Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not find the labels "pro-life" and "pro-choice" useful

218 replies

Middlelanehogger · 22/06/2023 19:35

My position is that over the course of a 9-month pregnancy, the "thing" inside the womb transforms gradually from a ball of cells with value 0 (on the first day of conception) to a fully-grown baby (in the minutes just before it exits the birth canal).

There are some significant milestones, for me personally somewhere around 12 weeks after the risk of miscarriage dramatically lessens, and somewhere around 24 weeks when the baby is viable, but that doesn't lessen the "gradual" development of the life inside.

I don't have an issue with the current decrim legal framework in the UK. I think it's fine. I think abortion is sad and is taking a life. I think sometimes that's justified. I think even if it's sad, I'd rather the procedure be in the light of day with medical care. I think the closer you get to the end of the pregnancy the more the life inside starts to count in ethical calculations, such that there is an almost smooth transition for the rights of a baby 1h before birth vs 1h afterwards. I think it's similar to killing puppies - it's really sad, sometimes necessary, should be regulated, shouldn't be a free-for-all...

So I don't count as pro-choice or pro-life. But I don't think my position is all that different from a lot of people's.

It really concerns me that people want to push this "pro-choice means as late as necessary for any reason and that's the only feminist position" thing. It will damage our current status quo.

Aibu?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thebestwaytoscareatory · 24/06/2023 12:40

The thing I don't get about anti-abortionists is the whole "life begins at conception" stance.

If you were to take an anti-abortionist for a pizza and served them raw chicken and blocks of cheese on an uncooked pizza base they wouldn't eat it becuase its not an edible pizza at that point.

So they understand, on a conceptual level at least, that simply combining and arranging ingredients together doesn't make the finished article.

Not sure why they suddenly loose that ability when it comes to foetuses. Well I have an idea, it's because it's about control not about 'life', but until the anti-abortion brigade are honest about that we'll just keep going round in circles.

80sMum · 24/06/2023 12:37

Tryagainplease · 24/06/2023 11:49

This is also why I agree with the 24 week cut off

@NoodlePlanet , @Tryagainplease It may be very rare, but babies born before 24 weeks have survived. The baby referred to in this article was less than 22 weeks. Astonishing, but it's possible.

https://www.uab.edu/news/health/item/12427-uab-hospital-delivers-record-breaking-premature-baby

UAB Hospital delivers record-breaking premature baby

Guinness World Records officially named Curtis Means, born at 21 weeks and one day at UAB Hospital, the most premature infant to survive.

https://www.uab.edu/news/health/item/12427-uab-hospital-delivers-record-breaking-premature-baby

Tryagainplease · 24/06/2023 11:49

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

This is also why I agree with the 24 week cut off

FoodCentre · 24/06/2023 11:33

No baby has ever survived at 22 weeks. 24 weeks is the earliest on record.

It's actually 21 weeks, but it is rare to survive that early, obviously hence it being the record.

NoodlePlanet · 24/06/2023 10:44

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

StarchySturgess1 · 24/06/2023 10:31

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 24/06/2023 10:29

'Pro life' is not a neutral term. It's not the media-style-guide term. It's the term anti-abortionists use for themselves because it sounds kind and fluffy and positive.

They aren't pro life. The movement generally doesn't give 2 hoots about the mother's life, or the life of the baby after it's born, or the lifes of other children growing up in poverty or difficult circumstances, or lives cut short by illness, or taken by gun violence, or lost to climate change or war ...

Not pro life, just anti-abortion.

👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 24/06/2023 10:29

'Pro life' is not a neutral term. It's not the media-style-guide term. It's the term anti-abortionists use for themselves because it sounds kind and fluffy and positive.

They aren't pro life. The movement generally doesn't give 2 hoots about the mother's life, or the life of the baby after it's born, or the lifes of other children growing up in poverty or difficult circumstances, or lives cut short by illness, or taken by gun violence, or lost to climate change or war ...

Not pro life, just anti-abortion.

