Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not find the labels "pro-life" and "pro-choice" useful

218 replies

Middlelanehogger · 22/06/2023 19:35

My position is that over the course of a 9-month pregnancy, the "thing" inside the womb transforms gradually from a ball of cells with value 0 (on the first day of conception) to a fully-grown baby (in the minutes just before it exits the birth canal).

There are some significant milestones, for me personally somewhere around 12 weeks after the risk of miscarriage dramatically lessens, and somewhere around 24 weeks when the baby is viable, but that doesn't lessen the "gradual" development of the life inside.

I don't have an issue with the current decrim legal framework in the UK. I think it's fine. I think abortion is sad and is taking a life. I think sometimes that's justified. I think even if it's sad, I'd rather the procedure be in the light of day with medical care. I think the closer you get to the end of the pregnancy the more the life inside starts to count in ethical calculations, such that there is an almost smooth transition for the rights of a baby 1h before birth vs 1h afterwards. I think it's similar to killing puppies - it's really sad, sometimes necessary, should be regulated, shouldn't be a free-for-all...

So I don't count as pro-choice or pro-life. But I don't think my position is all that different from a lot of people's.

It really concerns me that people want to push this "pro-choice means as late as necessary for any reason and that's the only feminist position" thing. It will damage our current status quo.

Aibu?

OP posts:
FoodCentre · 23/06/2023 19:26

This reply has been deleted

This user is a troll so we have removed their threads and posts.

Most people think 23 weeks if horrendous but we accept this as the limit as few people do it (99% medical reasons).

There is no need to increase it any further. 23 weeks is hard enough to swallow. We have free contraception and abortion for 6 months.

Isitpaydayyet · 23/06/2023 19:25

@camieandatop who is forcing the woman?

camieandatop · 23/06/2023 19:23

This reply has been deleted

This user is a troll so we have removed their threads and posts.

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/06/2023 19:22

Isitpaydayyet · 23/06/2023 19:09

@SouthLondonMum22 you are assuming it would be rare. As we are well know people push boundaries if they can. Rules and regulations are in place for a reason.

You are being unreasonable infact I'm going to be blunt you are being selfish. Why exactly would anybody terminate at 8 months pregnant? For what reason?

Your coming across as entitled. Where is the mother's accountability factor here??

Are you willinging to listen to my opinion as I have listened to yours and try gain an understanding or was that you jumping the gun because YOU don't want to take my view point on board?

Medical conditions or rape is a valid reason.

Terminating a baby at 8 months pregnant because you couldn't be arsed to have an abortion is IDOL bone IDOL. Hope I've made myself clear!

The current law is 24 weeks. 90% of abortions happen during the first 12 weeks. Where are all these women running out getting abortions at 23 weeks just because they can?

So it is about punishing the woman? That isn't about the foetus at all then, is it?

If it was about the foetus, how they were conceived would be irrelevant.

Isitpaydayyet · 23/06/2023 19:16

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/06/2023 18:56

There does have to be a line drawn somewhere, for me that is as long as a woman is pregnant. It doesn't have to be a free for all but it can be decriminalised and be between a woman and her doctor. It would be incredibly rare.

Also, surely a baby is a baby? If you believe abortion is wrong after 24 weeks, why does it matter how the pregnancy happened regarding rape? Makes no sense to me unless the idea is to punish women for having consensual sex.

If you can't comprehend the difference between women being allowed to have an abortion at 24 weeksor under and 8 months pregnant..

You are the reason why rules need to be put in place. You clearly lack a lot of understanding to the point it's dangerous. I'm astonished I'm having to point out to you that it's unacceptable to want to abort a full term baby almost when the women had the CHOICE to do it sooner.

birdsongismyfave · 23/06/2023 19:09

The US pro life lobby is not pro life, speaking as someone who would call myself pro life. If you are pro life, then you must rationally support the abolition of capital punishment, be pro BLM, support gun restrictions and anything else to make children safer in schools, pro maternity leave and other employment rights to help families look after these children and bring them up out of poverty once they're born, pro universal health care, supportive of refugees...
Oh wait, it seems they are only pro unborn life. It's like it's about control of women, children, poor people, minorities.:.

Isitpaydayyet · 23/06/2023 19:09

@SouthLondonMum22 you are assuming it would be rare. As we are well know people push boundaries if they can. Rules and regulations are in place for a reason.

