Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the UK economy is utterly broken…

208 replies

Paul2023 · 22/06/2023 09:02

Things were never the same after the crash of 2007/2008. Austerity was imposed with the Conservatives in 2010 and things never really recovered after that.

Of course we had Brexit and the pandemic.

We’ve had best part of 15 years of cuts to public services, of which we saw services decimated. We’re now seeing the results.

The Bank of England continues to raise interest rates, yet inflation still ain’t coming down fast enough. Yet, most people with mortgages and who privately rent ( which is most of the population) will be poorer as a result of this.

I think the county is in denial. The economy is in a poor state and I don’t think anyone in government ( who ever it is) has the answer. It’s just a case of sticking plasters over the wounds to fight another day.

Here’s an email a poster got from his father , from another forum I’m on;

“I hate to be the bearer of bad news, but someone must point out the grim truth facing the UK; we're going bust.

The UK has just hit a new and totally unwanted milestone, as the country now owes more money than its entire economy is worth - and it’s only going to grow as government borrowing continues to soar. The UK is particularly vulnerable because much of our debt is linked to inflation, and the cost of it rises with prices. Inflation is not stabilising because of wage demands, pension and supply chain increases.

It's a major symbolic moment but one that is in danger of getting lost, as the cost-of-living crisis rages unchecked

and homeowners panic over how they're going to pay their soaring mortgage bills.

The government continues to spend a lot more than the nation collectively earns, forcing it to fund everyday spending by borrowing money.

Taxes may be at a 70-year high – and set to rise even higher – but it's still not enough. As the nation gets sicker and older, the shortfall will grow.

We’re a nation in denial. So are France, Italy and even the US, but that doesn't make it right!”

Im just so scared for the future of our kids that I really can’t see how things will ever really get better. There’s going to be a bigger population of older people and less people paying tax. It explains why the government is so keen to get older people back into work!

Does anyone else really worry about the state of the UK?

Inflation remains ‘sky high’ at 8.7 percent

Prices have continued to go up, piling on the pressure on people's already cash-strapped budgets.

http://e.express.co.uk/_act/link.php?mId=RM68163407139974513zzzzz64646ae9ace71ccec8fcb135414adb6f5d60699ae1824ebc0a4dc5d820005826c1&tId=32349331

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Blossomtoes · 23/06/2023 14:38

Paul2023 · 23/06/2023 10:28

Were variable rates more popular in the 80s and 90s then?

They were the only rates. There were no fixes or trackers then.

GasPanic · 23/06/2023 14:36

Paul2023 · 22/06/2023 09:02

Things were never the same after the crash of 2007/2008. Austerity was imposed with the Conservatives in 2010 and things never really recovered after that.

Of course we had Brexit and the pandemic.

We’ve had best part of 15 years of cuts to public services, of which we saw services decimated. We’re now seeing the results.

The Bank of England continues to raise interest rates, yet inflation still ain’t coming down fast enough. Yet, most people with mortgages and who privately rent ( which is most of the population) will be poorer as a result of this.

I think the county is in denial. The economy is in a poor state and I don’t think anyone in government ( who ever it is) has the answer. It’s just a case of sticking plasters over the wounds to fight another day.

Here’s an email a poster got from his father , from another forum I’m on;

“I hate to be the bearer of bad news, but someone must point out the grim truth facing the UK; we're going bust.

The UK has just hit a new and totally unwanted milestone, as the country now owes more money than its entire economy is worth - and it’s only going to grow as government borrowing continues to soar. The UK is particularly vulnerable because much of our debt is linked to inflation, and the cost of it rises with prices. Inflation is not stabilising because of wage demands, pension and supply chain increases.

It's a major symbolic moment but one that is in danger of getting lost, as the cost-of-living crisis rages unchecked

and homeowners panic over how they're going to pay their soaring mortgage bills.

The government continues to spend a lot more than the nation collectively earns, forcing it to fund everyday spending by borrowing money.

Taxes may be at a 70-year high – and set to rise even higher – but it's still not enough. As the nation gets sicker and older, the shortfall will grow.

We’re a nation in denial. So are France, Italy and even the US, but that doesn't make it right!”

Im just so scared for the future of our kids that I really can’t see how things will ever really get better. There’s going to be a bigger population of older people and less people paying tax. It explains why the government is so keen to get older people back into work!

Does anyone else really worry about the state of the UK?

Compare :

"Things were never the same after the crash of 2007/2008. Austerity was imposed with the Conservatives in 2010 and things never really recovered after that.

Of course we had Brexit and the pandemic.

We’ve had best part of 15 years of cuts to public services, of which we saw services decimated. We’re now seeing the results."

