Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it will soon become more normal for families to live in smaller houses

286 replies

flipflopfloop · 21/06/2023 17:27

With the recent rates increasing, borrowing costs are so high now that it would be at least 1200pcm in repayments for a small 2 bed house around here and it’s a relatively cheap area of the country. If not higher than this. Surely this will mean the days of having more bedrooms than people are numbered, and more and more families will have to make do with smaller living space - possibly leading to smaller family sizes even. I personally don’t think this is necessarily a bad thing. They are building lots of new developments on the outskirts of our city with prices starting from 350 for a 2 bed. A 4 bed home with three useable bedrooms there is easily 450-500. I find it interesting to wonder who will occupy these as presumably they are not yet sold and you would have to have at least a 6 figure household income to be able to afford this.

OP posts:
CandyLeBonBon · 21/06/2023 23:56

I'm in a 4 bed shared ownership social housing. 2 boys (now 18 and 21) and 1 girl (14) - 21 y/o is autistic and increasingly difficult to live with and I needed a 4 bed as it was inappropriate for any of them to share but I'm going to have to downsize at some point and no idea how I'll manage as 21y/o has significant issues and I know I can't afford what we've got forever. But what do you do? I have to house them and private rent was 3-400 a month more.

Thatleadsingersbiggestfan · 21/06/2023 23:48

Deathbyfluffy · 21/06/2023 19:12

That’s not a cheap area of the country, sorry.
Around here a 4 bed detached is only £300k not needing much work.

Rather than reassess how much space people need, maybe people need to move to cheaper areas.

What part of the country is this, out of interest?

Apricotflanday · 21/06/2023 23:43

ToBeOrNotToBee · 21/06/2023 21:57

For those of us in social housing, it's been the way since the 90s.

We now have children spending their entire childhoods in 1 bed hostels with their entire families.

It's nice the middle classes are finally seeing what everyone else has had to put up with.

Exactly. People who aren't wealthy people have always had to live like this.

Nat6999 · 21/06/2023 23:42

Anyone wanting to move to a larger home & struggling for money,look at ex council houses, they are usually well built & well insulated with loads of storage & you will pay a lot less than for an ordinary house. Ones like my old one are selling for £130k & you would have to pay £300k+ for an ordinary private 3 bed with a lot less space.

Apricotflanday · 21/06/2023 23:38

Where I live it's common for families to live in a one or two bedroom bedroom flat. Among friends from DC's school, I know families of 3 and 4 people in one bedroom flats and a family of five in a two bedroom flat. Those of us with teo bedrooms (2 adults, 1 child) are considered very lucky.

Simianwalk · 21/06/2023 23:35

@Ourladycheesusedatum
Your experience definitely wasnt the norm in Manchester. I worked in housing in the 90s and 00s. Most children shared a bedroom. Many shared with 3 or 4 siblings. Your experience was unusual.

Nat6999 · 21/06/2023 23:32

Most 3 bedroom houses are really only 2 decent bedrooms & a box room. It would be brilliant if builders could build homes with 3 equally sized rooms. It's the same for 4 beds, 3 proper sized rooms & a shoe box, when will builders realise that home owners want & need all bedrooms to be practical & have enough room for each bedroom to have enough room for more than just a bed & set of drawers. When I bought my house, it was one of the things that made ita home we could start a family in as all 3 bedrooms were big enough to fit a double bed & furniture, it is something that makes ex council houses so good, the amount of space & storage they have. To have bought a home that was the same size, I would have had to pay more than double the price to get a 22' × 11' living room, a 12' × 9' kitchen, a downstairs toilet, a utility room, a 14' ×11 master bedroom, a 11' & 10' second bedroom & 12' & 9' third bedroom & bathroom.

