Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that I'm not 'too clever to be a nurse'?

119 replies

namechangee55 · 21/06/2023 19:44

After wanting to work in healthcare since I was a teenager I decided to finally take the plunge and apply to study paediatric nursing. I've told a few friends and family and whilst some have been supportive, a few have said that I'm 'too clever' to be a nurse and I should pursue medicine instead. It's kind of tarnished the excitement I feel about starting my course... I strongly disagree with them, and think nursing is a better option for me. I don't want to spend years studying medicine, and think nursing will provide a better work-life balance.

I do already have a degree Biomedical Sciences which I got a first in, and I have science a-levels (A*AB). But graduate-entry medicine is so highly competitive I don't think I'd stand a chance anyway.

I think I can still make a difference to patients' lives as a paediatric nurse and can still work my way up and have a fulfilling career.

AIBU to hate the idea that nursing is not as good an option as medicine?

OP posts:
Gracewithoutend · 21/06/2023 21:39

As a student nurse , I learned a lot from the highly experienced hcas.

My elderly mum has been in hospital twice recently and long hours in A&E triage and assessment has given me lots of (more than I wanted) opportunities to observe the staff. Honestly, to me, the ones dressed in white and pale blue are the workhorses. I watched 3 sisters (dark blues) and 6 doctors in different colours, watch as a lady in a cubicle asked for a nurse, threw up and started to wet herself and then they turned away. Only one doctor, the consultant, made a move to help her. Then a white coat came along and pointed out the mess and the sister in charge just shrugged. Nice.

It's been an informative time. The hca on the ward were fantastic, particularly one called Emma. I hope she recognises herself! She was cheerful, bright, and just made everyone laugh and happy. I hope all of them felt they were valued by the sisters and doctors, because they were certainly valued by the patients and relatives.

OrlandointheWilderness · 21/06/2023 21:37

I'm a student nurse. It definitely helps to be clever, the degree isn't actually easy although there are more academic ones.
Always irritates me that people think nursing is a substandard thing to do if you can't do medicine - it's a completely different career!

Lostmum2407 · 21/06/2023 21:37

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 21/06/2023 19:59

Me too, as an allied health professional. Us brainy ones become managers.

Exactly! Go for nursing!

JeandeServiette · 21/06/2023 21:34

Groutyonehereagain · 21/06/2023 21:31

All my GCSEs and A levels are As and I’m a retired now nurse. I retired on a band 7. Go for it, it’s a brilliant career with so many opportunities.

If you took GCSES you can't be older than 50ish, can I be nosey and ask why you retired early?

lemondust000 · 21/06/2023 21:32

I'm a band 7 clinical nurse specialist and I love my job. I qualified later in life though (late 30s) and I sometimes wistfully wonder what medicine would have been like. If I could do it all again I might pick the latter - but they are both very different jobs that need people at the top of their game. All these very dated outmoded perceptions of what nurses do is largely down to media and ignorance (not in a rude way, just not having the knowledge of the roles .. the days of bedpans are firmly in the past. I'm a prescriber, hold my own clinics and make my own decisions.

Groutyonehereagain · 21/06/2023 21:31

All my GCSEs and A levels are As and I’m a retired now nurse. I retired on a band 7. Go for it, it’s a brilliant career with so many opportunities.

SeemsPointless · 21/06/2023 21:29

I think there are different questions here that are getting mixed up.

Are there clever nurses?

Yes! Absolutely tons of very smart people becomes nurses and use their intelligence to provide incredible care.

Do you have to be clever to be a nurse?

No, not necessarily in the conventional academic sense.

I know of several people who have gone into nursing who have worked very, very hard to qualify - but having either worked closely alongside them previously, or gone to school/college with them, I can say categorically that they're not the most gifted intellectually. That doesn't mean they aren't great nurses.

But you could say that about lots of fields. My brother has a PhD in Physics which makes him sound like a huge brain box. He isn't. He barely scraped through GCSEs, didn't do A-levels, failed his professional qualifications when he joined a telecoms firm and then when he returned to education later, he had to work extremely hard to scrape a 2:2 degree. The structure, time and set-up of a PhD really suited him and although - again! - he only just squeaked through, he got his doctorate.

What my brother can do extremely well is research thoroughly, analyse a situation, sift through facts, and consider all elements before reaching a decision. I really value his opinion and consider him to be intelligent, even though he's not conventionally "clever".

There are lots of career paths in nursing nowadays. But equally, there's nothing wrong with not progressing. Doctors and nurses are different careers and require different skillsets, quite aside from any academic "cleverness". Choose the path that appeals to you. The cleverness - or lack of it in some cases - in your nursing colleagues isn't relevant.

Gracewithoutend · 21/06/2023 21:28

I think a lot of people think nursing is what it used to be. Changing sheets and bed pans. Nursing nowadays reaches into the role of a doctor. There areas so many career paths for nurses. So many opportunities. Don't be put off.

Spacecowboys · 21/06/2023 21:28

Throughalookingglass · 21/06/2023 21:12

They are spread around a number of different hospitals and know each other from way back when they were studying.

It’s really sad listening to them, they don’t rate HCAs at all or medical admin either.

My DC has medical issues which involve hospital stays. Most of the assistants are great as are most of the nurses.

Good luck to any nurse trying to do their job properly without hcas or admin staff. Every role should be valued and respected. As a student nurse , I learned a lot from the highly experienced hcas. Similarly, the newly qualified drs learned a lot from me as an experienced nurse. There’s always knowledge to be gained from others, irrespective of their seniority or job status.

