Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it will soon become more normal for families to live in smaller houses

286 replies

flipflopfloop · 21/06/2023 17:27

With the recent rates increasing, borrowing costs are so high now that it would be at least 1200pcm in repayments for a small 2 bed house around here and it’s a relatively cheap area of the country. If not higher than this. Surely this will mean the days of having more bedrooms than people are numbered, and more and more families will have to make do with smaller living space - possibly leading to smaller family sizes even. I personally don’t think this is necessarily a bad thing. They are building lots of new developments on the outskirts of our city with prices starting from 350 for a 2 bed. A 4 bed home with three useable bedrooms there is easily 450-500. I find it interesting to wonder who will occupy these as presumably they are not yet sold and you would have to have at least a 6 figure household income to be able to afford this.

OP posts:
Notjustabrunette · 21/06/2023 20:26

i have actually done something like this. Previous owners put a shower in the bedroom cupboard.
it was also the only shower in the house, so I put a shower in over the bath and took the shower out of the cupboard. Now I have a nice big storage cupboard in the bedroom instead of strange shower.

Notjustabrunette · 21/06/2023 20:16

I think in a lot of other countries apartment living for families is seen as normal. I’ve lived a few counties in Asia and in Europe and large 3/4 bed apartments are common place.

groupery · 21/06/2023 20:15

People seem to have started to expect their first house to be bigger than in previous generations, so they may have to adjust their expectations a bit to the way they used to be.

Do you not think the increase of FTBs ages has something to do with it. Certainly the average family today won't end up in a 6 bed.

TenTenby · 21/06/2023 20:14

I do think it’s daft that social housing aims to provide separate rooms for children of different sexes in a family when many middle earners don’t have that luxury.

Many, many teenagers in social housing share with siblings of the opposite sex. There is a huge shortage of social housing so nowhere for families to move to as children grow. Millions live in cramped conditions while they sit for years on waiting lists.

It may be an "aim" to have separate rooms for children of different sexes in social housing but the reality is very, very different. And I'm not sure about using the word "luxury" in relation to social housing policy.

thepantsoffmethod · 21/06/2023 20:13

SparkyBlue · 21/06/2023 19:02

It's honestly only here on MN where the obsession with each child having their own room seems to exist. In my normal day to day life lots of siblings share and it's not an issue. We could do with more space and could afford to move but we are in a lovely little cul de sac where we are happy and settled with great neighbours.

Interesting to read this thread. I don't know a single family where the children share a bedroom. I didn't know anyone when I was at school in the 70s and 80s either. However, when I was a child, people started off in small houses and worked their way up (my parents started off in a two-bed new build, and ended up in a six-bed former rectory). People seem to have started to expect their first house to be bigger than in previous generations, so they may have to adjust their expectations a bit to the way they used to be.

CatsOnTheChair · 21/06/2023 20:10

There is very much a divide related to housing costs.
Borrowing 290k - so buying a house over 300k, that needs work, puts the house value above the average of around 285k.

250k would buy you a 4 bed detached round me. 125k would get you a 3 bed semi where I used to live - ok, street parking, but it was walking distance to a lovely high street, and I never had any issues. At the time we moved, the secondary school was dire, but it has been completely turned around, and is now outstanding.

Ourladycheesusedatum · 21/06/2023 20:07

Orban · 21/06/2023 19:20

@Nevermind31 yep, especially wrt storage. New builds in particular are atrocious for this. Those places look great if you're a 25 year old guy and all you own is a futon and a games console but they soon get claustrophobic when you add in toys/clothes/Xmas decorations/Halloween decorations/books/tables big enough for more than one person to sit and eat at etc.

I agree with this.
I recently looked at a penthouse flat. Lovely , all mod cons, fantastic area.
But the 3rd bedroom had absolutely no storage. At all. You may have been able to squeeze in a small set of drawers if you got a small bed.

Stupid in my opinion. I would have bought it but for that tiny room.
Probably the whole flat would have been ok for a couple, no children or only one child. With that tiny room as a home office.

