Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it will soon become more normal for families to live in smaller houses

286 replies

flipflopfloop · 21/06/2023 17:27

With the recent rates increasing, borrowing costs are so high now that it would be at least 1200pcm in repayments for a small 2 bed house around here and it’s a relatively cheap area of the country. If not higher than this. Surely this will mean the days of having more bedrooms than people are numbered, and more and more families will have to make do with smaller living space - possibly leading to smaller family sizes even. I personally don’t think this is necessarily a bad thing. They are building lots of new developments on the outskirts of our city with prices starting from 350 for a 2 bed. A 4 bed home with three useable bedrooms there is easily 450-500. I find it interesting to wonder who will occupy these as presumably they are not yet sold and you would have to have at least a 6 figure household income to be able to afford this.

OP posts:
Oliotya · 22/06/2023 13:04

Willyoujustbequiet · 22/06/2023 12:53

It really depends where you are.

Near me you can get a lovely 4 bed detached for approx £800.

But are there jobs to match?

Willyoujustbequiet · 22/06/2023 12:53

It really depends where you are.

Near me you can get a lovely 4 bed detached for approx £800.

Ingrowncrotchhair · 22/06/2023 12:16

Orban · 21/06/2023 18:58

Yes we've always had small houses. We still have small houses.

Big golf courses though.

I‘m with you on everything you said but particularly the big golf courses!!

Oliotya · 22/06/2023 12:09

I do wonder also what the broader societal impact of the housing crisis will be. Younger people whether in insecure private lets, or precariously mortgaged to the hilt, are likely going to feel very let down. A generation totally disenfranchised and disengaged with little stake in society. That surely can't be good.

bonfirebash · 22/06/2023 12:06

ichundich · 21/06/2023 22:48

Houses are already ridiculously small in Britain. People need to change their attitudes about flats and building up. They are not a bad thing, and I don't understand why they have such a bad reputation. All across Europe its totally normal to live in a flat.

The management fees are my issue
They basically can charge what they want, use expensive contractors and pass the costs on to us
I pay £170pm and that's in the NW. what does that cover... someone "gardening" or wrecking my tiny lawn once a month whether it needs doing or not, window cleaning and building insurance
They came to cut a tree that was too high and just lopped off one side of it to the trunk. No attempt at actual shaping of it

louladybug · 22/06/2023 12:03

I already know people who are stopping at one child because they can't afford to move.

Honeychickpea · 22/06/2023 11:53

Upallnightfeeding · 21/06/2023 23:30

I agree with the post. Myself, husband and two year old live a one bed flat as it’s all we could afford to buy. My husband works full time and myself part time. A ‘family’ house of a 2 or 3 bed is something I don’t know if we’ll ever achieve. We are just so grateful for what we have and in reality it’s the perfect amount of space we need. Certainly no room for extras but I feel it’s perfectly manageable with a bit of creativity. I find it so sad to think of big old houses not being used properly. Im not jealous I just think a house should be used and enjoyed to the fullest potential. There’s so much life that could be lived in those rooms and garden yet you don’t see a soul ever, you know those kinds of holiday houses. It’s such a waste.

So what do you view as the solution? Someone does a free house swap where you get the big old house and in return they gey your one bedroom house?

KirstenBlest · 22/06/2023 11:45

Not RTFT.
@Arabels , most of the new housing in the town where I live is flats. They are mainly open plan kitchen-diner-living room, and are short on storage space, because the floor space has been used to make money for the builders.

I think the consumption won't slow down all that much, but there will be more items being discarded.

Orban · 22/06/2023 11:08

DyslexicPoster · 22/06/2023 09:23

But your making vast assumptions here. I bought a spacious 3 bed in Hampshire bordering Surrey that I extended out to 5 five bedrooms. We have 4 comfortable doubles and I didn't extend over the garage side. Our income is £29,000.

Want to guess how we got a five bed detached house on 29k income?

There are so many possibilities of where the money came from you couldn't possibly guess correctly

Did you steal it?!! 🧐

Wiccan · 22/06/2023 10:34

DyslexicPoster · 22/06/2023 09:23

But your making vast assumptions here. I bought a spacious 3 bed in Hampshire bordering Surrey that I extended out to 5 five bedrooms. We have 4 comfortable doubles and I didn't extend over the garage side. Our income is £29,000.

Want to guess how we got a five bed detached house on 29k income?

