Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if there comes a point where you just have to give up work?

659 replies

Bluewatersummer · 21/06/2023 11:06

I’m hopefully not there yet. But while I wish I could be very feminist about this the fact is DH earns a lot more than me and he always will, his talents lie where money is.

With one child we have managed through a combination of part time, taking turns to take time off when needed, and some good luck as well - haven’t had a lot of sickness to contend with. However, I’m due my second any day now and I’m wondering about a whole host of stuff.

It’s going to be so difficult when DC1 starts school and when DC2 is in nursery, reliance on wraparound care and rushing from A to B to C. I don’t honestly know if it is just easier for everyone - not just me - if one parent gives up work and just has their ‘job’ the children and house. Which isn’t very feminist but would potentially make a big difference to stress levels! Honestly wondering what others think: I’m not making any big decisions just yet.

OP posts:
GCWorkNightmare · 26/06/2023 07:29

Bluewatersummer · 26/06/2023 02:10

@anouskita thank you so much! It does become difficult on longer threads but I just keep endlessly repeating myself and it won’t be accepted and then I’m accused of thinking I’m special and unique - that post was pretty horrible to be honest.

Like you I honestly don’t see what the point would be in him working less hours or getting a new job for (much) less money. I think DH would think I had lost the plot if I made that demand.

DH could probably earn double what he does now but would have to be in London/travel a lot more. He earns well and that sort of lifestyle isn’t what he wants. He hated the 18 months that he worked away when DD was born and so has made choices that still allow him to be a parent. It’s also allowed me to climb the ladder.

”He can’t because he earns more” is yet another sexist stereotype that keeps women in this position.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 26/06/2023 07:19

What would be the actual point of the higher earner in a family doing less hours, so that OP can do more hours for less money? It's cutting off the nose to spite the face.

I guess if you see money as the most important thing, then you're right. It makes more sense for the higher earner to work all hours and for the person with lower earning potential to pick up all of the domestic stuff.

Money is not all-important for me, though, so I see it differently. I see value in both parents having a close, hands-on relationship with their children. I see value in both parents having a life and an identity outside of the home. I see value in modelling a more equal division of responsibilities to your children. And I see advantages in both parents retaining their earning potential.

I see the logic in your thinking. I just don't agree that money is the only consideration.

stealthbanana · 26/06/2023 07:01

Toooldtoworry · 26/06/2023 06:59

The fact that you can't see other people's family dynamics have to work differently to your ultruistic view is mind blowing.

Every family is different. What works for you is not going to work for everyone else.

Sure. But I’m not the one on the Internet complaining that my current set up doesn’t work for me and asking for advice - then ignoring all advice and calling it bonkers. Bizarre.

Toooldtoworry · 26/06/2023 06:59

stealthbanana · 26/06/2023 06:53

The point would be that it would enable him to parent his kids, which he doesn’t do now as he is unreliable and flitting in and out of family life. That you can’t see that is absolutely mind blowing.

The fact that you can't see other people's family dynamics have to work differently to your ultruistic view is mind blowing.

Every family is different. What works for you is not going to work for everyone else.

stealthbanana · 26/06/2023 06:53

The point would be that it would enable him to parent his kids, which he doesn’t do now as he is unreliable and flitting in and out of family life. That you can’t see that is absolutely mind blowing.

Bluewatersummer · 26/06/2023 02:10

@anouskita thank you so much! It does become difficult on longer threads but I just keep endlessly repeating myself and it won’t be accepted and then I’m accused of thinking I’m special and unique - that post was pretty horrible to be honest.

Like you I honestly don’t see what the point would be in him working less hours or getting a new job for (much) less money. I think DH would think I had lost the plot if I made that demand.

OP posts:
GCWorkNightmare · 25/06/2023 23:45

It isn’t feminist to stop work. I haven’t really participated in the sub discussion about this - it has been interesting - but I’ve tried to stress here it is the discrepancy between the incomes and not what is between the legs of the people earning those incomes that is the sticking point.

Childbearing is inherently sexist because only women can do it. Our whole lives turn upside down to grow and birth them whilst nothing (practically) changes for dad. Recovery takes time and Mother Nature would have it that baby and mum are attached for feeding and bonding.

