Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if there comes a point where you just have to give up work?

659 replies

Bluewatersummer · 21/06/2023 11:06

I’m hopefully not there yet. But while I wish I could be very feminist about this the fact is DH earns a lot more than me and he always will, his talents lie where money is.

With one child we have managed through a combination of part time, taking turns to take time off when needed, and some good luck as well - haven’t had a lot of sickness to contend with. However, I’m due my second any day now and I’m wondering about a whole host of stuff.

It’s going to be so difficult when DC1 starts school and when DC2 is in nursery, reliance on wraparound care and rushing from A to B to C. I don’t honestly know if it is just easier for everyone - not just me - if one parent gives up work and just has their ‘job’ the children and house. Which isn’t very feminist but would potentially make a big difference to stress levels! Honestly wondering what others think: I’m not making any big decisions just yet.

OP posts:
TheaBrandt · 24/06/2023 13:33

I think it’s one of those decisions you just can’t generalise it’s so personal and dependent on your character / marriage / future employability and industry or profession you are in. Personally took the “risk” of a few years out as secure in my marriage don’t rely on my job for my identity and knew I had a skill I could crank up if Dh had a personality transplant and ran off with his secretary. Good luck op hope you find a better way.

Also don’t shoot me but I wanted to be around. So wasn’t just for kids benefit but mine too! My job was so consuming I didn’t even want to kill myself trying to do both.

YoungerYears · 24/06/2023 13:04

GCWorkNightmare · 24/06/2023 09:51

Typed an enormous reply then lost it. 😡

Feminism is not about choice for women. It’s about equality of opportunity. For me that’s largely about challenging the stereotypes and expectations that hold us back in society compared to men.

eg changing names. Women expected (at least) to consider changing names on marriage. Not expected of men so I didn’t do it.

titles. Women expected to use a title that denotes marital status. Not expected of men so I don’t either.

women expected to have a lower status role than male partner. Absolutely not.

women expected to be primary childcarer. Absolutely not. Once breast milk isn’t needed it’s an equal playing field here. DH has always been the primary contact for school and we have shared time off if DD is unwell.

women to do bulk of housework/mental load. Absolutely not. Didn’t allow this from day dot. If it doesn’t require an adult with a vagina, it’s anyone’s job. (True even when DH worked away 5.5 days a week.)

woman to go part time to do bulk of childcare/housekeeping because she earns less was NEVER an option in our household. Both of my parents worked full time without family help or paid childcare. Same with DD.

When you base feminism on being about choice, you ignore that those choices aren’t made in a vacuum. We are all part of the whole. Every woman making the choice to adopt the stereotype reinforces it in the matrix. Every woman rejecting the stereotype opens up an opportunity for other women to do the same.

Good posts. Agree with all this esp the last paragraph.

‘When you base feminism on being about choice, you ignore that those choices aren’t made in a vacuum. We are all part of the whole.’

We need both men and women on board with this.

Bluewatersummer · 24/06/2023 12:59

This thread is so confusing now. No one has mentioned minimum wage jobs, but the argument seems to be I have to stay part time because then I’m going to be in an ideal position to pursue my career in my mid fifties - I really won’t be! (I doubt I would WANT to either!)

When I’m 54 I’m going to be looking at winding down not scrambling up!

And believe it or not I’m not really bothered by the whole working/SAHM debate. What is clear to me is that staying part time and juggling everything won’t be for me so looking at alternatives - which probably won’t involve giving up altogether but is a possibility I won’t completely discount either.

OP posts:
MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 24/06/2023 12:58

Lol at the idea of the children of WOHPs being "raised by a succession of randoms"!Grin

If you want to be a SAHP, your partner agrees and you can fund that lifestyle, you don't have to justify your choices to anyone. Your life, your family, your choices.

But ffs, don't feel like you have to come up with a load of bullshit stories about WOHPs to legitimise your choices. Be confident in your own decisions and stop trying to trash the decisions made by other people. You just make yourself look like a very insecure twat.

kikisparks · 24/06/2023 12:53

mummymeister · 21/06/2023 11:59

when did choosing to not go into paid work but to look after the children - the ones that you made a positive choice to have because you wanted them - become non - feminist? I am a feminist. so is my dh. we made a positive choice for one of us to not work to raise the children the way we wanted them to be raised. not to be raised by a succession of randoms who might not have the same views on things as we do. We spent a couple of years with me doing it and then both decided to start our own business so that we could both have the stay at home role. This idea that somehow you are "less" if you choose to devote your time and effort to other human beings is bonkers in my opinion.

Nothing wrong with being a SAHP but WOHP’s children are not raised by “a succession of randoms” they are still raised by their parents even if they are looked after by childcare professionals or grandparents or similar some of the time. And good childcare providers should do care broadly in line with parents preferred routines, food options etc.