Hollyppp · 21/06/2023 21:27

How rude and awful. You can be a specialist nurse and a complete expert in your field. It’s a different job than being a doctor

Smallyellowbird · 21/06/2023 21:24

You say that you don't think you'd get into graduate entry medicine, but with a first in Biomedical Science I think you're being very negative, as a pp has said you sound like a perfect candidate - you sound as if you think that there's no point in applying, which does make it seem that you might be going for nursing as you think it's the only option for a health care career.

Re nursing, while there are positives re mobility etc, the pay and conditions seem to be poor, unless you do further study, and in a hospital context, a lack of autonomy in decision making. I think this is why people would wonder why you don't go for medicine instead, as it sounds like you could easily get in, it's not a criticism of nursing.

JeandeServiette · 21/06/2023 21:23

Since when was being especially clever amongst your occupational peers a bad thing anyway? Assuming we even accept the premise. You could really build on that dual background and do very well.

TicTac80 · 21/06/2023 21:23

I'm a nurse. OP, if nursing is what you want to do, then go for it. I have a similar academic background to you and retrained as a nurse just over a decade ago. I've never regretted it. I absolutely love what I do and who I work with. My team is amazing (all of them, no matter what their role is: whether B1 or B8, Doctor, Physio/OT/SALT/Dietician, Cleaner, Porter, catering staff). I work in quite a specialist area and we look after critically ill patients - so tell the naysayers that you do have to be "clever". We often teach the new doctors how to manage vents, trachies, central lines, drains etc. What I love is that I spend more time (all my time) with patients, and the role is so varied.

It's bloody hard work. You'll laugh, cry etc. But find a ward/speciality that you love and it makes it wonderful.

mytitshaveshrunk · 21/06/2023 21:17

Well I have an IQ of 128 and my Mum is way, way smarter than me. She nursed from the age of 18 and adored it. Go for it OP. Best of luck x

mrsneate · 21/06/2023 21:17

You have to get through a very tough 3 year degree to become a nurse these days!

And pass a maths exam with complicated medicine calculations with a 100% pass rate and no calculator!

That being said, those who say it's about the pecking order is right. Depending on where you work.

I'm a paediatric nurse. I qualified 5 years ago and went straight into a level 3 surgical neonatal intensive care unit with 38 beds.

The doctors look to US nurses for the answers most of the time.

For example, a conversation I had with one of the top Nicu consultants in the country yesterday, whilst I was taking care of a ex 25 weeker with T21 who's now 6 weeks old, was about what I thought was causing his requirement of oxygen to go up and what did I think was the best resolution and plan, I came up with the plan. Because of course I am with that baby for 13 hours a day,

I love my job,

However, nursing atm, is very stressful, we are very short staffed and depending on the role you do, the work life balance is crap 😂

Throughalookingglass · 21/06/2023 21:12

Spacecowboys · 21/06/2023 20:55

😳 where does your sibling work , so I can make sure I never go there. They sound awful.

They are spread around a number of different hospitals and know each other from way back when they were studying.

It’s really sad listening to them, they don’t rate HCAs at all or medical admin either.

My DC has medical issues which involve hospital stays. Most of the assistants are great as are most of the nurses.

HotSince82 · 21/06/2023 21:09

In the kindest possible way I think you may be taking yourself a bit too seriously here...

My friend has a 2:1 in philosophy from a Russell group and works on the dior counter at Boots.

You aren't too clever for anything. Stack shelves at lidl if it makes you happy. The sun will probably continue to rise each morning either way.

Iwouldlikesomecake · 21/06/2023 21:08

It’s just a totally different job to being a doctor. Good on you if that’s what you want to do, nursing is a great career and there’s a lot of opportunities with it that are rewarding and you can earn a decent salary with it.

all the people saying ‘oh but maybe you could be a physician associate’ etc, maybe the OP doesn’t want to. Nursing is very valuable. We need clever and interested nurses.

ADHDDDDDDDBOOM · 21/06/2023 21:04

Im a nurse and I see both sides.

I think perhaps they mean you are too academic for nursing, as opposed to too clever.
Biomedical science is very specific and hardcore.

Nursing has its academic side but the caring role of it is enormous of course, so I can understand their surprise and the change (im not, my first degree was in something entirely different to nursing too).

What they don't realise is how clever some nurses are and how much they can progress.

So here's your chance to show them.

Bloody well done you!
I loved my children's nursing degree!

Nandocushion · 21/06/2023 21:04

It's a rude and frankly stupid thing to say...and I know this for a fact, because I also said it to someone, years ago now. I still cringe at the thought and I hope whoever has said it to you also cringes when they think about it a bit more.

Escapetofrance · 21/06/2023 21:03

It does make me laugh to read nurses are great-some may be great, but many are absolutely awful. It’s the same in all professions where caring is involved.

Escapetofrance · 21/06/2023 21:01

If you desire to be a nurse then that’s great. I think the people who say you could be a dr are not being unkind, they’re probably just surprised you’re not aiming higher.
You would earn a lot more being a dr but if it’s not want you want or need, I wouldn’t give it a second thought.

Cece92 · 21/06/2023 20:57

Nurses are bloody amazing! If that's what you want to do then do it. I'm hoping to get into nursing when my daughter hits high school in 2 years. I got a place at college then fell pregnant and been a single mum so always struggled with child care. Good luck xx

IseeBrigadoon · 21/06/2023 20:57

Throughalookingglass · 21/06/2023 20:25

I think its a pecking order.

Doctors.
Nurses.
Healthcare assistants.

Everyone of the above plays an important role. I think its natural for people to view the decision making as being better.

Its similar to being a psychologist v a psychiatrist People give more value to those who can prescribe medication.

I’m a nurse and can prescribe medication. I can prescribe chemotherapy and controlled drugs in my role. I wouldn’t say I provide more value than a HCA, just a different skill set.