As a result the expectations of women in the workplace are different. I remember not wearing my engagement ring for an interview because of the assumptions the panel would have about the 20-something woman in front of them. The gender pay gap means that women are basically unpaid from mid-November every year due to the discrepancy with male wages. Certain jobs are considered for women and others for men. I’ve caught against that my entire working life.

it’s not an accident of fate that you’re less bothered about your lower paid career than your husband. That he has a role that takes him away from home and keeps you there. I know that because I now have that sort of role and whenever I describe my job people will ask whether DD or DH mind me being away, don’t I miss them? Questions never asked of DH when he is away for work (5.5 days a week for the first 18 months of DD’s life).

I work completely flexibly and have control over my travel most of the time. I have no issue saying no to travel that clashes with something else.

DH contracts and works on his own terms. He is in an exceptionally specialist role, always in demand and nobody bats an eyelid at him turning down meetings at school run time.

it is completely possible to create a life where there is equality of role in all aspects. The question is whether you really want to.

anouskita · 25/06/2023 23:44

I'm really not sure why the OP needs to have this level of inquisition!

If she says (repeatedly!) that her DH can not 'just change his hours' then just accept that. What planet are some people on? Can you really not imagine how some people do not have jobs like that? It doesn't really matter one iota what your husband may or may not have done with his work schedule - he's not the OP's husband!

What would be the actual point of the higher earner in a family doing less hours, so that OP can do more hours for less money? It's cutting off the nose to spite the face.

If she says she is not concerned about her pension and she has that sorted - why question that?

If she tells you she is mulling things, then she's mulling things. These situations are not black and white.

Singlespies · 25/06/2023 22:57

Is part time work an option?

If you do stop work, make sure you still claim child benefit (even if your partner is a high earner and you have to pay it back) because that counts as NI for state pension.

Also, remember if you you get divorced later down the line, that all assets will get split, including pensions.

Mumofoneandone · 25/06/2023 14:37

It's a really tough call and you will figure out the right route for you at the right time. Please trust in yourself when everything is less hormonal 😊
For our family (DH, 2 DC) my husband works and I am SAHM. He works irregular hours and I need to be available for the children out of school hours (2nd child went full time in September). As he is an older dad, it will switch at some point to me working and him being SAHP but this is right for our family now. It is hard being a SAHM but the juggling of work and children would be much worse and not in my children's interest. DH is very involved with the children when he's at home.
I do look for part time work but it is limited - I am just philosophical about the situation! The right job will come at the right time.
Take care

sleepyscientist · 25/06/2023 12:39

Bluewatersummer · 24/06/2023 15:17

Definitely couldn’t - suspected chickenpox, vomiting, fevers, all sorts. It was tough going. Thankfully we are through it. Have to admit though I was always being sent into school even when unwell as my parents both worked and it was horrible.

It gets easier, fevers now are rare and cold etc gets calpol before school and a ring me if you want to come home. DS loves school so has never asked to and knows he could go to grandmas if he wanted. Suspected or confirmed chicken pox? DS was vaccinated so had few spots was in nursery for 4 days until one came up behind his ear that was definite pox so had 48 hours off until it burst. Really recommend the vaccine for your little one. I also was sent in but now as an adult can't even remember it, if I think of my childhood it's the good times I remember like time in the garden or holidays not having cold at school.

Have you considered going term time only or using unpaid leave for the school holidays?

Crikeyalmighty · 25/06/2023 12:18

As I said below- unless you have very much 'a career ' that you really need to keep a hand in (I don't think you have said) I would take the time out until 1st child is at school and then re evaluate. Do some online courses etc if you want to keep your brain ticking over- and make sure you have access to your Hs income too so you don't feel bereft without a salary. If you just have 'a job' these are not that difficult to pick up at a later date if needs be. I think these half way betweens never really work with small kids and it's easier if you are earning well to work almost full time and use a nursery/childminder/nanny if you aren't earning a decent amount and yet still rushing around to fit in multiple childcare arrangements then unless it's going to be worth it in terms of hanging onto a professional role that's taken you years to get- I wouldn't bother for at least 3 years I'm not one who loves being at home full time with small children either OP but in your case and without any family help I think it might help you keep your sanity and look at the bigger picture.

bussteward · 25/06/2023 12:12

is more how do you work and not end up pulled every which way.
I absolutely get this. Someone upthread (sorry, cba to go and find it) posted their schedule with drop-offs, work, pick-ups, homework, bedtimes, chores then finally sitting down when their DH came home at 9 or 10pm. It’s not a life, it’s an existence.

