Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if there comes a point where you just have to give up work?

659 replies

Bluewatersummer · 21/06/2023 11:06

I’m hopefully not there yet. But while I wish I could be very feminist about this the fact is DH earns a lot more than me and he always will, his talents lie where money is.

With one child we have managed through a combination of part time, taking turns to take time off when needed, and some good luck as well - haven’t had a lot of sickness to contend with. However, I’m due my second any day now and I’m wondering about a whole host of stuff.

It’s going to be so difficult when DC1 starts school and when DC2 is in nursery, reliance on wraparound care and rushing from A to B to C. I don’t honestly know if it is just easier for everyone - not just me - if one parent gives up work and just has their ‘job’ the children and house. Which isn’t very feminist but would potentially make a big difference to stress levels! Honestly wondering what others think: I’m not making any big decisions just yet.

OP posts:
FolkSongSweet · 25/06/2023 09:49

@Bluewatersummer it Is a little frustrating because I don’t think you’ve been completely honest. First you said a nanny wouldn’t work because they might be unreliable, then you said it was because it might be hard to get one, and now I think you’re saying that you actually don’t want to get one, without explaining why?

You must appreciate that if you had issues with your cleaner then you could solve that by getting a different cleaner.

You obviously feel that it would be better for you not to work and it seems you want some validation for that feeling, but if that’s the case you should have said so instead of phrasing the whole thing as a question and then fighting against all the suggestions for how to solve it.

Bluewatersummer · 25/06/2023 09:42

@Grumpyfroghats you know, if it has come across like that then I am sorry, because until the last couple of pages I genuinely thought it was an interesting and ‘nice’ thread in that it wasn’t overtly argumentative or anything.

Perhaps my perception of myself and others is just crap and that’s why I’m not seeing what you are seeing Sad

But I do think something huge is missing from your post above. It is not ‘how do I work.’ I do work.

It is more how do you work and not end up pulled every which way.

The thing is, DH and I can and do work around planned stuff, it’s the unplanned stuff. He can’t say to his workplace - look, I’m no longer travelling abroad. I’m no longer travelling further than a ten mile radius away between Monday and Wednesday because my son might be ill and I might have to get back at short notice.

I don’t think anyone actually expects that, surely? Except it seems they do.

As for me being special and unique - Christ, no. Anything but that. I think I am quite unlucky in that both parents are dead and have been for some time and therefore aren’t available (durrr) to help, but I do obviously know that is not a unique or special position.

I am obviously not coming across how I wished to come across and I can only apologise for that and put forward the heat and my late stage of pregnancy and the rather unfortunate circumstances we found ourselves in running up to my mat leave. I really am not prone to making dramas where none exist but I do personally find it helpful to write things down, and that possibly comes across as arguing when actually all I am doing is playing devils advocate in my own mind!

OP posts:
Bunnycat101 · 25/06/2023 09:34

My youngest is about to start school and I feel relief that I have nearly got through the early years. There have been times when it was really tough to carry on working and I think the toughest years were when I had one in nursery and one in school and my youngest was between 18m and 3. That was the really tough year. Things have got easier from then on. Winters will always be harder due to sickness but i now feel immense relief that I have got through it and have good career prospects, significant pension from that time and happy well-adjusted children.

I never think these threads are as black and white as people make them. There are jobs and jobs (some significantly more stressful than others). Family support makes a big difference as does ability to wfh and be flexible. What works for one family won’t work for another. I know and understand those feelings of feeling totally stressed and overwhelmed. There were definitely times I wanted to quit but with the benefit of hindsight I’m glad I didn’t.

Grumpyfroghats · 25/06/2023 09:27

My summary of the thread is:

I want to work, how can I work?

Get a nanny? Won't work because unreliable

Get a cleaner? Won't work because unreliable

Work part time? Doesn't work (not sure why)

Get DH to do more? That's not possible, he is always unpredictably away. And also he does his share and does have control over his schedule

It gets easier. Explain why? Lots of posters explain why it generally does. OP ignores them

I don't understand why posters think I don't want to work?! I desperately want to keep working but absolutely no suggestions from anyone could possibly work because I am so special and unique

Bluewatersummer · 25/06/2023 09:23

Yes, we need to fix it by him not doing his job, basically. I’m still unsure what there is to be gained by that.

OP posts:
stealthbanana · 25/06/2023 09:22

You have also had loads of comments about how you need to fix it with your dh. Which for some reason you’ve ignored (as per the above). Why do you think it’s only your problem to solve this? It’s incredibly frustrating to watch. I ask again, what did you want from this thread?

I wish you luck nonetheless.

