Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of living in a country that has decriminalised crime (Scotland)

112 replies

Torven · 22/06/2023 23:16

As you'll all be aware, it's very hard for an under 25 to be sent to prison now even if they commit a really violent assault or rape that leaves the victim with lifelong injuries. There is no reason for under 25s not to commit crime (aside from their own moral compass:-/ ) unless they're planning to go into a line of work that requires a background check.

Now, the law is being changed so that criminals won't be held in prison on remand except in very rare cases. So, victims will have to cope with dangerous people living alongside them for months and maybe years.

Why do people keep voting for this? And calling it "kindness"? It's frightening. Criminals might be vulnerable but non-criminal vulnerable people are completely stuffed. If you don't have a big threatening guy to chase people off you're fair game.

OP posts:
Bromptotoo · 23/06/2023 15:39

Sheepshop · 23/06/2023 15:32

This is what frustrates me. The view is entirely taken from the perpetrator’s perception, never the victim’s. I’m sure the background of the rapist is neither here Noelle there if you’re the victim. You still deserve retribution for the crime carried out against you.

No part of Criminal Justice is about retribution.

Guilt or innocence and, if guilty, punishment and rehabilitation.

As ever, so much of public perception is down to the lack of any real Public Legal Education in the UK.

Sheepshop · 23/06/2023 15:32

yogasaurus · 23/06/2023 14:39

it will never be a good thing for the victim.

This is what frustrates me. The view is entirely taken from the perpetrator’s perception, never the victim’s. I’m sure the background of the rapist is neither here Noelle there if you’re the victim. You still deserve retribution for the crime carried out against you.

JudgeAnderson · 23/06/2023 15:25

@Malbecmoron what, one rapist gets a derisory sentence and the other isn't jailed at all?

Malbecmoron · 23/06/2023 15:24

JudgeAnderson · 23/06/2023 14:54

There isn't any. Rape, particularly when carried out by u25s in Scotland, is all but decriminalised.

It's not! See my previous post re two very recent cases

MissConductUS · 23/06/2023 15:01

DemiColon · 22/06/2023 23:29

You see the same craziness taken to extremes in some places in the US, where things like stealing are effectively decriminalized. It ends up being a shit place to live.

Ironically it's often sold as being anti-racist, but it also tends to hit poor areas with lots of non-white people hardest. Those are the people in communities full of criminals who lose services when they leave the area.

Fundamentally I think those who really push this don't believe in personal responsibility. We make these criminals by being unjust, so it would be unfair to punish them, and the privileged deserve what they get anyway.

Most voters though, IMO, aren't really thinking about this stuff when they cast a ballot.

San Francisco and Seattle are circling the drain because they don't enforce basic public safety measures. I went to a conference in SF twenty years ago, and it was horrid then. It's reportedly worse now. When people started working from home during the pandemic, businesses realized they didn't need to be in the city center, and many have downsized and/or moved to the safer suburbs.

New York City was headed in a similar direction. A former NYPD Captain was elected mayor in 2021 mainly due to the realization that something had to change.

LakeTiticaca · 23/06/2023 14:56

Why the hell do you keep voting them in?

JudgeAnderson · 23/06/2023 14:54

There isn't any. Rape, particularly when carried out by u25s in Scotland, is all but decriminalised.

DisquietintheRanks · 23/06/2023 14:53

I just can't see why any rape victim would put themselves through the hell of a court process just so their attacker (if found guilty) is given a community service or a few months jail time. I mean, where's the justice?

Malbecmoron · 23/06/2023 14:51

Three years means he certainly didn't get away with it, also on the sexual offenders list. I can't see anywhere that the victim says she wishes she hadn't bothered?

Torven · 23/06/2023 14:44

Rhys Roberts got three years. The judge said he'd have got much longer if he were over 25. He'll also get a discount for time served. His victim said she wished she hadn't bothered.

OP posts:
yogasaurus · 23/06/2023 14:39

GottaGirlcrush · 22/06/2023 23:35

It says in that article they will take an 'individuate approach'

In some cases I can see this will be a good thing

it will never be a good thing for the victim.

Bromptotoo · 23/06/2023 14:38

FourTeaFallOut · 23/06/2023 14:30

So, there is something that we cannot know that you have a feeling about that keeps your world view in tact? That's convenient.

