Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this is grim. Funeral.

633 replies

ThatFraggle · 22/06/2023 19:24

A group of mourners all in normal funeral clothes. Some more formal, some less. Some not black. Fine.

Then a group of three girls. They looked older than primary school age, but younger than A level.

The one was in a skintight mini dress she kept having to pull down.

The other two were in those hotpants-vest combo unitard things people seem to wear these days. Basically like a spanx leotard, coming a couple of inches below the bum.

Yes, it's hot. And yes, people can wear what they like, but surely there's a time and a place, and a funeral is not the place.

AIBU that if it were my young teens coming down for a funeral dressed like that, I'd tell them to go back upstairs and get changed?

OP posts:
LaMaG · 23/06/2023 08:51

Havent read all posts but agree with you OP. It was inappropriate and wrong, we do have social conventions. If this thread said girl turns up at wedding in white dress there would be uproar. Convention is that funerals require conservative clothing. Even in summer. In fairness their parents were probably mourning themselves and didn't see it as a time to choose a battle so I would cut them some slack. I do think teenagers need to learn there is a time and place for everything though.

GwinCoch · 23/06/2023 08:51

ThatFraggle · 23/06/2023 08:43

There's no master arbiter. As part of a society, people learn what is considered acceptable and what is not.

At Tesco, do you push to the front of the queue, because you've only got one thing, so it will only take 30 seconds?

Is it acceptable to go to a party at someone's house and not take a bottle of wine/chocolate?

Is it acceptable to go inside a stranger's house without permission?

At a friend's wedding do you wear your old wedding dress, because it still fits and you looked gorgeous? (Yes, there was a news story of a bride who decided to ask guests to do that, but I'm talking about an 'ordinary' wedding).

Is it acceptable to sit on your new bosses lap (you met him yesterday) and sing 'happy birthday' Marilyn Monroe style?

We all get a sense of what the 'rules' are in the country/social circles we are in.

We are generally aware of the rules, then decide whether or not to break them.

The same applies to clothing.

Those examples are all whataboutery. Not comparable at all. Most people understand there is a social contract, seems fewer understand that grief can’t be arbitrated.

ThatFraggle · 23/06/2023 08:50

@CopperSeahorses

Sorry for your loss.

Yes, in grief some people don't remember/care what others wore. Some do.

And at pp, wearing something slightly shabby due to not being able to afford new clothes is not disrespectful. In the UK for £10 you can get something from a charity shop, so if you can't do that you're on a very tight budget/don't have the time/don't have transport/are one of those people who won't wear second hand clothes.

OP posts:
NotEverORNever · 23/06/2023 08:47

If someone came with a thong bikini I'd assume there was something wrong with them. I would definitely think it inappropriate. (I'd be imagining a whole back story.) That is a whole other level from the teens in your situation.

Of course there are outfits that are unsuitable for funerals but I think minding your own business and wearing the 'wrong' clothes is LESS OFFENSIVE than sitting at a funeral disapproving of other mourners for something that doesn't really matter. You are presumably at a funeral of someone you love but rather than than thinking about them you are having negative judgemental thoughts about other people, other people who are, presumably also mourning. It's such a sour thing to do.

Your situation involved teens on, presumably, a warm summer day. That I really couldn't get bothered about. I might notice it and I might clock that it isn't the best choice of clothing but I wouldn't care.

I felt The poster earlier who said teens turning up at another teens funeral dressed as though they were going clubbing was disrespectful was really out of order to be thinking their clothing were disrespectful when it's likely to be the opposite. Her being at the funeral sitting and judging teens at their friends funeral is really unpleasant.

Parker231 · 23/06/2023 08:46

parliamoglesga · 23/06/2023 08:40

Eh? What does sitting about on Christmas day have to do with turning up to a funeral with your arse hanging out and barely dressed?

i wouldn’t allow my daughters to go out dressed like that on any given day never mind to a funeral.

My post tried to show it’s not up to you to criticise or dictate how others should be dressed whether it’s a funeral or Christmas Day. It’s nothing to do with you.

ThatFraggle · 23/06/2023 08:43

TheaBrandt · 23/06/2023 08:32

Who is the mystery arbiter of what is or isn’t acceptable? Op? Prince Charles? I would be interested to know.

There's no master arbiter. As part of a society, people learn what is considered acceptable and what is not.