The one raising the child decides where they go to get care, what they eat, where they sleep at night, where they go to school, what they wear, etc etc, is there for them when they are ill, is there for them as often as possible when not working.

I mean I think most of us would balk at the idea of a grandparent who did childcare saying they were the one who “raised” their grandchild. Would you really say that only you, and not your DH raised your children when he was working out of the home?

TheaBrandt · 24/06/2023 12:51

. I loved my stress free sahm 7 years. If you’re professionally trained and smart you can work again. All the friends I made in my sahm years are now back doing what they were doing or career changed to what they always wanted to do. You’re appealing to employers. Older, sensible - no mat leaves!

One friend went from running the pta to being right hand of the ceo of her new company she sat in his office and he ran all his decisions past her!

RosesAndHellebores · 24/06/2023 12:42

Taking seven years off the treadmill, plus 10 yeats on much lower pay undoubtedly cost about £750,000 gross, less tax, ni and childcare, probably about £300,000 net.

But then I locked in 20 years' pension contributions into a final salary pension scheme in 2013, fss closed in 2014. My earnings post 2017 rocketed to six figures. That wouldn't have happened had I stayed working in the commercial sector. Part luck, part planing.

RosesAndHellebores · 24/06/2023 12:38

I went back to work on a very low salary when dd was settled in reception. It was more than worth it because I had no childcare expenses and was local. Provided a springboard for a second career.

One thing I would say is that working part-time meant I didn't feel I could subcontract additional cleaning, cooking, ironing, shopping childcare. So I left the house at 8am, dropped ds, drove to dd's school, did her hair in the car, and started work at 9.15. Finished at 2.30, whizzed home to do dishwasher and process a load of laundry: out of the washer, on the horse, dry off the horse and put away, next load on, wiped down the kitchen, collected dd, collected ds, juggled their after school stuff, tea at 6.30ish, tidied up, homework, reading, baths, pj's. Sat down about 9pm as dh came in. Ate with him, had a glass of wine, bed at 10.30.

When I went back full-time the cleaner did more cleaning and the ironing and the au-pair sorted the dc. I breezed in at 6.30pm. Much, much easier and the same money at the end of it but with a much better pension and better progression prospects.

GCWorkNightmare · 24/06/2023 12:37

hettie · 24/06/2023 12:30

Respectfully I think you're wrong. You are much more appealing an option as an employee (even part time) than you are as someone out of the workforce. You might not get back to a glittering career, but you are less likely to have to take minimum wage shitty jobs. What's your job now? Is it more than min wage?

I was going to say this too.

hettie · 24/06/2023 12:30

Respectfully I think you're wrong. You are much more appealing an option as an employee (even part time) than you are as someone out of the workforce. You might not get back to a glittering career, but you are less likely to have to take minimum wage shitty jobs. What's your job now? Is it more than min wage?

Lira715 · 24/06/2023 12:10

Same situation here DH earns double what I earn a month in a week, I tried not working and found it a little depressing, every day was Groundhog Day house work kids cooking more house work … I’ve found if I work I appreciate the days off I have and don’t get so frazzled with the kids. I work 20hrs but over 2 days so although those days are long it’s the only 2 days I have to sort childcare out for, I get a cleaner in and she does 3hrs per day on both my work days and she does my ironing too so days I’m at work I don’t come home to lots of chores just pop kids to bed and relax. I have had to have time off when kids been Ill but very rarely as it’s only 2/7 days so the chances of her being ill on a day im at work are reduced a bit. Not saying this will work for you , you might love being at home full time, I said I wouldn’t go back to work until DD started school .. lasted for a 18 months then just needed to be doing something more than mummying x

GCWorkNightmare · 24/06/2023 12:01

On what planet can giving up work (as was expected centuries ago) and being reliant on a man to provide for you and your children anything like a feminist decision?! 🤯

GCWorkNightmare · 24/06/2023 12:00

IndigoLaFaye · 24/06/2023 10:38

If it’s what you want to do then it’s totally
Feminist - Feminism is about having choice not about automatically not wanting to parent or be a homemaker.

Anyway, if you think you would be able to manage financially, still have some independence from hubby (that would always be my main concern, how do you get out if you need to), and be happier/less stressed, I’d say quit work. You can always try to pick something up when they are a little older.

Do men have that same expectation/choice levied upon them?

no?

Then it it’s still based in sexism, isn’t an equal opportunity and therefore isn’t a feminist decision.

IndigoLaFaye · 24/06/2023 10:38

If it’s what you want to do then it’s totally
Feminist - Feminism is about having choice not about automatically not wanting to parent or be a homemaker.

