Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the school are powerless to solve this? Parking related

87 replies

LeevMarie · 23/06/2023 10:01

Hi everyone - just wondering if this is the same everywhere in the country, or if your DC's school have managed to solve this problem.

DS (almost 5) was nearly run over this morning outside school. The school is at the bottom of a narrow lane with no car parking. We were crossing the road direct outside the entrance and he was on his scooter. I try and instill the importance of road safety, so I make him stand on the pavement, looking around for cars until I though it was safe to cross. We stepped out behind a car parked on double yellow lines on the pavement (the whole pavement is back to back with cars, so no alternative) and out of nowhere came a huge vehicle which resulted in a near miss. I shouted at the driver of the car (not ideal, but I got a shock).

When I was leaving the school, there was a stream of cars and I found it difficult as an adult to navigate my way across the road - kids have no chance.

The school are really trying to resolve the issue. They often send out emails/letters, have a sign on the gate saying that cars should not be driving down to the entrance and even have had a traffic warden on occasions to give out fines. Yet, still, inconsiderate people still keep driving down there.

I don't think there's anything more the school can do about it and fear that things will only change when there's an accident. I've emailed the Headteacher this morning to let her know that there was a near-accident, but also that I appreciate the steps they're taking to try and stop it.

Does everywhere have this problem? Are there any examples anyone has of their school successfully solved a similar issue? There is lots of parking available nearby - I can't help but think it's just lazy, entitled people who think that they have some kind of licence to do whatever they want.

OP posts:
Cindan · 23/06/2023 13:23

Our school has a drop off and pick up lane put in over Covid. The playground extended over 2 residential streets so they were able to take out a strip and make it entry one street exit another. It is WONDERFUL and a huge success with parents and residents. Oviousky depends on the school site though.

avocadotofu · 23/06/2023 13:01

Popsicle42 · 23/06/2023 10:06

I think speaking to the local council is your best bet. In our local area we have something the council has introduced called “school streets”. It means certain sections of roads can be closed at school drop off and pick up times. Our school is currently applying because like yours, despite constant messaging from the school, a number of selfish, entitled parents feel they have the right to drop their previous darlings right at the doors to school, despite there bring ample parking on neighbouring roads.

We have this where I teach and it's made a big difference at drop off and pick up. Its worth contacting your council.

neverenoughchelseaboots · 23/06/2023 12:58

CwmYoy · 23/06/2023 10:16

At a school near here a governor takes photos of illegally parked cars and forwards them to the police who issue fines.

Works like a charm.

Our teacher governor parks on the zigzags! It makes my blood boil.

He told DH he doesn’t have time to walk yet
he lives on our street and we walk but beat him back every day.

longtompot · 23/06/2023 12:52

A school in my area has only one road up to it and it has taken to closing that road between the times school drop off and then again when it's pick up time. They have had police patrols who have issued fines.
Other schools have had double yellow lines painted outside them with no drop off directly outside the school. They also had patrols of parking wardens who have issued fines.
Parents who drop their kids off are so blinkered to the dangers of other kids also trying to get to school safely. I think the school has to step in and be proactive about this. I wonder if contacting the governor's would be worth doing?

mumda · 23/06/2023 12:46

I did wonder if councils should do an analysis of how far kids travel to school.

HoppingPavlova · 23/06/2023 12:32

All of our schools have Lollipop people and an ‘official’ Lollipop crossing. No cars allowed to be parked/standing within x meters of the Lollipop crossing. If the Lollipop person believes there is the need they put in some sort of request and a Lollipop supervisor comes out and if they agree they request police presence, who do so and then everyone behaves for a few months then it rinses and repeats.

Forestfriendlygarden · 23/06/2023 12:31

GMH1974 · 23/06/2023 10:32

A couple of the schools near us which are off the same busy road have lollipop ladies. Could you try speaking to the council?

We nearly lost ours at primary due to funding cuts. But then an insurance company stepped forward to pay. Ladies or Gentlemen of course.

scrivette · 23/06/2023 12:28

Stepping out between parked cars is possibly the only place to cross along the road.

