Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ultra-Highly Processed Foods

280 replies

TheRealMBJ · 21/06/2023 21:25

At risk of sounding defensive here but I almost always cook from scratch and very seldom resort to pre-prepared or oven dinners (,maybe once a month)

However, all of this talk recently that demonises Ultra-processed foods is another stick to beat working mothers with.

Sometimes I feel something has to give and I can't always plan, shop, execute a fully cooked from scratch meal every night of the week.

YABU - Get your Arese into Gear woman and organise your life

YANBU - this is just another way to make woman feel guilty. Get the fish fingers out!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Bubbles254 · 23/06/2023 13:37

GraysPapaya · 21/06/2023 22:23

The thing is with this UPF research, how are the US cancer rates not FAR higher than here? The food over there is packed full of crap, I was shocked when I visited recently the amount of EU banned foods and pesticides they allow. I’m fairly normal by UK standards, I mainly cook from scratch but do use tinned goods, cereals, bread etc. over there they had cheese in a spray can, and sugar in their bread! My American friend thought nothing of getting a donut for breakfast, and eating out several times a week.

Or is it a ticking time bomb? I wonder if Americans have seen these studies?

Cancer depends on a lot of different factors and the rate in the US is within the top 10 in the world. Other countries with higher rates tend to have a lot more smokers or in the case of some (e. g. Denmark which is top worlswide for cancer) very good diagnosis rates.

lljkk · 23/06/2023 13:30

I must be like one of those "smoked 90 fags a day & lived to be 101" people, then, only high UPF not lots fags.

Iloveanicegarden · 23/06/2023 10:08

Many moons ago when I was teaching Food and Nutrition I remember talking about E numbers (big issue back then) and telling the students that although the chemicals had been tested individually, there hadn't been any work on combinations and that their inclusion in foods was a ticking time bomb.

And here we are. Dr Chris Van Tuleken? did some personal research on the cumulative effect of consuming an almost totally UPF diet. The effects on systems in his body were bad enough but the effect on his brain was shit scary. That alone is a good reason to stop eating crap.

lemonchiffonpie · 23/06/2023 09:54

Crispten · 21/06/2023 21:25

Eat what you want, food is food

No, it isn't. The longterm health/disease effects of many processed foods is well documented. The links with nitrates in processed meats - like bacon, ham, sausages, hot dogs, etc - and cancer of the digestive track, for example. If your diet is primarily UPF then you are probably not getting enough fibre, and your gut microbiome will have low diversity, leading to any number of inflammatory processes in the body, and setting you up for a lousy old age and/or middle age.

wwyd2021medicine · 23/06/2023 09:19

Here's my take fwiw
I eat unprocessed food and processed food (tinned tuna, frozen veg etc) for the vast majority of my diet. I found myself getting a bit obsessive when I was looking for a non-upf mayonnaise or making my own and thought that it was madness. So I use table sauces that are upf. The bread from below sounds fine too.

Such things as upf table sauces are such a small part of my diet, tbh I don't think they matter.

When cooking, I use tomato purée - maybe upf but again, a relatively small amount of the dish I'm cooking. Ditto coconut milk

Typical day:
Breakfast- Greek yoghurt and fruit
Lunch - tuna, salad, mayonnaise
Dinner fried sea bass/baked salmon or some meat with veg and potatoes/rice/pasta/salad

It's not onerous tbh

I have however been eating this way for a long time. It also means that I don't need to look at many aisles in the supermarket as I only really buy meat, fish, fruit, veg and dairy (and table sauces 😊)

But I only have adult DC and if they want other stuff, they can sort it themselves. DH has cereal which he buys for himself when he does the shopping

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 23/06/2023 08:14

ArseMenagerie · 22/06/2023 23:12

It’s not too hard to eat only unprocessed or processed food rather than ultra processed. You won’t get malnutrition :)
so a veg diet is brilliant say you had roast veg with hummus and loadsa salad : great. The hummus is processed if you buy it from a shop and it is posh brand or make it yourself. As in one process: whizzing it up.
shop bought pitta bread: ultra processed so you’d avoid that and make your own

Bread is not necessarily an ultra high processed food. These are the ingredients of the pitta breads I buy, which aren't the cheapest, but are very good. Mostly recognisable as things I could buy myself.

Wheat Flour (Fortified with Calcium, Iron, Niacin, Thiamin), Water, Wholemeal Wheat Flour, Seed & Grain Mix (5%) (Malted Wheat Flakes Golden Linseed, Sunflower Seeds, Brown Linseed, Pinhead Oats, Millet Seeds, Poppy seeds, Quinoa, Rye), Wheat Bran, Wheat Fibre, Wheat Gluten, Yeast, Fermented Wheat Flour, Sea Salt

Making bread is great, and not difficult, but you do have to build in time for it to rise (if using yeast), and that's why it's not that quick. Soda bread is much quicker - rising agents there are bicarbonate of soda and cream of tartar - does using those make soda bread UHP?

GCWorkNightmare · 23/06/2023 07:59

TheRealMBJ · 21/06/2023 21:39

Yes, I am sure the actual research is isn't meant to do this but when one person has the responsibility of feeding a family alongside working full-time and all other family organisation.

It doesn’t have to be like that though.

My parents both worked full time and it was my dad that did all the cooking for the family.

My husband and I both work full time (I’m away 2-4 days a week with my work). There’s no housework that requires genitals (that I’m aware of) so it’s all shared between us.

I don’t know why so many women accept such a shitty deal in their marriages that they end up responsible for all domestic tasks.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 23/06/2023 07:57

Nicecow · 23/06/2023 04:26

Huh? Assume you've heard of fruit and vegetables and meat? Of course you can eat unprocessed food, it takes a bit of effort though.

The post I was replying to said why is it so difficult not eating anything processed at all. I was giving my opinion on that.

Processing includes all forms of cooking and preservation. We need protein. Most forms of protein either need cooking to be safe and/or digestible, or they taste much better and/or are far easier to digest if cooked. I for one would not want to eat raw meat or eggs. Cheese is presumably ruled out, ditto smoked/tinned/frozen fish and meat. Unpasteurised milk? Not many of us have access to that, or would be happy to drink/eat it. That leaves nuts, seeds and some grains, raw fish (expensive), maybe obscure forms of dried meat that could be chewed on.

It must be next door to impossible to eat a raw food diet in the UK and remain healthy. I can't imagine how it could be combined with a full-time job and family responsibilities unless you are a market gardener eating your own produce.

This is a completely separate issue from avoiding ultra high processed foods, which is what this thread is about.

lljkk · 23/06/2023 07:55

An omelette takes 5 mins. Three eggs, grate some cheese, add some chopped tomatoes or mushrooms, spring onions.

I'm inadequate. I couldn't get all that together & cooked & cleaned up in 5 minutes. 15-20, maybe. Much more if distracted by small children. And I'm lousy at making omelets. They always turn into scrambled eggs. I like those alright, especially with lots of ketchup. Easier to just skip a meal or eat a banana instead.

I help adult DS make home-made pasta sauce sometimes. It's very fast. < 15 minutes with cleaning up time. That's With 2 of us helping. And then he has to worry about eating it quickly, keeping it refridgerated, before it goes mouldy. There's a list of special ingredients to make sure we get in for him. If we don't use them all up on that particular batch of sauce, then we have to worry about using up those ingredients before they go off.

DH & I smile supportively and actually think "Wow what a messy faff."

Nicecow · 23/06/2023 04:26

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 22/06/2023 15:24

Because you are not one of a tiny band of hunter gatherers wandering across the plains eating roots, seeds, nuts, berries and leaves supplemented with the odd bit of foraged egg or insects (raw) or fish, shellfish and meat from hunting/fishing/trapping. Like it or not, most humans are hundreds of thousands of years on from those days and agriculture, cooking and other forms of processing are absolutely essential to keep the human population alive, now there are so many of us. Eating unprocessed food is more or less impossible now and would put you at high risk of malnutrition.

Huh? Assume you've heard of fruit and vegetables and meat? Of course you can eat unprocessed food, it takes a bit of effort though.

lemonchiffonpie · 23/06/2023 03:39

It's kind of important.

More than 1.3bn adults will have diabetes by 2050, study predicts | Diabetes | The Guardian

But fish fingers or frozen peas or canned whatever is not UHP, it's just processed.

MintJulia · 23/06/2023 03:33

I'm a single working mum. Who says I have to fully prepare a meal?

An omelette takes 5 mins. Three eggs, grate some cheese, add some chopped tomatoes or mushrooms, spring onions. With some wholemeal bread.!

Or a defrosted homemade curry. 5 mins.

Or a tin of sardines in tomato sauce with some fresh broccoli florets, mixed into wholemeal pasta. 5 mins

Or just a salad with olives & nice bread. 5 mins.

Phoebo · 23/06/2023 03:11

ArseMenagerie · 22/06/2023 23:12

It’s not too hard to eat only unprocessed or processed food rather than ultra processed. You won’t get malnutrition :)
so a veg diet is brilliant say you had roast veg with hummus and loadsa salad : great. The hummus is processed if you buy it from a shop and it is posh brand or make it yourself. As in one process: whizzing it up.
shop bought pitta bread: ultra processed so you’d avoid that and make your own

It all takes time. Time, time, time that no one has.

