Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that I'm not 'too clever to be a nurse'?

119 replies

namechangee55 · 21/06/2023 19:44

After wanting to work in healthcare since I was a teenager I decided to finally take the plunge and apply to study paediatric nursing. I've told a few friends and family and whilst some have been supportive, a few have said that I'm 'too clever' to be a nurse and I should pursue medicine instead. It's kind of tarnished the excitement I feel about starting my course... I strongly disagree with them, and think nursing is a better option for me. I don't want to spend years studying medicine, and think nursing will provide a better work-life balance.

I do already have a degree Biomedical Sciences which I got a first in, and I have science a-levels (A*AB). But graduate-entry medicine is so highly competitive I don't think I'd stand a chance anyway.

I think I can still make a difference to patients' lives as a paediatric nurse and can still work my way up and have a fulfilling career.

AIBU to hate the idea that nursing is not as good an option as medicine?

OP posts:
Spacecowboys · 22/06/2023 11:50

The only issue with physicians associate courses is the lack of career pathway once qualified. PAs can’t prescribe in the UK which is a limitation.

JeandeServiette · 22/06/2023 11:24

JeandeServiette · 22/06/2023 11:20

How about a Physician's Associate OP? I know it's a new thing in the UK but they seem to be popping up in primary care now.

www.healthcareers.nhs.uk/explore-roles/medical-associate-professions/roles-medical-associate-professions/physician-associate

Most of the courses are two year Masters, and a bioscience UG seems to be the preferred entry qualification.

If you scroll down on that link, there's a course search and then a job vacancy search. There are definitely jobs.

JeandeServiette · 22/06/2023 11:20

How about a Physician's Associate OP? I know it's a new thing in the UK but they seem to be popping up in primary care now.

LaJolieMuse · 22/06/2023 10:00

There are career paths for bright and motivated nurses that involve them being very specialised and highly qualified. Advanced Nurse Practitioners have very medically based roles.

I was similar in that I wanted to be a midwife. I was told as a teenager I was too clever for this and should do medicine. I didn't get into medical school with my subjects/grades and ended up being a bit of a mess for a while before I eventually went to university to do something else. I now work in the NHS in a non-medical role and I'm glad at how my life has turned out but still find midwifery fascinating.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 22/06/2023 10:00

Now more than ever we need clever and critical nurses

So true!

damekindness · 22/06/2023 09:54

The being too clever for nursing trope has much to do with it being a female dominated profession and therefore nursing is just an extension of our feminine nurturing skills.

There's also the tiresome discussion around whether it requires degree level education at all because see above. This is generally from those who don't understand the depth and breadth of the current job or from older nurses who have a gazillion years of experience gained during the times that the NHS wasn't broken and medical interventions/care less complex

Now more than ever we need clever and critical nurses

ell32 · 22/06/2023 09:15

I got told this as a teenager about to do A-levels when I said I wanted to be a nurse.

Not currently a nurse as I actually left my degree at 18 after 1 term as I found it hard mentally but will go back one day when my children are older.

Nursing is a very highly skilled job and I actually think anyone saying that has no idea!

BadNomad · 22/06/2023 09:12

You really should try to get some experience of working on a ward before deciding. Being smart can be frustrating as a nurse (at band 5 anyway) because you'll spend most of your time being dismissed by 23-year-old doctors who think they are the dog's bollocks. Then if your long-serving colleagues catch wind that you have any ambition they'll make your life hell.

Only be a nurse if you want to be a nurse. Don't go into it because you couldn't get into medicine. It is not the "next best thing". Pharmacology might be a better fit if you want science. Paramedical science if you want hands on medical-ish.

QuintanaRoo · 22/06/2023 09:11

Nursing certainly has lots of opportunities and I know a lot of amazingly academic nurses who have progressed into advanced roles. Diagnosing, prescribing, etc.

one thing to consider though is that while yes you can make a difference a lot of nurses are frustrated and burnt out due to feeling that they can’t make a difference due to staffing. This might be a bit better in paeds I don’t know.

but ultimately if medicine is your dream you must apply for GEM. Someone has to get in. Don’t be put off by being scared of rejection.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 22/06/2023 09:08

Ireolu · 21/06/2023 22:34

Do you want to do medicine? Are you not applying for medicine because you don't think you stand a chance? I don't necessarily think one has to be clever to do medicine. I had a friend who had a 3 C offer to do medicine a top university. He got 4 As but they were keen on him and even if he didnt get the predicted grades he would still have got in. Don't let fear of rejection stop you from applying if that is what you are interested in. However if paediatric nursing is in fact your calling go for that instead.

