Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the school are powerless to solve this? Parking related

87 replies

LeevMarie · 23/06/2023 10:01

Hi everyone - just wondering if this is the same everywhere in the country, or if your DC's school have managed to solve this problem.

DS (almost 5) was nearly run over this morning outside school. The school is at the bottom of a narrow lane with no car parking. We were crossing the road direct outside the entrance and he was on his scooter. I try and instill the importance of road safety, so I make him stand on the pavement, looking around for cars until I though it was safe to cross. We stepped out behind a car parked on double yellow lines on the pavement (the whole pavement is back to back with cars, so no alternative) and out of nowhere came a huge vehicle which resulted in a near miss. I shouted at the driver of the car (not ideal, but I got a shock).

When I was leaving the school, there was a stream of cars and I found it difficult as an adult to navigate my way across the road - kids have no chance.

The school are really trying to resolve the issue. They often send out emails/letters, have a sign on the gate saying that cars should not be driving down to the entrance and even have had a traffic warden on occasions to give out fines. Yet, still, inconsiderate people still keep driving down there.

I don't think there's anything more the school can do about it and fear that things will only change when there's an accident. I've emailed the Headteacher this morning to let her know that there was a near-accident, but also that I appreciate the steps they're taking to try and stop it.

Does everywhere have this problem? Are there any examples anyone has of their school successfully solved a similar issue? There is lots of parking available nearby - I can't help but think it's just lazy, entitled people who think that they have some kind of licence to do whatever they want.

OP posts:
hettiethehare · 23/06/2023 11:49

I'm in two minds about school streets - my DC's school has one and there is one at the school we live next to. Both have just pushed the problem one road further along and made the traffic and pollution worse on the adjacent roads.

LeevMarie · 23/06/2023 11:41

onefinemess · 23/06/2023 11:32

What else could she have done?

I don't know, wait until the cars had moved?

I absolutely guarantee you, if (God forbid) her had been killed by that car which "came out of nowhere", the OP would have spent the rest of her life thinking .

"why did I cross the road, why didn't I just wait"

"Wait for the cars to move". Are you serious? There is no pathway on the other side of the road, so no option but to cross where I did. The car was turning round at the bottom of the dead end.

I also need to drop DS at school, walk back up to my car, which I'd parked 10 minutes away, then get to work. I'd love to have the luxury of waiting until all of the assholes have vacated the area before I show up on a morning, but back in the real world, that isn't a reality.

Fair point about the scooter - I acknowledge that isn't safe under the circumstances, so will rethink that one.

Also love the idea of the walking bus. I've seen this on the TV before and thought it was a great idea. I'll see if there is any interest from other parents to maybe set something like this up.

OP posts:
BelindaBears · 23/06/2023 11:40

This one is entirely on you.

No, it’s on the selfish pricks parking there because they couldn’t possibly walk 500 yards themselves. The OP and her child on a scooter aren’t polluting the air all the other children breathe, causing congestion, physical hazards and inconvenience to others and not taking appropriate care of their large, heavy, motorised metal boxes.

Lcb123 · 23/06/2023 11:33

We live by a school that has a ‘school street’ for drop off and pick up, you can’t drive down that section of the street during that time. The school should be doing everything possible to promote active travel as well-so much better for kids wellbeing and learning

onefinemess · 23/06/2023 11:32

Bluevelvetsofa · 23/06/2023 11:28

You’re right that schools can do nothing, other than send letters, emails, speak to parents etc, so it has to be something that will affect the pockets of the regular offenders.

It would be great to have someone patrolling every day, but the teaching staff can’t do that, the police can’t do that and would those people who feel they’re entitled to park where they want, take any notice of anyone else.

Trying to get involved in School Street, Walking Bus, or other schemes is a good plan. When there are more people being considerate, rather than inconsiderate, it might make a difference.

@onefinemess the OP said that there was no sight line because the cars were parked closely together and parked on double yellow lines anyway, so unless she can see round them, what else could she have done? I agree that a young child and a scooter in that environment is not a good idea though.

I visited many schools during my working life and I never saw any that had satisfactory parking arrangements. Not the fault of the school, but the fault of people who feel entitled to please themselves. Round here, they park and sit with engines running for half an hour. All kinds of wrong.

When I picked up my grandchildren from primary school, I parked in the village hall car park and walked the five minute walk to the school gate. Every day, there were arguments about parking, because the road was too narrow to allow two way traffic when cars were parked each side ( and mostly half on and half off the pavement). I’ve seen a fight between two women in the middle of the road, because both refused to back up.

What else could she have done?

I don't know, wait until the cars had moved?

I absolutely guarantee you, if (God forbid) her had been killed by that car which "came out of nowhere", the OP would have spent the rest of her life thinking .

