Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel slightly annoyed at DH not getting a higher paying job?

866 replies

carrotstyx · 21/06/2023 17:19

So dh is very well qualified. When we first met, I was always told by him how he was going to get X job and earn X amount by this stage of life etc. I believed him. It came around to applying for these jobs, and the market had all but closed up. So he accepted a different job as a stop gap. It's decently paid, but not very highly paid like he said he was going to get.

That's fine. His employer knows the market has changed so dh is at risk of jumping ship for far higher pay elsewhere. So they have offered to fund a masters course for him, which he has accepted, which means he would have to work for the company for 2 years or face paying back £20k. The masters isn't really worth that, and people in his industry have told me that it's a bit of a waste of time. Essentially, his employer has dangled a rotten carrot to keep him working for them as they wouldn't be able to replace him. There is no scope for asking for a pay increase as it's a huge multinational with strict rules.

I think the real reason dh wants to stay in the job is that it's 10am-6pm, and generally zero pressure. But before this, he was all for going for the very highly paid job and working long hours to set himself up in a lucrative career. This suited us as I work in a long hours high pressure job, so it sort of feels like he no longer aims for the stars because he knows that (hopefully) I am on the track to a high paying job, so he will still benefit from a high salary.

OP posts:
YeahIsaidit · 25/06/2023 10:43

MaybeSmaller · 25/06/2023 10:38

When we first met, I was always told by him how he was going to get X job and earn X amount by this stage of life etc. I believed him.

It amazes me how much weight is being put on this statement. For all we know they may have been 19 year old undergrads when they had this conversation. Adolescent bravado based on zero real world experience does not amount to a shared life plan.

When you actually get to the stage of life where you understand what it takes to earn the big bucks, you may well decide that it's not for you, and that's when the serious conversations need to start. When I was 19, 20, 21 I wanted to do all sorts of things that never actually came about.

There are some crazy opinions on this thread, such as working a low-stress full time job you love for £40K is "coasting". Nobody I know who earns £40K is coasting, and surely nobody sane actively seeks out career paths that they know in advance are going to be severely stressful to them. Stress is a huge killer. Not much point planning your £250K lifestyle when dh is dead of a heart attack at 40 years old.

There seems to be a pernicious opinion among high earners that if someone earns a quarter as much as them, they must only work a quarter as hard, or must be 4 times lazier, or some variation of that theme.

Exactly this!!

Crikeyalmighty · 25/06/2023 10:43

@MaybeSmaller Yep I posted as such a while back- it's an incredibly arrogant view

MaybeSmaller · 25/06/2023 10:38

When we first met, I was always told by him how he was going to get X job and earn X amount by this stage of life etc. I believed him.

It amazes me how much weight is being put on this statement. For all we know they may have been 19 year old undergrads when they had this conversation. Adolescent bravado based on zero real world experience does not amount to a shared life plan.

When you actually get to the stage of life where you understand what it takes to earn the big bucks, you may well decide that it's not for you, and that's when the serious conversations need to start. When I was 19, 20, 21 I wanted to do all sorts of things that never actually came about.

There are some crazy opinions on this thread, such as working a low-stress full time job you love for £40K is "coasting". Nobody I know who earns £40K is coasting, and surely nobody sane actively seeks out career paths that they know in advance are going to be severely stressful to them. Stress is a huge killer. Not much point planning your £250K lifestyle when dh is dead of a heart attack at 40 years old.

There seems to be a pernicious opinion among high earners that if someone earns a quarter as much as them, they must only work a quarter as hard, or must be 4 times lazier, or some variation of that theme.

G5000 · 25/06/2023 10:33

If a marriage is dependent on someone's earning potential, it's a shite marriage and I feel sorry for everyone involved

It's part of the bigger picture. I want what I believe is best for our family and that includes financial stability and a certain lifestyle. I want not to stress about paying bills, I don't want to tell my DC they can't do an activity because we can't afford it. I want them to be able to travel and see the world, and not on a shoestring. I've been poor and I really didn't like it. This does not mean that other people should want the same. But my partner should.

whumpthereitis · 25/06/2023 10:06

MykonosMaiden · 25/06/2023 09:53

The lack of reading comprehension on here Is astounding

It’s deliberate. Probably taken directly from ‘A Beginner’s Guide to Sophistry’.