Anyway, if you think you would be able to manage financially, still have some independence from hubby (that would always be my main concern, how do you get out if you need to), and be happier/less stressed, I’d say quit work. You can always try to pick something up when they are a little older.

Thepeopleversuswork · 24/06/2023 10:38

LT1982 · 24/06/2023 08:37

I had pressed reply to a comment which said women going back to work is "anti-feminist"

The whole point of feminism is for women to be treated equally and have the choice to work so telling working mothers they are anti-feminist is ridiculous.

The same poster claims childcare isn't good for children so she is clearly against working mums 🙄

The new breed of trad wife tends to dress this up as “feminism”. See also “feminism is about choice” which is a catch all slogan for “I want to stop work but I want to disguise this as feminism”. Or “being a SAHM is a valid choice”. Which is literally meaningless. The confusion around what feminism means on these boards often makes me utterly depressed.

Feminism is not fundamentally about choice (although choice should be an output of feminism). Feminism is about equality.

Someone will then invariably tip up to say “no feminist would judge another woman’s choice”. Which is true in as much as women should recognise other women’s choices are circumscribed and limited and not judge one another for making the best of what’s available to them. But it doesn’t follow from this that any choice made by any woman is a “feminist choice”.

I have no problem with women choosing not to work if if suits them and their families but claiming this is feminism in action is delusional nonsense.

GCWorkNightmare · 24/06/2023 10:27

LT1982 · 24/06/2023 09:57

I agree with everything you said. But it doesn't make women who go back to work anti-feminist if that is their choice.

How many years have been spent fighting for womens equality of treatment and equal pay at work? A mother choosing to work or having to for economic reasons is not anti-feminist

Are you going to address the comments of the poster I was replying to saying childcare is bad for children?

Sorry - I didn’t go that far back. I’ll look at that later.

Bluewatersummer · 24/06/2023 10:16

@hettie you are assuming it’s all the same. Everything you say above about me being out of work applies equally to part time. I’m not as appealing to employers, I still have a load of drudgery and not as much time to do it in.

I know everyone’s workplace is different but I’m definitely not going to be able to work PT until I am 53/54 (when Dc2 will leave primary) then go into a glittering career 😂

OP posts:
hettie · 24/06/2023 10:01

OP, you seem very clear that queening part time is not a good option. This appears to be about the juggle and the fact that it wouldn't offer any future protection anyways. Honestly the juggle does ease off, it does get easier. And they're are no two ways about it, staying in a job you are trained in have experience of (even part time) would give you far greater options if you were forced (for any reason) to return to earning. It may not be very enlightened but having 5-8 years out of work will not make you an appealing prospect for employers. It just won't.
That's before you get into the whole loss of identity, changes in relationship balance and the sheer drudge of domestic chores that clearly don't hold much appeal to you (or you wouldn't be mulling this over and saying you don't much fancy it but it would be easier). Easier is not doing something you don't really want to do for 8 years, that's not easy it's horrible. It will take a toll.

LT1982 · 24/06/2023 09:57

GCWorkNightmare · 24/06/2023 09:51

Typed an enormous reply then lost it. 😡

Feminism is not about choice for women. It’s about equality of opportunity. For me that’s largely about challenging the stereotypes and expectations that hold us back in society compared to men.

eg changing names. Women expected (at least) to consider changing names on marriage. Not expected of men so I didn’t do it.

titles. Women expected to use a title that denotes marital status. Not expected of men so I don’t either.

women expected to have a lower status role than male partner. Absolutely not.

women expected to be primary childcarer. Absolutely not. Once breast milk isn’t needed it’s an equal playing field here. DH has always been the primary contact for school and we have shared time off if DD is unwell.

women to do bulk of housework/mental load. Absolutely not. Didn’t allow this from day dot. If it doesn’t require an adult with a vagina, it’s anyone’s job. (True even when DH worked away 5.5 days a week.)

woman to go part time to do bulk of childcare/housekeeping because she earns less was NEVER an option in our household. Both of my parents worked full time without family help or paid childcare. Same with DD.

When you base feminism on being about choice, you ignore that those choices aren’t made in a vacuum. We are all part of the whole. Every woman making the choice to adopt the stereotype reinforces it in the matrix. Every woman rejecting the stereotype opens up an opportunity for other women to do the same.

I agree with everything you said. But it doesn't make women who go back to work anti-feminist if that is their choice.

How many years have been spent fighting for womens equality of treatment and equal pay at work? A mother choosing to work or having to for economic reasons is not anti-feminist

Are you going to address the comments of the poster I was replying to saying childcare is bad for children?