ConfusedBear · 21/06/2023 20:04

@Kazzyhoward those are shocking numbers. It just seems so unfair to do the right things and it not pay off.

Well done though to your son for getting the graduate placement! They are really competitive so he should be proud to have the place.

It'd probably be worth him speaking to the recruitment team at the company to see if there is an internal staff noticeboard where he could ask about renting a room on. I know a few people who have moved cities and found initial accommodation from a work colleague.

AmaraTamara · 21/06/2023 20:02

May I ask, why is it so engrained that each child should have their bedroom (I mean even if they are a compatible age/gender) ? Is it about teaching children independence? Is it considered to be poor if kids share? I'm asking because my dh is from Spain, and his family were, let's say upper class, had 4 bedrooms plus, but he shared with his two siblings, because they just liked it that way.

bonfirebash · 21/06/2023 20:00

My area is cheap enough but stuff isn't selling

2 bed house 130k
2 bed apartment 115k (this won't sell because of the management fees, we pay £160pm)

Emmamoo89 · 21/06/2023 19:59

I'm moving to a 2 bed and pregnant with my second child and stopping at 2. It'll have to do for now.

groupery · 21/06/2023 19:58

But just imagine how much higher house prices would be if wages had increased over the last decade!

I think we would have seen higher interest rates. It's low rates that has contributed to wage stagnation

Kazzyhoward · 21/06/2023 19:56

Orban · 21/06/2023 19:49

Yeah not been a lot of future proofing going on. Meanwhile the rest of the world outside of Europe is skilling up.

Ofc the pension gap is exacerbated by us having had stagnant wages for 15 years. Nobody can put a lot aside when their earnings don't grow but their expenses do.

But just imagine how much higher house prices would be if wages had increased over the last decade!

Kazzyhoward · 21/06/2023 19:55

Babyroobs · 21/06/2023 19:40

The days that are coming are likely where adult kids can no longer afford to move out because rent and home ownership become out of reach of young people. I know a few thirty year olds who have overstretched themselves jumping in with 4 bedroom houses that they barely struggle to afford but those in their twenties i doubt will even be able to afford a 2 bed starter unless something changes.

They're already here. My lad has just finished Uni and had secured what we thought was a good graduate job with a national firm in a city 100 miles away. We thought, naively, that his salary would be enough for him to rent a flat to live there. Nope! Flat rental prices are insanely high as the city has 2 Unis and a teaching university, so lots of student demand, and it's also a major tourist destination, so lots of flats are holiday lets on AirBnB etc. Flats only appear on the market at the rate of 1 or 2 per week, and they are "let agreed" typically 2 days later - you have to be there to get a viewing as the agents expect you to drop everything and view on the day they appear on the market! Typically £1250 to £1500 for a flat, and even £800-£900 for a room rental in a shared house! Son is now seriously considering giving back word which is an absolute travesty as there are no decent employers within commutable distance of home for his chosen profession!

Orban · 21/06/2023 19:49

Inthedarkagain · 21/06/2023 19:32

I agree. We have prioritised housing wealth over what the country actually needs and now we have depreciating housing values anyway, but with a smaller birth rate and a future pension and health care problem due to it.

Our politicians and economists are thick as shit.

Yeah not been a lot of future proofing going on. Meanwhile the rest of the world outside of Europe is skilling up.

Ofc the pension gap is exacerbated by us having had stagnant wages for 15 years. Nobody can put a lot aside when their earnings don't grow but their expenses do.

FindingMeno · 21/06/2023 19:47

I hope to see more communal living.
I see it as a real fingers up to the powers that be.
People need to start banding together.

Babyroobs · 21/06/2023 19:42

Decafflatteplease · 21/06/2023 19:39

6 of us in a 3 bed / 1 bathroom here.

Would love to be able to move to a 4 or 5 bed but no way we can afford it

Same here - well seven adult ( 6 of us plus Ds's gf who doesn't really have a home to go to due to parents splitting and each now having new partners kids living with them ). fortunately we have a decent sized lounge/ diner at the back so can use out front downstairs room as a bedroom. I see it being this way for a while as no-one can afford to move out.

