Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not find the labels "pro-life" and "pro-choice" useful

218 replies

Middlelanehogger · 22/06/2023 19:35

My position is that over the course of a 9-month pregnancy, the "thing" inside the womb transforms gradually from a ball of cells with value 0 (on the first day of conception) to a fully-grown baby (in the minutes just before it exits the birth canal).

There are some significant milestones, for me personally somewhere around 12 weeks after the risk of miscarriage dramatically lessens, and somewhere around 24 weeks when the baby is viable, but that doesn't lessen the "gradual" development of the life inside.

I don't have an issue with the current decrim legal framework in the UK. I think it's fine. I think abortion is sad and is taking a life. I think sometimes that's justified. I think even if it's sad, I'd rather the procedure be in the light of day with medical care. I think the closer you get to the end of the pregnancy the more the life inside starts to count in ethical calculations, such that there is an almost smooth transition for the rights of a baby 1h before birth vs 1h afterwards. I think it's similar to killing puppies - it's really sad, sometimes necessary, should be regulated, shouldn't be a free-for-all...

So I don't count as pro-choice or pro-life. But I don't think my position is all that different from a lot of people's.

It really concerns me that people want to push this "pro-choice means as late as necessary for any reason and that's the only feminist position" thing. It will damage our current status quo.

Aibu?

OP posts:
Middlelanehogger · 23/06/2023 11:23

Which side @Rainbowsandbutterflies1990

OP posts:
Rainbowsandbutterflies1990 · 23/06/2023 11:22

Noorandapples · 23/06/2023 11:19

This is a very refreshing post op. Big things like this have so many grey areas and I hate how many people insist on either one extreme or the other, even to the point of telling other people what they think. Ie you think women are just incubators or you think child murder is acceptable. It's like rational discussion and respect for other's opinions goes out of the window.

Only one side is telling what others should think.

Rainbowsandbutterflies1990 · 23/06/2023 11:19

Bumpitybumper · 23/06/2023 11:05

Do you think everyone should hold the view that murder is wrong? Rape? Genocide? If so, do you accept you're an extremist?

I think anyone with common sense and just human decency holds the view murder, rape and genocide is wrong. It's not about whether we should or not.

Noorandapples · 23/06/2023 11:19

This is a very refreshing post op. Big things like this have so many grey areas and I hate how many people insist on either one extreme or the other, even to the point of telling other people what they think. Ie you think women are just incubators or you think child murder is acceptable. It's like rational discussion and respect for other's opinions goes out of the window.

Rainbowsandbutterflies1990 · 23/06/2023 11:14

Bumpitybumper · 23/06/2023 11:02

Doesn't the compassion and understanding have to work both ways. If I am to be compassionate to someone who believes abortion is evil etc then that person should be compassionate to me when I say that I don't believe that. People are allowed to believe what they like they don't have to right to force that belief on to others.
I know this wasn't directed at me but just wanted to add I would say someone who is pro life is an extremist , crazy is debatable thou

Of course compassion and understanding needs to work both ways. Prolifers need to understand that people that are pro choice also have genuinely held strong opinions that underpin their beliefs on the issue. Most people are ultimately trying to do the 'best thing' often in very difficult circumstances.

As a pro choice advocate of course it is easy to say that people can believe what they want but shouldn't force it on others. That is the belief that underpins the whole idea of choice. There are plenty of areas in our lives though where we as a society aren't pro choice because we think that certain things should be banned. People that are prolife think abortion fits into this category alongside other things that there is more of a general consensus on.

They might think that doesn't mean it's actually a fact thou. That's just their way to justify it.

nothingcomestonothing · 23/06/2023 11:13

Bumpitybumper · 23/06/2023 11:05

Do you think everyone should hold the view that murder is wrong? Rape? Genocide? If so, do you accept you're an extremist?

Murder is an interesting one, because most of us (I think) believe murder is wrong. But if someone is going to kill me, and I have the means to stop them by killing them, I am allowed to do that in law. Is that murder? They're just as dead.

But murder is a different question, because as a society (almost?) all of us agree that it's not okay. Whereas with abortion, there are lots of differing opinions about whether it's okay, and if it is under what circumstances and in what time frames. So with murder we have a good consensus going, with abortion we don't have that.