"why did I cross the road, why didn't I just wait"

Bluevelvetsofa · 23/06/2023 11:28

You’re right that schools can do nothing, other than send letters, emails, speak to parents etc, so it has to be something that will affect the pockets of the regular offenders.

It would be great to have someone patrolling every day, but the teaching staff can’t do that, the police can’t do that and would those people who feel they’re entitled to park where they want, take any notice of anyone else.

Trying to get involved in School Street, Walking Bus, or other schemes is a good plan. When there are more people being considerate, rather than inconsiderate, it might make a difference.

@onefinemess the OP said that there was no sight line because the cars were parked closely together and parked on double yellow lines anyway, so unless she can see round them, what else could she have done? I agree that a young child and a scooter in that environment is not a good idea though.

I visited many schools during my working life and I never saw any that had satisfactory parking arrangements. Not the fault of the school, but the fault of people who feel entitled to please themselves. Round here, they park and sit with engines running for half an hour. All kinds of wrong.

When I picked up my grandchildren from primary school, I parked in the village hall car park and walked the five minute walk to the school gate. Every day, there were arguments about parking, because the road was too narrow to allow two way traffic when cars were parked each side ( and mostly half on and half off the pavement). I’ve seen a fight between two women in the middle of the road, because both refused to back up.

Dotjones · 23/06/2023 11:22

onefinemess · 23/06/2023 11:11

OP, by your own admission, you stepped out behind a car which was parked on double yellow lines.

Do you think drivers can see through cars?

You didn't give the driver any opportunity to see you, let alone avoid you. This one is on you entirely. Your reckless decision to cross the road from behind a parked car almost cost your son his life.

And the idea that you didn't have any choice is bollocks, of course you did. You could have made the choice to wait until one of the vehicles had moved so that you and your son could have crossed the road safely.

This one is entirely on you.

Be more careful in future. You almost killed your son.

I'm glad someone else said this, I was going to say a very similar thing. You have set a bad example by teaching your child it's OK to cross the road between parked cars. If there genuinely is no way of crossing the road (like walking a few hundred yards to a place without parked cars) it's your responsibility to check that there aren't any cars coming. Vehicles don't come "out of nowhere" - they come from round the corner, out of a junction and so on. Don't cross the road where you can't safely see. Maybe he was speeding but as a pedestrian you need to take into account that drivers might speed, be distracted or just be plain incompetent.

onefinemess · 23/06/2023 11:11

OP, by your own admission, you stepped out behind a car which was parked on double yellow lines.

Do you think drivers can see through cars?

You didn't give the driver any opportunity to see you, let alone avoid you. This one is on you entirely. Your reckless decision to cross the road from behind a parked car almost cost your son his life.

And the idea that you didn't have any choice is bollocks, of course you did. You could have made the choice to wait until one of the vehicles had moved so that you and your son could have crossed the road safely.

This one is entirely on you.

Be more careful in future. You almost killed your son.

helpfulperson · 23/06/2023 11:03

There is a limit to what the police even can do. We have a school street and have had two parents, both mums, fined for being abusive to the police officers enforcing it.

SleeplessinScarbourough · 23/06/2023 11:03

Your DC should not be using a scooter during the school commute as PP said they should be holding your hand. I am not suggesting the scooter contributed to the situation in this instance as I witnessed a young child no scooter or anything just with Dad and sibling - almost knocked down at a zebra crossing because the car in the opposite lane was not stopping - if their Dad had not been vigilant and grabbed them - and we are talking seconds - it would have had a tragic outcome. The driver was entirely at fault.

However good luck with resolving this issue but there is no reasoning with pick-up/drop off parents - they can be as entitled as they like because, you know, they have a child who needs taking to/ collecting from school so they can do whatever they want.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 23/06/2023 10:57

Some people will ignore it whatever they do.

DDs school has a walking bus from the pub car park at the end of the road. Loads of space, you hand over your DC and they walk the three minutes with some staff who volunteer to do it.

Some idiots still insist on driving down the dead end, narrow street to park on double yellows, or block a drive, to run to the gate and hand their child to a different member of staff.

Can understand it when someone has to go in to speak to the teacher or something, but most are just dropping off to another TA or SLt member on the gate.

Danikm151 · 23/06/2023 10:55

Schools near me have the little bollards shaped liked children out every morning. The caretaker puts them out all the way up the road.

Round here people drive like lunatics and parents think nothing of parking on double yellows because their child can’t be expected to walk the 5 minutes to school.

EatYourVegetables · 23/06/2023 10:54

Our school had the same setup. In the end, the council stepped in and instituted a “School Street”, so no access 8:30-9:30 and 2:30-3:30 for anyone except residents and blue badges. It works great.

Dixiechickonhols · 23/06/2023 10:54

I’d contact local cllr ours is really trying to come up with a solution for our village and is working with the council.

