Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think this is grim. Funeral.

633 replies

ThatFraggle · 22/06/2023 19:24

A group of mourners all in normal funeral clothes. Some more formal, some less. Some not black. Fine.

Then a group of three girls. They looked older than primary school age, but younger than A level.

The one was in a skintight mini dress she kept having to pull down.

The other two were in those hotpants-vest combo unitard things people seem to wear these days. Basically like a spanx leotard, coming a couple of inches below the bum.

Yes, it's hot. And yes, people can wear what they like, but surely there's a time and a place, and a funeral is not the place.

AIBU that if it were my young teens coming down for a funeral dressed like that, I'd tell them to go back upstairs and get changed?

OP posts:
5128gap · 23/06/2023 12:36

Whether people like it or not, each generations time to dictate what is appropriate for an occasion lasts only until the next generation changes the rules.
When I was young jeans and trainers were inappropriate office wear, tight fitting clothing was deemed inappropriate for overweight women, men who stepped outside of masculine dress codes had their sexuality questioned, and school girls weren't allowed to wear trousers.
Norms evolve and people, particularly young people, will create their own appropriate. Trying to stay in your comfort zone by pushing your ideas of what is 'fitting' on to a new generation is doomed to failure. Which is just as well, or we'd all still be in corsets.

ManateeFair · 23/06/2023 12:36

So as long as you don't get arrested for public indecency, you can wear as skimpy an outfit as you want to a funeral? That's what you're saying?

If the family of the deceased are OK with that, then yes, of course you can. What's 'appropriate' is down to the immediately family to decide.

You are entitled to think someone's outfit is 'grim' if it's not to your taste. You would be entitled to be unhappy about someone turning up to the funeral of your parent/spouse/child in a skimpy outfit. But you don't get to police what's 'appropriate' for other families; it's up to them.

My cousin's daughters wore jeans and velour hoodies to my uncle's funeral. I personally would have made them dress a bit more smartly if they'd been my kids at my father's funeral, but as it was my cousin's father who had died, it was absolutely up to him to decide what his kids could/couldn't wear. And I'm pretty sure my uncle (their grandad) would have wanted them wearing whatever they were most comfortable in.

I'm not really sure why you're even asking this question. You've already made up your mind what you think, and you're arguing with anyone who thinks differently. What you're really saying is not 'AIBU to think this is grim?' but 'I enjoy slagging off grieving families for their sartorial choices, and I would like everyone else to pile on and join in.'

IamstilltheWalrus · 23/06/2023 12:33

Some posters on here, sound very jealous of attractive young women. Maybe these posters (including the OP,) feel tinges of jealousy and resentment because those days are behind them, and/or they know they could never get away with wearing the same outfits.

😂😂😂

Just because you can, doesn't mean you should...

You know when you are young and attractive enough, you stay young and attractive even when you wear appropriate clothing? Some people seem to suffer from a lot of insecurity and resentment, insecurity being understandable for a young teen, but it gets a bit sad later.😂

You have to love the miffed posters on MN taking comments strangely personally

Hotsummerlatenightstrolls · 23/06/2023 12:30

Gettingbysomehow · 23/06/2023 12:28

A lot of people do not understand what dressing for occasions means.
last week a colleague of mine turned up for a work meeting at a conference centre away from work (normal office wear required) in what I can only describe as hot pants and the smallest top I've ever seen because it was very hot. We all gawped. You could see her arse cheeks.
She was sent home.

It's a shame schools and colleges don't do the same. They had every right to turn her away does she have teenage daughters and is trying to keep up with them.

movein · 23/06/2023 12:29

I literally couldn’t bring myself to care

Gettingbysomehow · 23/06/2023 12:28

A lot of people do not understand what dressing for occasions means.
last week a colleague of mine turned up for a work meeting at a conference centre away from work (normal office wear required) in what I can only describe as hot pants and the smallest top I've ever seen because it was very hot. We all gawped. You could see her arse cheeks.
She was sent home.