Bumpitybumper · 23/06/2023 11:05

Rainbowsandbutterflies1990 · 23/06/2023 11:02

I would say anyone who has the opnion that their view needs to he held by others is extreme, I can hold opnions about anything I don't belive my opnion is the right and only one or that others should also do what I think or belive. Like religion. I could be religious (I'm not) but I would be extreme if I forced that religion onto others, weather they ageed or not. That's definition of extreme to me. Which is why I think pro life is extremist.

Do you think everyone should hold the view that murder is wrong? Rape? Genocide? If so, do you accept you're an extremist?

user9630721458 · 23/06/2023 11:04

@cameoveragain It was a pretty shocking statement that jumped out at me. I don't know what people on the extreme end of pro-choice think, but I have heard some very extreme views. You are using the usual dehumanising language in calling the foetus an invader and making references to 'hosts.' I support abortion within UK limits, but I wonder about people who refer to the foetus with distaste and detachment, claiming any time any reason is valid.

Rainbowsandbutterflies1990 · 23/06/2023 11:03

Just wanted to add aware it wasn't directed at me , but still think it's valid comment

Rainbowsandbutterflies1990 · 23/06/2023 11:02

Bumpitybumper · 23/06/2023 10:48

I did read your post. My point is that a lot of prolifers hold this view for religious reasons and wouldn't define it as an extreme view at all. To them the concept that anyone can murder a defenceless and innocent child of God is extreme.

I fundamentally disagree with your assertion that all absolutes are considered 'extreme'. We have loads of absolutes in society that aren't considered extreme at all. For example, we don't have the death sentence in this country even in relation to the most heinous and awful crimes. By your definition this is an 'extreme' as it is an absolute but most people that are anti the death penalty wouldn't accept that it's an extreme. We also aren't allowed to murder each other or rape each other.

The issue with abortion is that prolife and prochoice advocates often see the whole issue so completely and fundamentally differently that it's hard to empathise with the other side. If you see a fetus and think 'a bunch of cells' then it's much much easier to take a 'non extreme' position than if you see the fetus and see a defenceless baby.

I would say anyone who has the opnion that their view needs to he held by others is extreme, I can hold opnions about anything I don't belive my opnion is the right and only one or that others should also do what I think or belive. Like religion. I could be religious (I'm not) but I would be extreme if I forced that religion onto others, weather they ageed or not. That's definition of extreme to me. Which is why I think pro life is extremist.

Bumpitybumper · 23/06/2023 11:02

Doesn't the compassion and understanding have to work both ways. If I am to be compassionate to someone who believes abortion is evil etc then that person should be compassionate to me when I say that I don't believe that. People are allowed to believe what they like they don't have to right to force that belief on to others.
I know this wasn't directed at me but just wanted to add I would say someone who is pro life is an extremist , crazy is debatable thou

Of course compassion and understanding needs to work both ways. Prolifers need to understand that people that are pro choice also have genuinely held strong opinions that underpin their beliefs on the issue. Most people are ultimately trying to do the 'best thing' often in very difficult circumstances.

As a pro choice advocate of course it is easy to say that people can believe what they want but shouldn't force it on others. That is the belief that underpins the whole idea of choice. There are plenty of areas in our lives though where we as a society aren't pro choice because we think that certain things should be banned. People that are prolife think abortion fits into this category alongside other things that there is more of a general consensus on.

cameoveragain · 23/06/2023 10:55

This reply has been deleted

This user is a troll so we have removed their threads and posts.

user9630721458 · 23/06/2023 10:52

For most of my life I've been vehemently pro-choice and I would liberalise access to abortion further - I think it should be allowed up to the point the child starts to become properly aware of its surroundings, probably 18-months to 2 years after birth.

@Dotjones Are you saying you would be OK with people killing 2 year olds?

Bumpitybumper · 23/06/2023 10:48

nothingcomestonothing · 23/06/2023 10:32

Did you even read what I wrote? I didn't call anyone a crazy extremist, I said that saying 'oh there are crazy extremists on both sides putting me off, my views are the sensible middle ground' obfuscates that the pro life position is, of necessity, an extreme one.

There is only one pro life position, which is no abortion in any circumstances ever. That's it. That is an extreme position. Whatever the reasons someone has for holding that position, it is extreme, all absolutes are by their nature extreme.

I did read your post. My point is that a lot of prolifers hold this view for religious reasons and wouldn't define it as an extreme view at all. To them the concept that anyone can murder a defenceless and innocent child of God is extreme.