I’m also currently on maternity and planning the hours I’ll go back on, with one DC in primary and one in nursery, in opposite directions, and I have this big spreadsheet of who needs to be where when, taking into account DP’s commute days and DCs’ tiredness levels (I make children that need tea, bath, bed quite early and very strictly, otherwise all hell breaks loose), homework and hobbies, and my work being strictly timetabled, and it’s just so, so depressing. Every minute accounted, no minutes spare for toddler joy or rage (the “no shoes, no!” tantrums in the depths of winter when you need to leave the house ten minutes ago). Plus it can’t account for illness – especially a nursery bug that gets us one at a time in succession, or extra hassle like a car breaking down or the cleaner being crap or a D&V bug with the nonstop washing.

Yet like you I don’t want to stay at home more than a day or two max with my kids because as you say, JFC. For me I think changing from a very strict “billed by the hour” job with a time sheet, to working for myself, is a better option than quitting – ironically I think I’d work more hours but I wouldn’t have the ball of anxiety in the pit of my stomach I’ve had since starting my current job, where every dawdle on the wall to nursery spikes my blood pressure, and every lunch break is spent frantically adminning to ensure things get done.

Is your career self-employment friendly? It doesn’t suit everyone but certainly knowing I can do my job for an hour at 10pm if I want makes me feel less “headless chicken” when an email comes in from nursery going “and tomorrow is costume day! Bring a £1 even though we all stopped using cash during covid, and handmake an outfit for environmental reasons!”

Final thought: you may have to be the one physically there, rushing about, but can you outsource more mental load or hand over to your husband? Every party invite: snap a pic, text to him and forget it – he rsvps, adds to the family Google calendar, ensures the drawer of birthday cards and presents is kept stocked (even if you have to unpack the delivery he orders from afar). Six-week rolling meal plan so you never ever have to think about it, and he arranges the online shop even if you're the one into receive it. Every insurance renewal, email from school and nursery, etc. Meter readers done when he’s home. Basically he does the bill of mental load because your plate is the physical load. So much can be done online, at a distance – DP does our food order on his commute and as much other admin/thinking/whatever as he can as those days I do drop off, pick up?”, bedtime for two, dinner, etc. He’s the virtual PA (if I win the lottery I’m getting a PA as well as a nanny).

Kilorrery · 25/06/2023 11:49

Bluewatersummer · 25/06/2023 10:03

it Is a little frustrating because I don’t think you’ve been completely honest. First you said a nanny wouldn’t work because they might be unreliable, then you said it was because it might be hard to get one, and now I think you’re saying that you actually don’t want to get one, without explaining why?

I don’t think that’s dishonest! All the above can apply. A nanny would be:

  1. more than I earn.
  2. worries about reliability - going off sick, possible maternity leave etc
  3. ds settled in nursery and about to access free hours in six months or so.
  4. difficulties in recruitment

You must appreciate that if you had issues with your cleaner then you could solve that by getting a different cleaner

Well sure, but I’m a bit once bitten to be honest, and unfortunately I don’t think my cleaner problems were massively unique ones. In any case, even the most amazing cleaner would only totally solve things by coming every day or every other day - I wish!

You obviously feel that it would be better for you not to work and it seems you want some validation for that feeling, but if that’s the case you should have said so instead of phrasing the whole thing as a question and then fighting against all the suggestions for how to solve it.

I have actually said the opposite …

@Grumpyfroghats

I had a go earlier this thread and others have too in suggesting relatively small things that your DH might ask for at work but you seem to wilfully over state the suggestion to make it sound ridiculous. I suggested asking for one day a week to always be a WFH/no travel day

I’m sorry if you feel I made it sound ridiculous but no, he wouldn’t be able to ask for this. It would be one of those sometimes but not always. He generally does WFH Mondays and Fridays, there is some flexibility on the other days so for example I have a hospital appointment Tuesday and he will stay home then. But if he is abroad or in the UK but somewhere quite remote then no. Quite a lot of work is in South east Asia and in America so you can appreciate it isn’t possible to always be at home Mondays or whenever. It is recently they have stipulated Mondays and Fridays are the WFH days and it’s annoying because if I do stay PT I either have to do first part of the week (Monday - Wednesday) or second part (Wednesday - Friday.) Obviously ideally I would be at work when DH is WFH but that’s not what has happened.