Bluewatersummer · 25/06/2023 09:19

@stealthbanana do me a favour then and leave it. Because I don’t think answering questions is ‘not taking anything on board’ but maybe it is, who knows.

The comments I have had have overwhelmingly been.

  1. Pension. Been through this so many times now.
  2. Don’t put yourself in a position where you rely on a man. I agree with that, more so than you might think. But I am already doing that by being part time. I am not sure what the solution to this is.
  3. It isn’t feminist to stop work. I haven’t really participated in the sub discussion about this - it has been interesting - but I’ve tried to stress here it is the discrepancy between the incomes and not what is between the legs of the people earning those incomes that is the sticking point.
  4. Get a cleaner / nanny - not really something I wish to do. I have said a few times that what I think will be more likely than me stopping work is actually exploring the independent school route because of wraparound care, which would mean I work FT. It is ironic that either route means I have no money though 😂
  5. ’you don’t want to work’ this is the one that is irritating me I must admit, because it is so patently untrue. It’s true in the sense that I am lazy and do not see work as a part of my identity and would not work if I won the lottery. However, I don’t have a burning desire to stay at home with toddlers. I have two days a week off with mine, I love him and dote on him but JFC (sorry Christians) it is enough for me!

And I have not said any of the above for the first time - it is endless repeating myself, and sorry but it does become really irritating.

OP posts:
stealthbanana · 25/06/2023 09:11

It’s not the cleaner. It’s that you don’t seem to want to take on board ANYTHING anyone is saying. Your dh can’t possibly do anything differently (despite having flex and goodwill), you won’t look at different forms of childcare, you won’t get a cleaner etc etc. if you’re not happy now and the only thing you’re prepared to change is quitting your job then quit your job! But you’re unlikely to magically become happy with your current set up if you won’t do anything to make it better.

im not sure what’s exasperating about pointing out that you’ve consistently rejected every piece of advice you’ve been given on this thread. What did you want to get out of it OP?

Bluewatersummer · 25/06/2023 09:06

The thread is becoming really circular now and while I am aware it is very hot and I am very pregnant and have gone through some not totally nice memories this morning, I do think people must realise this becomes quite frustrating.

It is not about me ‘not wanting to work.’ I went back full time when DS was 10 months, then part time a year later. As I’ve said, I do three days a week. I honestly don’t mean this aggressively - but does that sound like someone who ‘doesn’t want to work’? (Of course I am currently on maternity leave now.) I’ll be going back for sure - it’s really the year(s) after that I’m thinking about.

@stealthbanana ”how can this possibly be? You pay a cleaner, they come to your house, they clean it. You sound like you are massively over complicating things”

The first part - you pay a cleaner - is right.

What happened to us was that the cleaner was constantly changing, cancelling, rearranging. It just wasn’t practical for her to come when I was off with DS, but she’d often say she’d come at a time and that would be fine as he’d have a class on but then she wouldn’t and arrive back to the cleaner there and DS needing lunch …

The biggest stress for me was getting everything tidy beforehand so she could clean. And she really wasn’t cleaning well. She started out well but then started just cleaning the bathrooms and the kitchen and everything else was very superficial, and the last time she came DH and I worked out she could only have done 45 minutes but charged double claiming she’d had to do a deep clean Hmm I know everyone will reply with not all cleaners are like that (NACALT) but she caused a load of stress! It isn’t an experience I want to repeat quite honestly.

Re a nanny, we live rurally, they aren’t as plentiful as in more ‘city’ areas (I’m really thinking London here but probably applies to other areas too.) And would it suit us / our family? I’m not totally sure it would. We all have childcare preferences, after all, and my DS is happy and settled in his nursery.

@GnomeDePlume and @AromanticSpices thanks for understanding what I’m saying.

Sorry but it really is bloody exasperating when you start a thread thinking of possibly maybe but probably not doing something in a year or two years and then because you reasonably point out the answer to life’s problems is not a cleaner you “don’t want to work.” Hmm

OP posts:
AromanticSpices · 25/06/2023 08:50

“We did have a cleaner but it created far more problems than it solved.”

how can this possibly be? You pay a cleaner, they come to your house, they clean it. You sound like you are massively over complicating things.

In my experience (over the years, not all the same person):
They didn't bother doing half the cleaning.
They would turn up and let themselves in on the wrong day when the alarm was on so I had to come back from work to switch it off because they panicked and couldn't use it/ would phone their boss instead of me - repeatedly.
They would have to cancel at last minute, and having spent ages having got dc to clear their rooms I would then have to hoover them when I got back from work otherwise it wouldn't get done for a month
They change days and times and whether they're bringing someone else or not, which matters when one or two adults are working from home
There were politics within the cleaning firm which gave me a headache about how to proceed and who to ask for

Plus you have to have the whole house reasonably tidy so they can clean - worth it, but not always easy to do when you're living and working there.