MykonosMaiden · 25/06/2023 09:53

karmakameleon · 25/06/2023 08:20

Nobody needs to add bits in. The OP was clear that the DH wasn’t wishy washy “that’s nice dear”. In fact he was very specific.

So dh is very well qualified. When we first met, I was always told by him how he was going to get X job and earn X amount by this stage of life etc. I believed him.

The lack of reading comprehension on here Is astounding

SouthLondonMum22 · 25/06/2023 08:52

YeahIsaidit · 24/06/2023 23:13

If a marriage is dependent on someone's earning potential, it's a shite marriage and I feel sorry for everyone involved

For me, it’s based on equality and shared goals including finances.

I would not agree to marry someone if it meant carrying the majority of the financial load because the other person didn’t fancy it.

karmakameleon · 25/06/2023 08:20

ProfessorXtra · 25/06/2023 08:14

Why are you assuming things op hasn’t wrote?

The Dh isn’t posting. We can only go off what op is saying like on all thread. She said they made and agreed a plan.

You have decided this grown man half hearted listened to ops plan, have some platitudes of ‘that’s nice dear’ but was never on board, then he married her knowing that he wasn’t on board. That would make him a really shitty person. You don’t mislead someone into thinking you have the same life plan, pretend to agree then marry them and back track.

Is it not more likely that he changes his mind? Your version makes him a shit.

Besides which, if we can all add bits in, shall I add in that in a few years he probably won’t work at all. He is going to get sacked. The type to have an affair. All of that is as irrelevant as your opinion that he didn’t actually agree to it. How would you even know that?

Let’s hope you don’t marry someone who pretends their goals align with yours and then backs out.

Nobody needs to add bits in. The OP was clear that the DH wasn’t wishy washy “that’s nice dear”. In fact he was very specific.

So dh is very well qualified. When we first met, I was always told by him how he was going to get X job and earn X amount by this stage of life etc. I believed him.

DisenchantedDewberry · 25/06/2023 08:19

That was meant to say totally agree with the comments disagreeing with you 🤣 it didn't put the quote in aha.

Clearly too early for my brain to engage properly.

DisenchantedDewberry · 25/06/2023 08:16

Totally agree.

ProfessorXtra · 25/06/2023 08:14

YeahIsaidit · 24/06/2023 22:17

Everyone should have access to the money that they earned. That's not complicated. It isn't lying to say "that sounds nice" when someone's talking about how they want to travel the world and have a nice big house etc, it also isn't committing to achieving it or agreeing that's a shared goal, it's simply saying that it sounds nice. We don't know if they sat down and said in X amount of years we want to be here and have and do this, it's just being assumed due to the OP. For all we know she wants all that's mentioned and he doesn't and never said he did.

Regardless, as said this man is being bashed saying he's happily benefitting from ops wage. He is earning his own money and contributing, he's studying alongside that so it isn't stopping him from working so who gives a toss if its his 4th masters, it's effecting nothing and he's happy. I'm not saying that OP should sacrifice her happiness but at the same time why should he sacrifice his for her aspirations, he's not telling her that she has to work this high pressure high earnings job, SHE is annoyed that he isn't doing the same. I hope if I ever get married it's for love and not earning potential and nice houses

Why are you assuming things op hasn’t wrote?

The Dh isn’t posting. We can only go off what op is saying like on all thread. She said they made and agreed a plan.

You have decided this grown man half hearted listened to ops plan, have some platitudes of ‘that’s nice dear’ but was never on board, then he married her knowing that he wasn’t on board. That would make him a really shitty person. You don’t mislead someone into thinking you have the same life plan, pretend to agree then marry them and back track.

Is it not more likely that he changes his mind? Your version makes him a shit.

Besides which, if we can all add bits in, shall I add in that in a few years he probably won’t work at all. He is going to get sacked. The type to have an affair. All of that is as irrelevant as your opinion that he didn’t actually agree to it. How would you even know that?

Let’s hope you don’t marry someone who pretends their goals align with yours and then backs out.

DrSbaitso · 25/06/2023 07:38

YeahIsaidit · 24/06/2023 23:13

If a marriage is dependent on someone's earning potential, it's a shite marriage and I feel sorry for everyone involved

If you don't think it matters to have a shared outlook towards finances with your life partner, then you are free to ignore it when looking for someone, discussing your compatibility and going through life together. Good luck.

whumpthereitis · 24/06/2023 23:40

YeahIsaidit · 24/06/2023 23:13

If a marriage is dependent on someone's earning potential, it's a shite marriage and I feel sorry for everyone involved

Okay 🤷🏻‍♀️

For me, a happy marriage is dependent on not only love, but shared outlook and goals (and yes that does indeed involve finances!). That’s fine if you don’t like it, it isn’t necessary for you to approve.

PegsPigs · 24/06/2023 23:13

MykonosMaiden · 24/06/2023 16:09

So, you work PT and earn more. Presumably because you are 'PT' you do more of the household stuff, yet he gets to coast?
You're being taken for a mug.

I have more time to do things round the house on my day off but we divvy things up and we each choose to do them when it suits us. He does the cooking and food shopping whereas I do the ironing and bill paying. There's other stuff obviously but I have spoken to him about the division of labour and we've evened it out more.

YeahIsaidit · 24/06/2023 23:13

If a marriage is dependent on someone's earning potential, it's a shite marriage and I feel sorry for everyone involved

whumpthereitis · 24/06/2023 23:04

I hope if I ever get married it's for love and not earning potential and nice houses

it’s not an either/or, as you can indeed have both. Shared attitudes and plans when it comes to money are important, and it’s foolish to think they’re not. Love can turn to resentment and dislike very quickly if you find yourself on a different page to your partner.

whumpthereitis · 24/06/2023 23:01

YeahIsaidit · 24/06/2023 22:17

Everyone should have access to the money that they earned. That's not complicated. It isn't lying to say "that sounds nice" when someone's talking about how they want to travel the world and have a nice big house etc, it also isn't committing to achieving it or agreeing that's a shared goal, it's simply saying that it sounds nice. We don't know if they sat down and said in X amount of years we want to be here and have and do this, it's just being assumed due to the OP. For all we know she wants all that's mentioned and he doesn't and never said he did.

Regardless, as said this man is being bashed saying he's happily benefitting from ops wage. He is earning his own money and contributing, he's studying alongside that so it isn't stopping him from working so who gives a toss if its his 4th masters, it's effecting nothing and he's happy. I'm not saying that OP should sacrifice her happiness but at the same time why should he sacrifice his for her aspirations, he's not telling her that she has to work this high pressure high earnings job, SHE is annoyed that he isn't doing the same. I hope if I ever get married it's for love and not earning potential and nice houses

Given that OP is married to him, it’s generally pretty safe to assume they talked about it beyond half hearted ‘yes, that looks nice’ when OP spoke of holiday and house plans, especially as he was engaged enough to talk of his plans for career progression.

it’s unfortunate that OP won’t get those things with him, but that thankfully doesn’t mean she won’t get them, either by herself or with someone else that DOES share her ideals.

If it’s unreasonable for her to expect him to do anything that makes him unhappy, then it’s unreasonable for him to expect that of her. He doesn’t have to sacrifice anything if he doesn’t want to though, as he can take his 4 masters and his £40k and live as he is able to. Maybe he’ll be happy, and maybe he won’t.

DrSbaitso · 24/06/2023 22:33

YeahIsaidit · 24/06/2023 22:17

Everyone should have access to the money that they earned. That's not complicated. It isn't lying to say "that sounds nice" when someone's talking about how they want to travel the world and have a nice big house etc, it also isn't committing to achieving it or agreeing that's a shared goal, it's simply saying that it sounds nice. We don't know if they sat down and said in X amount of years we want to be here and have and do this, it's just being assumed due to the OP. For all we know she wants all that's mentioned and he doesn't and never said he did.