My saying it isn’t possible really honestly is not intended rudely Flowers but as you can see above it is just I know the nature of the work and I know that he can’t just come back from Vietnam! Smile

I have to be honest here - I’m feeling a bit attacked and I know that’s probably just lack of sleep and all the rest of it. But I’m not saying anything awful or hugely controversial if I explain what our lives are like.

But surely the solution is that he changes jobs to one that can work with the requirements of yours?

DH was in the same position when we had DS — a job that was crazy hours, frequent unpredictable travel to the other side of the world, assumption that there was a SAHM or a wife with a ‘little job’ to pick up the slack. Our jobs suited us both fine before becoming parents — I worked in another country for six months a year for a decade. We both changed jobs to something more child-friendly when I went back to work after DS, despite both taking a significant salary cut.

Your DH is a parent. He can’t continue in a job that requires him not to be available to look after his own children on a regular basis. Unless, of course, he’s fine with not parenting them a lot of the time.

FolkSongSweet · 25/06/2023 11:33

We also don’t have family support.

You’re coming across as really defensive here. We’ve had the same cleaner for 4 years and she is excellent. Just needs a minimal wiping down of surfaces between her visits - i’m not sure how much mess your one toddler generates but that’s fine for us with 2 kids, one of whom is at home full time.

re nanny and nursery, the nanny could look after your baby and do drop off and pick up for your DS. It wouldn’t involve taking him out of nursery but would mean that you had cover if he was ever sick and in the holidays. That’s the arrangement we had and it’s been great. If you think it’s too expensive to commit to that full time there are emergency nanny services who can come at short notice to cover an I’ll child. I was only happy with this if I was working from home to keep ah eye but something that you or your DH could explore with your employers as better to wfh than not at all.

No idea what your job is but is there any scope for moving your non working day to cover illness? And both you and your DH are entitled to unpaid leave each year per child until they are 18.

There are so many different options if you actually want to keep working. Since you’re part time anyway personally I’d be doing everything I could to keep that up as you’ve already got a great balance with work and kids and there are only downsides to quitting imo.

Grumpyfroghats · 25/06/2023 10:34

stealthbanana · 25/06/2023 10:11

But he could think about over a period of time changing jobs or industries? If you did want to work and it was important to you and your family that you solve for that. As many of the women and their dhs have in fact done on this thread.

fyi I have a nanny and she has been sick for precisely one day in 6 years. I have a great cleaner who we’ve now had for 11 years. We have zero family support so have built a great network of babysitters who the kids know and trust. All of these things are eminently possible.

im sorry you feel attacked and that is not my intention but it is a bit baffling how negative you are about any suggestion that doesn’t involve you giving up work. For what it’s worth, there is no solution that doesn’t involve periods of time where you WILL feel pulled in too many directions. I have the occasional week where everything is hitting at once / going wrong where it’s hilarious how overstretched I am. But it’s a week. It passes. It’s not a good basis to make changes to my whole life. (And I’m sure sahms have those weeks too - where the kids are being nightmares, DH is being a prick etc). Life is like that with 2 kids regardless of your set up!

I think that final point is really right - unless you are so wealthy that you can do a Pippa Middleton and not work and also have a full time nanny, whatever you choose will have stressful moments.

Life with two children just is stressful at times, you just choose what kind of stress you prefer.

I much prefer working and I find it overall less stressful. I don't think I have the patience to entertain under 5s all day every day. When they get to school age, I think I would get a bit depressed.

I don't want to take anyone's feminist card away for staying at home with their kids either, if it works for you, that's fine. I was trying to take the OP at face value and suggest things that might help her to stay in work as that's what she says she wants but she had yet to find any suggestions from any of us who successfully work with young children at all helpful so what is the point?

(We have no family support either)

Toooldtoworry · 25/06/2023 10:31

@Bluewatersummer given your updates about pensions, etc and as long as you make sure you contribute your 35 years NI to the state pension so you get full pension (you can buy them). I think you should do what works for you, and it sounds like giving up work, at least for the next 5 years, would work for you.

My ex husband was armed forces when my youngest was your first child's age and I had to give up for a while because I just couldn't run my 60 hour per week career around the children's schooling/nursery/cadets/swimming/being unwell. You end up in a constant state of stress.

Bluewatersummer · 25/06/2023 10:15

@stealthbanana i go through this in an earlier post, I’m sorry; I don’t want to be no, he can’t but I don’t see how he could.

I do think that as with many things the hypothetical is worse than the actuality. You think ‘oh god how will I cope’ and then in the moment you just do, somehow.

I say I went ‘back to work’ after DS but it was actually to a new job - hence full time at that point. DH was on his first trip away in over a year because of covid and DS was really unwell, fever over 40 and I was in a bit of a flap as he was only a baby then. I’m more sanguine now! And of course being this pregnant makes everything seem harder work than it actually is!

OP posts:
GnomeDePlume · 25/06/2023 10:11

Having a SAHP gave us flexibility.

It gave DH flexibility to deal with issues or opportunities which occurred domestically. It gave me flexibility to deal with issues and opportunities which occurred at work.

DH could decide to make trips out, zoo, swimming pool, play park etc according to what worked for him and DCs.

I could come home and say I needed to be in Hamburg the next day and other than getting up a little earlier to get to the airport there was no disruption to the family.

The important thing was mutual respect and communication. I respected how he ran the home. He respected how I earned the money.

There were times when I felt disconnected from home. This would be at its worst when I was travelling a lot. But we kept communicating. I was always careful not to extend trips beyond what was strictly necessary. No extra days sightseeing. I often joke that I have been to the Milton Keynes of everywhere. I would go to the office I was visiting, stay in a hotel nearby then head straight back to the airport.

stealthbanana · 25/06/2023 10:11

But he could think about over a period of time changing jobs or industries? If you did want to work and it was important to you and your family that you solve for that. As many of the women and their dhs have in fact done on this thread.

fyi I have a nanny and she has been sick for precisely one day in 6 years. I have a great cleaner who we’ve now had for 11 years. We have zero family support so have built a great network of babysitters who the kids know and trust. All of these things are eminently possible.

im sorry you feel attacked and that is not my intention but it is a bit baffling how negative you are about any suggestion that doesn’t involve you giving up work. For what it’s worth, there is no solution that doesn’t involve periods of time where you WILL feel pulled in too many directions. I have the occasional week where everything is hitting at once / going wrong where it’s hilarious how overstretched I am. But it’s a week. It passes. It’s not a good basis to make changes to my whole life. (And I’m sure sahms have those weeks too - where the kids are being nightmares, DH is being a prick etc). Life is like that with 2 kids regardless of your set up!

Bluewatersummer · 25/06/2023 10:11

OK, well, I guess we’re not really going to understand where the other is coming from then.

My solution in all likelihood is going to be throwing money at the problem, rather than giving up work.

I will definitely quit if I win the lottery though. Must start doing the lottery!

OP posts:
Grumpyfroghats · 25/06/2023 10:08

Sorry, I don't see why it's not possible for him to ask. There will be loads of scheduling things they work around when deciding when he needs to travel, this could be one more. Sometimes they will doubtless say "no, client, that date doesn't work because of another client meeting clash", this could just be a other clash they work around. If they value him and he is good at his job, nothing you have said above suggests they wouldn't consider it.

As I said, what's the worst case scenario? They say no and nothing has changed. But if he doesn't ask for it, he definitely won't get it.

I have asked for and got (and so has my DH) flexible working patterns that no one else has previously had in those roles.

Bluewatersummer · 25/06/2023 10:03

it Is a little frustrating because I don’t think you’ve been completely honest. First you said a nanny wouldn’t work because they might be unreliable, then you said it was because it might be hard to get one, and now I think you’re saying that you actually don’t want to get one, without explaining why?