I fundamentally disagree with your assertion that all absolutes are considered 'extreme'. We have loads of absolutes in society that aren't considered extreme at all. For example, we don't have the death sentence in this country even in relation to the most heinous and awful crimes. By your definition this is an 'extreme' as it is an absolute but most people that are anti the death penalty wouldn't accept that it's an extreme. We also aren't allowed to murder each other or rape each other.

The issue with abortion is that prolife and prochoice advocates often see the whole issue so completely and fundamentally differently that it's hard to empathise with the other side. If you see a fetus and think 'a bunch of cells' then it's much much easier to take a 'non extreme' position than if you see the fetus and see a defenceless baby.

Rainbowsandbutterflies1990 · 23/06/2023 10:35

Bumpitybumper · 23/06/2023 10:22

Many religions have a fundamental belief that life starts at conception. Are you calling anyone that follows these religions 'crazy extremists'? I think this calls into question fundamental values in our society such as tolerance and religious freedoms.

Whilst I am personally a pro choice atheist, I think it's important that we show compassion and understanding to those who have genuinely held opposing beliefs. A Christian may strongly believe that an abortion kills a child of God and a soul irrespective of the stage of gestation. You can't expect someone with this belief to be pro choice or to readily accept women having abortions. To them it is equivalent to condoning the murder of babies and I don't think any of us on this thread would accept the murder of babies even if society's consensus was that it's ok.

Doesn't the compassion and understanding have to work both ways. If I am to be compassionate to someone who belives abortion is evil etc then that person should be compassionate to me when I say that I don't belive that. People are allowed to belive what they like they don't have to right to force that belief on to others.
I know this wasnt directed at me but just wanted to add I would say someone who is pro life is an extremist , crazy is debatable thou

therescoffeeinthatnebula · 23/06/2023 10:33

Bumpitybumper · 23/06/2023 10:22

Many religions have a fundamental belief that life starts at conception. Are you calling anyone that follows these religions 'crazy extremists'? I think this calls into question fundamental values in our society such as tolerance and religious freedoms.

Whilst I am personally a pro choice atheist, I think it's important that we show compassion and understanding to those who have genuinely held opposing beliefs. A Christian may strongly believe that an abortion kills a child of God and a soul irrespective of the stage of gestation. You can't expect someone with this belief to be pro choice or to readily accept women having abortions. To them it is equivalent to condoning the murder of babies and I don't think any of us on this thread would accept the murder of babies even if society's consensus was that it's ok.

I think abortion is where the UK’s belief women should have safe access for any reason should come first. In the same way that France’s belief wearing religious symbols in schools is wrong comes before any religion’s wish to do so.

Of course, this would require the UK having such a belief… but I live in fear we’ll follow America and in hope that we won’t.

I’m obviously not pro killing babies, but I am anti women being the only ones to suffer the consequences of sex, especially where that sex is not entirely consensual. Most anti-abortion rules (including in some US states) permit abortion due to rape, but there are many more scenarios where sex doesn’t meet the definition of rape, but it’s pretty damn murky.

I also don’t see why a woman should have to admit to any of that to get an abortion. It’s like the punishment continues. If a woman doesn’t want to continue with a pregnancy, why not accept that at face value?

nothingcomestonothing · 23/06/2023 10:32

Bumpitybumper · 23/06/2023 10:22

Many religions have a fundamental belief that life starts at conception. Are you calling anyone that follows these religions 'crazy extremists'? I think this calls into question fundamental values in our society such as tolerance and religious freedoms.

Whilst I am personally a pro choice atheist, I think it's important that we show compassion and understanding to those who have genuinely held opposing beliefs. A Christian may strongly believe that an abortion kills a child of God and a soul irrespective of the stage of gestation. You can't expect someone with this belief to be pro choice or to readily accept women having abortions. To them it is equivalent to condoning the murder of babies and I don't think any of us on this thread would accept the murder of babies even if society's consensus was that it's ok.

Did you even read what I wrote? I didn't call anyone a crazy extremist, I said that saying 'oh there are crazy extremists on both sides putting me off, my views are the sensible middle ground' obfuscates that the pro life position is, of necessity, an extreme one.

There is only one pro life position, which is no abortion in any circumstances ever. That's it. That is an extreme position. Whatever the reasons someone has for holding that position, it is extreme, all absolutes are by their nature extreme.

Bumpitybumper · 23/06/2023 10:22

nothingcomestonothing · 23/06/2023 09:31

Pro life is no abortion for anyone in any circumstances ever. That's it, blanket ban. Any other position is pro choice.