Regardless, as said this man is being bashed saying he's happily benefitting from ops wage. He is earning his own money and contributing, he's studying alongside that so it isn't stopping him from working so who gives a toss if its his 4th masters, it's effecting nothing and he's happy. I'm not saying that OP should sacrifice her happiness but at the same time why should he sacrifice his for her aspirations, he's not telling her that she has to work this high pressure high earnings job, SHE is annoyed that he isn't doing the same. I hope if I ever get married it's for love and not earning potential and nice houses

Everyone should have access to the money that they earned.

I don't think anyone is saying otherwise?

It isn't lying to say "that sounds nice" when someone's talking about how they want to travel the world and have a nice big house etc, it also isn't committing to achieving it or agreeing that's a shared goal, it's simply saying that it sounds nice.

Well it's actually something that someone who wasn't there made up in order to portray OP as the villain, but even if it's what happened...what an imbecile. Of course you need to speak up if your life partner is telling you what they want and you aren't prepared to go along with it. Being mealy mouthed and wishy washy in response doesn't make you the good guy.

I'm not saying that OP should sacrifice her happiness but at the same time why should he sacrifice his for her aspirations, he's not telling her that she has to work this high pressure high earnings job, SHE is annoyed that he isn't doing the same.

Yes, because they had a shared vision and he has now gone against it. But if he really doesn't need her income to be happy, he'll be just as fulfilled and satisfied as he is now if they split up, on his £40k.

I hope if I ever get married it's for love and not earning potential and nice houses

I hope if you ever get married, you and your husband have a truly shared vision regarding money, because it's the number one thing that couples argue about and anyone who thinks you can build a life together without agreeing about it is living in cloud cuckoo land. It's facile to reduce it down to mere materialism and to imagine it's not important.

Nsky62 · 24/06/2023 22:29

You want what you may not get, fertility and health are valuable, despite high paying jobs.
Don’t assume things will go plan

YeahIsaidit · 24/06/2023 22:17

DrSbaitso · 24/06/2023 22:05

One income doesn’t necessarily equal one pot. It's entirely possible to siphon it off into more than one account and some couples do it that way. It's more a question of who has access than who fills it up.

As I said in a previous post it could be the case that OP spouted off all these ideas and DH just half heartedly agreed that that did indeed sound nice without actually committing to achieving it.

Well then he's an idiot or even a liar, because OP was clear about what she wanted (and why do you consider an honest conversation to be "spouting off"?) and he didn't have the decency or guts to be honest and open about the fact that he wasn't on board with it. Why would you think that would make OP look bad?

The high income is really affecting how people feel about this, isn't it? No wonder OP didn't want to give the numbers.

Everyone should have access to the money that they earned. That's not complicated. It isn't lying to say "that sounds nice" when someone's talking about how they want to travel the world and have a nice big house etc, it also isn't committing to achieving it or agreeing that's a shared goal, it's simply saying that it sounds nice. We don't know if they sat down and said in X amount of years we want to be here and have and do this, it's just being assumed due to the OP. For all we know she wants all that's mentioned and he doesn't and never said he did.

Regardless, as said this man is being bashed saying he's happily benefitting from ops wage. He is earning his own money and contributing, he's studying alongside that so it isn't stopping him from working so who gives a toss if its his 4th masters, it's effecting nothing and he's happy. I'm not saying that OP should sacrifice her happiness but at the same time why should he sacrifice his for her aspirations, he's not telling her that she has to work this high pressure high earnings job, SHE is annoyed that he isn't doing the same. I hope if I ever get married it's for love and not earning potential and nice houses

DrSbaitso · 24/06/2023 22:05

YeahIsaidit · 24/06/2023 21:58

In the instance of a STHP it's disingenuous to say it all goes into the one pot when there is only one, the working parents earnings. That isn't what's happening here, both partners are contributing one just seems to be happier in a more easy going, lesser earning job. Aspirations change, it's unfortunate that means OP won't get the high flying lifestyle she wants from that but other than OP saying "that's what WE wanted" there's no indication he actually did. As I said in a previous post it could be the case that OP spouted off all these ideas and DH just half heartedly agreed that that did indeed sound nice without actually committing to achieving it.