BelindaBears · 23/06/2023 10:51

Some schools in the city I live in have designated “school streets”. It’s been really successful.

On school days, the streets outside school are closed to traffic in from 8-9:30am and 2.30-4pm.
During those times traffic isn’t allowed to drive through those streets and people can’t park for the school. Residents and blue badge holders still have access to the street but other traffic has to use alternative routes between those times.

Hamburgerandchips · 23/06/2023 10:49

You describe the vehicle as 'huge' but you didn't see it? And it can't have come 'out of nowhere'. Why shout at the driver because you didn't see their huge vehicle?

Quisto · 23/06/2023 10:46

We have lollypop ladies as our school is on a busy road. They don't have any powers to move people on or stop them parking. It's quite a hazardous job. I can't see the council funding a lollipop person (ours are ladies and both lovely) for a dead end lane.

Rubyupbeat · 23/06/2023 10:44

I have complained several times about a school near me, the parents double park on double yellows, park on red routes and on peoples drives, I have contacted the school and the council, but nothing is done. I pass this school regularly and how no one has been killed,I don't know? There should be a parking attendant round there at school times.

Badbadbunny · 23/06/2023 10:43

I think it's the same everywhere. Trouble is that even with double yellows, zig-zags, cones, etc., you need the police or local council parking wardens to enforce them, and they usually just come down once or twice after prolonged complaints/campaigns and then disappear again. Fining is apparently difficult on double yellows as there has to be a "period of grace" of a few minutes, during which time, if the driver comes back, the "ticket" can't be given. Then of course, there's the argument between police and council and to which of them is responsible for parking violations - they usually say it's the other! PCSOs are apparently unable to deal with it other than giving advice, which of course, the drivers just ignore!

We had the same problems with our village primary school for all of the 26 years I've lived in the village. Nightmare traffic, speeding parents, parents abandoning their cars on double yellows, zig zags, junctions, driveways, etc. Nothing worked. The school eventually just closed and locked the main gates (opening to the main road), and now all the children have to enter/leave the school via the back gates across the playing fields, onto minor roads where there's a small car park and more on-street parking, but the whole area back there isn't on the main road, so a lot safer and quieter, no lorries, etc. Seems to have done the trick, but now lots of complaints from parents who have to actually walk further to the back gates - literally just a few minutes, but obviously they're just too lazy and preferred to abandon their cars within a few feet of the main gates causing traffic mayhem!

The real answer is proper enforcement - someone should knock the heads together of the local police and council and get them to agree to actually dealing with the congestion and fining people rather than just fobbing off to eachother!

GMH1974 · 23/06/2023 10:32

A couple of the schools near us which are off the same busy road have lollipop ladies. Could you try speaking to the council?

LeevMarie · 23/06/2023 10:31

Thanks everyone. I'd never heard of the School Streets scheme before, but from a quick Google, I see that there is a pilot scheme operating in another school in the area. I'll ask the local Councillors to see if they can put some pressure on to have this instated here. Nothing seems to happen with any speed around here - the Local Authority are notorious for dragging their heels with this type of thing, so the more people I can get to engage with the Councillor, the better.

The Headteacher can often be seen at the bottom of the lane, but the school is on a dead end. Once she sees the rule breakers, they've already driven down there and parked up. Some people honestly have no shame at all. If I was cornered by her for my parking, I'd be mortified, but many just don't seem to care.

Cones would definitely be a good start - I'll suggest doing this.

@CwmYoy I love this! If I didn't have to be at work, this would be me with my camera and hi-viz jacket!

OP posts:
TakeMe2Insanity · 23/06/2023 10:31

State schools near us have yellow zig zag lines so that there is a clear line of sight near the school. A few doors down is a private school which has the added complication of a junction in front of it. As residents we’ve asked the council to put zigzag in front of the private school and they’ve refused so twice a day when we leave to go to another school/car journey we have the same issue of children being stood between cars not being seen. Lorries driving down the road etc.

lanthanum · 23/06/2023 10:30

Any solution is going to have to be thought up locally, as what works will depend on the exact geography. But the idea of closing streets to traffic is catching on (and the means to enforce it, with ANPR), so don't be afraid to suggest it.
Here's an article about school streets:
https://www.cambridge-news.co.uk/news/cambridge-news/traffic-ban-outside-cambridge-school-24469357

Traffic ban outside Cambridge school made permanent

Councillor Mairéad Healy, from Cambridge City Council, said she hoped the scheme could be extended to schools across the city.

https://www.cambridge-news.co.uk/news/cambridge-news/traffic-ban-outside-cambridge-school-24469357

Quisto · 23/06/2023 10:29

When our school had problems like this they had two local PCs/PCSOs on the road moving people on. They only had to do it a couple of times.

Swipe left for the next trending thread