StarchySturgess1 · 24/06/2023 10:18

@Badbudgeter fantastic work, thanks for doing what I couldn't be arsed to do on not enough sleep 😂

I continue to stand by my point @Isitpaydayyet

KingOfThieves · 24/06/2023 08:58

As nicely as possible OP, no one cares about your opinion. If anyone were to ask (why would they? Who do you hang out with? ) They really aren’t looking for a debate on late term abortions and don’t care how you define your terminology- it is all subjective. We have this ridiculous thread which discusses scenarios which essentially rarely exist. Statistically speaking in 2021 for example, the majority of abortions took place in the early stages of pregnancy: 67% up to and including 7 weeks gestation; 93% up to and including 12 weeks, and 98% up to and including 17 weeks gestation. The stats for over 24 weeks are at 0.1% and are only carried out for medical reasons. How many people do you really think are seeking these out for any other reason? I am sure we could all quote a news story or a suspect mumsnet post, but realistically it is so few it is a waste of breath discussing the morality of it IMO. But enjoy your thread.

Badbudgeter · 24/06/2023 08:13

BMustard · 24/06/2023 07:59

No-one in the UK Is getting an abortion at 8 months because they couldn’t be arsed to sort it out earlier.

www.theguardian.com/world/2013/jun/12/appeal-jail-term-woman-aborted-baby-40-weeks

Jailing a mother of three - WTF www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/4826122-jailing-a-mother-of-three-wtf

It's happened and does happen, seemingly. Personally, I'd say one case like this is too many. Not only is is cruel to the fetus and hugely selfish, it gives weight to the idea that abortion really is murder - which hurts us all. It risks our rights.

If they're not doing anything wrong anyway, then however many times it happens is surely irrelevant?

No one is getting a legal abortion I suppose I should say.

I personally wouldn’t have jailed those women.

BMustard · 24/06/2023 07:59

No-one in the UK Is getting an abortion at 8 months because they couldn’t be arsed to sort it out earlier.

www.theguardian.com/world/2013/jun/12/appeal-jail-term-woman-aborted-baby-40-weeks

Jailing a mother of three - WTF www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/4826122-jailing-a-mother-of-three-wtf

It's happened and does happen, seemingly. Personally, I'd say one case like this is too many. Not only is is cruel to the fetus and hugely selfish, it gives weight to the idea that abortion really is murder - which hurts us all. It risks our rights.

If they're not doing anything wrong anyway, then however many times it happens is surely irrelevant?

Badbudgeter · 24/06/2023 06:32

StarchySturgess1 · 24/06/2023 05:36

Terminating a baby at 8 months pregnant because you couldn't be arsed to have an abortion is IDOL bone IDOL. Hope I've made myself clear!

Well, no. Partly because it's "idle". And partly because you just said "having an abortion because you couldn't be bothered to have an abortion", which is nonsense.

I'd also like to see statistics on how often this actually occurs, because I'll bet my favourite Oxford dictionary that it isn't ten a penny.

Statistics define late abortions as over 24 weeks. In 2021 there were 276 (about 0.1%) late term abortion in the UK. These were carried out because the Foetus was severely disabled due to deformation or chromosome abnormalities. Or the woman’s life was at severe risk. No-one in the UK Is getting an abortion at 8 months because they couldn’t be arsed to sort it out earlier.

StarchySturgess1 · 24/06/2023 05:36

Terminating a baby at 8 months pregnant because you couldn't be arsed to have an abortion is IDOL bone IDOL. Hope I've made myself clear!

Well, no. Partly because it's "idle". And partly because you just said "having an abortion because you couldn't be bothered to have an abortion", which is nonsense.

I'd also like to see statistics on how often this actually occurs, because I'll bet my favourite Oxford dictionary that it isn't ten a penny.

AnotherDayOfSun · 24/06/2023 00:20

Of course, both sides are trying to win hearts and minds, to a cause that they believe is morally right.

I mean, "life" is such a beautiful word! And "choice" - who doesn't want choices? And throw the word "woman" in, too, assuming that many women will support anything with the word "woman" in it.

That's why you have to be careful with what you read and hear, thinking critically, as well as listening to your heart and conscience.