Upallnightfeeding · 21/06/2023 23:30

I agree with the post. Myself, husband and two year old live a one bed flat as it’s all we could afford to buy. My husband works full time and myself part time. A ‘family’ house of a 2 or 3 bed is something I don’t know if we’ll ever achieve. We are just so grateful for what we have and in reality it’s the perfect amount of space we need. Certainly no room for extras but I feel it’s perfectly manageable with a bit of creativity. I find it so sad to think of big old houses not being used properly. Im not jealous I just think a house should be used and enjoyed to the fullest potential. There’s so much life that could be lived in those rooms and garden yet you don’t see a soul ever, you know those kinds of holiday houses. It’s such a waste.

Labraradabrador · 21/06/2023 23:28

Arabels · 21/06/2023 22:09

Mixed feelings about this one because I tend to read all the references to ‘storage’ as evidence of our massive overconsumption. We really, really need to stop producing and buying so much of everything-clothes, kitchen gadgets, sports stuff that only gets used once…whatever.

Not children though! We really need them. I hope all the miserable fuckers relentlessly voting against young people are looking forward to the massive wave of immigration we’re going to need to keep the country running. Currently it’s too expensive and scary (what a world to bring a child into!) for a lot of people to have kids, or the number of kids they would ideally like.

But unless you are Uber minimalist, everyone has things to store: a cupboard for the mop, various bits of sports kit, shoes, uniform extras. I have maybe 5-10 outfits per season (so about a week’s worth) and need either space for everything or space to store half at a time. Most double bedrooms in the uk have no additional storage (a closet) and then barely fit a bed + wardrobe and dresser. There are also things you really should have, but rarely use (toolkit, torches, power tools, , etc. that need a space. We looked at some new builds in the UK that had zero built in cupboards and minimal space for freestanding storage furniture. I am not looking for massive walk-in closets to house handbags and designer shoes - I just want to be able to store the basics rather than live in a cluttered and/or claustrophobic environment.

Tophy124 · 21/06/2023 23:23

I think you’re right that less families can afford bigger homes and it’s being reflected in smaller family sizes. We won’t have more than 2 as we know we can’t afford them and probably will always have a 3 bedroom house.

caringcarer · 21/06/2023 23:15

When I was growing up I shared with my younger sister and my older sister had her own room. Other older sisters already.legt home. When my older sister got married and left home Mum offered me and my sister for one of us to move into the empty room but we chose not too. Were still incredibly close today. Closer to each other than to older sisters. Same sex children don't need their own room especially if it's a large room and they get on well.

nebulae · 21/06/2023 23:12

KipferlandCroissant · 21/06/2023 23:04

why the constant race to the bottom?

It's ok for the royal family to have multiple palaces and overseas property, but the rest of us should be grateful to have a roof in over-crowded accommodation? It's fine if people have properties with a "bedroom" so small they can't even fit a child's bed?

Why do we settle and accept to live like this?

Followed by "It's worst in Hong Kong", oh so that's ok then.

My post isn't about a race to the bottom. It's about someone coming onto a thread like this to ɓrag about how amazing their house is and how they couldn't possibly live in anything smaller.

(And no, I'm not jealous, I'm perfectly happy with my house, just don't feel the need to crow about it. )

25sheets · 21/06/2023 23:08

MyWishIsMyCommand · 21/06/2023 17:56

I don't understand this post.

It's completely out of context.

BestZebbie · 21/06/2023 23:05

In my recollection, in the 1980s/90s people had more children in a 3/4 bed house, so you often had three or four siblings sharing two rooms whereas now families with four children seem a bit less common overall and so the same house might now have two siblings, each with a room of their own.
Of course, that family of four moving to a 2-bed house wouldn't really just reset to the previous level of crowding, because the shared spaces would all get smaller too.

KipferlandCroissant · 21/06/2023 23:04

nebulae · 21/06/2023 22:52

Bloody hell! Have you any idea how privileged you sound?

"I love my huge house and I could never live in one of those little boxes you peasants live in"?

I think you'll find you could, if you had to 🙄

why the constant race to the bottom?

It's ok for the royal family to have multiple palaces and overseas property, but the rest of us should be grateful to have a roof in over-crowded accommodation? It's fine if people have properties with a "bedroom" so small they can't even fit a child's bed?