At Tesco, do you push to the front of the queue, because you've only got one thing, so it will only take 30 seconds?

Is it acceptable to go to a party at someone's house and not take a bottle of wine/chocolate?

Is it acceptable to go inside a stranger's house without permission?

At a friend's wedding do you wear your old wedding dress, because it still fits and you looked gorgeous? (Yes, there was a news story of a bride who decided to ask guests to do that, but I'm talking about an 'ordinary' wedding).

Is it acceptable to sit on your new bosses lap (you met him yesterday) and sing 'happy birthday' Marilyn Monroe style?

We all get a sense of what the 'rules' are in the country/social circles we are in.

We are generally aware of the rules, then decide whether or not to break them.

The same applies to clothing.

OP posts:
CopperSeahorses · 23/06/2023 08:42

My memories of DH's funeral are

A sea of white work vans, the team he worked with all turned up fresh from work.

A sea of black among the colour, we requested wear colour but his workmates turned up in their uniform black polo shirts and black trousers.

The chatter of small children while we waited outside

The purple ties the pall bearers wore

His wicker coffin with the spray of sunflowers on the top of it

His photo in the back window of the hearse then the photo by his coffin through the service

And the fact that, once again, my mother chose not to be there for one of the most painful events of my life. if she had turned up in a string bikini singing the Hokey Cokey it would've meant the world to me. The fact that she had chosen to be there would've been more important than what she wore.

I have no clue what other people wore. I can only remember what I wore. A bright green dress that I have worn since that awful day and it somehow brings me comfort.

brunettemic · 23/06/2023 08:40

It’s definitely grim that you’re being so judgemental yes. Was the the question?

parliamoglesga · 23/06/2023 08:40

Parker231 · 23/06/2023 08:12

Perhaps the deceased was a grandparent and was proud of her grandchildren and couldn’t care less what they wore? It’s not for the general public to dictate what someone wears - it’s a decision by the family - not you.
We spend Christmas Day in pj’s - all three generations - the grandparents love it - no one is offended.

Eh? What does sitting about on Christmas day have to do with turning up to a funeral with your arse hanging out and barely dressed?

i wouldn’t allow my daughters to go out dressed like that on any given day never mind to a funeral.

aSofaNearYou · 23/06/2023 08:38

ThatFraggle · 23/06/2023 08:23

So those who think it's fine, what's your 'limit' or is there no limit at all?

If someone chose to turn up in a thong string bikini, 'because people should just be happy they turned up' would that be ok?

If, not ok, why is it not ok? Why does that reasoning not apply to hotpants at a funeral?

I would be wondering why they'd chosen that - if the bikini was colourful. But wearing a short/tight dress in black, I'd be thinking the obvious - they thought they had to wear black and this is all they had. I wouldn't judge them for not going out and buying a slightly more modest black outfit specifically for the occasion. If I had to go to a funeral right now and had to wear black, I'd have to wear my slightly shabby maternity leggings. I can't afford to splash out on a formal black outfit, and the last thing anyone needs whilst dealing with a loss is more financial pressure.

TheaBrandt · 23/06/2023 08:32

Who is the mystery arbiter of what is or isn’t acceptable? Op? Prince Charles? I would be interested to know.

ThatFraggle · 23/06/2023 08:30

Also, think about the last time you went clubbing. Now think about your last job interview?

Why didn't you wear the clubbing outfit to the job interview? You looked good clubbing, didn't you?

Why do some places have 'appropriate' clothing that you do stick to, even though you're on Mumsnet saying hotpants at a funeral are fine?

Is it because there is a consequence - not getting the job/being fired?

OP posts:
TheaBrandt · 23/06/2023 08:23

That sounds lovely 5128.

ThatFraggle · 23/06/2023 08:23

So those who think it's fine, what's your 'limit' or is there no limit at all?

If someone chose to turn up in a thong string bikini, 'because people should just be happy they turned up' would that be ok?

If, not ok, why is it not ok? Why does that reasoning not apply to hotpants at a funeral?

