Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of living in a country that has decriminalised crime (Scotland)

112 replies

Torven · 22/06/2023 23:16

As you'll all be aware, it's very hard for an under 25 to be sent to prison now even if they commit a really violent assault or rape that leaves the victim with lifelong injuries. There is no reason for under 25s not to commit crime (aside from their own moral compass:-/ ) unless they're planning to go into a line of work that requires a background check.

Now, the law is being changed so that criminals won't be held in prison on remand except in very rare cases. So, victims will have to cope with dangerous people living alongside them for months and maybe years.

Why do people keep voting for this? And calling it "kindness"? It's frightening. Criminals might be vulnerable but non-criminal vulnerable people are completely stuffed. If you don't have a big threatening guy to chase people off you're fair game.

OP posts:
AlbaAurora · 23/06/2023 08:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Naunet · 23/06/2023 08:56

Its terrifying to me that under 25s basically now have a free pass to rape anyone they want. Are we all meant to pretend that a 24 year old is not mature enough to understand that rape is wrong? Because if that’s the case, they shouldn’t be allowed to drink, drive, have sex or go out unsupervised either.

Torven · 23/06/2023 07:55

I've been Scottish for all of my life and I'm very comfortable with that generalisation. There's almost total political homogeneity. Some people are nationalists and some people are not but the underlying values system is the same.

Looking at moving but my husband is under long term renal care so it's a scary leap into the unknown. Ten years ago we could have happily moved to Europe :( not that anywhere is perfect.

OP posts:
Quiverer · 23/06/2023 07:51

If you're sick of living there, move.

GulesMeansRed · 23/06/2023 07:51

Loving the generalisations about Scottish people thinking X or Y, as if we all move in a whole homogenous mass. And that other trope, if you don't vote SNP, you're a Tory.

Yes it's a shitshow up here with all sorts of things including male rapists being considered a woman and addressed as such, plans to scrap exams, money wasted on a deposit scheme which is not going ahead, and a missing £600k and Sturgeon being arrested.

Hoping that the scales are starting to fall from the eyes of the Braveheart contingent.

MichelleScarn · 23/06/2023 07:46

Not be too ridiculous or take away from the gravity but is wee Nippy and her acolytes hoping this will save them from.a penal sentence? (Or they'll just self Id as 19?...)

Torven · 23/06/2023 07:36

Yeah, plus prison primarily exists to keep dangerous people off the streets. The notion that most people in there just accidentally forgot to pay their TV licence is rubbish.

OP posts:
JustDanceAddict · 23/06/2023 07:34

I didn’t know that - it’s crazy. I know under 25s’ brains aren’t fully developed but they certainly know right from wrong at a much younger age.

AllyCart · 23/06/2023 07:32

bobblyjob · 23/06/2023 07:19

Prison doesn’t work. That’s very clear. But as a PP pointed out the alternatives only work if you resource and fund them and look at the root causes of crime. And the American system is mental. A lot more people are in prison for very minor crimes there

Of course prison works.

A child rapist in prison for 10+ years isn't going to rape another child for 10+ years.

It's liberal bollocks to say "prison doesn't work". Build more of them and lock up more serious criminals, not fewer.

Torven · 23/06/2023 07:23

Prison works because it keeps you safe while your attacker is locked away. Don't belittle a few years' peace of mind.

It also absolutely was a deterrent. As above, if you are under 25 you might as well do what you want and take what you want. If an under 25 hits you, no big deal for them. If you hit them back, possible prison. It is unsafe.

OP posts:
bobblyjob · 23/06/2023 07:19

Prison doesn’t work. That’s very clear. But as a PP pointed out the alternatives only work if you resource and fund them and look at the root causes of crime. And the American system is mental. A lot more people are in prison for very minor crimes there

Torven · 23/06/2023 07:17

Also

OP posts:
Torven · 23/06/2023 07:16

If you're a witness to a crime I'd ask keep that to yourself because the accused is much more likely now to be out and about, paying you a wee visit.

Whatever happened to believe victims?

What frustrates me especially is, if this happened at a UK level I think there'd be a big campaign against it. It's an abuser's golden ticket. But we're too small and too lacking in accountability for anyone to do anything. They could legislate to do anything and get away with it.

OP posts:
Highandlows · 23/06/2023 06:56

It is terrible and will get worse. When the majority of people realise it will be too late. See San Francisco.