RobertaFirmino · 23/06/2023 23:45

Terminating a baby at 8 months pregnant because you couldn't be arsed to have an abortion is IDOL bone IDOL. Hope I've made myself clear!

As clear as mud. Having an abortion because you couldn't be arsed to have an abortion? Can't work that one out. Admittedly, I've got 'Rebel Yell' going round in my head though...

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · 23/06/2023 23:10

YABU to write things like "people want to push this 'pro-choice means as late as necessary for any reason..'
which people? what are you even talking about? i don't know of anyone campaigning (or 'pushing') to change the law to allow abortions any later than what is currently allowed.
In rare cases, it's considered 'necessary' to induce an end to a pregnancy, usually because there's been a severe medical complication and if it's not done, the woman is likely to die. In these cases, it's obviously very sad (for everyone involved - esp the woman) that the foetus won't become a living baby, but in these cases the other option would probably mean the end of the mother's life too.

YANBU to question the terms used. I prefer "pro-choice" and "anti-choice".

user9630721458 · 23/06/2023 22:59

@Qazwsxefv Many thanks for clarifying the position on later abortions and rape. I had a sense that our UK law would cover it, but wasn't sure. I completely respect what you say about euthanasia and what a difficult position that puts our doctors in.

StarchySturgess1 · 23/06/2023 22:36

@Isitpaydayyet

Like I said; available to all women, for any reason, at any time. I'm pro-choice without and "but". I prioritise the woman.

nothingcomestonothing · 23/06/2023 22:35

VestaTilley · 23/06/2023 22:24

A baby being a baby starts a lot earlier than an hour before birth! They can feel pain from around 24 weeks.

No they can't (credit to ditalini on another thread)

https://www.rcog.org.uk/guidance/browse-all-guidance/other-guidelines-and-reports/fetal-awareness-updated-review-of-research-and-recommendations-for-practice/

Qazwsxefv · 23/06/2023 22:34

Bumpitybumper · 23/06/2023 15:10

39% of doctors oppose changing the law when it comes to euthanasia. Some of this may well be due to religious beliefs but I think there is more to it than that. I find it hard to believe that all of these doctors are extremists.

As I mentioned, I like the vast majority of the population support euthanasia for many of the reasons you suggest but I also think it's wrong to accuse anyone that doesn't support it of being an extremist. There is nuance and genuine concerns about how it would work in practice and affect some of the most vulnerable people in society.

Speaking as a doctor I am worried about a potential change in the law because I will be required to enact it. It’s one thing to consider the concept of euthanisia in the abstract of for oneself but to consider being the person who has to give that injection or medication knowing it will kill someone, that’s a big things to consider. I have turned off life support for people who are brain dead and prescribed and administered massive doses of morphine to the already dying and signed the abortion act paperwork and given the abortion pills to women and I know what variations of am emotional mess I’m in with all of them. I’m not sure I’m emotionally up to straight up killing people.

I’d be a lot more pro euthanasia if I didn’t think I’d get called on to actually have to look someone in the eye when I kill them.

VestaTilley · 23/06/2023 22:24

A baby being a baby starts a lot earlier than an hour before birth! They can feel pain from around 24 weeks.

Qazwsxefv · 23/06/2023 22:14

user9630721458 · 23/06/2023 20:09

@SouthLondonMum22 Abortion to term is already available if there is serious risk to the mental/physical health of mother or baby. If a person who has been raped does not realise until after they are 24 weeks I imagine serious risks to their health would be assessed and a later abortion would still be available if it was necessary? If not they would have to give birth, which would be terrible, but I think once they enter 3rd trimester they would be most likely to have to give birth anyway. It would certainly be a difficult case, but very rare as you say. I would be interested to know how a case like this would be dealt with in the UK.

Abortion to term, to the moment of delivery in fact is available in the Uk as provided in the 1967 abortion act if certain conditions are met, cases of rape causing mental distress would almost certainly meet the criteria after all abortion has been legal in cases of rape in the UK since 1938 (r vs borne) (it was the doctor who went to court not the women btw) and the abortion act was a way to formalise the existing case law and make acsess easier

it’s probably worth saying again that after 24 weeks even if an abortion is carried out and even if it’s surgical the women is going to have some physical sequale - you can’t make pregancies of that gestation “disappear”

Qazwsxefv · 23/06/2023 21:58

MissTrip82 · 23/06/2023 01:05

Forced-birther another accurate term.