GCWorkNightmare · 24/06/2023 09:51

LT1982 · 24/06/2023 08:37

I had pressed reply to a comment which said women going back to work is "anti-feminist"

The whole point of feminism is for women to be treated equally and have the choice to work so telling working mothers they are anti-feminist is ridiculous.

The same poster claims childcare isn't good for children so she is clearly against working mums 🙄

Typed an enormous reply then lost it. 😡

Feminism is not about choice for women. It’s about equality of opportunity. For me that’s largely about challenging the stereotypes and expectations that hold us back in society compared to men.

eg changing names. Women expected (at least) to consider changing names on marriage. Not expected of men so I didn’t do it.

titles. Women expected to use a title that denotes marital status. Not expected of men so I don’t either.

women expected to have a lower status role than male partner. Absolutely not.

women expected to be primary childcarer. Absolutely not. Once breast milk isn’t needed it’s an equal playing field here. DH has always been the primary contact for school and we have shared time off if DD is unwell.

women to do bulk of housework/mental load. Absolutely not. Didn’t allow this from day dot. If it doesn’t require an adult with a vagina, it’s anyone’s job. (True even when DH worked away 5.5 days a week.)

woman to go part time to do bulk of childcare/housekeeping because she earns less was NEVER an option in our household. Both of my parents worked full time without family help or paid childcare. Same with DD.

When you base feminism on being about choice, you ignore that those choices aren’t made in a vacuum. We are all part of the whole. Every woman making the choice to adopt the stereotype reinforces it in the matrix. Every woman rejecting the stereotype opens up an opportunity for other women to do the same.

Saracen · 24/06/2023 09:47

Hollyppp · 23/06/2023 21:58

I didn’t know this! I’m SAHM and would love more detail - is there a specific name for this that I can google to get more info and set it up?

I only found out about it when I was reading all the provider's information while setting up a personal pension for my husband. We went with Fidelity, which has an easy interface and plenty of good information for non-experts. You might like to look at their info even if you aren't going to choose them. They also have low management fees on their SIPP if you EITHER invest a lot of money with them OR set up a direct debit to put in at least £20 a month.

Anyway, here are the HMRC rules. Scroll down to the bottom where it says "If you do not pay Income Tax" https://www.gov.uk/tax-on-your-private-pension/pension-tax-relief

So it looks like you have to choose a personal pension provider which can claim the tax relief on your behalf from HMRC, but I think most are able to do that.

Tax on your private pension contributions

Tax you pay and tax relief you get on contributions to your private pension - annual allowance, lifetime allowance, apply for individual protection

https://www.gov.uk/tax-on-your-private-pension/pension-tax-relief

roseeone · 24/06/2023 09:37

Honestly, I’m in a similar situation and is is genuinely easier all round for me to give up on working. Which I have done since my DS(3) was born. I’m now in sole charge of all of the domestic stuff, kids and general life admin (think buying insurance/gifts etc). This doesn’t mean that DH doesn’t help, he does, but only when I give him specific tasks. It’s much less stressful than juggling work/childcare and he now actually earns more money as a consequence. The downsize is that I miss the social interaction of working and the self fulfilment that it brings. Right now though, it’s definitely our best option and I don’t regret it.

GnomeDePlume · 24/06/2023 09:33

Work out what is best for you all.

We did what worked for us: DH became SAHP to three DCs.

At the time DCs were 5, 1 and 4 weeks.

Before DC3 was born we both worked full time. DC1 was at nursery, DC2 went to a childminder. With 3 DC this was not going to work (cost and logistics).

DH being SAHP absolutely worked for us all. DCs are all now adults but they really benefitted having a parent around all the time.

DH now works PT in a NMW job. I think it is even harder for male returners than female. We sometimes joke it would have been easier if he had been in prison.

LT1982 · 24/06/2023 08:46

Do what you think is best and it doesn't have to be a permanent decision. If you trial SAHM for 6 months or a year you may decide it's not for you and you want to go back to work or you might love it. The only way to find out is try. Maybe your employer offers sabbaticals or a career break?

Bluewatersummer · 24/06/2023 08:42

There’s a certain amount of taking a particularly anti MN view sometimes on threads like this. For all I know, they might be that posters sincerely held views but I ah, doubt it, I’ll put it that way Wink

There are so many different setups.

Mum and dad work full time and children are at nursery or with a nanny.
mum and dad work full time and children are cared for by grandparents or other family members.
Both parents work part time and child is cared for by a parent at all times
both parents work part time and child still has some paid childcare / cared for by family.
One parent works full time and one parent is a SAHP
One parent works full time and one parent is part time

And all combinations of above. And plus that’s only two parent families. I genuinely don’t think any of the above is ‘best.’ I really honestly don’t. I DO think that there will be a ‘this best fits our family’ out of the above.

OP posts: