Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of living in a country that has decriminalised crime (Scotland)

112 replies

Torven · 22/06/2023 23:16

As you'll all be aware, it's very hard for an under 25 to be sent to prison now even if they commit a really violent assault or rape that leaves the victim with lifelong injuries. There is no reason for under 25s not to commit crime (aside from their own moral compass:-/ ) unless they're planning to go into a line of work that requires a background check.

Now, the law is being changed so that criminals won't be held in prison on remand except in very rare cases. So, victims will have to cope with dangerous people living alongside them for months and maybe years.

Why do people keep voting for this? And calling it "kindness"? It's frightening. Criminals might be vulnerable but non-criminal vulnerable people are completely stuffed. If you don't have a big threatening guy to chase people off you're fair game.

OP posts:
TooOldForThisNonsense · 23/06/2023 12:11

Bromptotoo · 23/06/2023 10:42

Well it's not as if there's overwhelming evidence that prison works is it?

It works by removing dangerous criminals from society for a period. That’s kind of the point of prison (or one of the points).

TooOldForThisNonsense · 23/06/2023 12:10

Totally agree

too young to be fully criminally responsible for your actions

old enough to change sex

welcome to SNP Scotland. Sadly there are so many people who are brainwashed and would vote for a dogshit if it had a black and yellow rosette on it so who knows when it will change.

LlynTegid · 23/06/2023 12:06

Another example of why the best argument against Scottish independence is the SNP.

onefinemess · 23/06/2023 11:28

Well OP, we have just raised an entire generation of kids who now don't believe their words or actions should have any consequences. Feelings matter more that logic, science, or law. This is how we raised them, we got what we wanted.

Those laws around crime are designed to appeal to the above generation, so that they will vote for the party which sanctioned them.

Sheepshop · 23/06/2023 11:00

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 23/06/2023 10:39

What are the tories doing better at out of interest?

Locking up rapists, taking a hard line on blokes-pretending to be women who want to waltz into ladies loos, English kids can get into Scottish unis far more easily than Scottish kids can, English schools do much better than Scot’s in international educational league tables (with Scot’s pulling out as it was getting so embarrassing), then there’s drugs deaths and obesity. And in England there are ferries you can get to the to the Isle of Wight etc. speak to the poor people of Uist or Mull about that!

Torven · 23/06/2023 10:49

If you didn't live a nice middle class life you would be dreading what this means for your quality of life. "Prison doesn't work" is a sentiment for those who have no fear in their lives.

OP posts:
Bromptotoo · 23/06/2023 10:42

Well it's not as if there's overwhelming evidence that prison works is it?

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 23/06/2023 10:39

Sheepshop · 23/06/2023 10:35

When the Tories are doing a better job of running a country that’s saying something, but I really do think they are. That’s how bad things are here. And I don’t even live on a Scottish island.

What are the tories doing better at out of interest?

Babdoc · 23/06/2023 10:38

Since June last year, the Scottish NHS has been performing worse than England on virtually every measure, from A and E waiting times to ambulance delays, cancer treatment delays and surgery waiting lists.

There is a consultant recruitment crisis with posts vacant across Scotland, worsened by doctors having to pay £2,000 a year more income tax here than in England. GP practices have been closing to new patients, or struggling to run with foreign locums. The SNP have made a mess of every devolved area they attempt to run, from education to health, transport and the economy.

GasPanic · 23/06/2023 10:36

capitanaamerica · 23/06/2023 06:29

You see the same craziness taken to extremes in some places in the US, where things like stealing are effectively decriminalized. It ends up being a shit place to live.

This happens, but the ones I'm aware of in the US tend to severely reduce or eliminate jail time for first offences but actually increase it for repeats - like California's Three Strikes laws, where your third crime gets the full weight of the system thrown at you even if crime 3 is relatively trivial - so there is still a kind of deterrent built in. And the usual impetus is to reduce overcrowding without incurring the expense of building too many new prisons (and raising the ire of NIMBYs) rather than any kind of social engineering. Also, these programs usually wouldn't include violent crimes like rape; it's more for "victimless crimes" or crimes against property, financial crimes, drug possession, etc.

The under-25 aspect in Scotland seems particularly weird as Scotland has the "age of legal capacity" set at 16, as well as voting, marriage (when everyone else in Europe has committed to eliminating marriage for under-18s) and the new GRR which allows people to have social/medical sex/gender reassignment at 16. By what logic are people adults two years earlier than the rest of the world UK for all of those purposes, but not for taking responsibility for their violent crimes that destroy other people's lives?

The US incarceration rate is about 4x that of the UK.

Sheepshop · 23/06/2023 10:35

When the Tories are doing a better job of running a country that’s saying something, but I really do think they are. That’s how bad things are here. And I don’t even live on a Scottish island.

Torven · 23/06/2023 10:28

The Scottish health system has all the same problems as the English. I don't see anything for the money. I don't mind paying for something that works and creates a good safety net but this is a country that is protecting people less, not more.

OP posts:
Sheepshop · 23/06/2023 10:23

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 23/06/2023 10:22

You do know the Scottish government consists of more than 3 people right? I mean two of those arrested weren't even IN the Scottish government. It's always funny seeing the rabid unionists loose their shit over anything the SNP does while simultaneously ignoring the infinitely greater scandal and corruption of the UK government members 😂.

But for clarity if Sturgeon, Murrell, and Beattie are charged and found guilty of committing a crime, they should 100% be punished in accordance with the law, barred from politics for life, and in the case of Sturgeon have any lifetime benefits associated with her time in the government stripped.

