Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel slightly annoyed at DH not getting a higher paying job?

866 replies

carrotstyx · 21/06/2023 17:19

So dh is very well qualified. When we first met, I was always told by him how he was going to get X job and earn X amount by this stage of life etc. I believed him. It came around to applying for these jobs, and the market had all but closed up. So he accepted a different job as a stop gap. It's decently paid, but not very highly paid like he said he was going to get.

That's fine. His employer knows the market has changed so dh is at risk of jumping ship for far higher pay elsewhere. So they have offered to fund a masters course for him, which he has accepted, which means he would have to work for the company for 2 years or face paying back £20k. The masters isn't really worth that, and people in his industry have told me that it's a bit of a waste of time. Essentially, his employer has dangled a rotten carrot to keep him working for them as they wouldn't be able to replace him. There is no scope for asking for a pay increase as it's a huge multinational with strict rules.

I think the real reason dh wants to stay in the job is that it's 10am-6pm, and generally zero pressure. But before this, he was all for going for the very highly paid job and working long hours to set himself up in a lucrative career. This suited us as I work in a long hours high pressure job, so it sort of feels like he no longer aims for the stars because he knows that (hopefully) I am on the track to a high paying job, so he will still benefit from a high salary.

OP posts:
karmakameleon · 25/06/2023 13:38

DH and I trained as accountants with the big 4. Every single person I trained with lives in a million plus pound house and sends their children to private school. Personally I’m not at all career driven and I certainly won’t be dying of a heart attack because of work related stress and I’m on a comfortable six figure salary. If OP’s DH trained in a similar profession it’s really not unreasonable to assume that he’d be earning £100k+ one day. I think many people don’t realise that professions exist where £40k is what you earn as a starting salary.

whumpthereitis · 25/06/2023 13:35

YeahIsaidit · 25/06/2023 13:20

I get the impression that if DH was spending vast amounts of money on himself and hobbies it would have been mentioned in the OP as that would be another thing stopping OP from achieving "their shared goal"

Who said anything about hobbies, barring you? That’s another one of the strawmen you’ve constructed.

We get it, OP should be happy to settle for less, no matter what her partner may have said. She’s not allowed to have an issue over her husband either lying to her or changing his mind on a fundamental life plan. She’s a higher earner so therefore she’s the in the wrong, and how dare she want more than what you’re happy to settle for? And yes, we know, as is always the case when a poster is clearly butthurt over someone having more than what they have, you genuinely wouldn’t want that lifestyle and could have it if you did.

karmakameleon · 25/06/2023 13:33

YeahIsaidit · 25/06/2023 13:20

I get the impression that if DH was spending vast amounts of money on himself and hobbies it would have been mentioned in the OP as that would be another thing stopping OP from achieving "their shared goal"

His hobby seems to be studying for master’s degrees. That ain’t cheap.

YeahIsaidit · 25/06/2023 13:32

I have no issue with people wanting material things, everyone wants nice things and a nice lifestyle. I do think it's wrong criticise a partner who has found something that works for them when for most it would be more than substantial purely as years ago they said they wanted to be doing x and earning y as if it was some kind of promise they'd broken when they hadn't. It looks like OP saw £ signs and took this as the reason to get married, which is grim

SouthLondonMum22 · 25/06/2023 13:25

whumpthereitis · 25/06/2023 13:17

and once again you’re bleating on about materialism. We get it, you don’t approve of OP’s lifestyle. You don’t need to. No one cares whether you like it or not.

he is certainly benefiting from her bringing in the majority wage. He led her to believe he would be striving to match her, and he’s not done that. Once again, yes he’s entitled to change his mind. If he lied to her, he’s an arsehole, but if he changed his mind, which isn’t unreasonable for him to do, it’s still not unreasonable for her to decide that doesn’t work for her and it isn’t what she wants from a partner/out of life.

Who cares what way the vote has gone? OP is a higher earner, that was to he expected.

This too. Of course the votes haven't gone OP's way, she's a high earner and a woman. No one likes that.