With :

“I hate to be the bearer of bad news, but someone must point out the grim truth facing the UK; we're going bust.

The UK has just hit a new and totally unwanted milestone, as the country now owes more money than its entire economy is worth - and it’s only going to grow as government borrowing continues to soar. The UK is particularly vulnerable because much of our debt is linked to inflation, and the cost of it rises with prices. Inflation is not stabilising because of wage demands, pension and supply chain increases."

So here is a question. If the Tories hadn't done austerity during the 2010s, would we owe more or less money than we do now ? Or to put it more simply, would we be more or less bust ?

There are three arguments to this. One is that the government money spent increases GDP, boosts growth, and that growth compensates for the debt. I am yet to be convinced because I don't believe any government spends money to best effect (in fact quite the opposite).

The other is that austerity actually may have cut services, but actually got us to a much better fiscal position that we would have been in otherwise and that if the Tories hadn't done austerity then the load put on the economy by covid would have really trashed our debt levels (in fact if Corbyn had got in a while before covid then it would have been really interesting to see where our debt levels would have got to, since he proposed much higher spending levels than say Johnson in his budgets).

The third is we could have used taxation rather than borrowing to fund spending instead of austerity. Given the complaints people have about taxation at the moment, its not clear to me that that would have been very popular, and anyway that isn't (supposed to be) part of Tory ideology, tax and spend are not what people voted for when they put the Tories in power.

Personally I think the austerity through the early 2010s was a good example of Keynesian economics - reining in government spending when in economic terms things were "relatively" OK. GDP growth during that period was pretty stunted, but we never dipped into a prolonged recession. Services obviously got badly hit, but as you say - we are getting poorer. The consequences of being poorer are you can afford less, unless you are either willing to pay more (few people seem to be) or borrow more and put it on the kids slate.

Emotionalstorm · 23/06/2023 14:09

Paul2023 · 23/06/2023 12:32

What’s ridiculous?

The UK is a wealthy country with a strong economy. Every developed country in the world has inflation, housing, aging population etc issues. There's nothing broken or wrong with a UK economy we are just going through a natural part of the economic boom and bust cycle. We are most likely doing better than most.

Paul2023 · 23/06/2023 12:32

Emotionalstorm · 23/06/2023 12:29

What a ridiculous comment. Other countries have the same issues. It's a worldwide thing.

What’s ridiculous?

OP posts:
Emotionalstorm · 23/06/2023 12:29

What a ridiculous comment. Other countries have the same issues. It's a worldwide thing.

Paul2023 · 23/06/2023 12:26

The base rate could hit 6% by later this year. It hasn’t been at 6% since 2001.

OP posts:
SunnyEgg · 23/06/2023 10:31

From an economist (former BoE) the model the BoE use now has become somewhat out of date, in his view due to the change. Ie many more on fixed than previously

I haven’t looked up the exact numbers though

Paul2023 · 23/06/2023 10:28

Were variable rates more popular in the 80s and 90s then?

OP posts:
SunnyEgg · 23/06/2023 09:54

Which makes it a difficult tool to use

SunnyEgg · 23/06/2023 09:53

It is a lot but I’d say more people were on variable rates back then so these will hit people hard, but quite a few will be protected - either fixed, or older and no mortgage

Paul2023 · 23/06/2023 09:50

An economist on Talk TV said yesterday that these interest rate rises could actually be worse than the high interest rates of the late 80s and early 90s because house prices are soon much higher.

Interest rates of 13% on a house worth £60k or 5% on a house worth £350k.

A very similar problem. People’s mortgages are going to go up an average of 3-4 k per year. And people don’t have it.

The Bank of England has already said they could go up again in August.

OP posts:
Paul2023 · 23/06/2023 09:46

Surely it’s not economically sound to have high house prices and high interest rates?

This will kill off first time buyers and many people will want to sell to move into cheaper houses, cheaper areas. But they’ll struggle to sell because people won’t be able to buy the houses.

OP posts:
GimmeCoffee · 23/06/2023 07:39

We are a sovereign country. It’s all a smokescreen, including austerity. I wish people would learn about Modern Monetary Theory. Those in power could fund everything properly and fix the mess but they don’t want to. Remember the magic billions suddenly produced for the DUP ‘partnership’ or the millions for track & trace etc! But they want to keep the minions and plebs poor. It’s been the same throughout history.

Inthedarkagain · 22/06/2023 22:27

It's the global economy, not just the UK, but yes it is pretty bad. We may have a sovereign debt crisis, but so will other countries. Some have defaulted already.

I think the last few years have been partially by design (I think people made the most of a crisis) and has been about the transfer of wealth and creating an economic crisis where CBDCs are the only viable option. Sadly this means people will suffer, just so this can happen.