If you have a reliable cleaner who does a good job, keep hold of them at any rate!

GnomeDePlume · 25/06/2023 08:40

@FolkSongSweet doesn't having a nanny then create other problems? First, you have to be able to afford not just to employ them but also to house them. You will have to negotiate holidays with them, sick leave for them. Recruit them then recruit their replacement.

For us a nanny simply wouldn't have worked as the salary sacrificed by DH stopping work was less than a nanny would have cost.

FolkSongSweet · 25/06/2023 08:20

I completely agree that childcare is harder at primary than nursery for all of the reasons above. But completely solved by having a nanny.

GnomeDePlume · 25/06/2023 08:16

We found having a SAHP made life so much easier for all of us.

In our case DH was the SAHP.

It also created opportunities for us. I was offered a position in mainland Europe. We went and stayed for 5 years. This wouldn't have been possible if we had both been working.

From what I have seen, childcare problems really start when DCs start school. This is when you can no longer simply throw money at the problem to solve it. INSET days, sports days, sick days, your school is being used as a polling station days, Christmas fares, Summer fetes worse than death. Honestly the list is endless during the primary years.

Our DCs are all now adults so I am looking the other way down the telescope. We did what we did because it worked for us. There is a price to pay in terms of pension but we won't be on the breadline.

stealthbanana · 25/06/2023 07:24

“We did have a cleaner but it created far more problems than it solved.”

how can this possibly be? You pay a cleaner, they come to your house, they clean it. You sound like you are massively over complicating things.

OP, it sounds like to me you actually want to be a SAHM but for some reason don’t want to admit it to yourself. You seem highly resistant to taking on board any of the pages and pages of excellent advice from women who are able to make it work. If you want to give up work, and your dh is supportive, then do it!

and I’m sorry about your mum, it must have been very very tough for you 💐

FolkSongSweet · 25/06/2023 07:23

@Bluewatersummer is the problem that you can’t get a nanny or is it that you think they would be off ill a lot? Because the issues you mention re childcare and illness (which seems to be the main problem for you) completely disappear with a nanny.

If your cleaner is creating problems then get a new cleaner.

And I’m not suggesting your DH does nothing, but I’m willing to bet he could do more than he does.

If you don’t want to work then just own that.

Bluewatersummer · 25/06/2023 07:17

Ah @RosesAndHellebores thanks, will do so - think I’ll be a bit more comfortable when he or she is out of me, although I may never sleep again 😂

OP posts:
Bluewatersummer · 25/06/2023 07:15

@FolkSongSweet yes and no.

There are similarities in that there’s a difference in income but I do think that’s where the similarities might end!

I think some people have assumed that I’m saying that despite me working three days a week DH does nothing. I’m not actually saying that. Last time DS was too unwell to go to nursery DH had him. There is very little tolerance to me saying I can’t go into work due to an ill child because I only work three days a week. Likewise, once you walk into my workplace it is like the hotel California and you cannot get out again. So - thankfully this has only happened once this year - when you get a phone call to say your child has vomited it’s very stressful. If DH is at home that day it isn’t too bad. If he isn’t, and I can’t get out of work it’s a nightmare.

You say you have a city job so I think you may be somewhere nannies are a bit more plentiful Smile

We did have a cleaner but it created far more problems than it solved.

Some of this is just the nature of having preschool children and I do know that. There isn’t a magical solution. But we did have an exceptionally bad run just before my maternity leave. DS had some sort of viral infection one week. Then he threw up - I don’t actually think he was unwell on that occasion but understandably got sent home. Then a couple of other things.

I idly thought about two and a half years from now and managing that plus a child in reception and it may be hard to manage. Or not.

I wondered if others just got to the point where trying to stay in employment was more hassle than it was worth, which sometimes is how it feels. That isn’t me saying I will do anything drastic, it is just an acknowledgement of the situation we have and how best to manage that I suppose.

OP posts:
RosesAndHellebores · 25/06/2023 07:07

I am sorry about your parents. I had tried to be supportive throughout your thread.

We all have our reasons and demons; mine aren't wholly dissimilar to yours. DF died shortly after retirement and my mother and step have burned through her not insubstantial inheritance. Although mine invented serial divorce when I was 12 and before it was fashionable. My response has always been to 100% shore myself up for emotional and financial security so if the chips were ever down I can rely on just myself. I got lucky; I met DH.

