Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My SIL makes me feel uncomfortable

80 replies

mummypie17 · 21/06/2023 22:21

I am close with my brother and I generally get along with his wife. We have a WhatsApp group together and try to meet up when we can. However, she sometimes indirectly makes comments about my parenting and compares it to her own sister (who she admires deeply).

Some examples:

I put my ds in nursery when he was 2 years old whilst I was working. SIL's sister didn't put her ds into pre-school until he was nearly 4 (which is absolutely not an issue as to each their own). She will tell me that it's so much better for kids to not go to nursery until they're older and she'll ensure she does the same as her sister.

I have never sleep trained my 2 DS. My SIL will tell me how she's sleep-training her DD like her sister did and I should consider it to make my life easier.

I gave my 5 year old DS a chocolate cookie and she commented that her sister's DC don't even know what chocolate is.

I obviously won't say anything to my brother as I don't want to cause a rift. My brother has told me that his wife has always been in awe of her older sister. This is fine but I don't see what it has to do with me.

Would it be unreasonable for me to just distance myself from her as sometimes after speaking to her, I feel uncomfortable?

OP posts:
ButterflyOil · 22/06/2023 11:05

mummypie17 · 22/06/2023 08:06

I don't usually have a problem with speaking my mind but when it comes to family, I don't want to rock the boat. I don't think she wants a close relationship with me (which is fine). I do want us to have a cordial/civil relationship. However, my DB tells me she is very complimentary about me when talking to him 🤷

Urgh I hate this type of behaviour, I find it quite manipulative. Last time this happened to me the person in question was a colleague and was fucking vile to me, undermined me, escalated weird and horrible bitchy behaviour - and yet absolutely praised me to high heaven to your manager, other colleagues etc. Like OTT how amazing I am and how much respect they had for me. Which meant when I raised complaints about their behaviour for months I got responses like oh but x thinks you’re amazing, they respect you so much, they really like you, they mean well really. Bullshit, ‘x’ new exactly what they were doing and used that technique to bully people, me especially.

What I learned from that and wish i’d raised at the time was that if someone really does think that highly of you and respects you they would not repeatedly criticise you or put you down or make bitchy comments.

WonderingWanda · 22/06/2023 11:04

She sounds like a judgemental twat op and I would ignore her. I always think a 'Good for you' in a kindly, 'oh isn't it sweet that you've got all these good ideas that you think will work' kind of voice, is a good response to shut someone like that down.

Splishsploshsplash · 22/06/2023 10:57

You see YOUR mum every day so what exactly is the issue?

Honestly I’ve had enough of you criticising my parenting. Stop already.

Ah… yet another criticism of me. Lovely.

You need to bite back. She’s a bitch.

Northernladdette · 22/06/2023 10:41

Be firm, here’s a couple of tag lines you may like to use:
”Each to their own”
”It wouldn’t do for us all to be the same”
Finaly “Mind your own business “ 😊

Normalweirdo · 22/06/2023 10:41

It sounds like she is probably insecure in her own parenting skills. Confident happy people don't try to put others down. She obviously looks to her sister for "the right way" and is perhaps bringing it up with you because she's not 100% convinced it's right. I'd keep reminding her every child/family is different and it's great to see people finding their own parenting styles. Honestly, just smile and brush it off. It's a hidden compliment that she has to raise it with to gauge your thoughts.

Softoprider · 22/06/2023 10:39

I do not know why some women behave like this. I am sure most of us will have experienced something near to this when we have had children. I think the best way to react to the snidey comments is to smile and change the subject. Never react directly or answer her in context. She sounds awfully boring to me.

OhBling · 22/06/2023 10:38

Mmm, you say this is more recent. As in, since she had her own baby? I also find this sort of thing tedious, but it may well be that she's trying to engage with you as a mother but as her children are younger, she needs to use her sister's advice?

I agree with others though that the solution is to respond to those comments but only in a very brief, simple way and move on. "that's lovely that your sister was able to do what worked for her and her family. I'm very happy that DS is in nursery and he loves it so it's a win all round." etc.

Gothambutnotahamster · 22/06/2023 10:29

Grumpigal · 22/06/2023 07:01

She sounds like an absolute bitch to be honest.

If you’re close to your brother why can’t you say “Have I done something to upset “wife” because she is really passive aggressive towards me, it’s starting to really upset me - do you know why she’s doing it”

Be prepared to give examples.

Next time she says something like “oh MIL will be too busy with you etc” cut her off and call her out ”I’m not sure what you mean sorry - why is it an issue I’m spending time with my Mum, do you think I am abusing her free time?”

people like this need calling out! She knows exactly what she’s doing

Completely agree with this.

Mylifeislikeaboatrace · 22/06/2023 10:20

She and her sister are going to be in for a shock as their kids get older, parties, play dates, puberty and god forbid teens.....

greencheetah · 22/06/2023 10:07

I think she sounds like a bitch.

I would see her less. If she says anything annoying, either put her in her place, or laugh and say “If you say so.”

Couldntthinkofausername24 · 22/06/2023 09:49

Gawwwwd! Don't you wish you could just turn round to her and say 'I wish you would shut the fuck up'

My son is 3 and loves chocolate in moderation GASP!!!

MRex · 22/06/2023 08:25

See through it to the reasons for the comments. Where it's insecurity that your DM cares more for your child than hers, it's worth addressing openly.

Iloveacurry · 22/06/2023 08:16

You need to reply back with ‘Good for you’, ‘Each to their own I guess’. If she says things about your mum seeing or helping you, just say ‘Yes it is nice very a close relationship with mum, just like you do with your mum and sister’.

Caradonna · 22/06/2023 08:15

However, my DB tells me she is very complimentary about me when talking to him

Are you discussing your DSIL with DB - his loyalties are with her.
Honestly having babies rearing children is a minefield. Perhaps see less of her?
Before you know it they will be at school and life will be very different. They aren't little for long (I know everyone says this but it's true!) they'll grow up regardless of what mother does what.

mummypie17 · 22/06/2023 08:08

My DB isn't close with my DH but they get along and genuinely seem respect each other.

OP posts:
mummypie17 · 22/06/2023 08:06

I don't usually have a problem with speaking my mind but when it comes to family, I don't want to rock the boat. I don't think she wants a close relationship with me (which is fine). I do want us to have a cordial/civil relationship. However, my DB tells me she is very complimentary about me when talking to him 🤷

OP posts:
Lionjek · 22/06/2023 07:55

This reply has been deleted

This looks like spam

GabriellaMontez · 22/06/2023 07:49

mummypie17 · 22/06/2023 07:41

She's actually really close with her own mother and sees her everyday (at the moment she's on maternity leave).

The thing is I love my brother and my niece and I do like my SIL and want us to get on. She's always friendly with me. It's more recently that I'm getting these comments. It is getting me a bit down as it makes me feel incompetent when I'm usually confident and have a good job in Youth Work.

Does she want to be close to you? Are these honestly, friendly comments?

Because they sound unpleasant to me.

Chocolatelover3 · 22/06/2023 07:49

I’d say from what I’ve read in your posts she seems quite jealous / insecure. It’s easy for her to say now what she will and won’t do with her child but there’s no way she can know until her daughter is a bit older. There’s nothing wrong with her idolising her sister but the way she talks about things sounds like she doesn’t have her own mind.

I would flip it round and instead of feeling uncomfortable for yourself I’d start feeling uncomfortable and sorry for your SIL - she must be so sad and insecure that she needs to make these comments to you and live her life through her sisters choices.

GabriellaMontez · 22/06/2023 07:47

She's a dick!

Try this.
"Doesn't know what chocolate is, how ridiculous!"

Sounds like she says whatever she likes, no matter how rude/smug. Why are you mute? Why don't you also speak your mind?

ThisIsACoolUserName · 22/06/2023 07:43

Grey rock it OP.

With people like this, reply to their every comment with "Good for you", "Great", "Nice one", with a relaxed smile on your face.

At the same time you must continue exactly as you were, taking none of their comments on board.

It drives them nuts!

mummypie17 · 22/06/2023 07:41

She's actually really close with her own mother and sees her everyday (at the moment she's on maternity leave).

The thing is I love my brother and my niece and I do like my SIL and want us to get on. She's always friendly with me. It's more recently that I'm getting these comments. It is getting me a bit down as it makes me feel incompetent when I'm usually confident and have a good job in Youth Work.

OP posts:
Kingdedede · 22/06/2023 07:29

bookworm44 · 22/06/2023 07:05

Why is that so unbelievable to you? I agree each to their own but why do you think it's not possible for a 4 year old to not have been introduced to chocolate yet?

Has this child never been to a birthday party, had a Christmas, read a book or watched TV? Unless they live in a very isolated bubble they know what chocolate is! My 4 year has never had sweets, but he knows what they are because he lives in the real world.

ThisWormHasTurned · 22/06/2023 07:23

When I got unsolicited advice I had a stock answer. Now bear in mind I’m neurodivergent (ADHD and Autistic) and I believe DD is too. It’s been easy to parent her a lot of the time (she’s 10) but I have found my own style. Any time someone makes any comment like this I say ‘Ah well, we parent the individual child the best way we can’. For example, my sister’s two kids are totally different both from each other and from DD. We will share parenting ideas/strategies/books but we know only certain things will help.
I think you’re being too polite with SIL. She keeps making these comments because she can! Pick a stock phrase, stick with it, grey rock basically. Don’t give her any reaction til she gets bored of doing it.

Caradonna · 22/06/2023 07:20

Please ignore the childrearing comments - anyone who pontificates about how they will bring up their DCs is in for a shock once they have one.
She is obviously jealous of your time with DM but really needs to suck it up. How can't she see that some people are close to their DM's?

Swipe left for the next trending thread