SouthLondonMum22 · 25/06/2023 13:23

YeahIsaidit · 25/06/2023 13:20

I get the impression that if DH was spending vast amounts of money on himself and hobbies it would have been mentioned in the OP as that would be another thing stopping OP from achieving "their shared goal"

You only see what you want to see in the OP anyway so I'm sure even if it was there, you'd have your excuse ready for the DH.

YeahIsaidit · 25/06/2023 13:20

I get the impression that if DH was spending vast amounts of money on himself and hobbies it would have been mentioned in the OP as that would be another thing stopping OP from achieving "their shared goal"

whumpthereitis · 25/06/2023 13:17

YeahIsaidit · 25/06/2023 13:01

I don't see any carrying of financial burdens either, it isn't like they're hard up and DH is laying around doing fuck all. OP hasn't mentioned anything about struggling or that DH is spending a fortune on "hobbies" etc which would back up the claims that he's enjoying his lifestyle on her money. He isn't doing that. Nobody is demanding OP stays in a high earning job, she's miffed he won't get one. It just seems like "I WANT ALL THIS STUFF AND DH ISN'T HELPING ME GET IT!"

The vote has gone against OP and she hasn't returned to back anything up so by all accounts I am not alone with this view

and once again you’re bleating on about materialism. We get it, you don’t approve of OP’s lifestyle. You don’t need to. No one cares whether you like it or not.

he is certainly benefiting from her bringing in the majority wage. He led her to believe he would be striving to match her, and he’s not done that. Once again, yes he’s entitled to change his mind. If he lied to her, he’s an arsehole, but if he changed his mind, which isn’t unreasonable for him to do, it’s still not unreasonable for her to decide that doesn’t work for her and it isn’t what she wants from a partner/out of life.

Who cares what way the vote has gone? OP is a higher earner, that was to he expected.

SouthLondonMum22 · 25/06/2023 13:11

YeahIsaidit · 25/06/2023 13:01

I don't see any carrying of financial burdens either, it isn't like they're hard up and DH is laying around doing fuck all. OP hasn't mentioned anything about struggling or that DH is spending a fortune on "hobbies" etc which would back up the claims that he's enjoying his lifestyle on her money. He isn't doing that. Nobody is demanding OP stays in a high earning job, she's miffed he won't get one. It just seems like "I WANT ALL THIS STUFF AND DH ISN'T HELPING ME GET IT!"

The vote has gone against OP and she hasn't returned to back anything up so by all accounts I am not alone with this view

Earning the majority of the money is carrying the financial burden. They are comfortable because of her salary and they aren't hard up also because of her salary.

Like you said, OP didn't come back so we don't know for sure but you can't say her DH is or isn't doing anything either. I'd just be surprised if he wasn't benefiting from OP's money.

YeahIsaidit · 25/06/2023 13:01

I don't see any carrying of financial burdens either, it isn't like they're hard up and DH is laying around doing fuck all. OP hasn't mentioned anything about struggling or that DH is spending a fortune on "hobbies" etc which would back up the claims that he's enjoying his lifestyle on her money. He isn't doing that. Nobody is demanding OP stays in a high earning job, she's miffed he won't get one. It just seems like "I WANT ALL THIS STUFF AND DH ISN'T HELPING ME GET IT!"

The vote has gone against OP and she hasn't returned to back anything up so by all accounts I am not alone with this view

SouthLondonMum22 · 25/06/2023 13:00

YeahIsaidit · 25/06/2023 11:38

Not having foreign travel and a big house doesn't cause health issues

Carrying the financial load of a family can though.

It all seems to be about her husband's happiness, her husband's health etc with very little regard to OP's feelings and health.

Crikeyalmighty · 25/06/2023 13:00

@whumpthereitis I don't actually disagree- but compromise is a two way thing- if she can't live with a lesser plan (and totally her right) then if he loves her enough then he either steps up to the plate or they should separate.

At the end of the day it depends how much underlying love there still is in the pot and talking it through and making appropriate choices- even if that means moving on. Personally I think OP is probably setting herself up for a bit of a disappointment in life if she stays with it - as he sounds like a perpetual student.

