Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not find the labels "pro-life" and "pro-choice" useful

218 replies

Middlelanehogger · 22/06/2023 19:35

My position is that over the course of a 9-month pregnancy, the "thing" inside the womb transforms gradually from a ball of cells with value 0 (on the first day of conception) to a fully-grown baby (in the minutes just before it exits the birth canal).

There are some significant milestones, for me personally somewhere around 12 weeks after the risk of miscarriage dramatically lessens, and somewhere around 24 weeks when the baby is viable, but that doesn't lessen the "gradual" development of the life inside.

I don't have an issue with the current decrim legal framework in the UK. I think it's fine. I think abortion is sad and is taking a life. I think sometimes that's justified. I think even if it's sad, I'd rather the procedure be in the light of day with medical care. I think the closer you get to the end of the pregnancy the more the life inside starts to count in ethical calculations, such that there is an almost smooth transition for the rights of a baby 1h before birth vs 1h afterwards. I think it's similar to killing puppies - it's really sad, sometimes necessary, should be regulated, shouldn't be a free-for-all...

So I don't count as pro-choice or pro-life. But I don't think my position is all that different from a lot of people's.

It really concerns me that people want to push this "pro-choice means as late as necessary for any reason and that's the only feminist position" thing. It will damage our current status quo.

Aibu?

OP posts:
Dotjones · 23/06/2023 09:21

Both "pro-choice" and "pro-life" camps adopt that terminology because it is easier to sell a positive position (pro or for something) than a negative one (anti).

It's usually easy to tell someone's position on abortion by the terminology they use for people with a different point of view. Pro-choice people are the only ones who call pro-lifers "anti-choice" or "anti-abortion" and Pro-life people are the only ones who call their opponents "anti-life" or "pro-death" or "pro-abortion".

For most of my life I've been vehemently pro-choice and I would liberalise access to abortion further - I think it should be allowed up to the point the child starts to become properly aware of its surroundings, probably 18-months to 2 years after birth. My view has always been "if you don't like abortion, don't have one" which has always seemed sensible to me.

I think we should respect other cultures though and accept that while we should have liberal abortion laws in this country other countries like the US should be allowed to disagree. Joe Biden hasn't presided over much change in his term in office so far but the tightening of restrictions on abortion has happened on his watch and will be what most people remember him for. I think it's clear America is heading on a path to more stringent abortion laws and I wouldn't be surprised if it's outlawed entirely during my lifetime.

cameoveragain · 23/06/2023 09:21

This reply has been deleted

This user is a troll so we have removed their threads and posts.

BMustard · 23/06/2023 09:14

It can also be a relief and sad at the same time

BMustard · 23/06/2023 09:12

This reply has been deleted

This user is a troll so we have removed their threads and posts.

Abortion services use counsellors precisely because not everyone finds it easy. In no way does that undermine anyone's rights to choose

cameoveragain · 23/06/2023 09:08

This reply has been deleted

This user is a troll so we have removed their threads and posts.

Appleofmyeye2023 · 23/06/2023 08:58

Bill Clinton once used phrase “ abortion should be safe, legal and rare”
irrespctive of the man himself, I think this is what most pro choice people want.
but, he was saying it for USA and global needs
we need to ensure access to abortion is safe and legal globally, an d proliferation are stopping that - although in uk it is not gaining general traction
but we also need to focus on giving people, men and women, access to contraception to ensure it’s rare. Countries with strongest anti abortion laws often have poorest access to contraception or even laws against it, or at least women and men have to always pay for it privately. The burden of contraception, even in uk, falls mainly to women. Socially vasectomy is poorly supported, misinformed and avoided. Similarly too many men object to condoms. Similarly pill equivalents for men have been abandoned due to side effects that are no worse Han those women put up with for years.
abortion won’t be rare in uk until men also take more burden for preventing unwanted pregnancy

i am happy with limitations as they are, but out of point of principle it needs to be de- criminalised in uk. The law is way out of date, and is still written to trump right of women by the state.

FourTeaFallOut · 23/06/2023 08:54

I think the time-frames around abortion are about right in the uk.

The difficulty with holding a middle ground though is that it's difficult to dress it up as a slogan.

Taking on an extreme position, that all embryos and foetuses are sacred or that all foetuses, regardless of how late the term, are expendable are very simple and easily conveyable messages that you can turn into a placard or a meme with ease.

Occupying the middle ground, pitted with caveats and compromise, doesn't effectively satisfy the terms of current politics. 'Yes but' is boring, clunky, time consuming, detail orientated. How people in the middle keep the Overton window in a central position between these satisfying polarized extremes like trying to balance a ruler on the tip of your finger.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 23/06/2023 08:36

I don’t think the labels are useful and never have. I don’t think “pro life” is useful in particular as they should be called “anti choice” or at best “pro birth” - they don’t carry about the baby once it’s born, or it’s “life”.

I am pro choice but I think it’s important to acknowledge termination will often (usually?) be traumatic for a woman as it goes against all our instincts as a mammal to end a pregnancy.

Bunbuns3 · 23/06/2023 08:36

I think the pro lifers loose their argument, when they want women with etopic pregnancies not to be treated and severe handicap pregnancies to be left even though it endangers the woman's life etc.
The pro choice camp also loose their argument when they insist a foetus is not a baby until it is born up to any gestation.
As I said both camps do themselves no favours with their ridiculous non common sense views.

nothingcomestonothing · 23/06/2023 08:33

Bunbuns3 · 23/06/2023 07:47

I agree with you.
I have always said there should be a third camp "pro common sense" I actually think most people would be in this camp. Both pro life and pro choice have equally abhorrent views and I don't agree with either of them.