You are being unreasonable infact I'm going to be blunt you are being selfish. Why exactly would anybody terminate at 8 months pregnant? For what reason?

Your coming across as entitled. Where is the mother's accountability factor here??

Are you willinging to listen to my opinion as I have listened to yours and try gain an understanding or was that you jumping the gun because YOU don't want to take my view point on board?

Medical conditions or rape is a valid reason.

Terminating a baby at 8 months pregnant because you couldn't be arsed to have an abortion is IDOL bone IDOL. Hope I've made myself clear!

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/06/2023 18:56

Isitpaydayyet · 23/06/2023 18:11

@SouthLondonMum22 can you please elaborate on why you feel abortion should be allowed past 6 months? (Medical issues and tragic things like rape aside).

There are rules and protocols to follow in life like anything the line has to be drawn some where it can't just be free for all. These things have to be manged how can you not see that?

There does have to be a line drawn somewhere, for me that is as long as a woman is pregnant. It doesn't have to be a free for all but it can be decriminalised and be between a woman and her doctor. It would be incredibly rare.

Also, surely a baby is a baby? If you believe abortion is wrong after 24 weeks, why does it matter how the pregnancy happened regarding rape? Makes no sense to me unless the idea is to punish women for having consensual sex.

Isitpaydayyet · 23/06/2023 18:11

@SouthLondonMum22 can you please elaborate on why you feel abortion should be allowed past 6 months? (Medical issues and tragic things like rape aside).

There are rules and protocols to follow in life like anything the line has to be drawn some where it can't just be free for all. These things have to be manged how can you not see that?

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/06/2023 17:52

Isitpaydayyet · 23/06/2023 14:48

Who is actually forced though?

People are saying if you are going to CHOOSE an abortion why not decide BEFORE you get past 6 months pregnant. I don't think that is being unreasonable do you?

There are rules and protocols in life we have to follow for a reason. You can't just do whatever you want it's not how life works.

The vast majority of people do exactly that. 90% of abortions happen during the first 12 weeks of pregnancy.

The majority of people will agree that the earlier, the better but in a minority of cases it isn't always going to be possible and that's why I don't agree with a limit.

NuffSaidSam · 23/06/2023 15:50

ShippingNews · 23/06/2023 03:59

So your implication is that it's OK to kill a person who isn't healthy / who would need medical care ?

It's not ok to kill a person.

I believe this thread is about abortion/terminating a foetus.

80sMum · 23/06/2023 15:32

Autonomy is good, per se, but sometimes it's necessary to curtail it for the protection of others.

I find myself in agreement with the OP, that there comes a time where the foetus ceases to be a potential person and becomes an actual person - albeit an immature one - deserving of protection.

The point at which a foetus becomes viable outside the uterus would seem a sensible place to draw a line, then subtract a few weeks just to be sure.

The youngest live birth that I recall reading about, that survived, was 22 weeks gestation. So, taking that as a viability measure, if I were the law maker I would say that it should be unlawful to deliberately end the life of a foetus of more than 18 weeks gestation.

Bumpitybumper · 23/06/2023 15:10

Superdupes · 23/06/2023 14:24

Yes I think they are extremists and I think it is morally very, very wrong to not allow a person in constant pain with an incurable illness to be euthanised. You can choose not to be euthanised yourself - but you should not be making that choice for others whose shoes you have not walked in.

But lets face it, at the heart of both issues are the religious right, in the US they are huge - here IMO they are underestimated. The church has a lot to answer for in both issues IMO. We know that the majority of people in the UK think doctor assisted suicide should be legal so why isn't it? MP's are supposed to represent their constituents, unfortunately all they care about are their own interests.

https://yougov.co.uk/topics/health/articles-reports/2021/08/04/three-quarters-britons-support-doctor-assisted-sui

39% of doctors oppose changing the law when it comes to euthanasia. Some of this may well be due to religious beliefs but I think there is more to it than that. I find it hard to believe that all of these doctors are extremists.

As I mentioned, I like the vast majority of the population support euthanasia for many of the reasons you suggest but I also think it's wrong to accuse anyone that doesn't support it of being an extremist. There is nuance and genuine concerns about how it would work in practice and affect some of the most vulnerable people in society.