Our school sounds similar, a dead end road and parents parking as close as possible to the school entrances. I have had several near misses with cars reversing onto the pavement and almost hitting the pram as they don't look properly.

The Council have now turned the road into a School Street which has partially solved the issues. However the area just before the signs closing off the road parents turn dangerously and stop randomly in the middle of the road to get as close as possible to the school entrance. There are often traffic police there to monitor it.

Tessasanderson · 23/06/2023 12:28

The trouble is you are asking for them to have common sense when parking. Unfortunately with school run parents common sense goes out the window. There was a thread yesterday about a woman parking outside a house on the school road. Whilst what she was doing wasnt illegal, no other person other than me asked the question whether it was possible to be parked legally but still causing an access issue. Maybe it turned the road into a chicane. Maybe it meant emergency vehicles couldnt fit or maybe, like in your case, it could cause a blind spot. All the MN members replied if you are parked legally carry on.

It should not just be a case of parking legally. It should be a case of parking safely for everyone.

Bromptotoo · 23/06/2023 12:23

Dotjones · 23/06/2023 11:22

I'm glad someone else said this, I was going to say a very similar thing. You have set a bad example by teaching your child it's OK to cross the road between parked cars. If there genuinely is no way of crossing the road (like walking a few hundred yards to a place without parked cars) it's your responsibility to check that there aren't any cars coming. Vehicles don't come "out of nowhere" - they come from round the corner, out of a junction and so on. Don't cross the road where you can't safely see. Maybe he was speeding but as a pedestrian you need to take into account that drivers might speed, be distracted or just be plain incompetent.

If it's anything like round here then crossing between parked cars is pretty much unavoidable. The trick is to learn/teach how to do it properly but even then people driving way too fast with minimal clearance from parked cars are a threat.

My kids were walking to school together from around 10 & 8 which, in a semi rural commuter village should be OK, and were nearly wiped out while crossing a road with nose/tail parked cars for its entire length.

IfYouDontAsk · 23/06/2023 12:22

I think the most effective deterrent I’ve seen is the “don’t park here” signs with children on them that PP have linked to above. A school near me puts them actually on the road rather than the pavement so that parents can’t stop there even momentarily. Might your PTA fundraise for these?

elderflowerandpomelo · 23/06/2023 12:21

We have a School Street. It’s WONDERFUL. If you’re on a no through rd it will be easy to create and transformational. Lobby! I got the school to request one - it took a while but it’s so so so good.

huuskymam · 23/06/2023 12:18

We had a lot of issues with parking one year, school sent several letters and emails regarding it to no avail. The school went to the local police station and had a word about it, for a few weeks we had the local police down every morning giving warnings, making people move. We have a good bit of parking but late comers/new class parents were making it a nightmare and there were 2 near misses with kids. After a few weeks of the police being there, they eventually copped on. Would your school would be willing to try something like that.

DonnatellaLyman · 23/06/2023 12:18

Also scooter is a totally reasonable form of school transport. You can still hold child and scooter to cross the road safely.

MoiraDavidson · 23/06/2023 12:17

These threads do always highlight the posters who need some repeat driving lessons.

DonnatellaLyman · 23/06/2023 12:15

onefinemess · 23/06/2023 11:11

OP, by your own admission, you stepped out behind a car which was parked on double yellow lines.

Do you think drivers can see through cars?

You didn't give the driver any opportunity to see you, let alone avoid you. This one is on you entirely. Your reckless decision to cross the road from behind a parked car almost cost your son his life.

And the idea that you didn't have any choice is bollocks, of course you did. You could have made the choice to wait until one of the vehicles had moved so that you and your son could have crossed the road safely.

This one is entirely on you.

Be more careful in future. You almost killed your son.

This is utter rubbish. OP clearly said the whole street is full of cars illegally parked so she had no choice but to cross between parked cars.

Presumably they will only move once children have been dropped off at school. There is absolutely no reason that the selfish drivers should mean OPs child is late every morning ‘waiting until they move’.

OP you need a school street, particularly if it is a dead end. Most councils also have a scheme where you can photograph people parking illegally and report.

Cloudyz7 · 23/06/2023 12:14

onefinemess · 23/06/2023 11:11

OP, by your own admission, you stepped out behind a car which was parked on double yellow lines.