One income doesn’t necessarily equal one pot. It's entirely possible to siphon it off into more than one account and some couples do it that way. It's more a question of who has access than who fills it up.

As I said in a previous post it could be the case that OP spouted off all these ideas and DH just half heartedly agreed that that did indeed sound nice without actually committing to achieving it.

Well then he's an idiot or even a liar, because OP was clear about what she wanted (and why do you consider an honest conversation to be "spouting off"?) and he didn't have the decency or guts to be honest and open about the fact that he wasn't on board with it. Why would you think that would make OP look bad?

The high income is really affecting how people feel about this, isn't it? No wonder OP didn't want to give the numbers.

YeahIsaidit · 24/06/2023 21:58

In the instance of a STHP it's disingenuous to say it all goes into the one pot when there is only one, the working parents earnings. That isn't what's happening here, both partners are contributing one just seems to be happier in a more easy going, lesser earning job. Aspirations change, it's unfortunate that means OP won't get the high flying lifestyle she wants from that but other than OP saying "that's what WE wanted" there's no indication he actually did. As I said in a previous post it could be the case that OP spouted off all these ideas and DH just half heartedly agreed that that did indeed sound nice without actually committing to achieving it.

DrSbaitso · 24/06/2023 21:38

YeahIsaidit · 24/06/2023 18:51

I'm getting bothered by the "he's enjoying living off her wage" posts. Every single time a finance related thing comes up there are numerous "it's all goes into the family pot, it's all ours we have equal spends even though DH earns more" and it's supported and agreed on. Reverse situation and the guy is getting blasted. It's like women are encouraged to benefit from a man's wages but the other way round gets bashed

He's not a SAHD and even if he were, that also needs to be a joint decision.

They had a shared vision. It doesn't actually matter what it is. OP entered the marriage on the understanding that he'd at least try to fulfil his part of it and he isn't.

If he had progressed as expected and then suddenly become unable to work through illness or disability, I suspect OP would feel differently even if the changed life was a hard adjustment. The issue is that they're no longer on the same page in terms of the life they build together.

Meow8928 · 24/06/2023 21:10

If you have a teen you’re likely a bit older than OP and established yourself with a house, education earlier. So not comparable

ProfessorXtra · 24/06/2023 19:28

YeahIsaidit · 24/06/2023 18:51

I'm getting bothered by the "he's enjoying living off her wage" posts. Every single time a finance related thing comes up there are numerous "it's all goes into the family pot, it's all ours we have equal spends even though DH earns more" and it's supported and agreed on. Reverse situation and the guy is getting blasted. It's like women are encouraged to benefit from a man's wages but the other way round gets bashed

I don’t think that’s true. I think some posters do the family pot thing.

A lot of a posters do not. Which is shown by the ‘I am a sahm and dh gives me a fiver a week’ threads that pop up several times a week.

I also think the situation is different if both people have chosen for one person to be a sahp. I do believe that should be a family pot with equal access. But again, only if both are happy and want one to be sahp. I think it would really odd to say ‘yes I would also like you to be a sahp but have only have access to the money I allow’

Personally, I won’t get married and share finances with anyone again. Though me and exh never did the ‘one pot’ I don’t want to be financially linked to anyone again.

So you won’t see me advocating for ‘everything goes on one pot’

and as I said before, I out earn dp by quite a lot. I knew that when I met him and we got together. That was my choice. If we were earning the same and he decided to reduce his earnings and tries to make me obliged to carry most of the financial burden I would absolutely see it as him Attempting to live off me. The main issue is making decisions and plans that really impact the other person, not telling them and expecting them to pick up the slack.