Doesn't mean she doesn't care, just means they no longer actually value the same things. I'm not on one side or the other. Sometimes things don't work out.

YeahIsaidit · 25/06/2023 12:57

whumpthereitis · 25/06/2023 12:51

Funnily enough the onus seems to be on her to adapt and to accept him in the name of love, yet no one seriously seems to be suggesting that if he loves her then he should adapt to suit her.

You are separating those things out as if they can’t be intrinsically linked. Love can die very quickly when you feel your partner has lied to and misled you, or if your values and vision for the future no longer align. It easily dies when disappointment and resentments flourish.

There's a vast difference between accepting that buying a massive house and foreign holidays is out of reach and accepting that someone doesn't want to work a high stress job to earn the big bucks to get those things. Health and contentment should be put before material things.

We do not know that this was a shared goal that was committed to by DH we only have OPs POV, it could be crossed wires, misinterpreting what the other was saying etc. When OPs wants are a high flying lifestyle and DH wants to live comfortably without added stress, yes I do think that trumps the material shit

whumpthereitis · 25/06/2023 12:51

Crikeyalmighty · 25/06/2023 12:22

@ProfessorXtra they need to talk about it and she is of course well within her rights to split up if his expectations and values no longer tie in with hers. As I said it comes down to how much she/he really love each other and value the relationship - not just his/her earning power.

Funnily enough the onus seems to be on her to adapt and to accept him in the name of love, yet no one seriously seems to be suggesting that if he loves her then he should adapt to suit her.

You are separating those things out as if they can’t be intrinsically linked. Love can die very quickly when you feel your partner has lied to and misled you, or if your values and vision for the future no longer align. It easily dies when disappointment and resentments flourish.

whumpthereitis · 25/06/2023 12:45

YeahIsaidit · 25/06/2023 11:38

Not having foreign travel and a big house doesn't cause health issues

No, but the added stress of knowing you’re the one carrying the majority of the financial burden can. Especially when you thought your partner wanted the same as you, and was committed to maximizing their income as you have been.

Your entire position seems to be that OP is wrong because you think she’s materialistic. You’re totally ignoring that while it may be inherently unreasonable for someone to change their mind in regards to life plans they’ve made with their partner, it’s also not unreasonable for their partner to decide that’s not the life they want. Money, children, where to live, it doesn’t matter. The issue is a fundamental incompatibility has become apparent. I’m sure you can see why that would be a problem for OP, but instead you’re choosing to berate her because you don’t approve of what she wants from life.

She wants a large house and to travel. There’s nothing wrong with wanting those things, and it doesn’t matter if you personally don’t want/can’t have them. No one said you had to, yet you seem to think OP should have to settle for less than she wants because it’s works for you.

Crikeyalmighty · 25/06/2023 12:22

@ProfessorXtra they need to talk about it and she is of course well within her rights to split up if his expectations and values no longer tie in with hers. As I said it comes down to how much she/he really love each other and value the relationship - not just his/her earning power.

Blossomtoes · 25/06/2023 12:15

Or low earner and really old age. In fact life expectancy lowers, the less you earn. The areas of the country where life expectancy is at its lowest are the some of the poorest areas.

Life expectancy is extrapolated across population, it certainly doesn’t translate into it being lower on an individual level.

ProfessorXtra · 25/06/2023 12:09

MaybeSmaller · 25/06/2023 10:38

When we first met, I was always told by him how he was going to get X job and earn X amount by this stage of life etc. I believed him.

It amazes me how much weight is being put on this statement. For all we know they may have been 19 year old undergrads when they had this conversation. Adolescent bravado based on zero real world experience does not amount to a shared life plan.

When you actually get to the stage of life where you understand what it takes to earn the big bucks, you may well decide that it's not for you, and that's when the serious conversations need to start. When I was 19, 20, 21 I wanted to do all sorts of things that never actually came about.

There are some crazy opinions on this thread, such as working a low-stress full time job you love for £40K is "coasting". Nobody I know who earns £40K is coasting, and surely nobody sane actively seeks out career paths that they know in advance are going to be severely stressful to them. Stress is a huge killer. Not much point planning your £250K lifestyle when dh is dead of a heart attack at 40 years old.