As for the NHS performance you're just wrong. NHS Scotland has more staff per head, more funding per head, more GPs per head, lower A&E waiting times, faster ambulance response times, lower trearment waiting lists, quicker treatment times, and no parking charges at hospitals. NHS Scotland has outperformed the rUK in all core areas for the last 7 or 8 years at least.

You might not feel that is the case, and I'm not saying that NHS Acotand is brilliantly run, but it IS statistically better than the rUK

Does the Scottish NHS not employ 1/3 more staff than the rest of the UK? Yet it’s STILL shite. That’s so shameful.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 23/06/2023 10:22

GulesMeansRed · 23/06/2023 09:57

Scotland's health care system performs better than it's UK counter parts

Does it bollocks. Can't believe that there are STILL people out there prepared to defend the Scot Gov after all the recent shenanigans with motor homes, arrests and missing money.

You do know the Scottish government consists of more than 3 people right? I mean two of those arrested weren't even IN the Scottish government. It's always funny seeing the rabid unionists loose their shit over anything the SNP does while simultaneously ignoring the infinitely greater scandal and corruption of the UK government members 😂.

But for clarity if Sturgeon, Murrell, and Beattie are charged and found guilty of committing a crime, they should 100% be punished in accordance with the law, barred from politics for life, and in the case of Sturgeon have any lifetime benefits associated with her time in the government stripped.

As for the NHS performance you're just wrong. NHS Scotland has more staff per head, more funding per head, more GPs per head, lower A&E waiting times, faster ambulance response times, lower trearment waiting lists, quicker treatment times, and no parking charges at hospitals. NHS Scotland has outperformed the rUK in all core areas for the last 7 or 8 years at least.

You might not feel that is the case, and I'm not saying that NHS Acotand is brilliantly run, but it IS statistically better than the rUK

Sheepshop · 23/06/2023 10:22

Maidsmum · 23/06/2023 10:09

That is such a cheeky comment. How dare you?? We don't dislike English. Take your narrow minded head out of your arse

I’ve tried very hard but can see no other reason why anyone would vote SNP. And there are LOADS of Scot’s that hate the English. As a Scot living here I see it at least on a weekly basis. It’s so cringe! It’s these people who are narrow minded!

DoraSpenlow · 23/06/2023 10:17

bobblyjob · 23/06/2023 07:19

Prison doesn’t work. That’s very clear. But as a PP pointed out the alternatives only work if you resource and fund them and look at the root causes of crime. And the American system is mental. A lot more people are in prison for very minor crimes there

This thread reminds me of being on jury service a few years ago (England). The guy was found guilty of theft and his barrister was asking for community service. His client had been through borstal and prison many, many times so that route was not working. The judge agreed that it was not working for this man but said that at least while he was locked up he wasn't helping himself to other people's possessions and making them feel unsafe in their own homes. He got 18 months I think.

JudgeAnderson · 23/06/2023 10:15

My dental practice has had to scrap their NHS provision so I'm also private now. They weren't getting adequate funding to offer it.

talkingdeadscot · 23/06/2023 10:09

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 23/06/2023 09:51

Scotland's health care system performs better than it's UK counter parts and it has a lower crime rate too. So if those are your two over riding concerns I wouldn't move south if I were you.

I don't think that holds true anymore. GP's avoid referring to specialists at all cost and have done for a few years (based on my experience and that of my wider circle). I've been waiting 2 years for an op I was meant to have in 12 weeks. Also been waiting a year for an orthopaedic appointment and had to go private for a dentist.

Maidsmum · 23/06/2023 10:09

Sheepshop · 22/06/2023 23:21

why do people keep voting for it? Cause they don’t have two brain cells to rub together and don’t like the English.

That is such a cheeky comment. How dare you?? We don't dislike English. Take your narrow minded head out of your arse

GulesMeansRed · 23/06/2023 09:57

Scotland's health care system performs better than it's UK counter parts

Does it bollocks. Can't believe that there are STILL people out there prepared to defend the Scot Gov after all the recent shenanigans with motor homes, arrests and missing money.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 23/06/2023 09:51

Torven · 23/06/2023 09:25

Husband pays the same. We really should move it's not like English hospitals don't have nephrologists!

Scotland's health care system performs better than it's UK counter parts and it has a lower crime rate too. So if those are your two over riding concerns I wouldn't move south if I were you.

ChangeIsInevitable · 23/06/2023 09:48

Ironically it's often sold as being anti-racist, but it also tends to hit poor areas with lots of non-white people hardest. Those are the people in communities full of criminals who lose services when they leave the area.

Well that went there fast.

Anyway, OP I agree and with other pp that we need to put more people in prison for crimes and longer sentences. Take criminals out of the streets even if we have to build specific centres for different crimes, therefore having different punishments.

Criminals who disturb (and in many cases, abuse) other people's human rights shoulgn't get the choice to have theirs respected, bar the minimum.

And while we're at it, I'm also for the chair for heinous crimes! I don't think it makes sense to say 'either life is valuable or isn't'. Life is valuable to some extent. When you don't value life, you don't get to have yours valued.

Torven · 23/06/2023 09:25

Husband pays the same. We really should move it's not like English hospitals don't have nephrologists!

OP posts:
Torven · 23/06/2023 09:23

Prescription charges in England max out at about £120. Not really worth the extra £2,500 in income tax I pay tbh...

OP posts:
Caradonna · 23/06/2023 09:15

Would Scotland have voted to remain in Europe if the Nats had added to the question - and if you don't we will assume that you want independence

I didn't see it on my ballot paper so this constant ' Scots people want independence' is not held up by the stats. I thinkit's just over half want independence (but no one has ever asked me this and I'm in Scotland) and just over half don't.

The truth would be 'Some Scots want independence' - but that doesn't suit the wind up merchants in the media. you had your chance and blew it.