Isitpaydayyet · 23/06/2023 14:48

StarchySturgess1 · 23/06/2023 12:05

I am pro whichever choice the pregnant woman wants to make. Abortion should be an option for any woman, at any time, for any reason. It's not my business to put caveats on that.

I am anti forced birth.

Who is actually forced though?

People are saying if you are going to CHOOSE an abortion why not decide BEFORE you get past 6 months pregnant. I don't think that is being unreasonable do you?

There are rules and protocols in life we have to follow for a reason. You can't just do whatever you want it's not how life works.

nothingcomestonothing · 23/06/2023 14:27

Middlelanehogger · 23/06/2023 13:10

@nothingcomestonothing I don't understand how someone can be 'pro life' if they are okay with me being required to continue with a pregnancy that will kill me.

I think that's the thing though - a very common "moderate pro-life position" is more or less that abortion shouldn't be available as a "choice", but that it should be available in certain cases only (e.g. if mother's health is in danger, or severe foetal abnormalities, etc). Not that it shouldn't be available at all.

If you're going to use examples like this, it's the equivalent of saying "pro-choicers want babies to be aborted at 36wks so mum can go on holiday".

Most people lean in a direction but aren't at the extremes.

I genuinely have never seen a 'pro life' person say that they support abortion in some circumstances. It is always no abortion at all. There is no 'moderate pro life position', what you're describing is a restrictive pro choice position. Where are you seeing campaigners or groups who describe themselves as pro life advocating for abortion in some circumstances?

Superdupes · 23/06/2023 14:24

Bumpitybumper · 23/06/2023 11:31

Yes, I agree that there is much broader consensus on murder etc than there is abortion, but I think this is the reason why we need to be careful about labelling those with different views to ourselves as 'extremists'.

I think the best comparison I can make is possible with euthanasia. Personally I think euthanasia should be allowed provided the right checks and measures are put in place. There is a significant proportion of society that don't agree. Are they extremists because they believe in an absolute that euthanasia shouldn't be allowed? They are imposing their beliefs on me and taking away my choice and we seem capable as a society of understanding that the situation is nuanced and most people are coming from a good place with their beliefs. For some reason we just don't seem to be able to do this with abortion.

Yes I think they are extremists and I think it is morally very, very wrong to not allow a person in constant pain with an incurable illness to be euthanised. You can choose not to be euthanised yourself - but you should not be making that choice for others whose shoes you have not walked in.

But lets face it, at the heart of both issues are the religious right, in the US they are huge - here IMO they are underestimated. The church has a lot to answer for in both issues IMO. We know that the majority of people in the UK think doctor assisted suicide should be legal so why isn't it? MP's are supposed to represent their constituents, unfortunately all they care about are their own interests.

https://yougov.co.uk/topics/health/articles-reports/2021/08/04/three-quarters-britons-support-doctor-assisted-sui

WhatNoRaisins · 23/06/2023 13:42

The binary approach to debating abortion has been around for decades and it doesn't feel like it's achieving anything. It's a shame there isn't more of a nuanced way to discuss it because it's just the same old argument. The law in the UK feels old fashioned and in need of an update but it would be a pointless culture war debating how to chang it.

I'm not a fan of the pro-life position but think I'd be open to talking about how they imagine such a stance would actually work, ie. would they also campaign for more investment in social services and maternity care for the women with unwanted pregnancies? How would risky behaviour during a pregnancy be regulated?

WeWereInParis · 23/06/2023 13:40

The burden of contraception, even in uk, falls mainly to women. Socially vasectomy is poorly supported, misinformed and avoided.

The NHS doesn't even fund it anymore where we live.

C8H10N4O2 · 23/06/2023 13:18

Middlelanehogger · 23/06/2023 13:10

@nothingcomestonothing I don't understand how someone can be 'pro life' if they are okay with me being required to continue with a pregnancy that will kill me.

I think that's the thing though - a very common "moderate pro-life position" is more or less that abortion shouldn't be available as a "choice", but that it should be available in certain cases only (e.g. if mother's health is in danger, or severe foetal abnormalities, etc). Not that it shouldn't be available at all.

If you're going to use examples like this, it's the equivalent of saying "pro-choicers want babies to be aborted at 36wks so mum can go on holiday".

Most people lean in a direction but aren't at the extremes.

Yes, by the same people who then want to chip away at the reasons permitted under abnormality.