There are so many possibilities of where the money came from you couldn't possibly guess correctly

Well if you're anything like us we have a lot of skills and ability that we can do it all ourselves might take a bit longer but we get there. We also make our income go a long way ( not actually sure how we do it we shock ourselves sometimes) 😲 . But yes there are lots of different ways people achieve what they want .

sunflowersunday · 22/06/2023 10:16

DyslexicPoster · 22/06/2023 09:23

But your making vast assumptions here. I bought a spacious 3 bed in Hampshire bordering Surrey that I extended out to 5 five bedrooms. We have 4 comfortable doubles and I didn't extend over the garage side. Our income is £29,000.

Want to guess how we got a five bed detached house on 29k income?

There are so many possibilities of where the money came from you couldn't possibly guess correctly

Well obviously an inheritance is different but for the most part , people buy houses they can’t afford and the banks allow it . We’re all suffering now and I’m part it’s due to our own greed and need to keep up with the Joneses.

DyslexicPoster · 22/06/2023 09:23

sunflowersunday · 22/06/2023 09:00

Sorry to single you out but unless you are both 100k earners , this is a perfect example of why people can’t afford their mortgage rate rises. How is a 3 bed house a “smaller house” ? And unless you’re a high income family , why do you need a 4 bedroom house next ? Obviously your house size it’s entirely your choice and none of my business but this is a great example of how we’ve all screwed our selves over by our own greed and the banks willingness to let us buy houses we cannot afford.

But your making vast assumptions here. I bought a spacious 3 bed in Hampshire bordering Surrey that I extended out to 5 five bedrooms. We have 4 comfortable doubles and I didn't extend over the garage side. Our income is £29,000.

Want to guess how we got a five bed detached house on 29k income?

There are so many possibilities of where the money came from you couldn't possibly guess correctly

sunflowersunday · 22/06/2023 09:00

Isengard · 21/06/2023 18:06

There are 4 of us in a 3 bedroom house, although DP and I obviously share a room, toddlers currently share, but we do have that third room if they want their own at some point, I guess!
Our next will probably be at least a 4 bed, we bought a smaller house this time to have more money left over from our sale for a decent deposit to start our portfolio.

Sorry to single you out but unless you are both 100k earners , this is a perfect example of why people can’t afford their mortgage rate rises. How is a 3 bed house a “smaller house” ? And unless you’re a high income family , why do you need a 4 bedroom house next ? Obviously your house size it’s entirely your choice and none of my business but this is a great example of how we’ve all screwed our selves over by our own greed and the banks willingness to let us buy houses we cannot afford.

KimberleyClark · 22/06/2023 08:37

I grew up in the 60s/70s in a three bedroom one bathroom house which if it were demolished today would be replaced with a five bedroom house with en-suites. Huge hall and landing, big rooms with huge windows which made it lovely and airy but which would be considered wasted space today.

Appleofmyeye2023 · 22/06/2023 08:36

groupery · 21/06/2023 20:53

Economics goes in cycles and always will

@Appleofmyeye2023 when was the up cycle after 08?

I’m referring to when interest rates started to fall seriously, and we’re at an historic prescedent for over 10 years at below 3%. That’s very unusual if you look at historic trends going back to 1880s.
im talking cycles of decade, not cycling form year to year. Like stock market economics is a sluggish trend that takes 10-15 year shifts.

Kazzyhoward · 22/06/2023 08:20

Labraradabrador · 21/06/2023 23:28

But unless you are Uber minimalist, everyone has things to store: a cupboard for the mop, various bits of sports kit, shoes, uniform extras. I have maybe 5-10 outfits per season (so about a week’s worth) and need either space for everything or space to store half at a time. Most double bedrooms in the uk have no additional storage (a closet) and then barely fit a bed + wardrobe and dresser. There are also things you really should have, but rarely use (toolkit, torches, power tools, , etc. that need a space. We looked at some new builds in the UK that had zero built in cupboards and minimal space for freestanding storage furniture. I am not looking for massive walk-in closets to house handbags and designer shoes - I just want to be able to store the basics rather than live in a cluttered and/or claustrophobic environment.