Why do we settle and accept to live like this?

Followed by "It's worst in Hong Kong", oh so that's ok then.

nebulae · 21/06/2023 22:52

Wiccan · 21/06/2023 20:45

Agree . We love a large home , love the space and have rooms for everything we need and a large garden . Could never live in a small home .

Bloody hell! Have you any idea how privileged you sound?

"I love my huge house and I could never live in one of those little boxes you peasants live in"?

I think you'll find you could, if you had to 🙄

Guiltridden12345 · 21/06/2023 22:50

Flippper · 21/06/2023 17:53

Hmm, growing up in the 80s my experience was different. Don't remember any friends sharing and most houses had en suites, though no the tiny ones you see squeezed in nowadays. I don't know which experience was more typical.

IME most if not all my friends had their own rooms but I didn’t see an en-suite bedroom in a house until I was in my 30s. I guess it depends on how affluent an area you grew up in!

ichundich · 21/06/2023 22:48

Houses are already ridiculously small in Britain. People need to change their attitudes about flats and building up. They are not a bad thing, and I don't understand why they have such a bad reputation. All across Europe its totally normal to live in a flat.

Ap42 · 21/06/2023 22:48

Single parent with an 11 year old son and 8 year old daughter. I managed to scrape enough together to buy a very small house 6 years ago after splitting with the kids dad. Could only afford a 2 bed. As the children have grown they needed their own room. Thankfully I was able to make an extra room out of my front room and the dining room is now our front room. We make it work and the mortgage costs are a lot lower than private renting. My Mum's in her 70's and was 1 of 5. They all shared as they had no choice.

WillaHermione · 21/06/2023 22:37

I live in a cottage flat otherwise known as a four in a block. Two flats upstairs and two downstairs. Each of us has our own front door (no shared entry) and front and back gardens. My block are two bedrooms, kitchen, living room and bathroom. Even these modest flats are now out of reach for any individual or couple with a household income below £50’000. My neighbour through the wall has had to put up stud walls in one of the bedrooms as they have two DC, one DS and one DD who at a guess are now 10 and 12.

CaptainSeven · 21/06/2023 22:37

Our 3 bed home (for 4 people) has a ground floor, first floor and attic. In total 105 square metres. The attic can never be converted. So our living space is 70 square metres.

One bathroom.

One bedroom is tiny and officially the "box room" plus has the stairwell box in it but when we viewed had a double bed in! I would do a better job than previous family in making a double bed work.

I WFH (have done since 2019) and have a Secretary desk in the living room.

I'd like a second toilet but we've decided to make do here and not upsize because we're running out of money each month and couldn't afford a bigger mortgage.

So we are staying in a smaller house due to finances.

3BSHKATS · 21/06/2023 22:36

ToBeOrNotToBee · 21/06/2023 21:57

For those of us in social housing, it's been the way since the 90s.

We now have children spending their entire childhoods in 1 bed hostels with their entire families.

It's nice the middle classes are finally seeing what everyone else has had to put up with.

Its nice is it ?

What a shitty comment

Crikeyalmighty · 21/06/2023 22:34

@Ourladycheesusedatum ha yes - we had 'the hatch ' and yes a big garden too.

We knew we were 'posh' because we had aluminium sliding patio doors!!!

Rayna37 · 21/06/2023 22:21

@Kazzyhoward that seems extraordinarily naive, I graduated over 20 years ago and can't think of anyone who didn't house share (except couples in one beds) for a few years, in any part of the country! I would have loved to rent on my own, but even once I could have just about afforded it, I accepted I needed to share to enable me to save the difference towards a deposit.

Namechangedforthis25 · 21/06/2023 22:21

DrCoconut · 21/06/2023 19:20

Confused at the idea of £290k being a cheap area. I'd expect a lot of house and garden for that. You'd be looking at under £100k for a 3 bed house on my street. Small yard rather than garden and not very leafy and suburban but people can still buy something here.

Ok but it’s comparative
because a 3 bed on our street went for £900k last month

so 290 is comparatively cheap