When was this, and which university?

There is not a single UK university that would admit someone for medicine with 3 Cs now. The vast majority of universities require at least AAA and often higher. There are a couple which might allow a B or two, but certainly not "high ranking" ones.

The OP is entirely right in saying that graduate entry medicine is fiercely competitive. That's not to say that she wouldn't get in if she tried - she might or she might not - but it's a perfectly reasonable decision not to if she doesn't really want to go through all of that.

And I don't think that nursing should be regarded as an inferior second choice in any case. It is a hugely important role with an immense potential for career development and progression. We need good people to go into nursing for its own sake and not for it to be regarded as something that is left over for the people who wanted to do medicine but couldn't.

I'm sorry that your family are being unsupportive, OP. It seems that they are clinging on to some rather outdated and misinformed perceptions about nursing. Of course you aren't too clever to go for that if it is what you really want to do... and I'm sure that you will find that there are plenty of other very clever nurses on your course as well. Good luck with it!

bellalou1234 · 22/06/2023 09:07

Maztek · 21/06/2023 19:52

People will always be rude to you when you’re a nurse. I’m a mental health nurse and am leaving the career now. Grow a thick skin! The degree is hard work.

Can I be cheeky and ask why your leaving mh nursing

MissTrip82 · 22/06/2023 09:04

I’m a dr. Entirely different roles and not really comparable. If you’re great at one the other isn’t for you. There really isn’t much overlap.

If you don’t want to do the study (the degree is. nothing compared to the training for a decade+ after it) that’s the end of the matter. But if medicine is your dream - pursue it. Yeah it’s hard, it’s hard to get into, and through, and my job is fucking hard. Those people you know who failed to get in failed the easiest bit tbh. I’m entirely clinically responsible for the sickest people in the hospital; the buck stops with me. I’ve never worked a 40 hr week in my life.

Everything worth doing is hard.

Groutyonehereagain · 22/06/2023 08:58

JeandeServiette · 21/06/2023 21:34

If you took GCSES you can't be older than 50ish, can I be nosey and ask why you retired early?

You can be nosey, lol, it’s the other way round I went back into education and then did nursing as a mature student.

KimberleyClark · 22/06/2023 08:53

I do think there is now a “why be a nurse when you could be a doctor” attitude which has led to the nursing profession being devalued.

HVPRN · 22/06/2023 08:46

namechangee55 · 21/06/2023 22:34

Thanks all. I agree that nursing provides lots of opportunities.

For those who asked, no I've never applied for medicine before. It has been a dream of mine, but I feel like I don't have the ability for it so have never seriously considered it. During my master's, quite a few of my cohort applied for graduate entry medicine and none of them were successful despite all having first class degrees and being on track for distinctions which put me off.

If medicine is your dream, this is the career for you. Don't let fear of failure stop you.

Being a paeds nurse is an incredibly fulfilling career path, however like others have said, the two roles are different. Both doctors and nurses work incredibly hard and are often overworked, understaffed and underpaid. You just have to follow your dream and live with no regrets.

Do all the research and homework now to find out what is involved regarding the recruitment process to get into medical school, and apply yourself fully. If you fail, you can always try again. But at least you tried.

Daffodil92 · 21/06/2023 23:31

Throughalookingglass · 21/06/2023 21:12

They are spread around a number of different hospitals and know each other from way back when they were studying.

It’s really sad listening to them, they don’t rate HCAs at all or medical admin either.

My DC has medical issues which involve hospital stays. Most of the assistants are great as are most of the nurses.

They sound like a group of bitches and absolutely NOT the norm. Where I work, the HCAs and nurses all work as part of a team, and respect and value each other. They are colleagues and friends. Nights out together, having fun and propping each other up through tough shifts.
I can’t relate at all to your sister and her friends’ views.

TonysGaff · 21/06/2023 23:19

For those who asked, no I've never applied for medicine before. It has been a dream of mine, but I feel like I don't have the ability for it so have never seriously considered it.

Then there is your answer and justification for why your family and friends, who presumably know that, are asking why you aren't applying to read medicine.

If it's what you dreamed of, give it a go. Believe in yourself.