So yeah, it is shit, but the system we currently have has made the average person feel wealthy when in fact they aren't. I think some people are in for a shock.

Chatillon · 22/06/2023 22:02

Endlesssummer2022 · 22/06/2023 21:54

No they really are. If you genuinely think we are in this mess only because of them, then I have a bridge to sell you. They sped up the decline, but we were already declining and still are.

Why do you think Sunak is reluctant to throw them under the bus? He lost more than they did when he was Chancellor. We’ve had poor economic management for some time. It didn’t only start last year.

They were the Emperor's Clothes for sure. Still devalued us by a few %.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 22/06/2023 21:57

I agree we’re in a mess. But they made it worse.

Endlesssummer2022 · 22/06/2023 21:54

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 22/06/2023 21:43

Truss and Kwarteng are convenient scapegoats😂😂😂

Yeah, ok👌🏻

No they really are. If you genuinely think we are in this mess only because of them, then I have a bridge to sell you. They sped up the decline, but we were already declining and still are.

Why do you think Sunak is reluctant to throw them under the bus? He lost more than they did when he was Chancellor. We’ve had poor economic management for some time. It didn’t only start last year.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 22/06/2023 21:43

Truss and Kwarteng are convenient scapegoats😂😂😂

Yeah, ok👌🏻

Endlesssummer2022 · 22/06/2023 21:34

Chatillon · 22/06/2023 21:22

Most reinsurers had been in Bermuda for decades. It is a major reinsurance hub. Brexit would have had an effect for sure. Trussenomics also has sent the jitters round.

Truss and Kwarteng 'Ratnered' the UK sadly.

Truss and Kwarteng are convenient scapegoats. They sped up the trajectory, but we were going down this road way before they came into play. Inflation was skyrocketing before she became PM, and productivity had stalled way before. In fact they hit the nail on the head that the issue was productivity, it’s just they were Brextemists so had fantasy solutions to fix this.

Sunak (the more presentable Brextemist) can’t fix this, nor can Andrew Bailey. I would never trust a Bank of England governor, who was a Brexiter , with the countries finances as they’ve already proven they don’t understand trade, markets or money.

wheresmymojo · 22/06/2023 21:25

Obviously I realise that. But we weren't....and only moved because of Brexit.

Previous employers were insurers, EMEA head office was in London which employed hundreds of people. Due to Brexit the EMEA region ceased to exist. The Head Office closed. All European business is now run from Luxembourg.

Chatillon · 22/06/2023 21:22

wheresmymojo · 22/06/2023 20:56

I work for a reinsurer - global company, based out of the UK. Very high turnover, would have been a high tax income for HMRC.

After Brexit threatened the global trading model the HQ was moved to Bermuda and I image a lot of tax income with it.

Most reinsurers had been in Bermuda for decades. It is a major reinsurance hub. Brexit would have had an effect for sure. Trussenomics also has sent the jitters round.

Truss and Kwarteng 'Ratnered' the UK sadly.

JamSandle · 22/06/2023 21:21

I think it's shit everywhere. But different flavours.

Theoldgreygoose · 22/06/2023 21:12

Dinnerdinner1 · 22/06/2023 18:27

Who’s savings are getting interest on them? I don’t know anyone in that situation.

Surely if interest rates are going up then savers should be benefitting? I'm not in the UK but my savings are getting interest in the region of 5/6%, every time interest rates rise I get (a little bit) more.

wheresmymojo · 22/06/2023 20:56

I work for a reinsurer - global company, based out of the UK. Very high turnover, would have been a high tax income for HMRC.

After Brexit threatened the global trading model the HQ was moved to Bermuda and I image a lot of tax income with it.

Chatillon · 22/06/2023 20:11

GCalltheway · 22/06/2023 19:59

Many economists believe we are reaching the peak, so it might be worthwhile considering.

They will then have to try and re inflate the economy.

Bailey should be sacked

They will then have to try and re inflate the economy.

With the fullest of respect, read the room and smell the coffee.

There is no more reflating of the UK economy. QE is dead. We owe too much. We owe £2.6 Trillion. There is no more Truss / Kwarteng economics. We are never going to be a Singapore. We were once, briefly and inside the EU, but those days are over. Ireland is a 'Singapore' and Luxembourg is a 'Singapore' and they will sap the financial services out of the UK no doubt other financial centres in the EU will pop up and my bet is Poland and Romania.

The UK is overvalued. We have believed in the value of residential property too much to prop the economy up for 30 years. It is like a soap opera.

We do have some amazing industries, but the more we try to align personal wealth as a measure of our interest in the housing market the weaker we have become.

A crash is coming. This time we are alone.