There seems to be a pernicious opinion among high earners that if someone earns a quarter as much as them, they must only work a quarter as hard, or must be 4 times lazier, or some variation of that theme.

Except it’s not simple circumstance that he is earning what he does.

These are choices he is actively making.

Why would he be dead at 40? The majority of people who earn a lot of money don’t drop dead at 40. And of those that do, there’s no proof that wouldn’t have happened anyway.

The choices is that you can be a high earner but you will die at 40. Or a middle earner and die at old age. Or low earner and really old age. In fact life expectancy lowers, the less you earn. The areas of the country where life expectancy is at its lowest are the some of the poorest areas.

I am surprised how many people are putting weight on their entirely made up situation where this wasn’t a clear plan. Even though Op says it was. Op said it was a solid plan. I can’t believe so many people think it can’t possibly have been because they wouldn’t have made that plan. Your whole opinion is based on something you made up.

No one said anyone who earners less works less hard. But the man, that the thread is about, has decided to take an easier road than he and Op planned. That’s his choice. Doesn’t mean op has to stay. He is actively choosing this and could progress is choosing not to. It’s not like he is trapped in a job.

YeahIsaidit · 25/06/2023 11:38

MykonosMaiden · 25/06/2023 11:00

You've missed the point completely.
It's not the salary , it's the earning potential of the industry.
Nobody would consider a teacher or nurse on £40K coasting.
An IT professional? Definitely, seeing as that's the starting salary for a big company IT grad scheme in London (and others offer more!).

Also OP's health is important too.

Not having foreign travel and a big house doesn't cause health issues

RosesAndHellebores · 25/06/2023 11:32

Apologies- wrong thread.

RosesAndHellebores · 25/06/2023 11:31

At what point on MN is it acceptable to work as a team to facilitate the career of one person: £100k, £200k, £300k, £400k, £500k plus?

There are also the careers where flex is increasingly difficult: barrister, surgeon, pilot, etc.

I

whumpthereitis · 25/06/2023 11:08

MaybeSmaller · 25/06/2023 10:38

When we first met, I was always told by him how he was going to get X job and earn X amount by this stage of life etc. I believed him.

It amazes me how much weight is being put on this statement. For all we know they may have been 19 year old undergrads when they had this conversation. Adolescent bravado based on zero real world experience does not amount to a shared life plan.

When you actually get to the stage of life where you understand what it takes to earn the big bucks, you may well decide that it's not for you, and that's when the serious conversations need to start. When I was 19, 20, 21 I wanted to do all sorts of things that never actually came about.

There are some crazy opinions on this thread, such as working a low-stress full time job you love for £40K is "coasting". Nobody I know who earns £40K is coasting, and surely nobody sane actively seeks out career paths that they know in advance are going to be severely stressful to them. Stress is a huge killer. Not much point planning your £250K lifestyle when dh is dead of a heart attack at 40 years old.

There seems to be a pernicious opinion among high earners that if someone earns a quarter as much as them, they must only work a quarter as hard, or must be 4 times lazier, or some variation of that theme.

It’s coasting when you’ve got the qualifications and opportunity to achieve more.

“Adolescent bravado based on zero real world experience does not amount to a shared life plan.”

And what are you basing that assumption on? OP at least knows the man she’s married to, you don’t. It’s quite the assumption that you’ve got a better idea of what he really meant than she does. Are we supposed to never trust our partners, despite the conversations had discussing plans for a shared future? OP did commit herself to those goals, believing they were a team working together. He’s benefiting from her drive and achievements, and not even trying to meet her halfway as he led her to believe he would. That is why he is coasting.

Of course he could legitimately have changed his mind. Such a lifestyle doesn’t suit everyone and that’s fine, it doesn’t have to. However, that does mean that a fundamental incompatibility has been exposed in OP’s relationship. Him changing his mind is not something OP has to just accept and roll with.

