Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of living in a country that has decriminalised crime (Scotland)

112 replies

Torven · 22/06/2023 23:16

As you'll all be aware, it's very hard for an under 25 to be sent to prison now even if they commit a really violent assault or rape that leaves the victim with lifelong injuries. There is no reason for under 25s not to commit crime (aside from their own moral compass:-/ ) unless they're planning to go into a line of work that requires a background check.

Now, the law is being changed so that criminals won't be held in prison on remand except in very rare cases. So, victims will have to cope with dangerous people living alongside them for months and maybe years.

Why do people keep voting for this? And calling it "kindness"? It's frightening. Criminals might be vulnerable but non-criminal vulnerable people are completely stuffed. If you don't have a big threatening guy to chase people off you're fair game.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ThereIsNoTruth · 03/12/2023 18:11

Maybe you missed the point of the post. If under 25s can get away with violent crimes, then your safety and the safety of your family are at risk. The government is supposed to be for all the people, not just violent Ned’s who will treat this new law as a ‘get out of jail free’ card. Come back when your wife, daughter, mother or sister have been raped; or your children have been beaten up by a gang of thugs; or your property has been made uninhabitable by robbers. The list is endless. Yes, it would be safer in England!

DisquietintheRanks · 25/06/2023 12:53

There's no reason why incarceration and rehabilitation can't be combined. We're talking about a rapist here, not someone who shoplifts, so a lad that is already a violent, dangerous criminal. Why are you worried about him bring corrupted in prison, he's already corrupt. Be more worried about who he may be influencing in daily life.

Bromptotoo · 25/06/2023 10:52

DisquietintheRanks · 25/06/2023 10:42

@Bromptotoo the pertinent fact was his age and the change in the law that means that the under 25s should no longer be incarcerated if it can be avoided. Its easily avoided if you prioritize the rights of the criminal over those of his victim. And the judge did.

That's not how I'm seeing it at present. Might be different if I knew the facts around the incident.

On the whole, I'd prioritise rehabilitation over what several posters here are openly calling retribution or similar. Doing so is a philosophy of my own thinking and it ain't going to change.

If, in any case involving a young person, they're sent to gaol as a fay laddie and emerge as a skunk addict with a degree in other offending from the University of Crime who exactly is helped?

Gytgyt · 25/06/2023 10:49

bobblyjob · 23/06/2023 07:19

Prison doesn’t work. That’s very clear. But as a PP pointed out the alternatives only work if you resource and fund them and look at the root causes of crime. And the American system is mental. A lot more people are in prison for very minor crimes there

I think for rape at 17 and the girl was only 13. The boy needed to be punished weather prison would have worked or not for him in the long run isn't relevant to the victim. I suspect if this happened within your family you would take a different stance.

Following the thread with interest OP I had no idea about this law in Scotland.

DisquietintheRanks · 25/06/2023 10:42

@Bromptotoo the pertinent fact was his age and the change in the law that means that the under 25s should no longer be incarcerated if it can be avoided. Its easily avoided if you prioritize the rights of the criminal over those of his victim. And the judge did.

Bromptotoo · 24/06/2023 15:17

MichelleScarn · 24/06/2023 10:11

I'm confused @Bromptotoo are you saying that there can be 'facts' that make rape ok?
And in particular when a 14 yo is raped? Like she's possibly known him = there's OK reasons?

He's clearly guilty of rape; convicted by a Jury.

The issue at hand is the sentence. There must be something in the facts that led the Judge to give the order he did.

Until we know that we're flying blind.

MichelleScarn · 24/06/2023 10:11

Bromptotoo · 24/06/2023 09:11

As I said, it's about the facts at the time.

Unless somebody can provide links to a report of the trial and or what was said at sentence we don't know what those facts were.

I'm confused @Bromptotoo are you saying that there can be 'facts' that make rape ok?
And in particular when a 14 yo is raped? Like she's possibly known him = there's OK reasons?

JudgeAnderson · 24/06/2023 10:05

Yeah but in reality your attacker is probably learning new criminal skills while inside.

Great, we'll just not bother then.

AgentJohnson · 24/06/2023 09:23

Prison works because it keeps you safe while your attacker is locked away. Don't belittle a few years' peace of mind.

Yeah but in reality your attacker is probably learning new criminal skills while inside.

Bromptotoo · 24/06/2023 09:11

DisquietintheRanks · 23/06/2023 22:03

Well if he didn't know her before the first rape, he obviously did before the others. He raped her several times over the course of a few months.

