Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Compulsory skirt supplier- is this discrimination?

61 replies

greenmarsupial · 21/06/2023 15:25

My DD's secondary school have had an overhaul of their uniform policy. They have said that the new skirt is one specific type only and that it must be purchased from their online supplier or from a specific local shop. It costs £20.

The skirt itself is not compulsory, girls can choose to wear trousers but boys cannot choose to wear the skirt.

The other one-supplier uniform items are the PE top and the blazer.

It seems to me (as someone with no legal background at all) that there must be some discrimination law around making a single sex item only be allowed to be bought from one supplier when trousers etc can be bought cheaper from a supermarket.

I'm only bothered as a point of principle, the skirts were getting ridiculously short but I do think a general style would have been better.

Do I have any grounds to complain?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CasperGutman · 22/06/2023 11:55

Paq · 21/06/2023 17:42

It’s not discrimination. It could be phrased as “the uniform is trousers for boys and girls. Girls also have the option to wear skirts but they must be this specific style which is only available from this supplier”.

£20 isn’t a lot, they tend to last a long time.

How is that not discrimination? The girls have an option that isn't open to the boys. In practice, most of the boys would not choose to wear skirts. That said, a sizeable number of boys at a school near me did wear skirts during a heatwave a few years ago, as the uniform options didn't allow shorts and they said it wasn't fair that girls could wear skirts as trousers were too hot.

Arguably it also discriminates against girls (or at least leaves them open to unequal outcomes/harassment) as in practice most girls will likely feel pressure to conform to gender norms and wear a skirt, exposing their legs to view when male pupils are covered up in trousers.

greenmarsupial · 21/06/2023 21:32

itsgettingweird · 21/06/2023 17:53

I also don't agree with a one style fits all approach.

Young woman come in all shapes and sizes and develop at different speeds.

We encourage body confidence and autonomy and then force them into a skirt that only ever really fits half the female school population as intended.

This is a good point!

OP posts:
greenmarsupial · 21/06/2023 21:32

Postapocalypticcowgirl · 21/06/2023 17:58

I think it's to slowly encourage more and more girls to wear trousers. You can challenge single supplier, but I think it's a bit of a grey area because the girls do have an option to wear trousers.

I would guess the skirt has been carefully designed/chosen to make it harder to roll up as well!

Definitely- I totally get it, girls rolling up their skirts has been a problem since time immemorial.

OP posts:
greenmarsupial · 21/06/2023 21:31

LittleBrenda · 21/06/2023 17:53

They do sometimes wear very tight trousers...

Would you prefer it if all trousers had to be from the school supplier too?

No, just pointing out that they get round this too.

OP posts:
greenmarsupial · 21/06/2023 21:30

loveandpoprockz · 21/06/2023 17:29

What about cullots would they allow those? Sort of a skirt but could be argued to be trouser like so bought from a supermarket?

No, there are quite strict rules about trousers too...

OP posts:
Postapocalypticcowgirl · 21/06/2023 17:58

I think it's to slowly encourage more and more girls to wear trousers. You can challenge single supplier, but I think it's a bit of a grey area because the girls do have an option to wear trousers.

I would guess the skirt has been carefully designed/chosen to make it harder to roll up as well!

LittleBrenda · 21/06/2023 17:53

They do sometimes wear very tight trousers...

Would you prefer it if all trousers had to be from the school supplier too?

itsgettingweird · 21/06/2023 17:53

I also don't agree with a one style fits all approach.

Young woman come in all shapes and sizes and develop at different speeds.

We encourage body confidence and autonomy and then force them into a skirt that only ever really fits half the female school population as intended.

Susuwatariandkodama · 21/06/2023 17:51

Paq · 21/06/2023 17:42

It’s not discrimination. It could be phrased as “the uniform is trousers for boys and girls. Girls also have the option to wear skirts but they must be this specific style which is only available from this supplier”.

£20 isn’t a lot, they tend to last a long time.

Maybe to you but £20 is a lot for some people! I certainly can’t afford to spend so much on one item, I paid £5 for my daughters skirts, so I can get 4 for the price of one.

itsgettingweird · 21/06/2023 17:51

LlynTegid · 21/06/2023 15:47

You have grounds to complain about only one supplier I think.

You do.

Uniform should be easily available and affordable in order not to discriminate - and by that they also mean stop parents even applying to a school sue to their limited uniform and costs.

Problem is that most schools that do this are academies and I think they have different rules.

gemsgv · 21/06/2023 17:49

It's discrimination against boys, yes

Paq · 21/06/2023 17:42

It’s not discrimination. It could be phrased as “the uniform is trousers for boys and girls. Girls also have the option to wear skirts but they must be this specific style which is only available from this supplier”.