Coyoacan · 23/06/2023 03:08

Its a well known fact, that ultra processed food is bad for us and you arguing that we should not mention facts because someone will have hurty feelings is madness. It is just like the way they don't want us to say that breast is best because some neurotic woman who couldn't breastfeed might feel guilty about it.

Maybe when we have the facts, we could talk to our bosses, governments and unions to see how working hours could be adjusted to give people time to cook, for example.

Franticbutterfly · 23/06/2023 01:00

YABU - we are all aware (and have been for quite a while now) that stuff that comes out of packets probably isn't particularly good for the body.

I think it's good there is more awareness about UPFs and the damage they do. Knowledge is power and all that!

Judgyjudgy · 23/06/2023 00:44

OrwellianTimes · 21/06/2023 21:28

Scientific fact isn’t something to best mothers with sticks with. We as a society have fallen hook line and sinker for every trick the food industry has come up with.

As a mother I’ve no flipping idea what to do about it.

This. I've always been dubious about foods and what I feed my baby, and wonder about so many issues that children have that simply didn't exist 40 years ago. What's even more depressing is that food I thought was ok is not. I would love to cook from scratch but don't really have the time, inclination or skills but I will try to so this more.

Guineapigwoes · 23/06/2023 00:40

@wejammin its not easy, unfortunately the modern world is set up so we rely on convenience food. I’d take the hummous and bread but skip the crap like Doritos/cereal/biscuits/Pringles etc

wejammin · 22/06/2023 23:17

@ArseMenagerie this is exactly what I mean though, I'm vegan, it's really not as easy as you think. 'All you have to do' is whip up your own hummus (or spend a fortune on a fancy brand) and make your own pitta bread. Easy peasy?!

ArseMenagerie · 22/06/2023 23:12

It’s not too hard to eat only unprocessed or processed food rather than ultra processed. You won’t get malnutrition :)
so a veg diet is brilliant say you had roast veg with hummus and loadsa salad : great. The hummus is processed if you buy it from a shop and it is posh brand or make it yourself. As in one process: whizzing it up.
shop bought pitta bread: ultra processed so you’d avoid that and make your own

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 22/06/2023 17:15

Traditional block butter isn't ultra highly processed. It's made from cream, usually from cows' milk. That's it. Some butter has salt added.

Spreadable butter usually has vegetable oil and water added. I'm not sure that makes it UHP.

Lilyhatesjaz · 22/06/2023 16:56

I thought the ultra processed foods we should be limiting were things like chocolate bars, crisps, biscuits the worst types of chicken nuggets and sausages made of ground up bones.
Not things like fish fingers, butter and coconut milk.
You can make your own oat milk but it won't be fortified with the minerals and vitamins you would normally get in cows milk so it's probably better to buy it.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 22/06/2023 15:24

Because you are not one of a tiny band of hunter gatherers wandering across the plains eating roots, seeds, nuts, berries and leaves supplemented with the odd bit of foraged egg or insects (raw) or fish, shellfish and meat from hunting/fishing/trapping. Like it or not, most humans are hundreds of thousands of years on from those days and agriculture, cooking and other forms of processing are absolutely essential to keep the human population alive, now there are so many of us. Eating unprocessed food is more or less impossible now and would put you at high risk of malnutrition.

Royalbloo · 22/06/2023 14:14

I'm on day four now of not eating anything processed at all. It's been interesting and not that difficult until today when I forgot my lunch.

Popped to the supermarket and ended up with boiled eggs in a pot (I get these are somewhat 'processed'), carrot sticks, apples and a banana. Urgh! Why is it so difficult?!

LysHastighed · 22/06/2023 12:15

Kanaloa · 22/06/2023 07:57

I know people on mumsnet are totally obsessed with food to a worrying extent but in my experience most people just eat normal meals and snacks daily. I think over worrying about every morsel is actually as damaging as anything else. Some people agonise over everything to the point that I’ve seen someone call a mother on here ‘lazy’ for giving her child a ham and cheese toastie, and insist they should have ‘just whipped up’ some salmon and cous cous with sliced avocado. Totally out of touch.

Normal people accept that some foods are processed, and mix them up with fresh foods too. Balance.

Processed foods are not relevant here. This is about ultraprocessed food

Lcb123 · 22/06/2023 09:16

It’s a fact backed up by scientific evidence, I think you’re just reading it a certain way.

Swipe left for the next trending thread