JudgeRudy · 25/06/2023 11:00

This is a tricky one. Presumably if you earn a similar salary to him you would be unable to finance your lifestyle so yes in a way he is relying on you to subsidise you both.
Without knowing your husband it's difficult to gauge where he's at, but comfortable seem to cover it. He's happy with the status quo. If I was earning your salary I would not be happy that I'm not on the property ladder and if youre thinking about starting a family you need to do some serious talking. If your visions aren't aligned nows the time to quit and go your separate ways.
Just throwing in some ideas. Do you need to stay in London ie could you have a better quality of life elsewhere, maybe on a lower joint income? If you're both looking to start a family are there options for him to be the main care giver, so maybe part time/SAH? Are there additional courses he could take over the next 2 years or so that would increase his earning power? Could he do that alongside work/childcare? Are you emotionally ready for a family now?
I think you need to both lay your cards on the table but with the best will in the world people do change their minds and whilst I get your frustration, letting that bubble up into resentment is futile. Agree or disagree on your future goals and come up with a plan. This will of course need to be time specific and if expectations aren't met you need to be very clear with him and yourself what the outcome is.

MykonosMaiden · 25/06/2023 11:00

MaybeSmaller · 25/06/2023 10:38

When we first met, I was always told by him how he was going to get X job and earn X amount by this stage of life etc. I believed him.

It amazes me how much weight is being put on this statement. For all we know they may have been 19 year old undergrads when they had this conversation. Adolescent bravado based on zero real world experience does not amount to a shared life plan.

When you actually get to the stage of life where you understand what it takes to earn the big bucks, you may well decide that it's not for you, and that's when the serious conversations need to start. When I was 19, 20, 21 I wanted to do all sorts of things that never actually came about.

There are some crazy opinions on this thread, such as working a low-stress full time job you love for £40K is "coasting". Nobody I know who earns £40K is coasting, and surely nobody sane actively seeks out career paths that they know in advance are going to be severely stressful to them. Stress is a huge killer. Not much point planning your £250K lifestyle when dh is dead of a heart attack at 40 years old.

There seems to be a pernicious opinion among high earners that if someone earns a quarter as much as them, they must only work a quarter as hard, or must be 4 times lazier, or some variation of that theme.

You've missed the point completely.
It's not the salary , it's the earning potential of the industry.
Nobody would consider a teacher or nurse on £40K coasting.
An IT professional? Definitely, seeing as that's the starting salary for a big company IT grad scheme in London (and others offer more!).

Also OP's health is important too.

billy1966 · 25/06/2023 10:55

whumpthereitis · 24/06/2023 23:40

Okay 🤷🏻‍♀️

For me, a happy marriage is dependent on not only love, but shared outlook and goals (and yes that does indeed involve finances!). That’s fine if you don’t like it, it isn’t necessary for you to approve.

Agreed.

I find it extraordinary that so many don't get that financial compatibility is crucial to marital harmony.

He sold himself as one person and quickly decided that in fact a 4th, a 4th!!! Masters was preferable to moving forward in his career.

Clearly the OP is on one original path and 4th Masters boy is now on a different one completely.

On this basis she should take ANY statement from him going forward with a complete pinch of salt.

He has shown her who he is, unreliable, and she should walk whilst she can.

A 4th Masters is a wonderful hobby for someone with the money to fund it, not for someone at the beginning of a marriage wanting to purchase a home and start a family.

The OP has quietly been out manoeuvred by him and has been placed in the adult, high earning position where their London lifestyle will be dependent on her career trajectory.

OP, if you were my daughter I would be warning you to think long and hard about what you want and how you feel about a future that is going to be largely on your shoulders.

He has changed the posts, as he can anytime, but you do not have to accept it as a given.

He has very sneakily pulled a fast one on the OP, and I for one don't believe for a second this is accidental.

He's lazy, but not stupid.

The OP has been sold a pup, long enough to get married and now he has a new vastly different plan.

Up to the OP if she wants to remain married and trusting of someone who would do this.

Expect short mat leaves OP as women with big careers often return very quickly as the jobs need them and the London lifestyle demands it, particularly when they shoulder it alone.

Oh and those that study endlessly find it a great reason to avoid sharing the house hold duties load etc.

Apologies if the above is harsh, but reality often is!