Do what your heart tells you. Enjoy your children. Defer your decision until you can no longer. As I have said many times I loved being a mother, and had 7 wonderful years at home. But I also love work and as dh is a workaholic, my days were very long at home. I think it also broadened me and made our marriage stronger because I had something other than the dc, the house, school, and lunching to talk about.

Good luck. Enjoy your babies and lise yourself in the heavenly scent of newborn head for the time being.Flowers

FolkSongSweet · 25/06/2023 06:57

So we have a similar family set up
OP except that I am the high earning one with a city job and DH is the low earner (a tenth of my salary). Kids are 5 and 2.5.

Our set up is interesting because it’s contrary to gender norms and as a result very different from yours.

The expectation is that I will spend time with the kids (even though I work full time) and that DH will work (even though he earns a fraction of what I do). And when those are the expectations actually a lot of the issues you’ve mentioned fall away.

DH works part time and does more school pick ups, but I do all drop offs except when travelling.

I am senior enough that I can tell work I will log off at 6pm to do bed and bath routine and then log back in later. Obviously sometimes not possible but for the majority of time it is.

we have a cleaner and otherwise share household tasks. I do more of the mental load kid stuff, partly because a lot of it can be done on my commute (medical appointments, scheduling play dates, ordering new clothes); DH does the stuff you need to be physically at home for, like laundry.

You say you are rushed and hassled etc but there will be things that you are doing that could be done by your DH, if he was really motivated to do them (as I am).

We also have a nanny. I think you’ve written this off on the basis that they might be ill, but most people only have a few sick days a year, in which case you’re much better off than sending a kid to nursery where there will be many more sick days than that. A nanny will look after a sick child in their own home and it eliminates pick up and drop off. It’s more expensive but would still cost you less than you giving up work altogether.

I think you said you’re pregnant so you don’t know yet what life is like with 2 DC but it’s absolutely possible for you to continue working and for all of you to be happy. If you really wanted to you could make it work, but the question is whether you want to.

Tinybrother · 25/06/2023 06:55

Sarahtm35 · 21/06/2023 11:23

Personally I think it’s anti-feminist for a women to have to give birth and then go out to work, it’s also not very kind to the child either.
having worked in childcare, I can tell you these children who spend all day in a childcare setting are not happy and a lot of the parents refuse to acknowledge it as they’re too busy with work and life.
I understand many women have no choice but to work, but if you’re husband earns enough or you’re able to make cutbacks to stay home, then I think that’s the kindest thing to do for your child.

“I understand many men have no choice but to work, but if your wife earns enough or you’re able to make cutbacks to stay home, then I think that’s the kindest thing to do for your child.”

I bet this sentence sounds weird to you.

Bluewatersummer · 25/06/2023 06:40

Pretty much. I’m not claiming it’s some sort of life of luxury. Clearly it isn’t. But many people survive on less after paying mortgage or rent. If what you want is to retire as early as possible and then enjoy the benefits of that then a state pension won’t do that.

OP posts:
Goldencup · 25/06/2023 06:25

Bluewatersummer · 25/06/2023 06:06

Sorry Flowers that was way snappier than intended. Just feeling a bit bad about my poor mum!

I have to admit that the MN line on pensions has always been a bit alien to me. So (just had a quick google) it is currently just over £200 a week. Clearly that is not a fortune but it is actually only marginally less than I have at the moment after nursery fees are paid and I don’t consider myself to be living in abject poverty. And that’s just the state pension.

Does that £200 (now) cover food, utilities and home maintenance (presuming there will be no mortgage or rent) ? Or is it your spending money after nursery fees ?

Bluewatersummer · 25/06/2023 06:06

Sorry Flowers that was way snappier than intended. Just feeling a bit bad about my poor mum!

I have to admit that the MN line on pensions has always been a bit alien to me. So (just had a quick google) it is currently just over £200 a week. Clearly that is not a fortune but it is actually only marginally less than I have at the moment after nursery fees are paid and I don’t consider myself to be living in abject poverty. And that’s just the state pension.

OP posts:
Goldencup · 25/06/2023 06:06

Apologies if that is how it comes across good luck whatever you decide.

Bluewatersummer · 25/06/2023 06:03

Yeah @Goldencup … I know. I do know. But you’re making it clear in a sort of politely incredulous tone that you don’t / won’t accept that I do have an OK pension -
obviously not as much as it would be if I worked FT between 22 and 62 or whenever - but (sorry) I’m not going to stress myself to the max throughout my forties and fifties so I can be the wealthiest woman in the cemetery , to paraphrase dickens, it just is not going to happen. Can you please leave it?

OP posts: