Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think that saying "my house is messy but clean" is a big fat lie?

245 replies

SwordViolin · 22/06/2023 21:13

People say this all the time, my house is a mess but it's always clean but how? If your house is a mess then who knows what filth lurks under piles of papers or clothes or boxes. Anytime I've ever been in a messy house it has always been pretty dusty and unclean. Times when my house has been messy its much harder to actually clean, I need to tidy everything up and organise the space to get ot properly clean.

I mean it's fine if your house is messy and not cleaned because that's life we all have different tolerances of mess and dirt, we all have different circumstances but why say "my house is messy but clean" when it is so obviously not true?

OP posts:
Dullardmullard · 23/06/2023 18:55

Every surface is covered in crap but floors are clean that’s the best I’ve got and I don’t give two fucks

Scirocco · 23/06/2023 18:53

I'll describe mine as untidy but unlikely to be a health hazard. That's fine.

Mumuser124 · 23/06/2023 18:51

There is definitely a difference between messy and clean. I clean all of the door handles and switches with antibacterial, put the toys through the dishwasher, clean bathrooms and kitchen thoroughly and regularly BUT there is a massive pile of washed clothes currently on the dining table, toys all over the living room floor, toys all over the bathroom floor and cups waiting to go in the dishwasher.

I would consider my house to be clean, in that you are unlikely to pick up extra germs by being in my home but you will have to make sure you don’t break an ankle whilst hopping o er the 100 dinosaurs..swings and roundabouts.

ladyvimes · 23/06/2023 18:39

Outing but my grandma used to say ‘a clean house is a sign of a wasted life’, which makes me feel better when I’d rather take my kids to the beach than clean on a weekend!!

ladyvimes · 23/06/2023 18:37

I always clean my kitchen and bathrooms but my house is messy. I have two young kids, my husband and I work full time in demanding jobs and I’m not a massive fan of cleaning! If you came round you’d probably think it was untidy but it is clean!! To be fair almost all my friends’ houses are the same!

GordanoBenito · 23/06/2023 18:33

My house is usually the opposite Blush

Things are tidied away etc but it's all quite dusty and I don't hoover v often. I have guilt over the state of the skirting boards but not enough to bother scrubbing at them...

Avondale89 · 23/06/2023 18:31

It’s perfectly possible. I live in this state constantly. I’m not sure why you care so much to keep popping back up and arguing with people. Maybe enjoy your clean house instead of arguing with strangers online.

3AndStopping · 23/06/2023 18:30

God who cares. This constant war between (women ONLY) on who has the cleanest most showy house is f*ing boring frankly.

Most of us try to maintain some sort of order but people genuinely think they’re better for having a cleaner home. Let me tell you some of the people I know with the cleanest homes have the most boring bloody lives/conversations (my mother included.)

It’s nice to keep your home reasonable for your own pride/peace of mind but we should remember our homes are to be lived in not photographed!

Branleuse · 23/06/2023 18:28

Mine is neither. I give up x

Bowbowbo · 23/06/2023 18:26

Who cares?

MrsRaspberry · 23/06/2023 18:24

I'm not sure why you're bothered about someone elses home. You don't have to live in it. Whilst you say it's an obvious big fat lie for them to say their home is clean their idea of clean is clearly different to your own definition of the term. Your post comes across that your standards are better than someone elses therefore you're not as "trampy" as someone else without actually using that term directly. Maybe find something better to do than judge others that don't live up to your expectations

Walkaround · 23/06/2023 18:14

They probably mean their house is clean enough not to be a health hazard. Probably also don’t have many allergies, so don’t actually need to be obsessional. If a house doesn’t make you ill, then it’s plenty clean enough.

Vergeofbreakdown23 · 23/06/2023 18:11

My house used to be messy but clean - not it’s a messy tip and even the spiders have moved out!

ilovesushi · 23/06/2023 17:54

Depends how long the mess sits there. DD has a habit of chucking her clothes down on the bathroom floor and leaving them for days. That pile will gather dust. Simple.

ChristmasFluff · 23/06/2023 17:49

I was a cleaner for a few years, and the people I cleaned for were largely messy - in that every week there'd be mess to clear before cleaning could start. My standard 3-bed clean was 3 hours and this allowed for gradually sorting through even the most neglected areas.

So all my long-term clients would have had messy but very clean houses, thus any person with a 3-bed house who 'booked' themselves for 3 hours per week to do housework would be the same.

MereDintofPandiculation · 23/06/2023 17:41

The big fat lie is that having a clean house somehow makes you a better person. Yes!

Along with the other lie, that someone who comes into work at 8.30 and bunks off at 4.30 is more moral than someone who comes in at 10.00 and is still working at 6pm.

MereDintofPandiculation · 23/06/2023 17:38

Obviously it's possible to lift up piles of mess, clean under them and then just drop them down again. But most people don't do that. If you could be bothered to pick stuff up and clean under it, why wouldn't you then put it away/throw it away etc. Because sorting it out so you can put it away tidily rather than just ram it in a cupboard takes time. Just because you can keep stuff clean only by tidying everything away doesn't mean everyone's the same. And I know houses which are superficially tidy, with nothing on tables, work surfaces, windowsills, but if they open a drawer or cupboard, everything is rammed in anyhow.