Saying 'oh there are crazy extremists on both sides putting me off' is a false equivalence - there are some pro choice advocates who are extreme, but all pro life advocates are extreme.

Many religions have a fundamental belief that life starts at conception. Are you calling anyone that follows these religions 'crazy extremists'? I think this calls into question fundamental values in our society such as tolerance and religious freedoms.

Whilst I am personally a pro choice atheist, I think it's important that we show compassion and understanding to those who have genuinely held opposing beliefs. A Christian may strongly believe that an abortion kills a child of God and a soul irrespective of the stage of gestation. You can't expect someone with this belief to be pro choice or to readily accept women having abortions. To them it is equivalent to condoning the murder of babies and I don't think any of us on this thread would accept the murder of babies even if society's consensus was that it's ok.

therescoffeeinthatnebula · 23/06/2023 10:13

yadeciN · 23/06/2023 07:04

better access to contraception

Uk has great access to contraception and for free though.

As an older woman, I can’t access any of the contraceptive options I had when I was young. I’m basically limited to condoms now, which is the least foolproof option (partly because you’re delegating the responsibility to a man and partly because it doesn’t protect you from more spontaneous situations).

I’ve given up on a relationship but I can fully understand how a woman in her 40s could become accidentally pregnant and panic.

Contraception is easiest to obtain when you’re under 25.

Rainbowsandbutterflies1990 · 23/06/2023 10:01

Really shouldn't everyone be pro choice , u can be very anti abortion and would never have one. But that's separate from thinking urself as not having one and deciding you have the right to decide for other women. If the opposite argument was saying everyone should be made to get an abortion then that's a level playing field. But it's obviously not.

WeWereInParis · 23/06/2023 09:54

Middlelanehogger · 22/06/2023 19:50

I'm not pro choice though - I don't think women's choices should apply much later

Very few pro choice people don't have some sort of cut off in their head where they think abortion shouldn't be carried out though. I don't think you have to be fine with abortion up to 40 weeks in order to be pro choice.

Rainbowsandbutterflies1990 · 23/06/2023 09:54

What I find frustrating and just gets me angry is the pro life, it is just force life not pro life. The idea that if u don't agree with abortion, u need to force your choice onto other woman. Pro choice isn't force abortion on women than don't want it. Everyone SHOULD have a every right to decide what they personally wants. Noone should force their choice onto others.
This never seems to be spoken about. There should be a acknowledgement that if u r "pro life" , your also "forced life". And u r forcing your choice to others.

nothingcomestonothing · 23/06/2023 09:31

Bunbuns3 · 23/06/2023 08:36

I think the pro lifers loose their argument, when they want women with etopic pregnancies not to be treated and severe handicap pregnancies to be left even though it endangers the woman's life etc.
The pro choice camp also loose their argument when they insist a foetus is not a baby until it is born up to any gestation.
As I said both camps do themselves no favours with their ridiculous non common sense views.

Pro life is no abortion for anyone in any circumstances ever. That's it, blanket ban. Any other position is pro choice.

Saying 'oh there are crazy extremists on both sides putting me off' is a false equivalence - there are some pro choice advocates who are extreme, but all pro life advocates are extreme.

Bromptotoo · 23/06/2023 09:28

Until somebody comes up with a better term pro choice seems OK for those of us supporting the UK type position where abortion is easy to obtain in the early stages but much more restricted later on. The point at which a pregnancy moves from the one to the other is a matter for debate informed by scientific advice on foetal viability etc.

GreatBigBoots · 23/06/2023 09:25

The extremists on both sides of the argument use the terms 'pro choice' and 'pro life' because as a stand alone, out of context, statement no sensible person would disagree with either of them.

I would class myself as pro-choice but I think that even when abortion is safe and legal many women don't have a true choice over whether to have a child. There are societal pressures and pressure from partners to have/not have a child. Plus lack of affordable child care for women who choose to have baby and little to stop the father from leaving and/or failing to support the child financially. In many countries the cost of medical care relating to pregnancy and birth is also a consideration. Not to mention the impact of being a mother on the careers of many women for reasons that could fill several threads. So I think being pro-choice actually is about far more than whether abortion is legal.

Equally I think that to be truly pro-life (not just anti-abortion) campaigners etc would need to be fighting for decent and affordable medical care for the child and mother, post-natal support, affordable childcare, good quality education, housing etc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread