Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

£75k salary, landlord wants parents as guarantors

233 replies

Sadleaver · 22/06/2023 17:24

I'm 35, earn £75k a year in a stable industry, as a permanent member of staff. I've been renting for 12 years and have glowing past landlord references. Excellent credit score.

Just agreed a new tenancy on a flat after a stressful 6 week hunt. It's £1250pm. Passed all the reference checks. And the letting agent is now asking for my PARENTS to be guarantors! I have to provide evidence of their income and it has to be above a certain amount. I'm honestly done with this bullshit. This is insane right?

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 23/06/2023 14:46

It's not great foe renters but Landlords are subject to tax at ridiculous levels unlike other businesses

Are they? Not in my experience and as a pp pointed out landlords can take out insurance for £150 which would cover most eventualities and can even be set against tax.

emark · 23/06/2023 14:41

Landlords are needing to do this for security reasons.

A home owner guarantor can have any debts set as a charge against their own property.

Tenants including high earners have just left properties without notice and rent arrears.

The 5 week deposit cap in most cases will not cover damages especially where pets are involved.

An abandoned property, rent arrears, rubbish clearance. Redecoration, repairs will often run into thousands.

It's not great foe renters but Landlords are subject to tax at ridiculous levels unlike other businesses

Blossomtoes · 23/06/2023 14:26

Daddydog · 23/06/2023 14:14

Not 100% sure of this as advanced rent is not part of the Deposit Scheme. Also know from friends who rent explicitly to an agency that deals with Expats that pay up front as there is no credit history and he gets this in full from Agent.

I went though all my friends paperwork and there was nothing that stated his advanced rent would be looked after in any form of Escrow like their deposit. Don't even think there is a scheme for this, so what happens if the Agency goes belly up if they are keeping the funds?

No idea. But that’s what happened when I rented my parents’ house out. The tenants paid six months rent up front and fed it into my account a month at a time.

Daddydog · 23/06/2023 14:14

Blossomtoes · 23/06/2023 08:42

LL getting 6 months up front on a 6 month AST means they could overpay mortgage at lower rates,

That isn’t how it works. The agency holds the money and passes it on to the landlord a month at a time.

Not 100% sure of this as advanced rent is not part of the Deposit Scheme. Also know from friends who rent explicitly to an agency that deals with Expats that pay up front as there is no credit history and he gets this in full from Agent.

I went though all my friends paperwork and there was nothing that stated his advanced rent would be looked after in any form of Escrow like their deposit. Don't even think there is a scheme for this, so what happens if the Agency goes belly up if they are keeping the funds?

TonysGaff · 23/06/2023 11:17

The LL was OK to let her DD be the 5th tenant without a guarantor as she was happy with 4 out of 5

@SweetBirdsong I'm sure the landlord was happy with 4/5 because usually student lets are joint and several liability contracts (ie all tenants and their guarantors are legally liable for the entire rent for the property, not just their "share") so when your BF's DD didn't pay up, the landlord could have chased her DD's friends or their guarantors for her DD's debt. Whilst it was a smart decision for your BF to avoid taking responsibility for her feckless DD's behaviour, she was actually making it the responsibility of her friends' parents. Lucky for them that the landlord didn't chase them straight away and let her DD repay the money over time. I hope her DD realises she wasn't just screwing over the landlord, she was screwing over her friends and their families.

Blossomtoes · 23/06/2023 08:42

LL getting 6 months up front on a 6 month AST means they could overpay mortgage at lower rates,

That isn’t how it works. The agency holds the money and passes it on to the landlord a month at a time.

Butchyrestingface · 23/06/2023 07:37

I had to ask my retired father to go guarantor for me four years ago at the age of 40(!). He was retired on a pension and I had just sold a property so had several hundred thousand sitting in the bank.

But hey…

Daddydog · 23/06/2023 07:29

It's awful. Totally understand why with interest rates but the Guarantor contracts LAs use are a throwback to very different times! A best friend was recently in that position and asked me to be a guarantor. Considered it but wanted time to read both the rental agreement and guarantor agreements. Mysteriously both were delayed until hours before key hand over. When the contract arrived, was chased but refused to sign until I had read every word and had space to think which delayed the move. Thank god I did as the Guarantor contract was appalling.

After the initial rental period the guarantor is stuck being a guarantor in perpetuity. Under no circumstances can they request to come off at end of contract! The renter can continue to re-new for decades and you are still listed as Guarantor.

In the end, I offered to pay 6 months rental up front which was snapped up by LL and Agent. Friend would simply pay me monthly. More fool me, not received a dime and never took any of my phone calls. Still better then being liable for paying their rent and having a black mark on my file making it hard for me to re-morgage!

The whole thing seamed fishy, with rising rates, LL getting 6 months up front on a 6 month AST means they could overpay mortgage at lower rates, and in 6 months not renew, and find another mug to do the same again. LL happy, LA happy. Renters screwed!

User195376587 · 23/06/2023 06:45

If this becomes widespread I'm sure there will be lots of insurance type companies popping up to offer guarantor services for a price so adults don't have to bother parents and other relatives. It will be another cost for renting.

PermanentTemporary · 23/06/2023 06:28

Please write to your MP?

Essentially your first post, and ask them to review tenant's rights.

ThisIsACoolUserName · 23/06/2023 06:06

SweetBirdsong · 22/06/2023 18:09

There's no way in flaming f*cking hell I would be a guarantor for ANYone.

Me too!
Some posters are saying 'My parents are dead and I don't have any aunties or uncles to ask'.
If a niece or nephew came to me asking if I'd guarantor their mortgage, my response would be 'HELL no!'

BAFlightQuestion · 22/06/2023 23:46

That’s ridiculous- I have landlord insurance for a house where the rent is over £5k a month. Total premium for a year’s cover including cover for legal proceedings and missed rental payments for up to a year: £150.

2bazookas · 22/06/2023 23:25

Probably an admin error by a numpty at the agents. I'd discuss it with the owner of the property.

TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 22/06/2023 23:10

Its probably just another scheme the Letting Agent has cooked up so they can charge yet another fee for something.. We noticed ours started adding inspections (4 per year) as soon as the law changed so they couldn't sting tenants anymore. They milking the landlord instead.

PimmsandCucumbers · 22/06/2023 22:51

dreamingbohemian · 22/06/2023 20:37

Not paying rent would not be a no-fault eviction

It can be quicker and easier to use Section 21 for someone who has stopped paying rent. That’s why the implications haven’t been thought through. If someone doesn’t pay rent it costs the landlord and can take months, through a more difficult process.

SweetBirdsong · 22/06/2023 22:47

naturemumma · 22/06/2023 20:11

This is madness. Surely they have insurance that pays if someone doesn't pay. Loads of people by the time they're 35 don't have living parents or their parents are retired. a lot of people simply don't have someone they could ask. I thought this was what insurance was for - eliminating risk. As if it isn't bad enough for renters as it is. Completely ludicrous. We wouldn't have been able to find a guarantor - but then we have a daft amount of money in savings (sold a house and haven't bought another yet) so maybe they weren't bothered. We're lucky our landlord wasn't so ridiculous about it.

This. ^ When my best friend's (BF) daughter was at uni -12-13 years ago, she needed guarantors for the student house, (for year 2, she had her first year in Halls,) and my BF wouldn't do it. Because she couldn't. She was in a precarious position financially after the credit crunch, as her DH had lost his fairly well-paid job he had had for 2 decades, and had to take a lower paid one (40% less pay.) They had about £30K of debt at the time, and struggled to make ends meet.

They said no - sorry but no. The LL is going to have to trust you to pay the rent. The other 4 people in the house (her 4 mates from uni) all had their parents be guarantors. All had quite well-off parents. On much more money than my BF- and her DH... (some £80K - £90K joint income, compared to my friend and her DH who had £25K between them.)

The other parents owned land/farms/businesses/villa in Spain/small private yacht etc, and they were happy and able to be guarantors. BF couldn't. The LL was OK to let her DD be the 5th tenant without a guarantor as she was happy with 4 out of 5, and the 5 girls were firm friends and the other 4 wouldn't move in without the 5th girl. (BF DD.)

Turns out it was a wise decision as my BF's DD pissed about with her money. Got bursaries and extra monies as her parents were on low money, and spent the whole term's money in 6 weeks. By 5 months in she had only paid 2 months rent. The landlord was patient and tolerant, and waited for her to catch up - which she did. She was straight by 8 months...

But if my friend had been a guarantor, the landlord would possibly have chased her for the £1125 rent owed. (3 months.) She was on the bones of her arse at the time, and already struggling to pay mortgage, loans, overdraft fees, bills etc, and had more outgoings than income... And debt collectors chasing her for £1125 would have finished her off.

Unless you have multiple 10s of 1000s surplus income, it's incredibly foolish to be a guarantor.

LlynTegid · 22/06/2023 21:58

I wonder if you could speak to the owner of the property directly, I wonder if he or she knows about this stupidity?

Uokhon · 22/06/2023 21:44

That’s ridiculous. Do you have enough savings to pay up front? My last two tenants have paid 6 and 12 months upfront as the competition was fierce.

Stravaig · 22/06/2023 21:32

Laugh in their face and tell them you're going to take your extremely stable income and impeccable tenant history elsewhere!

BCCGoAway · 22/06/2023 21:31

This should not be allowed. It’s discriminatory against immigrants to ask for parents (in the U.K.) or a “U.K. homeowner” to be a guarantor to be able to rent a home. And direct discrimination against immigrants is indirect discrimination against ethnic minority groups.

FancyFran · 22/06/2023 21:25

@Doggymummar
I worked in Brighton, my nephew lives there. There are shared ownership in Shoreham on sea. Would that be an option? At least you own 50%+ and can build equity.

Dibbydoos · 22/06/2023 21:23

I have no words....

TurquoiseDress · 22/06/2023 21:22

This is total batshit bonkers!

Seriously, has the rental market come to this now?!

TurquoiseDress · 22/06/2023 21:21

BatildaB · 22/06/2023 17:38

Can you ask in return for a check that the landlord’s mum can cover any repairs that the landlord can’t stretch to?

GrinGrinGrin

I dare you to do it!!

User195376587 · 22/06/2023 21:21

We are retired so couldn't anyway