Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this is grim. Funeral.

633 replies

ThatFraggle · 22/06/2023 19:24

A group of mourners all in normal funeral clothes. Some more formal, some less. Some not black. Fine.

Then a group of three girls. They looked older than primary school age, but younger than A level.

The one was in a skintight mini dress she kept having to pull down.

The other two were in those hotpants-vest combo unitard things people seem to wear these days. Basically like a spanx leotard, coming a couple of inches below the bum.

Yes, it's hot. And yes, people can wear what they like, but surely there's a time and a place, and a funeral is not the place.

AIBU that if it were my young teens coming down for a funeral dressed like that, I'd tell them to go back upstairs and get changed?

OP posts:
floradora · 24/06/2023 15:23

@5128gap I don't disagree with you; for me and my DD it was natural to have a chat about what was going to be appropriate for a religious, traditional funeral. I get that other people think differently

IsThisReallyPC · 24/06/2023 15:02

Gracewithoutend · 24/06/2023 13:50

No, I think I get your point. Yours is a very chilled and laid back congregation where anything goes. So if someone wears a low cut top and short shorts, it's just great they came. And when her husband joins her in his football strip, they're fine when he takes his top off because it's a bit hot. I get it. It's all about the feelz.

Canterbury Cathedral do have a dress code for visitors.

ie. No bear chests, short shorts, basic stuff like that
Haven’t been to any others recently.

IsThisReallyPC · 24/06/2023 14:59

chalkiegirl · 24/06/2023 14:17

Black is no longer standard where I live in West Wales, although the chapel community still mainly holds to its old customs.
It's quite acceptable for navy, grey, purple , prints containing muted colours to be worn elsewhere without anybody going into shock.
Most people have a innate idea of what's appropriate and adults keep a few suitable outfits in their wardrobe.

No black not standard at all.
Ireland, England and Wales.
Am currently becoming a serial funeral goer, unfortunately
I wear black as I have one smart for everything dress, but I’m invariably in the minority

pickledandpuzzled · 24/06/2023 14:45

There's a huge assumption being made that the girls dressed as they did to show off and be the centre of attention.

That would of course be wrong.

I think it's more likely that they wore clothes they already had in black, and didn't realise that today's fashion is so shocking to older people.

I object to being expected to pretend I don't have cleavage. Given the choice between a v neck which inevitably shows my cleavage and a crew neck that leaves me feeling trussed up like a turkey, v neck it is.

Given the scrunch bum nude leggings people wear now, all bets are off.

chalkiegirl · 24/06/2023 14:17

Shinier · 22/06/2023 20:29

Black everything is standard unless the person that died said bright colours, steel toe cap boots etc. How hard is this to understand?

no it’s not

Black is no longer standard where I live in West Wales, although the chapel community still mainly holds to its old customs.
It's quite acceptable for navy, grey, purple , prints containing muted colours to be worn elsewhere without anybody going into shock.
Most people have a innate idea of what's appropriate and adults keep a few suitable outfits in their wardrobe.

Gracewithoutend · 24/06/2023 13:50

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 23/06/2023 22:44

Again
Never seen a cathedral with an itemised list of what can and can't be worn like a club might have...
And if your church judges people for what they wear and would turn them away then you are ENTIRELY missing the point

No, I think I get your point. Yours is a very chilled and laid back congregation where anything goes. So if someone wears a low cut top and short shorts, it's just great they came. And when her husband joins her in his football strip, they're fine when he takes his top off because it's a bit hot. I get it. It's all about the feelz.

IsThisReallyPC · 24/06/2023 13:48

aSofaNearYou · 24/06/2023 11:56

@IsThisReallyPC Yes I'm uk based - and I haven't been to loads of funerals. If you haven't been to multiple in recent years, how would you know that black is out? It's been the done thing for centuries.

No I quite agree.
Tbh I was shocked when I went to one in Ireland that people came wearing ‘normal ‘attire. Nothing dressy black etc. I knew it was the case in the Uk but I suppose I thought it would be more traditional there.

TheaBrandt · 24/06/2023 12:23

See also Brazil. Dds friends mum is Brazilian and is actually super strict and fierce but is utterly ok with the most outrageous outfits!

