Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ultra-Highly Processed Foods

280 replies

TheRealMBJ · 21/06/2023 21:25

At risk of sounding defensive here but I almost always cook from scratch and very seldom resort to pre-prepared or oven dinners (,maybe once a month)

However, all of this talk recently that demonises Ultra-processed foods is another stick to beat working mothers with.

Sometimes I feel something has to give and I can't always plan, shop, execute a fully cooked from scratch meal every night of the week.

YABU - Get your Arese into Gear woman and organise your life

YANBU - this is just another way to make woman feel guilty. Get the fish fingers out!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Covidwoes · 27/06/2023 07:26

And yes @Cormoran I agree with everything you say about the French! I lived in France for a while, and the attitude to food is so much healthier. I particularly loved that carbs weren't demonised. Packed lunches didn't exist either at the school I worked at. All kids had balanced school lunches.

Covidwoes · 27/06/2023 07:24

@Raggletagglegypsy, well that's lucky about your son, as I've witnessed children who aren't allowed junk food gorge themselves when unsupervised at parties, and be sick everywhere. That's including a child who brought his own food, but didn't eat it! Re the vegan thing, no it wouldn't be acceptable, BUT it is really easy these days for a party host/party venues to offer vegan alternatives so vegan children don't feel left out. There's absolutely no need for a vegan to bring their own food. A lot of vegan food is UPF anyway.

I meant to ask, how do you fit it all in with working? That's the bit I would find really hard. I cook from scratch most days, but I do find it harder when I've been on my feet for 12 hours. I'm guessing you did school packed lunches rather than dinners? Genuinely fascinated!

lljkk · 27/06/2023 07:14

All the healthy food guides have said very long said should replace fats or low nutrition but high calorie substances (like sugar) with more high fibre foods, specifically vegetables, fruits & whole grains.

Cormoran · 27/06/2023 06:53

I think the problem when talking low fat or low carb is what you substitute the fat or carb with. Remove a macro and put junk in it, both low fat or low carb fail to improve health.
The winning aspect of a low carb or low fat is that in the early days of the diet, people are forced to cook from scratch and remove the UPFs since they mostly have a combination of both.

I was listening to the ZOE podcast about snacking. Fascinating that only 10% of French snack. It is true, you never see people eating in the streets whilst walking or carrying around food in their bags or cars. Kids stop having an after school snack around the age of 14 and dinner is never before 7 pm, yet they survive. You are judged if you snack. No French office has biscuits in the office kitchen.

I live in Australia and people here eat all day long. You go to a sport event, parents come with a massive esky filled with the worst possible junk. School canteen the same. UPFs are the stars of the menu.

I can always tell an Aussie from a French in New Caledonia, because the Aussie will unpack junk food, the French a book. Family size of Doritos or some other snacks. There seems to be this inability to go between one meal to the other without food and that food is UPF. Or TV requiring something. Why?

The worst is the baby junk food. From melty puffs, baby crisps (why the hell do you give crisps to a baby, it is party food in France!! and party food is fine at partie) , rusks, rice cakes, "veggie" straw .... kids are hooked before they can walk or talk.

I have been here for years, but the food quality is so bad and so industrial. They eat crap without realising it. The bread is the worst. You can use a supermarket loaf if you forget your volleyball. Use a French traditional bread, and you break our hand.

I find it amusing how bread and carb is demonised in Australia and other Anglo-Saxon countries. The higher the carb hate, the higher the weight. If you take a walk in a French city, you will see very slender women eating croissant at a cafe or in Italy, eating pasta. The difference is the quality of food.

Reading the book leaves you with a bad taste, so hopefully it will change people's perspective on what to feed their kids.

moogle87 · 27/06/2023 04:27

I was ahead of the curve & knew about this 2 years ago as my friend was doing her MSc dissertation on her relationship with food & she shared her research with me.

I went as UPF free as possible & there were positive changes; I started to lose weight & my taste buds changed (I tasted foods more) within a month.
But it’s like any addiction, as soon as you fall off the wagon, it’s extremely difficult to get back on it. & that’s really where I am now tbh.
I still try & stay as UPF free as possible within reason, but I have fibro & get migraines, so sometimes it’s an achievement to shove something in the oven rather than get a takeaway.

it’s not a stick to beat you with. If they knew about this & did nothing, that would be totally irresponsible. Education is so important.
Its the food companies & our governments at fault.
Do as much as you can do & don’t feel guilty; we’re all just trying to do our best at the end of the day.

One thing that scares me though is the move to sweeteners from sugar. Yes, sugar is bad for us, but my body has an extreme reaction to sweeteners, especially in drinks, & that tells me everything I need to know about them. As bad as sugar is, a few sips of a drink with just sugar does not make my gums blow up & give me migraine. But sweeteners do that. I’ve drink water exclusively for years now, so I suspect that I’m sensitive, but regardless, that’s not a good sign.