Fully agree. Our house has three small storage cupboards (about 3 feet square) and it's one of the reasons we love the house and havn't moved. As you say, you need somewhere to store your vacuum, clothes airer, ironing board which we use the understairs cupboard for. We also have a cupboard by the front door for coats, shoes, etc. And an upstairs cupboard we use to store bedding, duvets, etc. The house, otherwise, is actually pretty small, only room for a small wardrobe in each bedroom (so no space for bedding, duvets etc), and kitchen is small and only just fits in the white goods and cabinets, so no room in there for ironing board, vacuum, etc. We've often looked at houses for sale, new and older, and it's always the lack of storage that puts us off - when we think of the practicalities of where we'd put stuff, there simply isn't anywhere. Eg in some, there's literally nowhere to put long term storage like suitcases, christmas tree/decorations, etc. And no, it's not "overconsumption" - I wouldn't say having a vacuum, airer and ironing board is a sign of "overconsumption" and I'd hate to have things like that just lying around on open view in the lounge! We're actually pretty minimalistic and don't buy things we don't need, but I just like things put away!

Kazzyhoward · 22/06/2023 08:12

@IBetGordonRamsayDoesntHaveTheseProblems

High housing costs and suchlike is only going to push people towards having no or fewer children.

But it won't stop Wayne and Waynetta popping out a few extra sprogs between watching daytime TV and drinking copious amounts of lager.

Kazzyhoward · 22/06/2023 08:10

stayathomer · 21/06/2023 20:44

Are you not mostly assuming people are living in towns and cities though? I think more people will realise that there isn’t as much of an advantage to living in expensive houses in a city or near one when you can live rurally and get a cheaper house

It's the towns and cities were the decent jobs are though! It's often only low paid retail/hospitality work in more rural areas. Not easy to live in a lower cost rural or run down area when you have a 2 hour commute (or longer) to the nearest city where the decent jobs are located!

Wiccan · 22/06/2023 02:09

nebulae · 21/06/2023 23:12

My post isn't about a race to the bottom. It's about someone coming onto a thread like this to ɓrag about how amazing their house is and how they couldn't possibly live in anything smaller.

(And no, I'm not jealous, I'm perfectly happy with my house, just don't feel the need to crow about it. )

Well I'm happy with my house and I'm allowed to say so !!

Wiccan · 22/06/2023 01:57

nebulae · 21/06/2023 22:52

Bloody hell! Have you any idea how privileged you sound?

"I love my huge house and I could never live in one of those little boxes you peasants live in"?

I think you'll find you could, if you had to 🙄

Absolutely did not say anything like what you have quoted ! . I didn't have a very good upbringing and have lived in a tiny box of a house actually and at one point in a caravan on someone's sodding driveway ,oh yeah that felt really privileged !!!! so i have worked my bloody tits off so me and my family never had ever live that way again. OK !

IBetGordonRamsayDoesntHaveTheseProblems · 22/06/2023 00:42

The birth rate is already declining, and this sort of thing will only accelerate it. It's not just the cost of housing, it's childcare, clothes, food, and all the rest of it.

I'm in my 30s. Good job we never intended to have children as we've put a lodger in the spare room and the money has been very useful; a baby would mean losing the lodger income and having all the usual expenses on top.

In our immediate social circles, 5 are adamantly childfree, 3 have never really talked about it and I can't envisage them parenting anyway, 2 are fence sitters, 2 have vague future intentions to procreate and only 2 are keen. It's an unremarkable group from a demographic point of view; not career high fliers nor poverty stricken. High housing costs and suchlike is only going to push people towards having no or fewer children.

Bluedab · 22/06/2023 00:24

I also didnt no anyone with a spare bedroom when u grew up in the 90s. Now, i dont no anyone who doesnt have one. Partly driven by people moving further from their family for work potentially but it was unheard of when i was young.

Bluedab · 22/06/2023 00:18

I grew up in the 90's and shared a bedroom with DS. No one thought anything of it. Thinking back around half my friends probably shared a room. I grew up in a victorian house, those who didnt share had new builds. Their house had more rooms but my house was probably bigger. The bedroom I shared was huge. Im not saying you couldn't do it but two kids sharing in a new build isnt the same. I dont remember knowing anyone with an ensuite as a child.

Mamai90 · 22/06/2023 00:12

Flippper · 21/06/2023 17:53

Hmm, growing up in the 80s my experience was different. Don't remember any friends sharing and most houses had en suites, though no the tiny ones you see squeezed in nowadays. I don't know which experience was more typical.

I honestly didn't know one family with an ensuite back in the 80s or early 90s and I'm from a middle class area. I think my auntie was the first to have an ensuite when she bought a new build in around '96.

And as for the rooms all of my childhood friends shared unless they had siblings of a different gender. Even my sister and I shared and we had 3 bedrooms but one was kept for guests. We didn't have separate rooms until we had an extension built in the late '90s.