OP posts:
TheaBrandt · 23/06/2023 08:20

So what?! Why do you care what other women wear? You can wear a twin set and pearls out clubbing if you like others will make other choices. This thread is like being back in 1952

5128gap · 23/06/2023 08:20

Twinsmummy1812 · 23/06/2023 00:07

I kind of agree with you OP. There was a funeral in our town yesterday for a teenager who was tragically killed in a car accident and some of the girls walking along the road looked like they were going clubbing with short skimpy outfits and weirdly chunky rubber colourful sliders. Everyone was in black as well which I haven’t seen at a funeral for years. I don’t understand why they would think that was appropriate and think a grown up should have guided them but I guess at least they showed up?

When my friends teen DS died, all his friends, male and female turned up dressed for a night out. Girls full on glam, boys in new shirts with fresh hair cuts. Pulling out the stops with their appearance was their way of honouring the occasion. Sometimes older generations just need to accept that there's a new type of appropriate. Otherwise we'd still be in veiled hats and covering up our mirrors.

FarmGirl78 · 23/06/2023 08:16

NerrSnerr · 23/06/2023 08:04

It's not the clothes that are the risky things in the night clubs. It's the men who sexually assault women.

I should have expected that shouldn't I?

I wasn't thinking risky as in being attacked by an evil preditory man, I was thinking more along the lines of having an escapee boob pop out of a jodie marsh style 'belt' dress. Which I'd be mortified about even if I was in a nightclub of only straight women.

TheaBrandt · 23/06/2023 08:16

We are having a few “issues” with Dd2s outfit choices she came with me to see my mum in hospital and afterwards I said to mum “see what I am dealing with” and mum was adamant she looked gorgeous and was thrilled to see her. Think it’s only the middle aged busy bodies that care - the people that really matter don’t.

Parker231 · 23/06/2023 08:12

parliamoglesga · 23/06/2023 06:55

Of course it’s inappropriate but given the responses on here are you surprised people turn up looking a state?

permissive parenting and a lack of respect for others and traditions has led to exactly what you described

Perhaps the deceased was a grandparent and was proud of her grandchildren and couldn’t care less what they wore? It’s not for the general public to dictate what someone wears - it’s a decision by the family - not you.
We spend Christmas Day in pj’s - all three generations - the grandparents love it - no one is offended.

TheaBrandt · 23/06/2023 08:06

Well I think you all sound like dreadful Hyacinth Bucket types. Maybe you know think about the deceased at funerals rather than sneering at young women.

NerrSnerr · 23/06/2023 08:04

FarmGirl78 · 23/06/2023 07:26

We have the same at our local church, but with Christenings. They'll publish photos each month of the Christening with all families, godparents and friends, and there's ALWAYS one ruining the photos by being dressed in something wildly unsuitable for church which would probably be considered risky in a lot of nightclubs too. It doesn't upset me, its actually funny seeing how completely out of place they look.

It's not the clothes that are the risky things in the night clubs. It's the men who sexually assault women.

Maireas · 23/06/2023 07:53

Well, no one says they have to dress like Kate Middleton. Come on now. There's a middle way.
Anyway, all the girls I teach wear those tight very short skirts so it's obviously a thing.

TheaBrandt · 23/06/2023 07:42

It’s not easy with teens though. As a parent you suggest but what do you do if they refuse? You have a row on your hands plus you have to be pretty careful not criticising their appearance / choices it can have a long lasting impact. Dh and I have not chosen clothes as the hill to die on. Assuming the judgy posters either have tiny children or compliant biddable teens.

We got a letter from the widow afterwards saying how pleased she was that our teens had attended. That’s the important thing not making them dress like Kate Middleton.

Maireas · 23/06/2023 07:29

Zola1 · 23/06/2023 07:06

I don't think my 13 year old would know how to dress appropriately for a funeral. I also think I'd need to buy her a new outfit as all of her clothes are either sportswear or as you describe. She would definitely need my input to avoid her dressing in black short shorts. Maybe these girls didn't have someone to give them that feedback.

I think this is the point, really. It's great to have that much body confidence as a teenage girl, but we all know that in life there are dress codes. It doesn't mean you have to dress like a surrendered wife, just modify the look a little.

FarmGirl78 · 23/06/2023 07:26

We have the same at our local church, but with Christenings. They'll publish photos each month of the Christening with all families, godparents and friends, and there's ALWAYS one ruining the photos by being dressed in something wildly unsuitable for church which would probably be considered risky in a lot of nightclubs too. It doesn't upset me, its actually funny seeing how completely out of place they look.