£20 isn’t a lot, they tend to last a long time.

Bornslippery · 21/06/2023 17:37

Our school had this but at £30. Thought it awful at the time. Only bought 1, DD wore it every day for 5 years and it still looks new. So very good value for money. Misses point of thread

loveandpoprockz · 21/06/2023 17:29

What about cullots would they allow those? Sort of a skirt but could be argued to be trouser like so bought from a supermarket?

greenmarsupial · 21/06/2023 17:26

CasperGutman · 21/06/2023 17:03

Sounds to me like this discriminates against girls who are from less well off families, because the supplier is a relatively high-cost one and they may not be able to afford it and so have less choice of what to wear than a richer girl would (or more likely, their family has to do without something else to buy a skirt). I understand why schools like having a specified supplier for skirts, but the supplier should be the lowest cost supplier consistent with meeting minimum standards for quality (and meeting a minimum ethical standard, e.g., not made by sweated child labour).

It also discriminates against boys, as they cannot wear skirts. I know in practice very few would choose to, but I'm surprised a school would introduce a new uniform policy with distinct requirements for boys and girls. Is this a religious school by any chance?

It's not a religious, just an Academy Trust.

OP posts:
greenmarsupial · 21/06/2023 17:24

cansu · 21/06/2023 17:18

Everyone knows that this is to avoid the issue of girls buying short skirts or tight lycra skirts. There is of course the choice to buy trousers. It is a non issue.

They do sometimes wear very tight trousers...

OP posts:
greenmarsupial · 21/06/2023 17:24

newusern1 · 21/06/2023 17:17

Our school has a specific pleated skirt from uniform supplier but it turns out m and s has a skirt which is exactly the same. Maybe investigate that as an option?

Good tip, thanks! I've checked and none of the M&S ones are the same but I could look elsewhere.

OP posts:
SchoolShenanigans · 21/06/2023 17:19

It's not ok, and YANBU.

When it's hot, I assume most girls want to wear skirts and not trousers, so it's not good enough that trousers can be sourced in a supermarket.

I would enquire and then complain. School uniform should be accessible to all families. I'm sick of schools making children where uniforms that most adults wouldn't need to wear now, just to keep relationships with suppliers (and back handers?).

cansu · 21/06/2023 17:18

Everyone knows that this is to avoid the issue of girls buying short skirts or tight lycra skirts. There is of course the choice to buy trousers. It is a non issue.

newusern1 · 21/06/2023 17:17

Our school has a specific pleated skirt from uniform supplier but it turns out m and s has a skirt which is exactly the same. Maybe investigate that as an option?

Jux · 21/06/2023 17:15

What I meant to post was, what if your daughter wants to wear a skirt?

Jux · 21/06/2023 17:12

I've no idea why Iposted that. Sorry Blush

Jux · 21/06/2023 17:12

An aunt sent her sons to a Public school. Her sons' trousers were constantly falling apart, holed in the knees, seams ripping etc. At the end of her tether, she took the boys off to the school's tailor for measuring yet again. Being something of a seamstress herself (grew up during the war where they were all make do and meend, remodel etc) she fell into conversation with one of the younger tailiors. He too her to their stock room to show her the piles upon more piles of fabric. Much of it over 50 years old.

No wonder the trousers kept falling apart under ordinary wear and tear. The cloth was so old before they even cut the patterns the trousers didn't have a chance.

Nice little earner though.

Tockomtele · 21/06/2023 17:05

LookingWest · 21/06/2023 16:03

It is a bit of a dick move by the school. I volunteer with a charity that supports families in financial difficulty in our borough. There is government guidance out there regarding costs of uniform which arguably your school is complying with by the letter but not the spirit. Having said that, the trousers option helps. I’d worry about those families really financially struggling, the range of uniform costs from school to school is huge here, and often the families struggling the most don’t get the choice over where they live or what school they go to.

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/cost-of-school-uniforms/cost-of-school-uniforms

But why??? All girls are allowed ro wear cheap trousers. No issue.

CasperGutman · 21/06/2023 17:03

Sounds to me like this discriminates against girls who are from less well off families, because the supplier is a relatively high-cost one and they may not be able to afford it and so have less choice of what to wear than a richer girl would (or more likely, their family has to do without something else to buy a skirt). I understand why schools like having a specified supplier for skirts, but the supplier should be the lowest cost supplier consistent with meeting minimum standards for quality (and meeting a minimum ethical standard, e.g., not made by sweated child labour).

It also discriminates against boys, as they cannot wear skirts. I know in practice very few would choose to, but I'm surprised a school would introduce a new uniform policy with distinct requirements for boys and girls. Is this a religious school by any chance?