do exist.

whereaw · 23/06/2023 23:20

I do agree with you though @Skiggles2018 "Gender is something we have created".

Somanycats · 23/06/2023 23:16

Skiggles2018 · 23/06/2023 22:31

This - people are to caught up in sex: you will be born (mostly) with either male or female sexual organs. This is biology.

Gender is something we have created so why is it so hard to think that people will choose what they most relate to for their own unique personality. We obvious put too much onto gender as a social construct due to years of form filling and stereotypes.

I have taught two pupils in primary school who now identify as the opposite gender to the sec they were born. They are lovely kids and I hope they have having a tolerant experience at secondary school.

why do people care so much - if it doesn’t hurt you or anyone else then let them be happy.

It does hurt everybody else. I don't want to make my child lie every day because these over indulged kids (no, they are not lovely) insist on it. I hope they do not have a tolerant experience in secondary school. I hope someone pulls them up on this crap before they harm themselves with surgery or annoy everyone else so much they are social outcasts

writingsonthewall · 23/06/2023 23:15

whereaw · 23/06/2023 20:22

I'm sorry, I really don't get the problem. If someone identifies as a cat, that's what they are.

I know a family who adopted a cat recently but didn't even consider a transcat. I was appalled.

They have it really hard and lots of vets won't even take them on as patients.

It's like a genocide really. No other word for it.

Grin
whereaw · 23/06/2023 23:07

Opposite implies that the two are in opposition. Ie. If something is big it can't be small.
Surely to say someone has taken the opposite gender is to imply you know very well what their sex (gender?) is, and that they have rejected it for the binary opposite.
Which is problematic in itself.
But then when you throw in that there are 107 genders surely no one can be the 'opposite' gender? Is that not meaningless at best? Or from a trans activist perspective, transphobic? If a persons gender is innate, to say it is 'opposite' is in denial of who they fundamentally claim to be, and therefore are?

DelphiniumBlue · 23/06/2023 23:03

Clymene · 23/06/2023 18:20

You're wrong. There is a kid in my child's year who identifies as a baked product. Teachers have apologised to her for referring to her as a young lady.

It's fucking idiotic but then so is gender ideology

They may have apologised for calling her a young lady, as that is pretty old fashioned and potentially sexist and offensive. It may well be nothing to do with the baked product, unless that is a fruitcake.
We are encouraged not to stereotype children, and addressing or referring to people by their sex or gender is not necessary in most cases. If it is necessary, then young woman would be more appropriate.

Moonandstarzz · 23/06/2023 22:59

@whereaw it's meant to baffle & confuse people so they stop questioning it... There is a method to the madness..

whereaw · 23/06/2023 22:57

But if sex and gender are totally different and unconnected how can gender be opposite to sex? @Skiggles2018 Especially if there are far far more than 2 genders - 107 currently. The whole thing baffles me.

Skiggles2018 · 23/06/2023 22:52

whereaw · 23/06/2023 22:48

@Skiggles2018 8 million kinds, yet the two you know have simply chosen the 'opposite' gender? What is the 'opposite' gender when there are 8 million kinds? How do you know its opposite?

Sorry I was unable to edit all the errors in my post typing too quickly on a phone but it did say they now identify as the opposite gender of the sex they were born as.
So scientifically the opposite sex to male is female and vice versa if you need me to spell it out.

I also didn’t use the word ‘chosen’ for the gender they identify with out of respect for them.