Do you think drivers can see through cars?

You didn't give the driver any opportunity to see you, let alone avoid you. This one is on you entirely. Your reckless decision to cross the road from behind a parked car almost cost your son his life.

And the idea that you didn't have any choice is bollocks, of course you did. You could have made the choice to wait until one of the vehicles had moved so that you and your son could have crossed the road safely.

This one is entirely on you.

Be more careful in future. You almost killed your son.

One of the key skills you need as a driver is to ability to assess the situation around you and anticipate any dangers.

So if you are driving past a school at school drop off/pick up time and there are parked cars - whether those cars are parked legitimately or not you bloody well SLOW DOWN and be alert to the possibility that a child could step out.

So many drivers are fixated on having the right of way that they fail to look out for more vulnerable road users.

MoiraDavidson · 23/06/2023 12:09

OP, as many have said, do look into School Streets. I live opposite a primary school and the street was made into a ‘School
Street’ a few years ago. Before the School Street was introduced parents would stop on the double yellows around the school, engines running for ages. Kids had to cross between the gaps in parked cars. There were also speeding incidents and road rage showdowns between parents driving in opposite directions who couldn’t fit past each other (although will admit these were sometimes quite entertaining). Since the School Street was introduced the pollution has dropped and the street is so much safer. It’s not a perfect system, and does push part of the problem further away, but it definitely deters drivers who live close to the school from making a short trip. Also visitors can’t enter the street during drop off/pick up time but this is a minor inconvenience compared to the benefits.

Ottolenghilover · 23/06/2023 12:02

lanthanum · 23/06/2023 10:30

Any solution is going to have to be thought up locally, as what works will depend on the exact geography. But the idea of closing streets to traffic is catching on (and the means to enforce it, with ANPR), so don't be afraid to suggest it.
Here's an article about school streets:
https://www.cambridge-news.co.uk/news/cambridge-news/traffic-ban-outside-cambridge-school-24469357

This! Our school sounds very similar re set up & it's been such a relief since it was made a school street. There's still always one though! 🙄

LlynTegid · 23/06/2023 12:02

The school is powerless I agree. They probably don't have enough staff members to observe every offence, report 100% to the police, for example.

Closure of the road with bollards or a gate to create a safe area won't happen.

The law does not provide for random breath/drug testing and the limit is not the European one such that you could remove a few cars off the road as I think some morning drivers are still over the limit.

You will never have a place at a secondary or junior school conditional on the parents' behaviour when taking a child to and from primary school, which given that some will fake their faith or move house for a good school, would probably work.

Whammyyammy · 23/06/2023 11:57

*happened

Whammyyammy · 23/06/2023 11:56

Happens in our village, the head and local pcso encouraged residents to photograph all illegally parked cars and forward to police. Stopped the parking idiots within a week and parents and children learned how to walk...

Stickybackplasticbear · 23/06/2023 11:54

Put a member of staff at the top of the lane?
Cones?
Stagger drop off tines?

Don't have your kid on a scooter

Berthatydfil · 23/06/2023 11:51

There is a school near me, situated in among some terraced streets. These houses have no front gardens but a lot have rear gardens with garages accessed via single car width rear lanes. There were massive issues with parents parking down those lanes and blocking access for residents so the council installed lockable bollards and only gave keys to the residents.

I appreciate this may not work if its a main road but it seems to me there should be something to stop people driving down this road so could the council put up no entry signs (except for deliveries and residents).

SayHi · 23/06/2023 11:49

Some parents are lazy and entitled and will always make life difficult for others.

My DDs school created a walking bus and spoke to the local council who gave parent’s permission to park for free.

The walking bus would meet at the carpark and they’d all get high viz jackets and the leaders would have big lollipop signs.

It was nice because it was so much quicker dropping your child off there than it would have been walking them all the way to school yourself, so it had a lot of interest.

The only issue is that it was organised by the school but depended on volunteer parents which as most parents work or have other commitments is difficult to do.
My DC was in year 6 when it started so I don’t know if it’s still going.

Another option would be to have a school minibus but this would cost money.

Swipe left for the next trending thread