Can you find a report of his trial where his evidence and that of his victim is clearly laid out. HAve the full remarks of the judge at sentence been published?

We're told he was convicted by a jury so presumably his plea was not guilty. Normally, or at least in England, that would be a massive aggravating factor in sentencing.

To me, as a long term observer of the law, something does not add up.

Malbecmoron · 23/06/2023 14:38

It's not true to say under 25's don't get a custodial sentence for rape www.cumnockchronicle.com/news/23577423.rhys-roberts-rape-sentence-judge-says-no-alternative-custody/ as an example.

FourTeaFallOut · 23/06/2023 14:30

Bromptotoo · 23/06/2023 14:29

There's something about that case that's either not in the public domain or is extremely difficult to find and which differentiates it from the public's perception of what 'raping teenage girls' constitutes.

Until I know what that is I'm reserving my opinion on whether he should be inside or not.

So, there is something that we cannot know that you have a feeling about that keeps your world view in tact? That's convenient.

Bromptotoo · 23/06/2023 14:29

FourTeaFallOut · 23/06/2023 14:14

But clearly Sean Hogg is dangerous. Being dangerous or not clearly isn't being utilised as a differentiating factor when it comes to raping teenage girls

There's something about that case that's either not in the public domain or is extremely difficult to find and which differentiates it from the public's perception of what 'raping teenage girls' constitutes.

Until I know what that is I'm reserving my opinion on whether he should be inside or not.

JaneyGee · 23/06/2023 14:27

Sheepshop · 22/06/2023 23:22

But it is totally mind blowing. They think they are being progressive because Scandinavia does this sort of thing but in Scandinavia there is an extensive, extremely well funded rehabilitation program. Here there is nothing so they are free to rape and rape again.

But Sweden’s crime rate has massively increased in the last few decades. In the 1970s they had very low rates of gun crime and rape. Not true today.

As with every other form of dreamy left-wing idealism, it sounds great in the university seminar room, or sixth form debating society, but doesn’t work in practice. I’m not right-wing on crime. I oppose the death penalty, and I recognise that people do not all get the same start in life. Abuse, trauma, mental illness, etc, also play a part. But constantly telling people they are victims backfires. The only approach that works is a sensible, humane conservative one: you have done wrong, and you are going to be punished. However, we are not going to humiliate or degrade you. There will be a prison therapist, and there will opportunities for you to re-train and contribute something to society. So accept you have done wrong, take your punishment, stop blaming everyone else, and don’t do it again. If you do, we’ll lock you up.

FourTeaFallOut · 23/06/2023 14:14

Bromptotoo · 23/06/2023 12:14

I get that of course. If they really need to be removed then, so far as I can see, the Judge has that option.

If they're not dangerous but need training and rehabilitation is prison, with all its baggage for their future, the best place to deliver that training etc.

But clearly Sean Hogg is dangerous. Being dangerous or not clearly isn't being utilised as a differentiating factor when it comes to raping teenage girls

Torven · 23/06/2023 14:03

Well, the grass is no greener but it would be 5k cheaper for my household and if a 21 year old raped me or knocked my husband unconscious then he might at least in theory go to jail for it.

Your defensiveness is so irrational. A shame that so few scots have that giftie of seeing ourselves as others see us...

OP posts:
SunnyEgg · 23/06/2023 13:26

Agree with majority, yanbu

ChaToilLeam · 23/06/2023 13:26

There is just no effective opposition to the SNP right now so they do whatever they want. And they’ll keep doing it because the carrot of independence is perpetually dangled in front of voters.

AlbaAurora · 23/06/2023 13:25

Torven · 23/06/2023 09:25

Husband pays the same. We really should move it's not like English hospitals don't have nephrologists!

Move then. You'll soon get a shock at the grass is greener Tory mess down south. Cheerio!

JudgeAnderson · 23/06/2023 13:11

@TooOldForThisNonsense Yep that about sums it up. It's incredibly depressing.

Bromptotoo · 23/06/2023 12:14

TooOldForThisNonsense · 23/06/2023 12:11

It works by removing dangerous criminals from society for a period. That’s kind of the point of prison (or one of the points).

I get that of course. If they really need to be removed then, so far as I can see, the Judge has that option.

If they're not dangerous but need training and rehabilitation is prison, with all its baggage for their future, the best place to deliver that training etc.