Hotsummerlatenightstrolls · 23/06/2023 12:27

TheaBrandt · 23/06/2023 11:55

I am very very slow to judge young people for what they wear. They are just starting out and finding their way. Pretty much all my friends (mums of teens) have a similar mindset - the opposite of this po faced op.

Unfortunately, we live in a world where people do judge you on how you look are you marriage material, intelligent looking, do you fit in the culture of a work environment, or other.

Each year, 15 milion girls are married before they are 18. That's one in four girls. Education is a powerful tool that will help our young girls succeed in life. Let's close the gender gap together and help our daughters to be independent in life.

aSofaNearYou · 23/06/2023 12:27

IamstilltheWalrus · 23/06/2023 11:27

What I find utterly depressing in this thread is to see how many people.
pride themselves on being above social rules and basic manners, and smugly would refuse to give any clue to their own children.

I know there are many threads about people becoming more and more selfish, but it puzzles me how so many must always be the centre of attention, must have every event around them and don't give a second of care for anyone else.
Is it linked to social media, the need for constant selfie and the impression they are the star of some reality show?

We are not talking about exaggerated strict dress code, just some appropriate clothing. How hard can it be.

Possibly quite hard for people that don't own those sorts of clothes and don't have the money to splash buying them especially.

I agree that people should have manners, but when the "manners" in question are just adhering to specific clothing related traditions that make people feel obliged to put themselves under financial strain, I find that more depressing, tbh.

Americano75 · 23/06/2023 12:24

I really hate the 'older women just jealous of younger women' pish.

TheaBrandt · 23/06/2023 12:20

There’s only one “grim” person in this scenario and it’s not the young girls.

TheaBrandt · 23/06/2023 12:19

Spot on ebony 100 % agree

CherryBlossom321 · 23/06/2023 12:16

EbonyRaven · 23/06/2023 12:03

@gannett

Yes, a couple of teenage girls wearing slightly revealing clothing in a heatwave is EXACTLY the same as breaking and entering. Not a tortuous, overegged analogy at all.

Of course some elements of etiquette are necessary for everyone to rub along nicely in society but etiquette has also historically been used as a tool of oppression, particularly of women. It's important to apply critical thinking to it and to encourage people to defy convention in some areas. So all this snooty social contract bollocks doesn't wash with me.

Those girls did no harm to anyone with their outfits. You don't always get things right at 13. What's really grim is a grown woman noticing them enough to judge them, getting in such a state about it that she has to post her judgment of them on the internet hours later, and then spending two days frothing online about them.

Anti-youth attitudes are weirdly common on MN.

100% this. The level of histrionics and hysteria on this thread (from some posters,) about how young girls are dressed these days, and how disgraceful it is that these girls dressed in a bit of a racy outfit for a funeral, is laughable. 😆

Some posters on here, sound very jealous of attractive young women. Maybe these posters (including the OP,) feel tinges of jealousy and resentment because those days are behind them, and/or they know they could never get away with wearing the same outfits.

Yep! Posting a rude and scathing thread about these young women is FAR more GRIM than any outfit anyone has ever worn!

You need to get out more @ThatFraggle And so do a few more posters on this thread! Grin

Absolutely this!

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 23/06/2023 12:12

I agree with you OP, regardless of whether it was a church funeral or not.

And I don't believe for one single solitary second that those people saying 'not your business' and 'why do you care' wouldn't have a) told their own children to change into something more appropriate (and guided them if they didn't have a clue); b) at least have something to say afterwards to their significant other or a friend. At the very least, they'd be thinking the same as you.

We unfortunately had a funeral not so long ago. My children went - they wore their school uniform as the only smartish clothing they have.

EbonyRaven · 23/06/2023 12:03

@gannett

Yes, a couple of teenage girls wearing slightly revealing clothing in a heatwave is EXACTLY the same as breaking and entering. Not a tortuous, overegged analogy at all.