Unless you think abortion should be 100% banned, you're pro choice. You can tell yourself otherwise if you like, but what you are calling 'pro common sense' is pro choice.

Anti choicers are trying (and apparently to some extent succeeding) to move the Overton window on abortion. Pro choice just means you think abortion should be legal in some circumstances - where you draw the line is up to you but if you believe any abortion should be allowed, you're pro choice. So you're pro choice.

Framing it as 'both are equally abhorrent ' is playing into the hands of people who don't want abortion to be legal in any circumstances, including for pregnant 10 years olds, foetuses with awful abnormalities who would suffer horribly if born, women who will be killed by the birth etc etc. These people are not pro life.

ZenNudist · 23/06/2023 08:21

I agree with a lot of what you say. Its very sensible. I still think the euphemisms pro life and pro choice apply and you are pro choice. But like you I'm in the middle. Most people are.

I think that once the foetus is viable then the situation is complicated and abortion is akin to murder. Most women won't have late term abortions only in awful circumstances where the life led by the baby would have been awful with insurmountable handicaps. Even then some people wouldnt abort.

HRTQueen · 23/06/2023 08:17

If you believe that women should have full autonomy over their own body it is that black and white

there are no grey areas

its just makes it more comfortable to put conditions around women

cameoveragain · 23/06/2023 08:14

This reply has been deleted

This user is a troll so we have removed their threads and posts.

DisquietintheRanks · 23/06/2023 08:13

TheEverdelightfulsamantha · 23/06/2023 08:07

You don’t have to be either - it’s not a rule! Also 12 weeks isn’t a magical date where you become less likely to miscarry as and individual - miscarriage becomes exponentially less likely through the pregnancy- it’s not binary

That's not entirely true, a whole range of genetic mutations not compatible with life cause miscarriage/silent miscarriage before 12 weeks. 12 weeks is also coming to the end of the time where its safe to terminate at home, by 14 weeks options tend to be surgical or going through labour.

WhatNoRaisins · 23/06/2023 08:10

In an ideal world we'd think of it as a spectrum with the most extreme no abortion even in life threating circumstances on one end and abortion on demand up to term on the other. With plenty of positions in between.

Never going to happen, it's been a culture war for too long now.

NoSquirrels · 23/06/2023 08:08

It really concerns me that people want to push this "pro-choice means as late as necessary for any reason and that's the only feminist position" thing.
—-
I don't like the trend of everyone talking about abortion as either blanket "a boring medical procedure" or "genocide", or aggressively weighting either the ball of cells or the mother's total free choice way too much.
—-

I’m* *going to guess that I’m older than you, and I just feel it twas ever thus.

Your thread title is misleading - what term would you use if not ‘pro-choice’? You are pro women having a choice (within an agreed legal framework on timescales etc) to terminate a pregnancy if they wish to.

TheEverdelightfulsamantha · 23/06/2023 08:07

You don’t have to be either - it’s not a rule! Also 12 weeks isn’t a magical date where you become less likely to miscarry as and individual - miscarriage becomes exponentially less likely through the pregnancy- it’s not binary

Quiverer · 23/06/2023 08:06

It is "pro life" that is the real misnomer. It should be something like "pro forced birth".

AuntieJune · 23/06/2023 08:06

You can't ban abortion, it's always happened and always will. You can only ban legal and safe abortion. So the 'pro life' people would be making a return to women maimed and killed by backstreet abortionists.

I also don't believe that most people who think they're 'pro life' wouldn't change their minds if a loved one needed one - a 13 year old say, or pregnancy after rape, or where the baby wouldn't live more than a few hours, or where the mother would die if the pregnancy proceeds.

My mother was anti abortion but said she'd support us if we ever wanted one. To me, that's hypocritical. If you think people should be criminalized and imprisoned for abortion, that should apply to your own daughters too

AuntieJune · 23/06/2023 08:02

This reply has been deleted

This user is a troll so we have removed their threads and posts.

The thing is, what if science made it possible to support babies born earlier and earlier - from 12 weeks, say. Should the abortion limit be brought back to then and there?

poetryandwine · 23/06/2023 07:50

OP,

I lived in America for a while and you have essentially reflected the reasoning used by the Supreme Court when it (briefly) established a limited national right to abortion in Roe v Wade.

I think it is a thoughtful, nuanced position and I largely agree with you. I support choice but I liked President Clinton’s motto that the ideal would be that abortion should be ‘safe, legal and rare’, reflecting the inherent loss.

Of course good access to contraception is crucial and that can be complicated.

Duckinghel · 23/06/2023 07:48

So @Bunbuns3 what is ‘common sense’ in this context. Your personal judgement on other people?

Bunbuns3 · 23/06/2023 07:47

I agree with you.
I have always said there should be a third camp "pro common sense" I actually think most people would be in this camp. Both pro life and pro choice have equally abhorrent views and I don't agree with either of them.

Spendonsend · 23/06/2023 07:47

Pro choice works for me

Pro forced birth doesnt sit right with me. It works for first trimester and unwanted pregnancies but not so much for after the anomoly scan, plus a delay to access medical care. As my understanding is its quite a big procedure and some women even give birth at that point.

Pro life doesnt work for me as women seem to end up dead in pro life countries.

Nordicrain · 23/06/2023 07:43

"pro-life" shoul;dn't be used. It should be anti-abortion. The pro-life movement gives zero shits for what happens to that baby, or the life it will have, after it's been born. It also does not care in the slightest about the life of the pregnant woman (as we see in extreme legal frameworks where abortion is still not allowed even if the woman's life is in danger).

So call yourself whatever you want, but please do not buy into the terminology of "pro-life" as though they are doing something noble protecting all those lives from those who are, by implication of the that terminology used, anti-life.

Swipe left for the next trending thread