Motherofjessie · 21/06/2023 23:02

It depends on what you actually want to do. Nursing involves a lot of patient care - actual care - washing, bathing , dressings and if you specialise then you work at a higher level but still looking after and treating patients. Doctors also do actual care but more ordering things and arranging investigations along with other health care professionals. Both are careers that help people and are vocations as well as careers. I am a nurse and find the caring for patients immensely rewarding. I have chosen not to progress up the career path because I love looking after people, helping them and making them as comfortable as possible but you can progress to very high levels as a nurse but usually means lots of meetings and management things. Don't be talked into things by other people. Think of why you want to be a paediatric nurse and why you would want to do medicine.

Vettrianofan · 21/06/2023 22:41

Nothing wrong with nursing, as others have pointed out there's lots of flexibility in the job.

Ireolu · 21/06/2023 22:34

Do you want to do medicine? Are you not applying for medicine because you don't think you stand a chance? I don't necessarily think one has to be clever to do medicine. I had a friend who had a 3 C offer to do medicine a top university. He got 4 As but they were keen on him and even if he didnt get the predicted grades he would still have got in. Don't let fear of rejection stop you from applying if that is what you are interested in. However if paediatric nursing is in fact your calling go for that instead.

namechangee55 · 21/06/2023 22:34

Thanks all. I agree that nursing provides lots of opportunities.

For those who asked, no I've never applied for medicine before. It has been a dream of mine, but I feel like I don't have the ability for it so have never seriously considered it. During my master's, quite a few of my cohort applied for graduate entry medicine and none of them were successful despite all having first class degrees and being on track for distinctions which put me off.

OP posts:
hedwigismyowl · 21/06/2023 22:20

Lollygaggle · 21/06/2023 20:32

Have you thought about physician associate/assistant ? Your first degree would give entry to this.
Most people who've gone into medicine find it incredibly stressful ,all consuming and difficult to reconcile with a personal life .
Physician associates have the patient contact , ability to be responsible for patient care but without the pressures of medicine or the work/life unbalance of nursing/medicine.

Tbh I would hesitate in advising anyone in becoming a PA right now, there's more opportunities for a nurse or an AHP. As an example, to request X-rays or scans, you have to be a state registered healthcare professional, which a nurse or AHP is. A physician assistant is not state registered and therefore legally cannot request X-rays or scans.

I suggest becoming a nurse or an AHP and then further training to be a ENP in A&E depts or advanced practitioner training- some of which is multidisciplinary training.

Thisisabsolutelyfine · 21/06/2023 22:13

Itisyourturntowashthebath · 21/06/2023 19:52

Being very clever and being a nurse will allow you to work your way up.
Get the nay sayers to check the salary for a band 8 nurse.
Good luck

This. As with many jobs, you would survive if you weren’t smart, but you will thrive if you are.

dickheed · 21/06/2023 21:49

Did you apply to medicine as a teenager and not get in so you did Biomedical Sciences? I'm wondering if you fear rejection, for possibly a second time, if you apply for graduate medicine. I don't think you should apply for it if it's not want you want to do, but I wonder why you are being so negative saying you don't stand a chance anyway. I think you would have a very good chance if that is what you wanted to do.

However, if you don't want to be a doctor and you feel nursing is a better fit for you, then do it and to hell with what anyone else says. There's no such thing as being too clever to be a nurse. The only thing I would say is if you are very academically inclined and less of a people person, then it wouldn't be suitable. You need to have the right skill set and personal attributes for nursing. If you happen to be clever/academic on top - so much the better.
There are plenty of opportunities to progress if you want or to take a more academic path, such as research and even lecturing later on when you have built up experience.

OrlandointheWilderness · 21/06/2023 21:41

Throughalookingglass · 21/06/2023 20:39

My sibling is a nurse. The pecking order is very real. My sibling and her peers feel very superior to healthcare assistants, its shocking how they sneer a them for being 'work shy' and 'lazy'. Maybe that is because doctors look at nurses the same way. From what I can see from listening to many friends who are nurses, nursing is a particularly toxic environment to work in.

God it's nurses like your sibling that make it horrible sometimes! I've meet some brilliant, intelligent HCAs without whom the whole ward would fall apart. They are the proper hands on care, they intimately know this patients and they can make or break quality of care. I have nothing but respect for the job they do, and when I'm on placement they are the first people I try and get to know!

Swipe left for the next trending thread