Either you believe in choice or you don't. If you believe in choice but don't like the late options then I hope you are lobbying to change the law to allow abortion on request in the first trimester, better access to diagnostic scanning earlier in pregnancy etc to make sure abortions are as early as possible.

If you don't support choice then yes you are forcing a woman to give birth. Its pretty binary - you cannot prevent an abortion without forcing a woman to give birth, however you dress it up as "pro life".

C8H10N4O2 · 23/06/2023 13:15

Cottagecheeseisnotcheese · 22/06/2023 20:58

The law in UK is quite liberal compared to most other countries most of Europe has a 12-14 week deadline for abortion on request of the mother, after that it is generally only available if there is a risk to mother's life ( very rare) rape or incest or the baby has a severe disability or is unlikely to survive post birth. I do not think there is anywhere where you can get an abortion on request rather than for medical agreed reasons post 20 weeks.
I do not agree with abortions on healthy babies that would survive if born ie past 24-26 weeks

Abortion is not legal on request in the UK which makes us distinctly less liberal than European countries you describe.

It is still under criminal law with "permitted exceptions" and requiring two doctors to say that continuing with the pregnancy will impair your physical or mental health.

For well resourced MC women the difference may be negligible - they can access the right clinic/doctors, pay for whatever is needed. That is far from true for all women.

Abortion on request and genuinely accessible to all women in the first trimester reduces the demand for later abortions.

Middlelanehogger · 23/06/2023 13:10

@nothingcomestonothing I don't understand how someone can be 'pro life' if they are okay with me being required to continue with a pregnancy that will kill me.

I think that's the thing though - a very common "moderate pro-life position" is more or less that abortion shouldn't be available as a "choice", but that it should be available in certain cases only (e.g. if mother's health is in danger, or severe foetal abnormalities, etc). Not that it shouldn't be available at all.

If you're going to use examples like this, it's the equivalent of saying "pro-choicers want babies to be aborted at 36wks so mum can go on holiday".

Most people lean in a direction but aren't at the extremes.

OP posts:
Badbudgeter · 23/06/2023 12:38

I would describe myself as pro-choice. I would like to see the right to abortion on the statute books rather than as a permitted exception to abortion being illegal.

Reality is late term abortion, over 24 weeks, is pretty rare 0.1% of the total. It’s only carried out due to the foetus having severe disabilities or the mothers life being in danger. I wouldn’t have an issue with keeping restrictions on late term abortions. I think it’s a decision best left to women and their doctors.

nothingcomestonothing · 23/06/2023 12:30

FloydPepper · 23/06/2023 11:50

The terminology is interesting. Each side sets the other side up to be anti

so you, pro choice, believes the others to be against choice and clearly that makes them wrong

the pro lifers believe the other side to be anti life, and to them clearly that’s wrong.

I'll admit I am biased but I think that pro choice is a more accurate description of the pro choice position, than pro life is of the opposite view.

I don't understand how someone can be 'pro life' if they are okay with me being required to continue with a pregnancy that will kill me. Or one that is 100% going to result in the birth of a baby who cannot survive outside the womb for more than a few hours. How is that stance pro life? In the first instance I'll be dead, so my life will be lost. In the second that baby would never have lived whether an abortion occurred or it was carried to term and died at or soon after birth, so no life either way. 'Pro life' isn't actually pro life, it's more accurate to call it anti abortion or pro forced birth or anti choice than pro life.

Pro choice is accurate, it's for women choosing whether to continue a pregnancy. Whether or not you think that choice should be allowed, the naming of the position is accurate.

StarchySturgess1 · 23/06/2023 12:24

It is absolute nonsense that women don't have complete caboodle autonomy the same way men do, and the same way DEAD PEOPLE do.

Dead person who isn't an organ donor? You can't take their organs. Pregnant woman who doesn't want to be? Sure, have an abortion, but only if you jump through these complicated and specific hoops, while fitting this specific criteria.

We value lives of the unborn over the mental and physical health of actual women.

That's without even touching on the fact that the people making the laws and decisions around all of this are generally and historically men, who cannot get pregnant but are responsible for 100% of all pregnancies 😑

user9630721458 · 23/06/2023 12:15

Fortunately extreme views such as abortion to term for any reason are not taken seriously in the UK. We do recognise the situation as more nuanced and do give women both options, and personal responsibility.

Swipe left for the next trending thread