Of course some elements of etiquette are necessary for everyone to rub along nicely in society but etiquette has also historically been used as a tool of oppression, particularly of women. It's important to apply critical thinking to it and to encourage people to defy convention in some areas. So all this snooty social contract bollocks doesn't wash with me.

Those girls did no harm to anyone with their outfits. You don't always get things right at 13. What's really grim is a grown woman noticing them enough to judge them, getting in such a state about it that she has to post her judgment of them on the internet hours later, and then spending two days frothing online about them.

Anti-youth attitudes are weirdly common on MN.

100% this. The level of histrionics and hysteria on this thread (from some posters,) about how young girls are dressed these days, and how disgraceful it is that these girls dressed in a bit of a racy outfit for a funeral, is laughable. 😆

Some posters on here, sound very jealous of attractive young women. Maybe these posters (including the OP,) feel tinges of jealousy and resentment because those days are behind them, and/or they know they could never get away with wearing the same outfits.

Yep! Posting a rude and scathing thread about these young women is FAR more GRIM than any outfit anyone has ever worn!

You need to get out more @ThatFraggle And so do a few more posters on this thread! Grin

TheaBrandt · 23/06/2023 11:55

I am very very slow to judge young people for what they wear. They are just starting out and finding their way. Pretty much all my friends (mums of teens) have a similar mindset - the opposite of this po faced op.

Hardbackwriter · 23/06/2023 11:51

CoffeeCantata · 23/06/2023 10:57

Different situation - sorry!

I'm not a believer but I once worked in an RC faith school and at the end of the summer term the students had a special mass from a visiting bish. They were allowed to wear their own clothes.

Oh my goodness - they eye-popping things that came to school that day. Only God knows where the bishop managed to let his eyes rest. They really were clubbing outfits, and for clubbing they were right on the button. It was an affluent area and the kids would definitely have had more than one outfit, so I'm surprised that the parents, who'd all had to sign up to a kind of social contract, hadn't advised their children better on perhaps more sober, less attention-seeking gear for a solemn religious service.

I don't know what the thinking was behind the 'own clothes' decision and I think blame must lie with the Head for that. But in your teens, surely it's time to begin to understand the concept of appropriate clothing?? I'm not getting into judgements about what's revealing/modest etc - please note!! Or 'telling women what they can wear'. No - I'm just saying that sometimes the message from clothes can be 'Look at ME! and other times it need to be much less attention-grabbing - when it's not about THEM.

I agree that it was a stupid decision to make it a non-uniform day! I suspect that part of the problem was that they cared more about impressing their peers than the bishop, but also that they may genuinely have not understood the difference between 'the outfit you like the best and feel you look best in' and 'the best outfit for this occasion', and that might also be the case for the funeral. I agree with the poster upthread that pointed out that tv - where funeral outfits are always entirely black but also often very sexy - isn't helpful here. This is a screenshot from a teen drama funeral scene, which I don't think is a handy guide for anyone who hasn't been to one before!

AIBU to think this is grim. Funeral.
IamstilltheWalrus · 23/06/2023 11:27

What I find utterly depressing in this thread is to see how many people.
pride themselves on being above social rules and basic manners, and smugly would refuse to give any clue to their own children.

I know there are many threads about people becoming more and more selfish, but it puzzles me how so many must always be the centre of attention, must have every event around them and don't give a second of care for anyone else.
Is it linked to social media, the need for constant selfie and the impression they are the star of some reality show?

We are not talking about exaggerated strict dress code, just some appropriate clothing. How hard can it be.

Mollymalone123 · 23/06/2023 11:26

unless they were told specifically to wear what they like then no absolutely it was inappropriate.
their parents should have told them what to wear and was is deemed appropriate to wear to a traditional funeral.

Thisisbollocksmark · 23/06/2023 11:21

gannett · 23/06/2023 11:16

Well, one of the unwritten rules in my social circles would be that you don't sneer at teenage mourners' outfits.