TheaBrandt · 24/06/2023 12:21

Would advise op not to visit Spain. The teen girls outfits there would finish her off. Ours did a Spanish exchange so witnessed first Hanns. Made my friend and I feel better when our dds dressed like that “well they all do it in Spain”!

aSofaNearYou · 24/06/2023 11:56

@IsThisReallyPC Yes I'm uk based - and I haven't been to loads of funerals. If you haven't been to multiple in recent years, how would you know that black is out? It's been the done thing for centuries.

IsThisReallyPC · 24/06/2023 11:42

aSofaNearYou · 24/06/2023 11:26

Very depressing quite right. However there is no need for kids to have new clothes bought when they already ( I assume) have a school uniform they could wear. So no one should put themselves under unnecessary financial strain.

No need for black these days. Unless someone’s set a dress code which I think would be very odd.

Yes this would be an option. But my school uniform was blue, not black, and I have not been to a funeral where people have adopted a "no need for black these days" approach. All the one's I've been to, it has very much been the assumption of the people there that they had to wear black.

That’s unusual, are you UK based. I know in Italy lots still wear black I was at one there last year ( still not everyone tho) but
We seem to be doing a few funerals a year at the moment and even in Ireland where you’d think they’d be more formal very very few people wear black.
I was the only one last time, except for an aunt in a black cardi.

No one wears yellow, pink, orange etc but black is out. Excepting certain religions I guess and maybe countries ?

aSofaNearYou · 24/06/2023 11:28

I'd rather I (or DD) wore a slightly too big borrowed cardi over the body con dress, or pinchy shoes for an hour rather than disrespect the expectations and beliefs of family.

I'd have given her a cardi as her mum but I wouldn't insist she kept it on if it was genuinely hot. I think there's something a bit sad about preferring a young teen to sit there sweating and uncomfortable so that other people don't have to see her shoulders.

aSofaNearYou · 24/06/2023 11:26

Very depressing quite right. However there is no need for kids to have new clothes bought when they already ( I assume) have a school uniform they could wear. So no one should put themselves under unnecessary financial strain.

No need for black these days. Unless someone’s set a dress code which I think would be very odd.

Yes this would be an option. But my school uniform was blue, not black, and I have not been to a funeral where people have adopted a "no need for black these days" approach. All the one's I've been to, it has very much been the assumption of the people there that they had to wear black.

Thisisbollocksmark · 24/06/2023 11:08

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 24/06/2023 07:30

Wow now

The level required is now tailored pants and a collared shirt?

And body con and strappy are wrong for the THEATRE now?

Get over yourself.

Theatres aren't fucking snobbery places now. It's not like when it was open to the highest in society only, unless you stood in a pit. Attitudes like that, proclaiming you should be modest and cover up and treat it like some kind of high society event are the exact attitude theatres are trying to DISPELL. They want people to know Theatre is for all.

And flesh baring? So women should be going to all these events covered head to toe? In fact no shorts or polo shirts or short sleeve shirts for the men either?

This reminds me of my grandmother again. I mentioned a while earlier that she spent her life in mini skirts.

Years ago, she was told by an in law that there was no way he was taking her to the theatre if she was going to insist on wearing a short skirt.

She said she was wearing one whether he liked it or not. And bravo to her!

The sooner women are allowed to 'bear their flesh' without it being seen like it's some hideous moral failing, the better. It's 2023 and people are still complaining about being able to see legs. It's absolutely ridiculous.

DaisyDaisyDaisyDaisyDaisyDaisy · 24/06/2023 09:23

God this thread is miserable to read. Any girl aged over 10 should have tailored trousers?! Strappy this, skimpy that..?! I move around a lot for my job and was unfortunate enough to have to listen to the staff room drivel of a bunch of strangers yesterday. One woman was chatting to another about a top her 9 year old daughter wanted. She said 'no way was I buying it for her. She would have looked like a right little slut!' This is her own precious child she was talking about. Now I don't know the details of the top but good god that is vile. Having read this thread I'm going to have my will changed to insist everyone wears hot pants so I can laugh in my grave at how much it would piss off the OP Blush

TheaBrandt · 24/06/2023 09:03

Mine wore a v short tight black dress. Didn’t love it but she insisted. It meant a lot to Dh extended family that she was there. She was brilliant actually particularly for a teen and had a lovely chat with Dh aunt the widow and her sister. She wrote to us afterwards thanking us for going. So forgive me for thinking attendance is more important than clothes.