I don’t think that’s dishonest! All the above can apply. A nanny would be:

  1. more than I earn.
  2. worries about reliability - going off sick, possible maternity leave etc
  3. ds settled in nursery and about to access free hours in six months or so.
  4. difficulties in recruitment

You must appreciate that if you had issues with your cleaner then you could solve that by getting a different cleaner

Well sure, but I’m a bit once bitten to be honest, and unfortunately I don’t think my cleaner problems were massively unique ones. In any case, even the most amazing cleaner would only totally solve things by coming every day or every other day - I wish!

You obviously feel that it would be better for you not to work and it seems you want some validation for that feeling, but if that’s the case you should have said so instead of phrasing the whole thing as a question and then fighting against all the suggestions for how to solve it.

I have actually said the opposite …

@Grumpyfroghats

I had a go earlier this thread and others have too in suggesting relatively small things that your DH might ask for at work but you seem to wilfully over state the suggestion to make it sound ridiculous. I suggested asking for one day a week to always be a WFH/no travel day

I’m sorry if you feel I made it sound ridiculous but no, he wouldn’t be able to ask for this. It would be one of those sometimes but not always. He generally does WFH Mondays and Fridays, there is some flexibility on the other days so for example I have a hospital appointment Tuesday and he will stay home then. But if he is abroad or in the UK but somewhere quite remote then no. Quite a lot of work is in South east Asia and in America so you can appreciate it isn’t possible to always be at home Mondays or whenever. It is recently they have stipulated Mondays and Fridays are the WFH days and it’s annoying because if I do stay PT I either have to do first part of the week (Monday - Wednesday) or second part (Wednesday - Friday.) Obviously ideally I would be at work when DH is WFH but that’s not what has happened.

My saying it isn’t possible really honestly is not intended rudely Flowers but as you can see above it is just I know the nature of the work and I know that he can’t just come back from Vietnam! Smile

I have to be honest here - I’m feeling a bit attacked and I know that’s probably just lack of sleep and all the rest of it. But I’m not saying anything awful or hugely controversial if I explain what our lives are like.

OP posts:
Kilorrery · 25/06/2023 10:01

Grumpyfroghats · 25/06/2023 09:49

Sorry, yes, to me at least you have basically come across as shooting down every suggestion except for giving up work. That's what comes across as you really wanting to do that. If that's not intentional, I will take your word for it.

I had a go earlier this thread and others have too in suggesting relatively small things that your DH might ask for at work but you seem to wilfully over state the suggestion to make it sound ridiculous. I suggested asking for one day a week to always be a WFH/no travel day.

I would personally be surprised if someone in a niche industry who is well paid and therefore valued had absolutely no ability to ask for anything like this. And the worst case scenario is he asks and they say no. But you seem consistently to say that it's not even possible to try that kind of thing.

I agree. I wonder why the OP is so absolutely certain her DH cannot make any alterations to his job, working patterns or travel, or if it’s ‘will not’?

My DH likewise has a demanding, high-level job in a particularly unforgiving, macho, male-dominated industry, in which he is vociferously judged (and jot just by his industry) for successes and failings — and it’s an industry where virtually everyone at his level is make with a SAHM wife facilitating his job.

But I am not that woman, and made it clear from the moment we decided to have a child that he would be participating equally in all the parenting, because I would be working, too. So he is the one saying at overrunning meetings ‘We need to finish now. I have to pick up my child’, and checking his travel doesn’t clash with a conference I’m speaking at, and having a male CEO doing that openly has probably done more than anything to push family-friendly policies in his industry.

Sure, it would be way easier for him if I were a SAHM, but my work is important, and it’s irrelevant that I earn less than him.

Grumpyfroghats · 25/06/2023 09:49

Sorry, yes, to me at least you have basically come across as shooting down every suggestion except for giving up work. That's what comes across as you really wanting to do that. If that's not intentional, I will take your word for it.

I had a go earlier this thread and others have too in suggesting relatively small things that your DH might ask for at work but you seem to wilfully over state the suggestion to make it sound ridiculous. I suggested asking for one day a week to always be a WFH/no travel day.

I would personally be surprised if someone in a niche industry who is well paid and therefore valued had absolutely no ability to ask for anything like this. And the worst case scenario is he asks and they say no. But you seem consistently to say that it's not even possible to try that kind of thing.