They are doing you no harm whatsoever. You don't need to be concerned about them and your opinion is utterly irrelevant to them and their families.

Focus on yourself more.

Hear hear!

Whoever these girls are, they've bereaved. I can't believe people think it's appropriate to sneer at their outfits.

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 23/06/2023 11:20

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 23/06/2023 11:06

Drawing attention to ourselves at solemn rites is in poor taste.

Anyone can draw attention regardless of what they wear
"Oh look. There's X. They made it after all"
"Oh no, Y just tripped over accidentally
Or even
"WOW, Z is dressed super appropriately for the funeral and I love that dress"

If I turned up in brigh leggings to this funeral it would be
"Oh she did love her leggings didn't she?"

NathanielSitsOnASpike · 23/06/2023 11:17

I'd assume they had no money (or didn't want to spare the money) to buy special 'funeral' clothes for teens who - one would really hope - would grow out of them after a single wear.

At my mother-in-law's funeral, there were quite a few people who were clearly wearing something they already owned that was black - some quite obvious party dresses rather than mourning wear. Nobody took offence; it's not a rich area and they wouldn't have been expected to buy special 'funeral clothes'.

It's a privilege to be able to afford the perfect outfit for every occasion; sometimes people have to make do.

gannett · 23/06/2023 11:16

ThatFraggle · 23/06/2023 11:02

@gannett

It's not a tortuous analogy at all. PP was asking how anyone is supposed to know what is appropriate.

The same way we know all these other things.

If I'm feeling a bit tired on a walk, I know I can't just knock on a random door and ask to rest on their sofa for 5 minutes. (I'm not talking about being taken ill).

There are many many unwritten rules of society which we know.

That's one interesting thing about travel, seeing the different rules in a different place, even if you share a common language.

Well, one of the unwritten rules in my social circles would be that you don't sneer at teenage mourners' outfits.

They are doing you no harm whatsoever. You don't need to be concerned about them and your opinion is utterly irrelevant to them and their families.

Focus on yourself more.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 23/06/2023 11:06

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 23/06/2023 10:28

I'm wearing bright, lycra cycle shorts right now
And if a certain friend died today I'd consider wearing similar to her funeral because they are the same as ones she's well known for wearing and I'd consider it a sign of rememberance.

Drawing attention to ourselves at solemn rites is in poor taste.

ThatFraggle · 23/06/2023 11:02

@gannett

It's not a tortuous analogy at all. PP was asking how anyone is supposed to know what is appropriate.

The same way we know all these other things.

If I'm feeling a bit tired on a walk, I know I can't just knock on a random door and ask to rest on their sofa for 5 minutes. (I'm not talking about being taken ill).

There are many many unwritten rules of society which we know.

That's one interesting thing about travel, seeing the different rules in a different place, even if you share a common language.

OP posts:
CoffeeCantata · 23/06/2023 10:57

Different situation - sorry!

I'm not a believer but I once worked in an RC faith school and at the end of the summer term the students had a special mass from a visiting bish. They were allowed to wear their own clothes.

Oh my goodness - they eye-popping things that came to school that day. Only God knows where the bishop managed to let his eyes rest. They really were clubbing outfits, and for clubbing they were right on the button. It was an affluent area and the kids would definitely have had more than one outfit, so I'm surprised that the parents, who'd all had to sign up to a kind of social contract, hadn't advised their children better on perhaps more sober, less attention-seeking gear for a solemn religious service.

I don't know what the thinking was behind the 'own clothes' decision and I think blame must lie with the Head for that. But in your teens, surely it's time to begin to understand the concept of appropriate clothing?? I'm not getting into judgements about what's revealing/modest etc - please note!! Or 'telling women what they can wear'. No - I'm just saying that sometimes the message from clothes can be 'Look at ME! and other times it need to be much less attention-grabbing - when it's not about THEM.