Embrace it.

I said this on the other thread. It’s a biological certainty after about 24 weeks gestation that a birth is going to take place. Its too late to avoid birth at this point abortion or no. Other humans aren’t forcing birth biology is.

The birth may be surgical or vaginal, it may come naturally or be induced, it may be of a dead foetus or alive baby but at some point in the next 24 or so weeks the pregnancy is going to exit the womb - a birth will take place (even if the mother dies a post death c-section is usually carried out to try and save the baby), as in something that looks to most of us like a (very) small baby will leave the womb usually through the process of labour via the vagina (but can be via an operation) and the women will have all the issues of being post partum baby or not

Trying to pretend that late stage abortion prevents unwanted births isn’t useful. It prevents unwanted live babies or when rarely done in the uk it’s prevents suffering via live birth of a baby that would have only known a short life full of pain. The mothers that make the very difficult but valid decision to terminate wanted pregancies because the baby will know nothing but suffering if born alive do have a labour and birth their babies and your “forced birth” rhetoric invalidates their experience.

SouthLondonMum22 · 23/06/2023 21:49

Isitpaydayyet · 23/06/2023 21:15

@user9630721458 @SouthLondonMum22 serious reasons like what? Because medical reasons have already been covered. Please elaborate genuinely interested to learn.

You can only think of medical reasons as possible serious reasons?

A woman or lets not forget that it isn’t just women that get pregnant but very young girls too and they aren’t always going to find out before 24 weeks for a start. Should a young girl be forced to remain pregnant because she either didn’t know or was too scared to tell anyone until 25 weeks?

There’s also rape, incest and domestic violence just to start where it isn’t always as easy as getting an early abortion.

Again, an early abortion is always the ideal but that isn’t always going to happen. Again, especially when we’re talking about very sad situations including the likes of abuse and also how potentially young someone may be.

Ihavehadenoughalready · 23/06/2023 21:44

The anti-choice people refuse to see in shades of gray. They think it's better to ban all abortions, even when the fetus is doomed due to genetic or other developmental mishaps, and they don't mind the psychological harm to the mother and her family of not being able to abort a fetus that has no chance to survive. The stance of the pro-choice people is that the GOVERNMENT should not be able to make such decisions, even if they themselves personally would not consider an abortion except in certain circumstances, none of which are the government's business. Pro-choice people are not forcing their beliefs on anti-choice people. If anti-choice people don't want an abortion, no one will make them get one. Anti-choice politicians ARE forcing their beliefs on pro-choice people, in that they make laws/tell people who need or want an abortion that they cannot get one, no matter what. (I'm in the US)

Anti-choice ("pro-life") people have exactly NO greater moral stance than anybody else, and probably have much less given their rigid and inflexible stance and the harm it does to others they think themselves morally superior to.

Pro-choice people include the rest of society that wants others to mind their own business and not worry about the morality of people whom the anti-choice people presume to be amoral.

In essence, it's the same argument of people who say atheists cannot be moral because they don't believe in God, even though it's quite possible that scores of atheists and agnostics and non-religious people are very much more compassionate and moral than the bunch of judgmental "conservative" anti-choice people are.

Pro-life people are not "pro-life"; they are misguidedly anti-choice.

Also; my sister had a molar pregnancy requiring an abortion due to a genetically abnormal fetus and with no chance of viability and an abnormally growing placenta causing life-threatening high blood pressure in my sister. Thankfully she lived at a time when and in a state where abortion was legal. She could have died if untreated. She would never have considered an abortion except that her life was in danger if the pregnancy continued. She was treated at a Catholic hospital which agreed with her doctor that an abortion was necessary. She recovered and went on to have three healthy babies. The anti-choice people could have killed her and my nieces and nephews never been born. The anti-choice people have zero monopoly on what is moral in this or any other circumstance of someone else's pregnancy.