Raggletagglegypsy · 26/06/2023 23:11

@putthatdownsteve and @Covidwoes The thing is - there is a 19 year gap between my oldest child and my youngest - with quite a few in-between! I have always had a zero tolerance to junk food. I just asked my oldest (now a doctor - and well aware of the impact of poor diet on health) whether my attitude to party food used to bother him (he took very delicious alternatives) - he said, not at all - just made him feel special! If, for the sake of argument, you were a vegan and bringing your children up similarly, would you think that it would be acceptable for them to consume animal-based products, as long as it was just at an occasional social event?

putthatdownsteve · 26/06/2023 20:06

Covidwoes · 26/06/2023 19:29

@DataNotLore so true re the party rings, haha! @Raggletagglegypsy what will you do when they get older? I can't imagine a 12 year old taking a plate of non UPF food to a party! My girls eat a lot of fresh food, but at parties anything goes. It's not like they're eating like they every day!

Even I let my children have what they want at parties, and I have basically turned into a less wanky Gwyneth Paltrow. They have the odd ice cream or packet of crisps on a day out and I don’t police them at parties or friends houses.

They have always made good choices on the whole though, which surprises me. None of them would chose any drink other than water, (although my 20 year old is partial to a few ciders at the pub now and again 🤣), they have always just asked for water totally unprompted as it’s all we have in the house and they like it.

My 9 year old turns down fizzy drinks/squash when offered at parties, I wouldn’t mind the odd one, but she just doesn’t like them.

Covidwoes · 26/06/2023 19:29

@DataNotLore so true re the party rings, haha! @Raggletagglegypsy what will you do when they get older? I can't imagine a 12 year old taking a plate of non UPF food to a party! My girls eat a lot of fresh food, but at parties anything goes. It's not like they're eating like they every day!

Gwenhwyfar · 26/06/2023 17:38

"have made small changes to my diet with it in mind that have massively improved my mental health among many other areas. "

Can I ask what the small changes were and what were the improvements you saw in your health?

VimtoVimto · 26/06/2023 15:50

I downloaded the yuka app yesterday and have been scanning random stuff in the fridge/cupboards with surprising results. A sachet of chow mein cooking sauce was bad but some savoury rice was good.

I am struggling to find out how to turn off the bleeping sound other than muting my phone.

Bubbles254 · 26/06/2023 13:02

Has anyone tried the yuka app where you scan barcodes and it gives a score based on nutrition and additives?

I found it quite useful in identifying some of the really harmful stuff (in particular in beauty and cleaning products) but am uncertain on how useful the overall score is e.g. it scored McCain crispy french fries as 72/100 based on nutrients despite the additives present but my yummy feta cheese only got 31 due to salt and saturates despite scoring well on additives.

It showed that the sunblock I am using on my children contains octocylene which is meant to be an endocrine disrupter. This seems to be in a lot of them but the app does offer suggestions for sunblocks without this. My exfoliator has phenoxyethanol which is meant to have toxic effects on blood, liver, hormones and fertility.

lljkk · 26/06/2023 12:48

I'm the only one in the family who would dare eat chickpeas.

Also the only mayo lover. Most the housemates never touch the stuff.

JazbayGrapes · 26/06/2023 11:17

It is common sense that what is artificial, synthetic, full of salt/sugar/chemical is not good for you. There will always be two groups of people: who are willing to go an extra mile for better nutrition, and those who won't be arsed, regardless of any scaremongering.

BarleySugars · 26/06/2023 11:01

I feel you OP, i love cooking, passionate about food and bust my ass to cook whenever i can, meal planning and batch cooking but quite a lot of the time it just does NOT fit in with work and after school activities, dont know how others do it, im like a blue arsed fly most days til 8pm

VimtoVimto · 26/06/2023 08:18

Gwenhwyfar · 25/06/2023 21:16

"Over the years the advice has been at various times to eat low fat, low carb, don’t eat fruit, don’t eat starchy veg and don’t eat wheat, all of which supposedly had convincing science behind them."

Low fat has been debunked except fo the bad fat that leads to high cholestorol.

Low carb/keto is a specific diet and has never been official advice for everyone.

No wheat is for people who are intolerant of it. I doubt it was ever official advice either.

Low fat may have been debunked now but at the time it had scientific advice behind it - what is to say this advice about UPF won’t be debunked in the future.

I agree that keto and gluten-free are for specific conditions but that hasn’t stopped it being advised for wider use. The trouble isn’t necessarily with the ‘official’ message but with Instagram nutritionists and the like giving advice that may have some basis in scientific research but goes far beyond what is necessary.

OttoGraph · 26/06/2023 05:05

@draxdomax you’re statement is totally at odds with what the research and science is finding

Satsumaonaplate · 26/06/2023 00:34

But it is linked to increased risk of cancer and dementia - so it's all about trying to lower it where possible. I don't think it's possible to eliminate it with everything else we have going on!! Its insidious, it's absolutely everywhere.

