Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think no teacher is affirming animal/moon/object genders

263 replies

Greenpotatosoup · 23/06/2023 13:13

Surely no teacher in the UK would or could affirm a child who claimed to be a cat or a moon or any other sort of animal or object - eg letting them wear non-uniform, eat from bowl, disrupt learning with neo-pronoun requests. Just nonsense. This must be kids taking the piss and feeding bullshit to gullible journos.

I’ve also seen posters on here claiming their kid/cousin’s kid/neighbour’s goat breeder’s Auntie Sue’s best friend has first hand knowledge of this, and again I call bullshit. Bullshit. Any posters who say it’s not bullshit, get off here and write to Gillian Keegan, who explicitly requested examples of batshittery in schools at a recent select committee hearing, and name the school, and write to your local MP and ofsted too. But I think it’s just bullshit and teacher bashing.

YABU: I believe teachers ARE affirming cat/moon/anything genders

YANBU: I don’t believe any teacher would affirm an animal or object gender.

I understand there are strong views on here about transgender issues. My AIBU is not intended to be about that.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
whereaw · 24/06/2023 11:05

Also I agree with a poster who said that there are bigger issues in schools, like gangs and violence and drugs.
And that's true in one sense.
But to be frank, and whether it's right or not, it's the privileged, pandered kids identifying as what they fancy and demanding validation and respect who are going to go on to be doctors and judges and educators and government officials, who will shape the world to come.

pinklama · 24/06/2023 11:00

Teachers will do what is required to keep their jobs. They are doomed if they do, screwed if they don’t. Pupils are without a doubt taking the piss.

what I do see happening now is that many employers won’t take on young employees and find themselves having to deal with this.

whereaw · 24/06/2023 10:58

And some people might think.. well so what? Why not live in a world where we can all be who we want to be?
But.. where's the line?
If my child identifies as a bird should I take them to a cliff and let them jump off?

whereaw · 24/06/2023 10:52

Because it's the dream isn't it.. everyone will see us as we see ourselves.
You affirm me and I'll affirm you.

OneTC · 24/06/2023 10:44

Oh no Tebbit said it would lead to men marrying their own children

OneTC · 24/06/2023 10:43

Greenpotatosoup · 24/06/2023 10:41

Boris “Officially A Liar” Johnson was in this camp, but a columnist rather than an M.P.

Yeah I definitely remember a Tebbit-type coming out with it too

Moonandstarzz · 24/06/2023 10:42

I just can't understand why it's all entertained? Why aren't mental health services or child safeguarding making interventions when a person says "actually I'm not a girl, I am a boy/cat/mouse/fork /santa"...?

Greenpotatosoup · 24/06/2023 10:41

OneTC · 24/06/2023 10:35

Serving MPs of the time

Boris “Officially A Liar” Johnson was in this camp, but a columnist rather than an M.P.

OP posts:
Greenpotatosoup · 24/06/2023 10:39

From that furry article, it’s a hobby rather than a sexuality or identity. No place for that in the classroom.

My kid plays in a marching band, but wouldn’t expect the teachers to endorse them marching round the classroom playing the trombone in band uniform during lessons. Doesn’t mean kid should be mocked for their hobby either, just not conducive to a productive learning environment.

OP posts:
NameChangeThreeThousand · 24/06/2023 10:37

When I was around 11 (late 80s) there was a girl in my class who would always pretend to be a horse. She didn't run, she galloped. She would neigh occasionally. I found her a bit annoying but on the whole we just let her be. The teachers still addressed her by her name and treated her as a human girl, not a horse! We didn't make a fuss. She could pretend to be whatever she wanted, people would comment 'she just has an active imagination'. Everyone obviously knew she was a girl not a horse and she never tried to force us otherwise. We just all got on with it.

There were also girls in my class that were quite boy-like on purpose. Liked to be seen as looking like a boy, tried to walk like the boys, do boy stuff. Again, we all just accepted it, got along, didn't make a fuss. We addressed our boy-like classmates as 'she', used their name, and treated them and considered them female. That was all fine and dandy!

No doubt horse kid has grown up to become a regular adult female! I know a couple of the 'boyish' girls are now married with kids and perfectly happy.

If this was today, I dread to think of these children's futures. In the 80s we just all accepted we are all different and that's ok! No need to change gender or species !! But you can 'pretend' for a bit if you.like.and everyone's cool with that! noone expected others to join in the pretence!!

OneTC · 24/06/2023 10:35

Moopsi · 23/06/2023 21:09

Insane people?!

Serving MPs of the time

Moonandstarzz · 24/06/2023 10:28

@Flickersy your post is about kids indentifying but as the Pink News link shows there is a large adult furry community & it seems that they are also accepted & welcomed by the lgbtq community (according to the link)

Greenpotatosoup · 24/06/2023 10:28

redfacebigdisgrace · 24/06/2023 09:22

@Greenpotatosoup I think @cadetmumstress is having you on 🙃

Well indeed. It’s literally unbelievable. And I know IABFU to ask the question and then not believe people’s answers. But honestly, I can’t believe it. Asked my 13yo about animal genders in their school, and they literally lolled at the idea their form teacher would tolerate anything like it.