Only issue were family members vying to compete with who dd2 looked most like when they were young (she’s stunning)

ThatFraggle · 24/06/2023 08:56

TheaBrandt · 24/06/2023 08:50

Thatfraggle if you had an otherwise pretty decent 14 year old but who insisted on wearing a dress you didn’t approve of to an event what would you actually do? Interested to hear.

If they insisted on wearing hotpants to a funeral, I'd probably just leave them at home.

OP posts:
5128gap · 24/06/2023 08:55

floradora · 24/06/2023 08:48

@5128gap "clothes do not define a person and will look at what you're wearing and assume things about your personality and attitude." - but at the same time we do talk about expressing ourselves through clothing, and our choices around our appearance are a form of communication. Otherwise we would all dress the same.

Absolutely. But there's a difference between picking up signals about a person's tastes and interests, your t shirt tells me you like that band, you dress tells me you like bright colours, and extrapolating that a person with that style and taste has certain negative personality traits. In this case that they want to be the centre of attention, that they are disrespectful, even as some suggest when its females in revealing clothes that they're sexually available or their morals are questionable.

TheaBrandt · 24/06/2023 08:52

Taking into account this is a child you love and want to have a positive ongoing relationship with you don’t want to crush their self esteem and they are 14 not 4 so shouting and ranting at them and telling them to change won’t work.

TheaBrandt · 24/06/2023 08:50

Thatfraggle if you had an otherwise pretty decent 14 year old but who insisted on wearing a dress you didn’t approve of to an event what would you actually do? Interested to hear.

floradora · 24/06/2023 08:48

@5128gap "clothes do not define a person and will look at what you're wearing and assume things about your personality and attitude." - but at the same time we do talk about expressing ourselves through clothing, and our choices around our appearance are a form of communication. Otherwise we would all dress the same.

ThatFraggle · 24/06/2023 08:23

CherryBlossom321 · 23/06/2023 23:15

I already have extensive conversations with them about dressing for their own comfort, not for anybody else’s, about how to identify misogynistic attitudes, not passing snap judgments on other girls and women based on their appearance.

We talk about how girls are hassled relentlessly when it comes to school uniform but not boys, how overall women are judged for their appearance much more commonly than men.

I’ve taught them that men are not in fact helpless animals who can’t control themselves, that their hearts and character are infinitely more important than their appearance, and that there is nothing wrong with wearing weather appropriate clothing.

We also discuss how so many women are still oppressed by cultural, societal and religious ideology, and I’m raising them to have autonomy and freedom when it comes to their own bodies. That their developing bodies are not for others to sexualise.

None of which is akin to what you’re suggesting.

So, if after those conversations, they still decided to go to a funeral in hot pants because they like the outfit, what would you do?

OP posts:
AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 24/06/2023 07:52

Every year my old university posts pictures ofbthr the graduations.

I bet some of you would pop a vein at the amount of flesh on show there 🤣

TheaBrandt · 24/06/2023 07:41

Zelda you are facing quite a stressful life for yourself if young girls not wearing “tailored trousers and shirts” upsets you. There are many countries in the world where you would fit in better - Saudi Arabia for example…

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 24/06/2023 07:30

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 24/06/2023 01:22

Exactly.

It's just all to disguise pure laziness.

Anyone age 10 or over who can't muster up tailored (non-legging) dark pants and a collared shirt, at bare minimum, for weddings, funerals and other rites of our society, is deficient. Providing such should be Parenting 101.

As most kids up through 17 or so have school uniform, there is no excuse for wearing bodycon, skimpy, strappy or flesh-baring attire to rites such as weddings, funerals, christenings, musical / theatre performances, etc.

It's always better to err on the side of more decorous than less decorous. I truly feel sorry for people who don't understand that.

Wow now

The level required is now tailored pants and a collared shirt?

And body con and strappy are wrong for the THEATRE now?

Get over yourself.

Theatres aren't fucking snobbery places now. It's not like when it was open to the highest in society only, unless you stood in a pit. Attitudes like that, proclaiming you should be modest and cover up and treat it like some kind of high society event are the exact attitude theatres are trying to DISPELL. They want people to know Theatre is for all.

And flesh baring? So women should be going to all these events covered head to toe? In fact no shorts or polo shirts or short sleeve shirts for the men either?