Explain to me why that mitigates the crime, I would have thought it compounds it.

As I said, it's about the facts at the time.

Unless somebody can provide links to a report of the trial and or what was said at sentence we don't know what those facts were.

DisquietintheRanks · 23/06/2023 22:03

Bromptotoo · 23/06/2023 16:42

Did Hogg and the 13yo know each other before he raped her?

Reports focus on his current age, 21. When this happened he was 17.

It's all about facts at the time.

Well if he didn't know her before the first rape, he obviously did before the others. He raped her several times over the course of a few months.

Explain to me why that mitigates the crime, I would have thought it compounds it.

Malbecmoron · 23/06/2023 17:02

JudgeAnderson · 23/06/2023 16:19

Both were given custodial sentences.

Sean Hogg wasn't given a custodial sentence, he just had to do community work.

Both cases I quoted were given custodial sentences

FourTeaFallOut · 23/06/2023 16:43

So you can be found guilty of raping a 12yo when you are 17 years old and knowing them in advance is a mitigating factor because....?

Fill in the blanks for me.

Bromptotoo · 23/06/2023 16:42

FourTeaFallOut · 23/06/2023 16:32

Ah, but, people have feelings about that which would make that a legitimate sentence for being found guilty of raping a child -

Did Hogg and the 13yo know each other before he raped her?

Reports focus on his current age, 21. When this happened he was 17.

It's all about facts at the time.

stargirl1701 · 23/06/2023 16:41

Nobody did vote it though. It was not in the SNP manifesto. Nobody would vote it!

Fightyouforthatpie · 23/06/2023 16:41

This isn't just an issue in Scotland. Where I live in the English East Midlands the Police appear to have given up on all but the most serious crimes.
Shoplifting, antisocial behaviour, street racing and open smoking of weed are all commonplace and ignored by Police.

Fandabedodgy · 23/06/2023 16:35

Sheepshop · 22/06/2023 23:21

why do people keep voting for it? Cause they don’t have two brain cells to rub together and don’t like the English.

Because 45% want independence over and above anything else

The 55% unionist vote splits between Labour, Lib Dem and Tories.

DismantledKing · 23/06/2023 16:35

The SNP are fucking nuts, and their Green accomplices even more so.

Bromptotoo · 23/06/2023 16:34

The sentence for murder is life imprisonment. Knocking a couple of years off the amount Bennet will serve before the Parole Board can even consider his release on licence isn't what the (Scottish) Sun pretends.

FourTeaFallOut · 23/06/2023 16:32

JudgeAnderson · 23/06/2023 16:19

Both were given custodial sentences.

Sean Hogg wasn't given a custodial sentence, he just had to do community work.

Ah, but, people have feelings about that which would make that a legitimate sentence for being found guilty of raping a child -

JudgeAnderson · 23/06/2023 16:19

Both were given custodial sentences.

Sean Hogg wasn't given a custodial sentence, he just had to do community work.

Malbecmoron · 23/06/2023 16:12

JudgeAnderson · 23/06/2023 15:25

@Malbecmoron what, one rapist gets a derisory sentence and the other isn't jailed at all?

Both were given custodial sentences.

VioletCreams · 23/06/2023 16:01

This person was under 25 (23) when he raped and murdered a poor lady when she was walking home after a night out. Because he is under 25 he got a few years knocked off his sentence. You know at that age (and younger) what you are doing is wrong so I don’t see why they should get less of a sentence. He will be the same age as his victim when he is due to be released 😡. He should never be released after what he did!! Jill Barclay murder.

Maniac who killed Jill Barclay gets years knocked off sentence because he's under 25

A MANIAC who raped a mum and then burned her alive got years knocked off his jail sentence because of his age. Depraved Rhys Bennett, 23, murdered Jill Barclay after he spotted her in a pub a…

https://www.thescottishsun.co.uk/news/10726210/rhys-bennett-sentence-reduced-age-murder-jill-barclay/amp/

JudgeAnderson · 23/06/2023 15:42

If it's anywhere near decriminalised it wouldn't get anywhere near a court and a jury as happened to Hogg

Which is an absolute waste of everyone's time if the punishment is that lenient.

Bromptotoo · 23/06/2023 15:40

JudgeAnderson · 23/06/2023 14:54

There isn't any. Rape, particularly when carried out by u25s in Scotland, is all but decriminalised.

Nonsense on stilts...

If it's anywhere near decriminalised it wouldn't get anywhere near a court and a jury as happened to Hogg.