Why are people making this stuff up? How much is adults piss-taking and how much is adults genuinely believing that there’s a problem of this particular type, based on kids piss-taking? How much is people with an agenda? What agenda(s)?

OP posts:
whereaw · 24/06/2023 10:27

Identity claims are totally dependent on other people to acknowledge and affirm their validity, because without that they are nothing at all.

This is why the 'live and let live' argument is flawed. Because that is not what is being asked and the majority of people simply do not get that.

Like Satre says, hell is other people because you are always trapped in what they think of you - by the mere appearance of the other, I am put in the position of passing judgement on myself as an object, for it is an object that I appear to the other.

Flickersy · 24/06/2023 10:23

Moonandstarzz · 24/06/2023 10:20

@Flickersy
Read this article.. Lots of adult furries & up until this week seemed to be very welcome in the lgbtq community according to this article here
https://www.thepinknews.com/2023/02/13/what-are-furries-furry/

I know what furries are. I'm not sure what that has to do with my post about it always being rude to laugh at and mock people.

StephanieSuperpowers · 24/06/2023 10:22

Skiggles2018 · 24/06/2023 10:17

And yet we are led to believe that everyone is capable of human traits such as tolerance, respect and kindness…

This is where this nonsense makes me properly angry. Pretending to unhappy children that they can change sex and it'll all go away is not kind. Telling them the truth and doing the painful work of accepting reality with them is kind and respectful. Encouraging them to believe that everyone will see them as they see themselves or else they hate them and want them dead is setting vulnerable young people up for a life of pain and feeling needlessly rejected. It's a horrible and cruel thing to do.

Flickersy · 24/06/2023 10:18

SamphiretheTervosaurReturneth · 24/06/2023 09:39

It's not that they are saying a kid is a giraffe as much as they are saying that if a kid says he's a giraffe then that is how he identifies and it is rude, bigoted, to laugh, correct him, refuse to use his preferred pronouns, sorry, gee / raff's preferred pronouns

Add to that the third sex malarkey and you have a perfect shit storm of #BeKind woolly liberalism that does real harm.

It's always rude to laugh at someone though.

Kids do weird shit, sometimes they want to be animals, sometimes they think they're vampires, sometimes they think they're witches. Sometimes it's just attention seeking, other times it's the kids who struggle socially who fall into these patterns. It's a phase. When I was younger everyone slightly alternative or not in the cool crowd was a goth.

In all cases, they are still deserving of respect and fair treatment, not laughing at or mockery, and teachers should rightly be pulling up other students for bullying.

I don't doubt that there are kids who want to be cats. I do think it's being blown way out of proportion though.

Moonandstarzz · 24/06/2023 10:17

StephanieSuperpowers · 24/06/2023 10:15

Yes. And the Irish Times is all about the power of self identification to alter reality.

You got that right.. Lots of articles about Hilaria's non existent "Spanish roots" the Irish Times was the first that came up in google search

Skiggles2018 · 24/06/2023 10:17

Somanycats · 23/06/2023 23:16

It does hurt everybody else. I don't want to make my child lie every day because these over indulged kids (no, they are not lovely) insist on it. I hope they do not have a tolerant experience in secondary school. I hope someone pulls them up on this crap before they harm themselves with surgery or annoy everyone else so much they are social outcasts

And yet we are led to believe that everyone is capable of human traits such as tolerance, respect and kindness…

Moonandstarzz · 24/06/2023 10:16

IWillNoLie · 24/06/2023 09:59

The thing about identities, be it a boy identifying as a girl, or a girl identifying as a cat, is it is not about self and how they feel - it is means to control the behaviour of everyone about them. A demand that YOU must behave in a certain way towards them. That YOU deny reality to uphold the fantasy they wish to impose.

Yes just this! It's about attention..
I think it's becoming more obvious that identifying as a boy when you're a girl is the exact same as identifying as a cat, horse, unicorn, Santa Claus or as in Hilaria Baldwins case a Spaniard...
I do think the tide is turning & no identifies will continue to be pandered to...

StephanieSuperpowers · 24/06/2023 10:15

Yes. And the Irish Times is all about the power of self identification to alter reality.

YukoandHiro · 24/06/2023 10:03

BellaTheDarkOverlord · 23/06/2023 19:31

Yabu. My cat identifies as a health visitor and gets extremely judgemental if I don't pick up newborn DD and soon as she cries. He even shouts at me angrily until I do.

😂😂😂

YukoandHiro · 24/06/2023 10:03

ThatOnePlease · 23/06/2023 18:25

I think YANBU, and if this has happened or is happening, it's a handful of extreme cases.

Problem is, once you agree to affirm an identity at odds with material reality, there's no logical line to draw on what's a step too far.

Different race or ethnicity? Why not? It's no more impossible than insisting you can change your biological sex.

So how do you draft a coherent policy that says, you can change sex and must be always and only treated as your chosen sex - even though that is impossible in reality - but you can't change your ethnicity or your species for legal purposes?

If we have to believe people are who they say they are, then we have to believe that men can truly be women, a girl can be a cat, that Ollie London can be Korean. It's all the same.

I know it's been said 1,000 times but I've never understood how the Rachel Dolezal comparison isn't made more often and why there is any difference between the two