I'm reducing UPFs drastically but I work part time. I don't think I'd manage if I worked full time.

lemonchiffonpie · 25/06/2023 23:58

draxdomax · 25/06/2023 20:47

There's very little harm in the "ultra processed foods" (whatever that means)

The main problems are that they are very rich, very tasty and very easy to buy and prepare.
So, people eat more of them.

Whether you cook a curry from scratch or pop a tray in the microwave - I seriously doubt it will result in significantly different macro/micro nutrient intake.

Another example is fish fingers which were mentioned: I just had a look in some that I have in my freezer and they are absolutely fine, nothing toxic or scientifically proven to be unhealthy.

There are no "special enteral life" vitamins in fish. Cooking them is going to destroy those anyway, whether they were £50/kg fillets or "reconstituted fish protein" - it's the same.
Our stomach doesn't even know the difference.

It's just that people get a mental health benefit from cooking and they eat less because cooking takes time and takes attention away from hunger, whereas almost-ready-to-eat meals feel like they are over much before we feel full.

That's all.

Have you not yet heard of the gut microbiome, and its effects on the brain in particular - it is where the vast bulk of serotonin is made, for one. The gut microbiome is a huge area in research these days, and the effects of what we eat on our gut bacteria diversity and the range of diseases affected/created there is becoming more and more known.

"There is very little harm" in UPFs is a bizarre statement. No-one is going to keel over and die from a ready meal. But basing your diet on frankenfoods will shorten your life, raise your risk of dementia, diabetes, heart disease, you name it. This is not one man's book, it is documented in hundreds of books now, in thousands of studies. Plenty of interesting docos on it.

It's in many ways not new news that we should not base our diet on "discretionary foods" - but that is what many people are now doing worldwide.

I am not a purist, but got interested in the microbiome nearly a decade ago, and since reading up on it and watching many docos, I have made small changes to my diet with it in mind that have massively improved my mental health among many other areas. Heart health, eye health, remain remarkably good for my age.

AlmostThere2023 · 25/06/2023 22:28

Theoldgreygoose · 25/06/2023 22:16

That's awful!!

It really is! After reading the book it has really made me think about what is in the food we’re eating.

Theoldgreygoose · 25/06/2023 22:16

AlmostThere2023 · 25/06/2023 21:27

thats the point, it is so incredibly processed and full of all sorts of non foods that it just did not melt. It’s clearly cheap, ultra processed ice cream. I can’t help with the ingredients as they were in Spanish. I’m

That's awful!!

DataNotLore · 25/06/2023 22:15

@Raggletagglegypsy

They'll be mainlining part rings as soon as you turn your back 😂

Raggletagglegypsy · 25/06/2023 22:02

Covidwoes · 25/06/2023 20:26

@Raggletagglegypsy what do you do when your kids go to parties? Do you not let them eat the food for fear of them being poisoned? I'm an everything in moderation person.

Send them with their own plates of delicious UPF-free party food - simple as!

deets · 25/06/2023 21:50

I was in my 50s, had been working all day and just hubby and I at home that night. So, as I hadn't had time to prepare anything before I left for work (hubby left a lot earlier then me and came home at the same time) and was too tired to start from scratch when I got home, thought that I would buy a couple of frozen meals and a pudding. This old woman saw what I had in my basket and started to berate me for being lazy. "You young things don't know how to cook a decent meal" being one of her comments. Though I was flattered at being called a young thing, I was also annoyed. First told her that what I bought was none of her business, that I had been working all day and that I could produce a four course meal, home made soup and bread, fish course, main meal, sweet and peppermints as well as squeezing oranges for a drink and if I decided to have a night off then that was my choice. Her face looked as if she had been sucking lemons.

Demigold · 25/06/2023 21:31

Is it not the pasteurised egg that helps as well. I use the whole egg, cup of oil recipe. I’m trying to limit my ultra processed, I’m not worried about the citric acid in tinned tomatoes or tomato ketchup etc.
One loaf of regular bread / bread buns and a sourdough does us now.
Teenager DD is now doing pasta as her lunch. Where normally she would have lots of toast. I call that a win.

AlmostThere2023 · 25/06/2023 21:27

Theoldgreygoose · 25/06/2023 20:33

One very interesting part of the book is where he talked about his daughters ice cre not melting in the sun as it was really not proper ice cream. I’m on holiday and kids grabbed ice cream from the snack bar - one didn’t get eaten and still didn’t melt despite the 30 degree heat.

What on earth is ice cream made from where you are??? I can assure you than ice cream here in NZ melts - I had one yesterday, in mid winter, and it was melting by the time I got home!

thats the point, it is so incredibly processed and full of all sorts of non foods that it just did not melt. It’s clearly cheap, ultra processed ice cream. I can’t help with the ingredients as they were in Spanish. I’m

Swipe left for the next trending thread