Torven · 23/06/2023 06:54

I do know that if I'm the victim of crime by an under 25 now my choices are to fight back hard (and possibly be arrested myself) or just let it go completely.

It makes me scared of seeing young people out and about.

OP posts:
Caradonna · 23/06/2023 06:54

It's cheaper - dressed up as modern thinking.
I hope there is a change in the make up of the Scot Gov after the next election.

Torven · 23/06/2023 06:50

It seems like this bail change was almost sneaked through. It was only in the news yesterday when the Bill was finally passed. I have friends who work in criminal justice who didn't know it was coming. It's so malevolent, this culture of "we'll do what we think is best".

The schools situation is also appalling, yes. Good kids who want to be doctors, nurses, even bloody civil servants are sitting targets because they can't fight back as there will be lifelong consequences that their attackers simply don't have to worry about.

OP posts:
MichelleScarn · 23/06/2023 06:43

Sheepshop · 23/06/2023 00:25

This is so true. Read any school exclusion policy in Scotland and it boasts how Scotland tries and tries to keep kids included in mainstream society - they actually boast about his few kids they exclude - but the numbers of school refusers are going through the roof and the reason in a lot of cases is violence-induced anxiety. Get violent kids out of our schools and let well behaved kids get on with learning in a safe, calm environment. It’s what our kids deserve.

This I really don't understand how their thinking works.
Push and change things to keep in mainstream pupils who vandalise and destroy school property and physically/verbally/sexually assault other pupils/staff, but ignore or chastise those who have been so badly affected by this they cannot go to school?!

BeethovenNinth · 23/06/2023 06:31

just another crack pot SNP policy

how do we actually get these lunatics out?

capitanaamerica · 23/06/2023 06:29

You see the same craziness taken to extremes in some places in the US, where things like stealing are effectively decriminalized. It ends up being a shit place to live.

This happens, but the ones I'm aware of in the US tend to severely reduce or eliminate jail time for first offences but actually increase it for repeats - like California's Three Strikes laws, where your third crime gets the full weight of the system thrown at you even if crime 3 is relatively trivial - so there is still a kind of deterrent built in. And the usual impetus is to reduce overcrowding without incurring the expense of building too many new prisons (and raising the ire of NIMBYs) rather than any kind of social engineering. Also, these programs usually wouldn't include violent crimes like rape; it's more for "victimless crimes" or crimes against property, financial crimes, drug possession, etc.

The under-25 aspect in Scotland seems particularly weird as Scotland has the "age of legal capacity" set at 16, as well as voting, marriage (when everyone else in Europe has committed to eliminating marriage for under-18s) and the new GRR which allows people to have social/medical sex/gender reassignment at 16. By what logic are people adults two years earlier than the rest of the world UK for all of those purposes, but not for taking responsibility for their violent crimes that destroy other people's lives?

ClareBlue · 23/06/2023 05:43

Sentencing for crime isn't just about rehabilitation. There is meant to be an element of punishment and deterent to deter others from committing crime. There is also the protection of public safety. These all seem to have got lost in a move to be progressive. Most crime is inflicted on poorer communities anyway, so it's not really helping them.

Sheepshop · 23/06/2023 00:25

Torven · 22/06/2023 23:43

Indeed. Everyone wants to assume the plans are reasonable. The plans are for life to be more dangerous.

The irony is, it's based on the fact that criminals are often created by trauma. Obviously true... But why respond to that by setting the scene for many, many more people to be traumatised?

This is so true. Read any school exclusion policy in Scotland and it boasts how Scotland tries and tries to keep kids included in mainstream society - they actually boast about his few kids they exclude - but the numbers of school refusers are going through the roof and the reason in a lot of cases is violence-induced anxiety. Get violent kids out of our schools and let well behaved kids get on with learning in a safe, calm environment. It’s what our kids deserve.

Torven · 22/06/2023 23:47

Without 23D a lot of domestic abusers will be heading back home pending trial.

#BeKind

OP posts:
Torven · 22/06/2023 23:43

Indeed. Everyone wants to assume the plans are reasonable. The plans are for life to be more dangerous.

The irony is, it's based on the fact that criminals are often created by trauma. Obviously true... But why respond to that by setting the scene for many, many more people to be traumatised?

OP posts:
tobee · 22/06/2023 23:42

Because there's loads of loony policies you can bring into the fold with people voting for you if you're "not Tory".

Speaking as someone who's not a Tory I found this very troubling.

Swipe left for the next trending thread