Flaskfan · 21/06/2023 19:41

MooseAndSquirrelLoveFlannel · 21/06/2023 19:32

In my city they either build pokey 1/2 bed flats and sell for North of £250k each. Or "executive" 4/5 beds for North of £650k each.

There is a spattering of 3 beds, but they tend to be dinky narrow things being built which I stare at and wonder how on earth they fit furniture in them.

Growing up in the 1980's my friendship group was all 2 parents & 2 children in a 1970s 3 bed house. The only friend with 2 siblings was rich and had a 4 bed house which was like a mansion to me. I was one of 4 kids in a 3 bed house. 3 girls shared one room.

A 4 bed house to me was a luxury to aspire to, we have 3 kids and just got our 4 bed in 2021 when my kids were 12, 10 & 9yo.

This is pretty much my life. I'm in my 40s and kind of felt: yes, I've done it! When we got the big house. Even though it's taken us nearly 20 years to get here and needs a lot of work. We bought our first tiny 3 bed in 2006, so made bugger all when we sold it. And by 3 bed, the 3rd room only fit a single bed in it. My parents' 3 bed is bigger. A house they bought in early 70s when they earned fuck all.

We're fixed for another 3 years, but I'd be gutted if we had to downsize so soon if mortgagesgo right up. I feel like stamping my foot and saying:"but it's but fair! We did it all the sensible way. Let us have this. "

Orban · 21/06/2023 19:40

Meh, I can't get exercised about that. Only around 15% of people live in social housing and a huge chunk of those are pensioners so don't have kids in the home anyway.

The bigger issue is that we're all expected to pay hundreds of thousands of pounds to live in tiny boxes with no storage, a million bathrooms, that are by and large inadequately ventilated, inadequately insulated and have endemic damp problems.

TrueScrumptious · 21/06/2023 19:40

The U.K. already has the smallest housing in Europe. I’m in a two-bed house and have three children -now in their 20s. They shared. Most siblings shared, amongst their primary school friends. We don’t have any en-suites, and only have one bathroom/loo. This is completely normal amongst those I know.

Babyroobs · 21/06/2023 19:40

The days that are coming are likely where adult kids can no longer afford to move out because rent and home ownership become out of reach of young people. I know a few thirty year olds who have overstretched themselves jumping in with 4 bedroom houses that they barely struggle to afford but those in their twenties i doubt will even be able to afford a 2 bed starter unless something changes.

Decafflatteplease · 21/06/2023 19:39

6 of us in a 3 bed / 1 bathroom here.

Would love to be able to move to a 4 or 5 bed but no way we can afford it

User19844666884 · 21/06/2023 19:39

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

No, not at all. And the two things are not unrelated.

Children are expensive. Being unable to have children means more disposable income than otherwise, and hence more affordability for a larger house, but it’s not a privilege.

Lavenderblume · 21/06/2023 19:39

Maybe there will be more multi -generational living with families pooling financial resources to buy or adapt a property they can share. We are about to move in with my husband's grandmother who lives in a big farmhouse. It will come with challenges but ultimately it'll help all of us.

Inthedarkagain · 21/06/2023 19:37

Orban · 21/06/2023 19:31

It's actual madness that we build houses with as many bathrooms as bedrooms while the bedrooms are so small they can't accommodate even basic bedroom furniture. Where are you supposed to put your clothes? Or study? In your frigging en suite bathroom?

We have this problem in our flat. 2 small bath rooms and two doubles that could be bigger. One room wouldn't fit a king bed that comfortably (would be hard to open the closet). It would have made much more sense to have a bathroom and a separate toilet and more bedroom space. But, we live near the sea, so they weren't built for families were they? They were built for second home/holiday let investors. This is a big problem. Much of what we have built in recent years were for either investors, pensioners with money, or people on large salaries upsizing. Very few starter homes for actual families.