It interests me that many things that I think of as cleaning, maybe not every day cleaning - behind furniture, taking everything out of cupboards , wiping down cupboard shelves - are now classed as "deep cleaning".

Libra24 · 23/06/2023 17:38

So loads of people have told you how it can be true and why it's not a lie
Then you're replying basically saying thats not what you meant and untidy people with no organisation are liars because it's harder to keep clean so in your view it must be dirty.

You don't sound very kind hearted. All these lazy dirty liars must really rub you up the wrong way.

Our value isn't tied to our ability to keep our space acceptable to others. Suggest you look up domestic blisters on tiktok or read how to keep house whilst drowning.
The big fat lie is that having a clean house somehow makes you a better person.

CakeBeautifulCake · 23/06/2023 17:33

My house is minimalist so it can be clean, from yesterday's cleaning, but messy from dirty laundry not yet put in for the morning wash, breakfast dishes not yet washed... My house at 8am and then at 1pm can be like chalk and cheese. It's clean because I'm regularly cleaning. But it's messy from living there with a family. So there's stuff making the mess.

Sartre · 23/06/2023 16:32

I disagree because there is a distinct difference between messy and dirty. Messy is having toys strewn around, maybe some clothes on your bedroom floor, cereal boxes left out on the side in the morning etc.

Dirty is piles of washing up, filthy worktops, brown toilet, smelly bathroom, loads of dirty laundry, dirty windows, dirty floors etc. Huge difference between the two, one is an actual health hazard and one is just annoying to be around (for some, like me).

Peppadog · 23/06/2023 16:26

mrsm43s · 23/06/2023 16:11

Obviously it's possible to lift up piles of mess, clean under them and then just drop them down again. But most people don't do that. If you could be bothered to pick stuff up and clean under it, why wouldn't you then put it away/throw it away etc.

In my experience, there's a large correlation between people who can't be bothered to put things away and tidy up after themselves and people who can't be bothered to clean.

That said, I wouldn't consider houses with toys out being played with or just generally day to day living stuff out being used as "messy" unless they weren't being tidied up at the end of the day. That's just living in a house. A house doesn't have to be a show home the whole time - it needs to be lived in. As long as it starts the day clean and tidy and ends the day clean and tidy what happens in between is just normal life!

But why does the day have to start clean and tidy and end clean and tidy?
Why does it count as acceptable mess during the day but not acceptable overnight?
I find this interesting because it is often just the biggest waste of time moving things backwards and forwards to achieve societies view of tidiness around some socially constructed view of when life must reset and restart, (night time).
I have to admit I've slowly laxed about this. 3 kids under 7 and I'm not going to keep moving things one way at night to have them moved the other in the morning, or move toys into bedrooms at night just to have them dragged down again after school the next day.
I prefer to tidy less often, and then clean, rather than tidy constantly just for it to be messed up again.

CheeseBandit · 23/06/2023 16:22

My kitchen is messy but clean. I cook a lot though so it’s super tidy and then I just undo it (I’m about to bake and make dinner for instance).

I have been in plenty of tidy houses that were dirty.
My MILs was very tidy but only surface cleaned and only the main areas, bedroom floors were never cleaned properly or very often. My feet were black staying there.
Friend only used to clean the middle section of her front room, not behind TV, furniture or under. She had laminate, it was absolutely filthy behind and under sofa.

Peppadog · 23/06/2023 16:17

I think when people say this they just mean it's clean as in the kitchen wiped down, toilets and bath cleaned regularly, clean up spillages etc, no dirty plates out. Most people don't care too much about dust. A bit of mess and dust is pretty normal.

mrsm43s · 23/06/2023 16:11

Obviously it's possible to lift up piles of mess, clean under them and then just drop them down again. But most people don't do that. If you could be bothered to pick stuff up and clean under it, why wouldn't you then put it away/throw it away etc.

In my experience, there's a large correlation between people who can't be bothered to put things away and tidy up after themselves and people who can't be bothered to clean.

That said, I wouldn't consider houses with toys out being played with or just generally day to day living stuff out being used as "messy" unless they weren't being tidied up at the end of the day. That's just living in a house. A house doesn't have to be a show home the whole time - it needs to be lived in. As long as it starts the day clean and tidy and ends the day clean and tidy what happens in between is just normal life!

LieInsAreExtinct · 23/06/2023 15:29

Hmm, always felt this conflict with my MIL - her house was FILTHY I mean kids' socks were black from her floors, dusty, cobwebby, greasy plates, sheets not changed between visits, makeup on the phone handset...but oh so tidy!
I had higher standards of hygiene/clean but low compared to a lot of people, but tended to be a bit untidy, especially with young children. She was always tutting at my house, but I didn't really say much about hers!
I think there's basic cleaning, like worktops and eating tables, toilets, floors done fairly regularly, and then there's spotless, and I think you have to be quite tidy to keep it spotless. I will never achieve this, except maybe one room at a time for a few days, but I am happy. I have plenty to keep me busy!